Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class/Upper middle class most frugal with money (in a good way!)

538 replies

Montana7 · 06/01/2022 10:01

Out of our friends with dc the same age as ours the most middle class & upper middle seem to be the most frugal & love a bargain.. Many are very high earners yet dc wear second hand clothes, uniforms, the families are very good with food & pride themselves on zero waste... Have great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips pre covid but always prided themselves on getting the best deals... I think its bloody brilliant & after realising how much disposable cash DH & I fritter away especially around Christmas I aspire to be more frugal... Aibu to suggest the mc/umc appreciate the value of money more or is it just the ones we know...

OP posts:
D0lphine · 06/01/2022 21:06

A friend of mine is from a poor working class background.

She explained to me that when you're so close to the edge of respectability, you will take the small wins to make you seem respectable in the eyes of others. If that's a branded pair of trainers / handbag or iPhone then so be it.

She also pointed out that you're skint after you buy these things, but if you chose not to buy them you'd also still be completely skint!

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 21:06

B&M is pricier than Aldi here? And doesn't stock a full range of food. The cleaning products are cheaper though.

Again, there is a B&M in my nearest town, and that won't have the same customer base as the farm shop.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 21:01

Everyone here talks about ALDI as if that is a really cheap place to go. It is just a supermarket like any other. None of you talk about buying food at Heron Foods or B and M.

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 20:56

I mean, even the cake example is crazy. Someone with not much money is likely to buy their kids party snacks at Aldi or Tesco.

Most wealthy people, if they want a 'luxury' cake, would not buy one at the supermarket. They go to a nice local bakery, or Bettys, or the farm shop etc. The person buying the 'nice' cake at Tesco is probably at the mid/upper end of middle income. Comfortable enough to afford the Taste The Difference range or whatever, but not 'rich'.

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 20:50

As an example, in the nearest market town to me (northern but naice) there is farm shop which sells pricy food, organic, local, small brands, artisans stuff. There is also a Morrisons and a Tesco. If you travel to nearby towns, you will also find Aldi, Asda, and Booths.

The customer base of each shop is very different. Yes, some people shop at more than one place, but overall the Aldi definitely does not have the same customer base as the farm shop.

Do you think that a checkout worker at one of these shops could possibly claim to see a genuine cross section of society and be able to make direct comparisons between the behaviours of rich and poor at each of the shops? Of course not.

Annaghgloor · 06/01/2022 20:50

@ivykaty44

Enzbear

sounds like that couple on goggle box - nutty and nutty, they look tatty, live in old clothes cut their own hair and no ideas what they drive but bets on its old, they're not short of a bob or two by any stretch of the imagination

Yet they’ve said in interviews that they’ve used bubble wrap as fake double-glazing, have no central hearing, and a kitchen infested with mould — are they examples of cash-poor-but-posh boho types, or just poor?
forcedfun · 06/01/2022 20:46

@Pirrip1868

My in laws aren’t rich but they’re really well off. They’re inconsistently frugal. They spend a fortune on good wine and eating out but my father in law drives miles to get cheaper car parking - he’d rather walk a mile and save a couple of quid.
The wealthiest person I know is like this to an insane degree. He has about 7 luxury homes dotted around Europe (the chalet, the beach house, city homes etc)... We once spent two hours sailing around in circles in his multimillion pound yacht while he tried to retrieve his cheap supermarket baseball cap that had blown overboard Grin
RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 20:43

I am poor. I don't know anyone my age who does the false nails, etc. A few of my younger female relatives do. None have kids and are at the stage of dressing up, going out and wanting to find a partner to settle down with. Applies to two of them. They work and spend their own money doing this. No I don't expect them to save the money towards some future house that they may or may not buy. They are young and having fun.

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 20:41

@Pirrip1868

My in laws aren’t rich but they’re really well off. They’re inconsistently frugal. They spend a fortune on good wine and eating out but my father in law drives miles to get cheaper car parking - he’d rather walk a mile and save a couple of quid.
This isn't 'inconsistently frugal', it's just prioritising spending.
CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 20:40

[quote Skinnymimi]@mewkins heya! They kind of do! People open up a lot to the ones they see almost everyday! They tell me about their lives! The kids are so proud to say it’s their birthday! Some people actually come to say goodbye when they move house etc. The “poor people will load a trolley with the cheapest party food and buy for 30£ of plastic toys for the kids. Toys that break after a month which I know because they come back for it. “Rich “ people take the fanciest cake and a juice fruit. Maybe one magazine for the birthday child. 9 times out of 10, the luxury cake is cheaper than all the snacks.[/quote]
Doesn't this contradict your claim that poor people spend more?

The rich buy one nice cake that costs more than all the snacks the poor buy.

Tbh though, I don't believe what your prior post said because the rich and the poor do not tend to ship at the same places or in the same parts of town. I dont believe you can possibly make the kind of direct comparison that you claim.

I also don't believe that rich people are falling over themselves to talk to checkout staff about how much money they do or don't have.

Pirrip1868 · 06/01/2022 20:36

My in laws aren’t rich but they’re really well off. They’re inconsistently frugal. They spend a fortune on good wine and eating out but my father in law drives miles to get cheaper car parking - he’d rather walk a mile and save a couple of quid.

SleepingStandingUp · 06/01/2022 20:12

[quote Skinnymimi]@SleepingStandingUp I am sure that you are the one example away from the rule. We all are. I actually judge people on one thing : their vibe. If you smile at me, chances we will get along just fine![/quote]
I'm not the one example away from the rule though. That's the point. There are those parents (grandparents??) at the school gate in their designer tracksuits and thick make up and false everything and there's plenty without. Hair washed and brushed and bobbles to run around after kids, nails short so you don't get poo up them, clothes basic and made to last. There's a few funky colours of hair (blues and greens) etc but that's as exciting as it gets. Plenty who live on bad credit and plenty who don't. So no, there's isn't a universal working class or MC person. You have no idea what I spend any of my saved cash for - whether it's kebabs on a Saturday night or front row at the ballet

ivykaty44 · 06/01/2022 20:04

Enzbear

sounds like that couple on goggle box - nutty and nutty, they look tatty, live in old clothes cut their own hair and no ideas what they drive but bets on its old, they're not short of a bob or two by any stretch of the imagination

Skinnymimi · 06/01/2022 20:02

@SleepingStandingUp I am sure that you are the one example away from the rule. We all are. I actually judge people on one thing : their vibe. If you smile at me, chances we will get along just fine!

notanothertakeaway · 06/01/2022 20:00

@Ninkanink

It’s much easier and more palatable to be frugal when it’s a choice. It’s also much easier and more palatable when you already have everything you need and an abundance more. Frugality in the little things feels really good when you can comfortably afford to pay for the big things.
Agree with this

Picking up a bargain when you know you could pay full price if necessary is totally different from worrying if you can buy that item at all

Longcovid21 · 06/01/2022 19:57

I moved to a new area recently and bought a small end of terrace in a naice area. The children go to a public but horribly middle class school. I'm sure the other parents judge me for living in a small house but what they don't know is I still own a large farmhouse in another part of the country. But yes, people are so judgey!

SleepingStandingUp · 06/01/2022 19:53

Poor” people (those talking to me about their struggle) ALL had : tans, nails, hair, bags and bags of shopping. They go out, eat out, drink, smoke, buy gadgets that will break in a month, and think they save by buying cheap everything else. I mean the Starbucks ALONE for a year would cover a mini family break in Paris, nice airbnb included. Sorry, this is not an opinion or how I wish things were. It’s facts.
Well I don't have fake nails (I bite them), never used fake tan (naturally pasty), my hair has been cut once since lockdown began, isn't coloured (used to do it at home) and never had extensions, I've never smoked. The bags and bags of shopping well its hard to comment without knowing what type of shop but most of my kids presents this year came from charity shops so I could buy Melissa and Doug etc. I'm sure your description covers lots of people in those brackets but the minute you start proclaiming "all" and "every" you just sound ignorant. Maybe there's some unconscious bias in who you'd talk to. Perhaps you'd just see me - late 30s, plump, plain and think I wasn't very interesting to talk to

CouldIhaveaword · 06/01/2022 19:50

@araiwa

I'm very frugal apart from my yacht and aeroplane which I use at the weekends
'Never spend on anything that floats or flies'

There is often an investment attitude to spending, so that would include paying for a decent education or property. Boats, cars and planes devalue, so don't waste your cash on those. Grin

Skinnymimi · 06/01/2022 19:45

@mewkins heya! They kind of do! People open up a lot to the ones they see almost everyday! They tell me about their lives! The kids are so proud to say it’s their birthday! Some people actually come to say goodbye when they move house etc. The “poor people will load a trolley with the cheapest party food and buy for 30£ of plastic toys for the kids. Toys that break after a month which I know because they come back for it. “Rich “ people take the fanciest cake and a juice fruit. Maybe one magazine for the birthday child. 9 times out of 10, the luxury cake is cheaper than all the snacks.

TheToddlerLife · 06/01/2022 19:39

@IntermittentParps Yes that's true, though it depends on where you go...in some countries you can get a cheap skiing package holiday that costs but much more than a holiday in Benidorm. One is seen as posh, the other not (though I realise a holiday in itself is a privilege). I'd say it's more about perception rather than cost.

@onlychildhamster
@Camomila
Yes, in my country too McDonald's was expensive relative to local wages. When we went, my mum could only afford to buy me a small bag of fries. I had a friend whose mum could buy her the whole Happy Meal with a burger or chicken nuggets. It seemed like such an extravagance, as those foods weren't widely available in our country at the time. We could only afford street food and home cooked food made from scratch with ingredients like lentils and beans (bought raw), home grown vegetables and things like fresh cherries or watermelon for desert. All really boring and low class in my mind, as those things were cheap and plentiful. But considered middle class in the UK.

Anyway, not to hijack the thread. Regarding frugality...people are often a lot less frugal than they think they are. We know a family who pride themselves on being "frugal" and "not materialistic" because their children wear second hand clothes, don't get bought gadgets and their house is furnished with stuff rescued from skips. Yes, but they have multiple buy to let properties and a boat! That's not being frugal and it definitely is materialistic, it's just that they're choosing to spend their money on property and a boat rather than clothes//furniture/gadgets. They were also the tightest people we know...refused to buy raffle tickets for £1 because they "already support their chosen charities", hardly ever did repairs in their BTLs and would send their teenage DCs out to mow the tenants' laws then demand they give the DCs pocket money in return (the tenants hadn't asked for the lawn mowing).

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/01/2022 19:36

I am guilty of this shopping in Lidl paid for our skiing holidays when the children were little ( £20pw X 52 = £1,040). No take away coffees, lunch from home so we could go away in the Summer.

tarasmalatarocks · 06/01/2022 19:24

I think OP what is a factor is a lot of ‘many’ (but by no means all) ‘MC/UC’ people (and I know many who fit your description) value different things— they aren’t less frugal in many cases but place more value on posh, showy, frequent holidays or living in a very nice area or private education or horses etc than they do on food or clothes or a constantly warm house . This still takes a lot of cash though, so they juggle what they have in different ways to someone who has different priorities— it doesn’t mean they are frugal because they are smart, many are frugal because they are busy paying out on these other ‘priorities’ and only have the same amount of surplus cash as many who would think they are average/good earners.

tonicwaterparty · 06/01/2022 19:21

@WhatWouldKalindaDo

I think you are definitely unreasonable to say that the middle class or upper middle class appreciate the value of money more. I am in a skilled but low paid job, and there have been months where I have been down to my last pound, trying to work out the best use for that pound, because after that I had nothing.

You learn the appreciation of money when you have nothing. It's also easier to be frugal when you actually have money.

Lastly, class doesn't equal high income.

It's definitely easier to be frugal when you have money. Being poor is expensive. As the late great Terry Pratchett wrote in Men at Arms:

“The reason that the rich were so rich, Vimes reasoned, was because they managed to spend less money.

Take boots, for example. He earned thirty-eight dollars a month plus allowances. A really good pair of leather boots cost fifty dollars. But an affordable pair of boots, which were sort of OK for a season or two and then leaked like hell when the cardboard gave out, cost about ten dollars. Those were the kind of boots Vimes always bought, and wore until the soles were so thin that he could tell where he was in Ankh-Morpork on a foggy night by the feel of the cobbles.

But the thing was that good boots lasted for years and years. A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that'd still be keeping his feet dry in ten years' time, while the poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet.

This was the Captain Samuel Vimes 'Boots' theory of socioeconomic unfairness.”

Idontknowlondon · 06/01/2022 18:53

@Enzbear

I never heard anyone in real life say that they'd like to earn a high six figure income so that they can drive an old banger, look like a scarecrow, buy the cheapest food, go camping for their main holiday, cut their own hair, have tatty furniture etc. Funny that.
Tbf, we go camping as main holiday because we enjoy it much more than flying with kids.
woodhill · 06/01/2022 18:53

I think you can be frugal without being mean.

We all spend our money on different things

I always bring lunch to work and I wouldn't buy a takeaway drink very often

My furniture is mainly old or inherited from family members as I would only replace if needed