Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class/Upper middle class most frugal with money (in a good way!)

538 replies

Montana7 · 06/01/2022 10:01

Out of our friends with dc the same age as ours the most middle class & upper middle seem to be the most frugal & love a bargain.. Many are very high earners yet dc wear second hand clothes, uniforms, the families are very good with food & pride themselves on zero waste... Have great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips pre covid but always prided themselves on getting the best deals... I think its bloody brilliant & after realising how much disposable cash DH & I fritter away especially around Christmas I aspire to be more frugal... Aibu to suggest the mc/umc appreciate the value of money more or is it just the ones we know...

OP posts:
OhdearOhdearOhdearIndeed · 06/01/2022 15:54

@Cactu

They’re not being frugal. They are spending an absolute fortune maintaining their lifestyle.

These people may buy the odd bag of second hand clothes for their children but overall they will spend more than the average on clothing their children. You know they will purchase good quality waterproofs, coats, shoes including things like walking boots. If their children need anything it can be bought immediately at whatever price is convenient.

The well off have absolutely no idea how little disposable income the majority of families have so you simply cannot take it seriously when they tell you they ‘don’t spend much’.

I agree with this. Having a skiing trip and a few other luxury holidays a year is not frugal.

I think it is a case of what is a priority to you. I wear shit clothes and don't do beauty treatments, cars or holiday abroad, but I will spend decent money to eat relatively well (well a lot for an Aldi shop anyway).

I think some wealthy people will sing from the rooftops about their frugal life style when it just amounts to growing veg (which actually is an expensive past time compared to going to Aldi to just buy the veg) and buying a few second hand clothes. I think a lot of these people feel a bit guilty deep down about their wealth and do it to try and look more eco-conscious, as it is fashionable in these circles. Still happy to buy a diesel guzzling 4x4 and go abroad 3+ times a year though.Grin I guess it all evens out when you look at the big picture. You don't really know anyone's financial situation so you really cannot tell.

I think it's a bit of a myth that poor people like labels, when I was dirt poor I really didn't choose between wearing Nikes and eating like some people (who again probably have never been poor and like these stereotypes) want to think. It's another myth to make people with money feel less guilty about not being very generous, as is rich people are actually very frugal and that's why they are rich. These stereotypes are just covert poor/class bashing really.

Weirdlynormal · 06/01/2022 15:53

I used to shop at Aldi so we could afford our ski holiday. Surely that's just savvy shopping.

Annaghgloor · 06/01/2022 15:53

MN is class obsessed!

It's reflecting a very class-divided society. Mn is only different in that people are overt about discussing class stereotypes, prejudices and shibboleths, whereas in RL for most people it's unconscious, or at least undiscussed.

Bluebluemoon · 06/01/2022 15:48

I don't think it's anything to do with class - it's comes down to values and what you personally consider to be a priority.

I know WC people who are frugal and scrimp and save and WC people who have the threadbare carpet thing but get Botox injections and spend money they can't really afford at Christmas. I also know MC people who are both ends of this spectrum too. But most are somewhere in-between.

MN is class obsessed!

Ninkanink · 06/01/2022 15:46

True. There are many variables and variations and no hard and fast rules. However as OP set it out I think my summary applies in many cases.

Lampzade · 06/01/2022 15:44

@Ninkanink

It’s much easier and more palatable to be frugal when it’s a choice. It’s also much easier and more palatable when you already have everything you need and an abundance more. Frugality in the little things feels really good when you can comfortably afford to pay for the big things.
This

However some upper class people don’t actually have much disposable income. They are asset rich

PenguinIce · 06/01/2022 15:41

@Freelady

PenguinIce to answer your question.. its because a middle class person who dressess dc in secondhand but goes to the ski slopes may be percieveing that as a value added thing.. a councoius tribe choice to be frugal / re cycling clothes .. and the holiday also value added.. sport/ new experiences / meeting people.. all seen as good .

When , as you say a wc person dresses dc in second hand ,and buys an i phone..( your eg not mine !) Its seen as less good is because an i phone has no added value of things that are valued (as in the middle class holiday..)as its sat on a phone rather than adventure/ sport/ fresh air .. therefore the judegement may come from and is a stament about what you value .. probably in both cases ?
For eg . I do not value phones or dishwashers. We did have a horse. All my money went on that horse .. no holidays , clothes etc. Its what yiu value. It was to provide dc with a passion, fresh air , delay her from.going off with boys (!)
Re the wc thing v mc thing.. i think some wc people get judged for their choices without understanding . I worked in public services for many years. Often the sterotype of the benefits mum with nails and lashes but no money for food was absouteltelty accurate.. that was , for some,because the more poor a person was the more pressure to appear extemally not to be was the case.
Wereas the circles i mixed in . Think... green party , veggi, trendy part of the city.. dc wore second hand as either they didnt need to prove anything/ were tribe signaling / virture signalling .. it was NOTcool at all to buy yr dc new clothes or phone s.. Dc at school all had violins etc.. in fact our dc was looked at a bit odd for liking football and wearing a football shirt.. most ds were rugby and skaters .
Intresting stuff. I only wanted to answer yr question but ranted on !

That iPhone could be the only access to internet for the whole household. Giving them access to free sites on social media; the ability to apply for jobs etc. If that’s the case I think it is more added value than a middle class holiday 🤷‍♀️
ChickenyChick · 06/01/2022 15:40

I know loads of nice Middle Class couples who pretend they are hard-up (or maybe in their mind they are ), for example they can't afford a round in the pub (bring £5 in their pocket for 1 drink for themselves), can't afford a tip when eating out, always talking about shopping at Aldi (when it turns out they were there once to try the chocolate), always talk about being hard up...

It's an act the pre-empt jealousy I think?

My "poor" friend with 2 kids in Uni who don't have a student loan, who has just been on holiday to Tobago, has no money for dog treats or poo bags so always needs some of mine when we meet, she also has a cleaner but can't afford to tip the cleaner at Christmas. Also, the Tobago trip was obviously a bargain and they ate out in shacks for £7 a meal. So it was not really a luxury trip. As in fact they are quite poor. Next month they go skiing. Very cheaply though, as they are very poor Wink

I like meeting up with her as I am fascinated by her thought processes Grin and her life. She genuinely is constantly stressed out about money, so I don't ever wish I was her...

Guacamole001 · 06/01/2022 15:38

I have always equated class with class and not money.

The idea that you can buy class with mere cash does not sit well with me.

Surely class reflects taste and interests plus the circles in which you move.

I may be off the point of this thread however.

mafted · 06/01/2022 15:35

@penjo

I don't know what 'class' mumsnet would call me - please enlighten me!

From the outside we look affluent - we own a deatched home with garden in a nice area with a huge mortgage, we are both aged 25.

But if you look at our budget it's a different story. More than half our takehome goes on the mortgage (We are now on one (DH) income since I've chosen to become SAHM ). We haven't had any inheritance or high paying jobs and a lot of people ask us how we've afforded a house so young. The answer is we both saved every penny - didn't go to university, got jobs straight out of school, worked overtime, never take holidays, never eat out, hardly buy clothes and they're from sainsburys if I do(best mix of quality and price I've found anywhere), cut each other's hair at home, no nails, tans, or other beauty treatments, no cigarettes or vapes, no ready meals, hardly drink alcohol, no pets, walk rather than drive, use own brand everything rather than leading brands, turn lights off and appliances off when not in use. We don't have Amazon prime, Netflix, magazine subscriptions, all those things where money is leaking out your account every month. We don't have a gardener or a cleaner or a gym subscription, imo those things cancel each other out by the calories we burn gardening and cleaning! Every single penny is watched and counted, I would say we live very very frugally.
So, of our takehome : 50% roughly is mortgage, 20% is utilities, 10% is groceries, 10% is donations and gifts, the other 10% covers clothes and nappies for my son, fuel, DIY costs, medical costs, all the other miscellanea.

The point of that whole load of waffle was in case any of ours ways of scrimping help you OP? You said you were looking for ideas. It's hard work to improve your financial situation but we have done it by scrimping (you'll notice we have a large giving budget though - call it karma or whatever, scrooges dont prosper). Every penny counts and people with an attitude of 'oh it's only one takeaway a week' are shooting themselves in the foot. The rich people I know can afford to spend on those things because they've scrimped first to get into a good financial position .

I have many family members who've done all of that and still haven't been able to afford to buy because their rent so high. More in many cases than a mortgage would be.
workingtheusername · 06/01/2022 15:32

I have a friend who went from lower working class to upper middle class and she was a lot more generous when she was poor.
By that I mean we would go out in a group and split the bill no issue now she insists everything is itemised 😂
I've gone from working class to lower middle class and I worried more when I didn't have enough pennies in the bank. Now I'm less bothered if someone spent £3 more on a drink than I did!
I just laugh apparently it's how the rich stay rich!

Grida · 06/01/2022 15:32

People prioritise different things to spend their money on. Snobby people also think it looks better not to flash the cash, so pretend to be frugal.

oakleaffy · 06/01/2022 15:31

@araiwa

You're not being frugal if you keep horses ffs
Agree... Horses need money to keep them well. If one has own land, obviously it's cheaper, but a horse kept as it should be kept is far from 'Frugal'. However, people can skimp in other areas to afford their horse.
FTEngineerM · 06/01/2022 15:28

it was quite common to see threadbare furnishings but the biggest TV possible in the corner

That irritates me no end, a colleague is similar had to have plain potato for lunch because they didn’t have money for anything else but they both had new cars on finance, latest phones with massive amounts of storage, latest tech.

Since when is tech more important than nourishment?

Notcontent · 06/01/2022 15:28

@Ninkanink

It’s much easier and more palatable to be frugal when it’s a choice. It’s also much easier and more palatable when you already have everything you need and an abundance more. Frugality in the little things feels really good when you can comfortably afford to pay for the big things.
I also agree with this!

I am MC and I am in quite a comfortable financial situation (although poor compared to many people I know and work with!). I buy a lot of second hand clothes and some of my furniture is stuff I have found on the street! I try to quite frugal. But I also have a nice home and if I needed to, I could buy new things.

I do know people who are annoyingly smug about being “frugal” and eco but at the same time live in houses worth millions. It’s quite annoying.

MrPickles73 · 06/01/2022 15:27

Don't confuse posh with wealthy. Historically posh = wealthy but now there are lots of wealthy non posh. These are completely different categories. The Wealthy non posh have big detached houses, private school / live in the right neighbourhood in London, black or white porsche cayenne / Q8 / range rover. The posh person will for private school, have dogs and horses, cars are not really rated so could be anything from a skoda to a VW golf. Preferably covered in mud. The posh person doesn't give a sh!t what everyone else thinks and is happy to wear a sweater with holes in. The Wealthy non posh is very appearance aware and will spend money on hair, nails etc. Posh will be frugal on things they consider non-essential and hand me downs are normal.

notquiteruralbliss · 06/01/2022 15:26

Having grown up with no money, I found that the biggest luxury of a well paid job was not having to think about what things cost. If I want something, I buy it. I still have a WC attitude to finances though. Most of my income goes on experiences, hobbies, or buying services, not on saving or investing.

vivainsomnia · 06/01/2022 15:25

I read this type of comment a lot on Mumsnet and I don't understand it. You seriously never notice your friend looking good or wouldn't see if they'd had their hair done or had bird poo on their coat
But looking good to me doesn't mean dress in labels or hair cut in a posh salon. Looking good to me means looking healthy, happy and dressed in clothes that suits their personality. Surely that can't be that strange of a concept?

Yet you can notice a 'nicer' house
Nicer as in bigger in a nicer area. Would be hard to miss even when not looking for distinguished signs Grin

RoseMartha · 06/01/2022 15:19

A couple of people I know who fall into your heading have overstretched themselves on a mortgage and school fees. The dc wear clothes that are good quality but usually too small and looking tired and often hand me down from other middle to upper class friends.

Generous with food shopping and usage of utilities and if guests come but tight spending on their kids and staff wages.

onlychildhamster · 06/01/2022 15:16

@penjo we scrimped for 3 years to buy a 400k flat in London. Scrimping got us a 15% deposit, we had to borrow the 85%. Someone on a low income cannot borrow over 300k, it is not possible. Scrimping means you buy earlier, I bought at 27 (and both DH and I went to university), scrimping meant we could buy in London. If we continued scrimping, maybe we could afford a 700k 3 bed flat earlier even with modest salary increase. But you cannot scrimp your way to buy a million pound house with no help or at least I have not worked it out!

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 15:11

The rich people I know can afford to spend on those things because they've scrimped first to get into a good financial position.

The rich people I know earn good salaries and/or have inherited plenty. They don't genuinely scrimp.

penjo · 06/01/2022 15:10

I don't know what 'class' mumsnet would call me - please enlighten me!

From the outside we look affluent - we own a deatched home with garden in a nice area with a huge mortgage, we are both aged 25.

But if you look at our budget it's a different story. More than half our takehome goes on the mortgage (We are now on one (DH) income since I've chosen to become SAHM ). We haven't had any inheritance or high paying jobs and a lot of people ask us how we've afforded a house so young. The answer is we both saved every penny - didn't go to university, got jobs straight out of school, worked overtime, never take holidays, never eat out, hardly buy clothes and they're from sainsburys if I do(best mix of quality and price I've found anywhere), cut each other's hair at home, no nails, tans, or other beauty treatments, no cigarettes or vapes, no ready meals, hardly drink alcohol, no pets, walk rather than drive, use own brand everything rather than leading brands, turn lights off and appliances off when not in use. We don't have Amazon prime, Netflix, magazine subscriptions, all those things where money is leaking out your account every month. We don't have a gardener or a cleaner or a gym subscription, imo those things cancel each other out by the calories we burn gardening and cleaning! Every single penny is watched and counted, I would say we live very very frugally.
So, of our takehome : 50% roughly is mortgage, 20% is utilities, 10% is groceries, 10% is donations and gifts, the other 10% covers clothes and nappies for my son, fuel, DIY costs, medical costs, all the other miscellanea.

The point of that whole load of waffle was in case any of ours ways of scrimping help you OP? You said you were looking for ideas. It's hard work to improve your financial situation but we have done it by scrimping (you'll notice we have a large giving budget though - call it karma or whatever, scrooges dont prosper). Every penny counts and people with an attitude of 'oh it's only one takeaway a week' are shooting themselves in the foot. The rich people I know can afford to spend on those things because they've scrimped first to get into a good financial position .

shinynewapple21 · 06/01/2022 15:09

What you are describing sounds like priorities - they have a limited amount of money but want to hold on to a certain lifestyle - exotic holidays, dogs, horses, so they prioritise what is really important to them.

However their 'limited' income is high enough to allow them to make these choices as opposed to someone who is wearing second hand clothing as there is nothing else to cut back on .

Sn0tnose · 06/01/2022 15:08

@BeefSupreme

It’s easily done. Beefeater for instance have a lunchtime menu that goes on til 5pm and meat dishes (lasagne, burger & fries, gammon etc) start from £5.99.

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 15:04

@middlenglander

I agree with this. I have been shocked to see, for example, people who can afford free range eggs buy battery farmed ones instead.

'shocked' Grin

Yes. If someone has the money to buy ethically, I find it shocking when they don't.

It's interesting that my comment prompted such hilarity, while the comments upthread using words like 'horrified' to describe poor people buying themselves a new TV went unmarked.