Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class/Upper middle class most frugal with money (in a good way!)

538 replies

Montana7 · 06/01/2022 10:01

Out of our friends with dc the same age as ours the most middle class & upper middle seem to be the most frugal & love a bargain.. Many are very high earners yet dc wear second hand clothes, uniforms, the families are very good with food & pride themselves on zero waste... Have great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips pre covid but always prided themselves on getting the best deals... I think its bloody brilliant & after realising how much disposable cash DH & I fritter away especially around Christmas I aspire to be more frugal... Aibu to suggest the mc/umc appreciate the value of money more or is it just the ones we know...

OP posts:
PGSTesting123 · 07/01/2022 10:33

By the way I'm not wealthy. Working class with a good job due to the movement allowed in this country in regards to profession and career.

PGSTesting123 · 07/01/2022 10:32

@xnowayout

The whole wealthy have threadbare carpets etc, they wouldn’t if they had more cash.
I live in a street which is working class. My and my partner's individual salaries are higher than the value of the actual house. Others on our street have jobs such as care worker, personal trainer, yoga teacher, lower IT level roles etc (we bought the house we rented after university and haven't moved out yet as it's still the 2 of us) However, our carpets are so worn out. We mean to get them replaced but ultimately think we really don't care. My point, we have money, we don't care about the carpet as it's too much faff to go and choose one, clear your house and get it laid. We just don't care. Nothing to do with having no money. People that know us and know our professions know we can afford to but don't. Now I've written that down I might change them!
RoyalFamilyFan · 07/01/2022 10:27

So I dont see people criticising that posh couple on gogglebox who have an expensive house, but are supposed to have a damp mouldy kitchen and a house in total disrepair. That is terrible priorities and choices in how to use money.

PGSTesting123 · 07/01/2022 10:26

Class isn't income though.
David Beckham is very wealthy, he can't even be said to be 'classy' let alone upper class.
He's new money.
All those rich Hollywood stars, they're not upper class though.

However, when it comes to middle and lower and working and underclass I guess these days people 'class' that as your job title, your parents and take a view from that.
My doctor sibling referees to themselves as working class because our parents worked in factories.
My parents refer to themselves as above working classes in this country as their parents are landowners and factory owners themselves in India, although they do recognise their reality in this country is the same as the people they work with, even though they have inherited wealth which most of their working circle won't as those people are from a poor background for generations.
A secretary at my work place is so snooty but, I know our local binmen earn more than her.
Class recognition isn't that easy these days.
Plus, it's all irrelevant.
Class unless your elite or multi millionaire doesn't mean anything.
Pathetic snobbery by people to make others feel inadequate.

RoyalFamilyFan · 07/01/2022 10:25

@NdujaWannaDance I think there are people in all classes who make daft choices and waste money. The difference in the middle class is that these people will have credit card debts and overdrafts, and in the working class they don't have enough money for food or rent.
The behaviour is the same, the consequences are different.

PGSTesting123 · 07/01/2022 10:17

06:01NdujaWannaDance
Totally agree.
Like you said you can never say this very reasonable thought to anyone in real life because I guess the truth will sting them too much.

xnowayout · 07/01/2022 09:44

The whole wealthy have threadbare carpets etc, they wouldn’t if they had more cash.

Pixxie7 · 07/01/2022 06:46

I thought we had outgrown upper and middle class. How do you define it, having read through it seems that how much money you have.
As a bank manager once told me a lot of people who you think are wealthy, in fact have very little disposable income or as he said, and I quote it’s all kippers and curtains.

incognitodorrito · 07/01/2022 06:39

@NdujaWannaDance - just came onto say I really liked reading your views !

NdujaWannaDance · 07/01/2022 06:02

your family.

NdujaWannaDance · 07/01/2022 06:01

And before anyone jumps on me for displaying an unlikely and outrageous caracature of a feckless an irreponsible person, yes of course that's what I was doing. I am fully aware that most people who are on low incomes and find themselves in huge debt don't do all or any of these things. And for those who do some of them, well we are all entitled to some small pleasures and occasional luxuries, to help us feel we can put on a presentable face to the world and feel a bit less downtrodden. I get that.

But when your sense of entitlement to those 'small pleasures' and luxuries is greater than your sense of responsibility to meet the basic needs of our family first (rent, food, utilities, suitable clothing, a bed with sheets) then we have a problem.

NdujaWannaDance · 07/01/2022 05:38

I spent all of my life blaming my upbringing for my problems: Class I was born into, parents level of education deciding of mine, lack of family money so no property ladder, lack of holidays. My life changed when I realized that some people make better choices and I can’t always blame outside factors for my own poor decisions

Of course hard work and conscientiousness and the ability to practice delayed gratification will hugely affect a person's outcome if they've been born into an environment of social and economic disadvantage, but it's still no guarantee that they will lift themselves out of some degree of poverty. To keep trotting out this mantra is to assume that people who remain poor must just never have tried hard enough.

Some people are far better equipped to make those good choices in the first place. Even among all the people who've had a somewhat hard start in life, they aren't all dealt identical cards. And luck and being in the right place at the right time plays a huge part in outcomes.

That said, I do agree with you to some degree. There is often a culture of learned helplessness.

Some people keep making the same old mistakes and poor choices and then act bewildered, indignant and hurt when its pointed out to them that that's exactly why nothing ever gets better in their life and frequently gets much worse.

This can be about wasting money you don't have to waste, by constantly prioritising the wrong things, culminating in debt and arrears that threaten to make you homeless, or it can be about other aspects of your life where poor judgement and daft choices are forever holding you back from sorting your shit out. For example having six kids when you were barely holding it together with two.

It's not just working class or benefits dependent people who do this - plenty of middle class people do to. But they are perhaps better cushioned to weather it, so it doesnt get so drastic so quickly and is less noticeable to the outside world.

It does strike me though, that there is so much defensiveness around this subject. If you bring attention to any individual who has (and as an example, let's go for the biggest tropes and cliches here) three kids by different men and pregnant with a fourth, none of the fathers giving any financial or practical support, in housing paid for via housing benefit/universal credit that's paid directly to her, and she's managed to get into massive rent arrears.

When she's photographed in the paper doing her sad face about the threat of homelessness and having no food in the cupboards for her children, you can clearly see she has lip fillers and botox, very complex tattoos and fancy 'nail art, ' maybe spray tan and a boob job, and three French pugs in the house, or whatever...(insert unnecessary excessive spending of choice)

And you just know that the initial outlay costs and then the ongoing maintenance of all of that runs into thousands of pounds, it's hard to not want to point out the obvious.

Her priorities are wrong and not only are some of her day to day choices poor, but her life choices are often poor too, which just compounds the problem.

Her rent arrears would be nil or at least much smaller and her children would have more food if she had different priorities. It's simply a fact.

But to shine a light on any individual like that causes others who are stuggling to be incredibly defensive and indignant, because they assume that you must think the same about them. But why would you?

If they aren't living the same way and they aren't making the same stupid choices, then why take it upon yourself to feel judged in the same way?

It's like someone moaning about dog owners letting their dogs crap on the pavement and not picking it up, and loads of dog owners who do pick it up saying 'How dare you accuse me of not picking up my dog's poo.'

Er...they didn't. Confused

NdujaWannaDance · 07/01/2022 04:24

@Ninkanink

It helps to look at it in terms of sets (in the statistical sense, not ‘London set’/‘Essex set’/whatever). There will be various sets within the classes. The generalities discussed here will apply very strongly to specific sets, depending on what elements one might be looking at.

One can’t be completely specific, of course, and there are always exceptions, but generalities do apply. There isn’t any need to get all riled up about it, especially when people are discussing it without necessarily applying value judgements.

There are usually shades of truth to every perspective, but some perspectives will be more correct more often.

Completely agree.
pinkpapaya · 07/01/2022 02:16

@Ninkanink

It’s much easier and more palatable to be frugal when it’s a choice. It’s also much easier and more palatable when you already have everything you need and an abundance more. Frugality in the little things feels really good when you can comfortably afford to pay for the big things.
This!
katkitty · 07/01/2022 01:52

@PenguinIce

I do find it strange how:

Middle class people who buy their children second hand clothes but go on fancy holidays are frugal and something to aspire to. Yet lower class people who buy their children second hand clothes but have an iPhone haven’t ‘got their priorities right’ and should be shamed.

That's because, in this theoretical situation, the money that was put towards the iPhone could've been put towards an experience for the children. iphones are quality but unnecessary for a lot of people where a standard phone would do the job. So buying an iPhone instead of that is actually quite shameful.
Skinnymimi · 07/01/2022 01:19

I am not saying that ALL people within their socio-economical class are all the same! I am just saying that there are SOME patterns of behaviors like in any other groups. People with less disposable income tend to spend it way more than other categories with more. There was this incredible experiment on youtube where they made people play monoply. The higher the income, the more conservative the player. The lower, the least careful. It is true. Every single day I see the same 10/20 families who I KNOW are on UC because they speak on the phone or to their friends in front of me. Every day, they come 2 or three time with the same 20 that becomes a tenner that becomes a fiver and they look for things to buy with the left over pennies. Every day for two decades I have seen the same pattern. They just roam the store looking for something to buy. This tenner once a twice a week would definitely be enough money for a nice holiday or a tutor fee etc.

Skinnymimi · 07/01/2022 01:09

Guys I absolutely do not want to start an argument. I am just sharing my experience. Yes, i worked for a very long time in central London. Derelict council houses just next to million pounds houses, all served by one giant Sainsbury. When you walk the streets, you recognize your customers and see which house they come in. Yes, they all buy at the same place. Yes “Rich” people take the Tesco cake because they do not care what anyone will say/ think. Yes, private tutor is prioritizing eduction. I spent all of my life blaming my upbringing for my problems: Class I was born into, parents level of education deciding of mine, lack of family money so no property ladder, lack of holidays. My life changed when I realized that some people make better choices and I can’t always blame outside factors for my own poor decisions

GarlandsinGreece · 07/01/2022 01:02

@limitedperiodonly

Oh God, not this old shit again about how the upper class have motheaten clothes and muddy Labradors and don't fritter their money away on big tellies like common people.
Quite. The Made in Chelsea lot and Caroline Stanbury are hardly bumming around in knackered clothes and forgoing the delights of expensive plastic surgery.
nettie434 · 07/01/2022 00:59

I absolutely agree with you about door to door canvassing, forcedfun. I just wanted to point out that we know a lot about who gives what and that while not giving money to door to door canvassers doesn't mean that the person doesn't give to charity at all, RoyalFamilyFun was right to make the point that poorer people give more of their incomes to charity.

forcedfun · 07/01/2022 00:44

@nettie434 I am not disputing that. Just criticising the example of canvassers being used because I find going door to door pressuring people to sign up incredibly unethical

nettie434 · 07/01/2022 00:37

[quote forcedfun]@RoyalFamilyFan I meant to follow up by saying that I was sure (from my time mentoring in the charity sector) that was probably correct. But I don't like the example of canvassers being used to illustrate it because I find the practice morally dubious at best[/quote]
RoyalFamilyFan is right that poorer people do give proportionally more of their income overall. The very rich give proportionally very little:

fundraising.co.uk/2021/12/15/donations-from-uks-richest-have-fallen-20-despite-their-income-rising/

massiveblob · 07/01/2022 00:16

My kids live in hand me downs as it's not a priority for me. They aren't bothered ( ages under 12, it will change)
We do spend an eye watering amount on all their extra curricular stuff.
Priorities

massiveblob · 07/01/2022 00:13

@Longcovid21 yep they'll assume you are poorer than those in bigger houses. No denying it.

massiveblob · 07/01/2022 00:12

@Longcovid21

I moved to a new area recently and bought a small end of terrace in a naice area. The children go to a public but horribly middle class school. I'm sure the other parents judge me for living in a small house but what they don't know is I still own a large farmhouse in another part of the country. But yes, people are so judgey!
They'll j
forcedfun · 07/01/2022 00:07

@RoyalFamilyFan I meant to follow up by saying that I was sure (from my time mentoring in the charity sector) that was probably correct. But I don't like the example of canvassers being used to illustrate it because I find the practice morally dubious at best