Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling the family home- who gets what. Please help !

343 replies

Pinksparke · 06/01/2022 11:28

Bob was with Sarah for 15 years . They have two children . They lived together in a big family home . Bob left when they split . The mortgage is in Bob’s name . Bob pays the mortgage .

Bob lives with his wife in their house with their son . Bob and wife pay the mortgage here . It is a financial struggle .

Sarah lives in the family home with Sarah and Bob’s children . Sarah is getting married and her new partner is moving in. Sarah’s partner is mortgage free ( he has a bungalow ) he will rent this to his son now that he is living in Bob and Sarah’s home .

Sarah wants half of the house when Bob sells it. Bob is happy to do this however Bob paid the deposit for the house from inheritance and is paying off £25k credit cards that Sarah and Bob racked up.

Should Bob still pay the mortgage when Sarah’s partner moves in?
Legally, does Bob have to wait until their youngest child is 18 before he can sell the family home ? Should Bob take off the deposit and half of credit card debit before he splits the profit from the house sale with Sarah ?
Legally does Bob have to give Sarah half ?

Bob pays the legal amount of child support and uniforms , shoes and extras . Kids stay with Bob 2 nights a week.

For clarification they were never married and house is solely in Bob’s name .

OP posts:
UniversalAunt · 06/01/2022 17:53

TY @Pinksparke Mum of Bob the Generous.

There does seem to be an imbalance that Bob & Mrs Bob are both working, with a young family, mortgage to pay & in need of a bigger place, whilst by contrast Sarah has had a roof over head because of the children she shares with Bob, not worked for a salary & is about to marry & bring STBMrSunder her roof.

I agree with a PP that likely to STBMrS may not know the nitty gritty of the very informal arrangement between Bob & Sarah.

The abstract test is how open has Sarah been with STBMrS before they tie the knot.

If STBMrS knows everything & is happy to legally bind with Sarah through marriage, knowing that Sarah may not get a share of the house which is Bob’s & for the use of his children with Sarah, so be it. . But I would not be entirely surprised to find that STBMrS believes that Sarah owns half the house if not all of it, hence no compulsion for her to pay a mortgage. No way should Bob (& Mrs B) be subsidising Sarah & her STBH who are both capable of earning a living.

If Bob & Mrs Bob fancy another baby, a career break, or their financial circumstances change, Bob may have to make some tough decisions.
Bob needs really good legal advice & some estate planning so all his children are considered.

Anordinarymum · 06/01/2022 17:51

@Pinksparke

Bob works full time in the NHS. Bob’s wife works full time . Sarah does not work . Sarah’s boyfriend works part time as he is mortgage free on his bungalow.

I do hope when Sarah receives her share that if Sarah and her partner buy a property that Sarah will ensure her children are protected in regards to inheritance .

I will make no further comments now . This is my first post on Mumsnet . It has been eye opening and extremely helpful . Thank you .

Interesting how you know so much about Sarah's new bloke.

I smell a right busybody

Offmyfence · 06/01/2022 17:51

[quote kittensinthekitchen]@Offmyfence

Don't be mean. Maybe Bob is married to his mother. After all, we've heard of Sisterwives...[/quote]
😂

WonderfulYou · 06/01/2022 17:50

Sarah and boyfriend need to buy the house off Bob - it’s his house.
He can give her a percentage but it sounds like he has given her more than enough over the years.

How does she think it’s acceptable to live rent/mortgage free?
Sounds like her new boyfriends a free loader too and wouldn’t surprise me if he’s only moving in so he can rent out his bungalow.

BendicksBittermints4Breakfast · 06/01/2022 17:50

Bob should be more careful with his knob

Maybe Sarah needs to be careful about what knob goes where too, contraception isn't a one way street.

Emerald5hamrock · 06/01/2022 17:46

Hilarious replies to Bob's wife.
Bob should have had a formal agreement in place when they split up.

Whatthefucketyfuck · 06/01/2022 17:41

@RoyKentsChestHair

The only thing I can say for sure is that Bob should not be paying the mortgage on a house that Sarah’s new partner moves into while he rents his house out. Otherwise Bob is essentially subbing his ex’s new partner’s son with free rent!!

Sarah and Bob need to sever their financial ties if they’ve both moved on to new partners. The old arrangement worked when Sarah was a single mum and Bob was keeping a roof over his DCs heads.

I was Sarah. I never moved my DP in so my ex is still on my mortgage (although I pay it, my earnings aren’t high enough to actually get a mortgage, so he’s only on it in name really). Had I ever moved my DP into my home I would not have expected my ex to remain on it, much less pay for it, so that DP’s kids could get a free ride.

Are you expecting to get the house when the mortgage is paid off? Because, regardless of you paying it surely when it is paid off the house will be his...
maddiemookins16mum · 06/01/2022 17:38

@Ylfa

Bob should be more careful with his knob.

Why has he made even more children if he is struggling?

No doubt his partner was up for it too.
WallaceinAnderland · 06/01/2022 17:36

Bob is a fool. And a fool and his money are easily parted.

clpsmum · 06/01/2022 17:32

Why can't Sarah's fiancé buy Bob out

clpsmum · 06/01/2022 17:30

I'd say Sarah is chancing her arm and Bob wants to get a good solicitor

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 06/01/2022 17:27

They are not married. Sarah does not get anything. Sarah can move in to the bungalow with her new man. Bob can sell the house

lisaandalan · 06/01/2022 17:25

Bob should tell Sarah now she's not a single mother her and her new partner need to move out and get their own shared mortgage or buy Bob out, she is absolutely taking the piss out of him and he needs to seek legal advice now. X

Onemumtwokids · 06/01/2022 17:13

OP, I think your son has been very generous and caring to Sarah. But I agree with you that this generosity now has a cost, not just to him but to his new wife and child. Sarah has no rights over the house. She is entitled to child support as per CMS formula. I agree with others that the time has come for her to support her own standard of living and pay Bob rent or move out to somewhere she and her new partner can afford.

My children moved house due to divorce and they have survived it, as have millions of other kids.

Options:

  1. Bob could have a formal tenancy agreement with Sarah and her new partner. This might entitle her to housing benefit (or universal credit these days). Drawbacks of this are that if she stops paying rent is is quite difficult and drawn-out to evict tenants, even more so if they include your own kids.

  2. He could move back into the house with his new wife and child. This might result in fireworks and an unpleasant atmosphere for the kids.

  3. He could put the house on the market and give Sarah and new partner notice to leave. This may be the neatest solution. He could promise via a solicitor's letter to gift her some of the proceeds once the house has sold and she has vacated, which may encourage her cooperation. This may encourage her cooperation. He does not legally owe her any of the house proceeds, so anything is a bonus. Morally, it may be appropriate to gift her enough to put down a 20% deposit on a small home. Remember she is marrying a home-owner so can combine resources.

  4. Do nothing and build up resentment.

I also wonder what Sarah's new partner thinks is going on? Maybe he believes she owns the house? Bob needs to make sure he knows he is currently living there as his guest as he may otherwise be marrying her under false pretences which would be a disaster for the family unit as a whole when the lie comes out.

Crimeismymiddlename · 06/01/2022 17:11

They both need legal advice. If they are not married and Sarah is not on the deeds she would only really be entitled to what she put in. However, considering Bob has been fine with this arrangement for 15 years he may have a job getting her and her partner out!

StaplesCorner · 06/01/2022 17:11

@SarahProblem

Can't Sarah and new partner buy Bob out by selling the Bungalow?
It sounds like Sarah and new partner aren't interested in giving Bob any money and don't forget, new partner's son wants a free house out of it too!
SarahProblem · 06/01/2022 17:04

Can't Sarah and new partner buy Bob out by selling the Bungalow?

ShinyHappyPoster · 06/01/2022 17:01

It's odd that you're Bob's mum yet one of your posts suggested Bob should stop paying child maintenance for your grandchildren because Sarah has a new partner. That isn't how it works and it's disappointing that a gran would be so quick to see her grandchildren as a financial burden to be passed on to a new partner. Sad

There is absolutely no point asking for legal advice on the internet. Regardless of how involved you feel in their finances, you won't know everything. Plus the legal situation differs in different countries. No-one here knows the details of the financials or even the country Bob and Sarah live in. Their advice is useless.

No-one - not Bob, Sarah or your grandchildren - will thank you for interfering in this.

Cleopatracat · 06/01/2022 17:01

I like Bob

Foxglovesandlilacs86 · 06/01/2022 16:58

If they’re not married then he doesn’t have to split anything with her legally does he? All he legally has to give her is child maintenance as far as I know but I’m not a solicitor Smile

ANameChangeAgain · 06/01/2022 16:55

You didn't say how old the children were, which is important, as this will affect Sarah's ability to financially "stand on her own two feet". Does she feel able, in terms of child care or even running young teens to and from school to be able to get a decent job, or like so many working single mothers I know, is she unable to get a job that is any better than minimum wage because she is tied to school hours? If she previously had a good career, do her years as a full time parent make it difficult to get back in? How much does Bob help out practically, is he prepared to shoulder 50% of the childcare responsibilities to enable Sarah to get back on her feet?
Really its unfair that Sarah and their children are villaised for sitting pretty in the family home just because Bob made the decision to leave and start up a new family, and this was a decision when he already knew he already had financial responsibilities for his first.

Lockdownbear · 06/01/2022 16:50

@reesewithoutaspoon

Either Sarah and new husband need to pay rent on the house or Bob needs to get legal advice . If Bob died, then the house would go to Bobs new wife and she could throw Sarah, her new husband and her step children out of the house and force a sale. So at the very least Bob needs to sort this out and get his head out of the sand to protect his children
That's a very good point.

Definitely he needs legal advice.

While he is happy to house his kids, Bill needs to be in agreement with paying rent. And what happens if Bill refuses?

And at what point does the agreement end when the youngest moves out?

kittensinthekitchen · 06/01/2022 16:49

@Offmyfence

Don't be mean. Maybe Bob is married to his mother. After all, we've heard of Sisterwives...

Pinksparke · 06/01/2022 16:48

Bob works full time in the NHS.
Bob’s wife works full time .
Sarah does not work .
Sarah’s boyfriend works part time as he is mortgage free on his bungalow.

I do hope when Sarah receives her share that if Sarah and her partner buy a property that Sarah will ensure her children are protected in regards to inheritance .

I will make no further comments now . This is my first post on Mumsnet . It has been eye opening and extremely helpful . Thank you .

OP posts:
Offmyfence · 06/01/2022 16:45

@Pregnagainagain

Hi Bob’s wife Grin
Hi poster who doesn't read even the OPs post 😃