Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class/Upper middle class most frugal with money (in a good way!)

538 replies

Montana7 · 06/01/2022 10:01

Out of our friends with dc the same age as ours the most middle class & upper middle seem to be the most frugal & love a bargain.. Many are very high earners yet dc wear second hand clothes, uniforms, the families are very good with food & pride themselves on zero waste... Have great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips pre covid but always prided themselves on getting the best deals... I think its bloody brilliant & after realising how much disposable cash DH & I fritter away especially around Christmas I aspire to be more frugal... Aibu to suggest the mc/umc appreciate the value of money more or is it just the ones we know...

OP posts:
forcedfun · 07/01/2022 16:43

@Lesserspottedmama I love your post. I love that it explains the difference without claiming one is better or worse than the other. Beautifully put. I would quite like it to be stickied to the top of every Mumsnet thread on differences between social classes

Cherryana · 07/01/2022 16:38

Oh I've got another good one.

Genuinely said to my Father in law (a gardener)... 'Why don't you just sell a painting?'.

Why not in deed.

Cherryana · 07/01/2022 16:35

If you are independently wealthy you can take bigger risks because they are not risks.

Eg taking a mulitmillion pound mortgage on a house, (that you don't need) and reinvesting the lump sum for a higher return than the interest you are paying on the mortgage.

CSJobseeker · 07/01/2022 16:13

[quote FTEngineerM]@CSJobseeker I’m glad I read it, it has put things into perspective.[/quote]
I'm glad I looked it up, because I was surprised that it wasn't higher.

That was for the pre-pandemic year as well (2019-20), so won't have been affected by furlough etc.

CSJobseeker · 07/01/2022 16:12

@Skinnymimi

Oh wow! You could just have said that you disagree!
Your first post on this thread said that your claims were "not my opinion... it's facts." But you obviously object to people pointing out that the information you have available cannot possibly prove the facts that you claim.

I've been shopping at supermarkets (and other shops) for years. I've not often seen anyone engage in anything other than small talk with staff. The odd person might be more chatty, but there is no way that you can assess the wealth or wider spending habits of all your customers in the way you claim.

Just look upthread! Post after post from comfortably-off people who choose to shop cheaply but spend the money on holidays, horses, or private schooling instead. You're not going to see where they spend their money from working in retail, so your claim to be able to state as a "fact" that rich people spend less was ridiculous.

FTEngineerM · 07/01/2022 16:04

@CSJobseeker I’m glad I read it, it has put things into perspective.

Skinnymimi · 07/01/2022 15:39

Oh wow! You could just have said that you disagree!

Lesserspottedmama · 07/01/2022 14:32

I get what you are saying OP. DH and myself are from very working class backgrounds but our close friendship circles are mostly made up of people who not only have a MC lifestyle now but were born into one. I see huge differences compared to our WC family and the people we knew in our younger days. For example priding yourself on a ‘nice’ car seems very WC - our wealthy friends who all live in old rectories and beautiful country homes all drive old bangers! And yes second hand, car boot sales, make do and mend. Threadbare old sofas, scruffy old rugs and carpets, one of my wealthiest friends wears (expensive) old clothes with holes in them. But the WC people we know, it’s really important to them to give their kids brand new everything, clothes, toys etc. Brand new sofas on finance, gleaming cars etc - it’s a working class thing, pride in being able to provide what they would deem as ‘the best’ (I.e new). Whereas in MC world that wouldn’t be seen as tasteful. It’s just a cultural thing. Surprised at all the people on here who don’t seem to have seen or experienced this. Of course you will always get some people who don’t fit in those boxes. And yes there is an irony to all the zero waste etc when you are jet setting around the world and all the rest but that doesn’t mean there isn’t value in all the ways a person is endeavouring to tread lightly.

Bluesarestillblue · 07/01/2022 14:27

@CSJobseeker. Ah, a bit more than that. I was actually basing it on an average salary of around 30k per adult. I’ll be honest, I feel very well off. It’s miles away from the lifestyle I had as a child (4 kids in a 2 bed council flat). My parents looked after us well and we didn’t go without, but when I went to uni I suddenly felt very poor (I worked right through uni and contributed to the family pot etc).
DH is from a middle class family: GP and pharmacist type.

I definitely don’t look or sound middle class; west coast Scottish accent: and I am quite fat, suspect people do make assumptions.

In mn world I’m very poor. In my various social groups there are all different income levels. Some single parents on minimum wage. Other friends well off professionals and business owners.
I think we’re in the middle

CSJobseeker · 07/01/2022 14:19

[quote FTEngineerM]@CSJobseeker FOR THE WHOLE HOUSE?! It seems I am out of touch 😬.[/quote]
Tbh, before I looked it up, I had estimated closer to £40k for average household income in my head.

It's really common to overestimate what "average" is, whether that's about income, house size, holidays, or other assets. Humans are inclined to think that our social circle is closer to average than it really is.

FTEngineerM · 07/01/2022 14:12

@CSJobseeker FOR THE WHOLE HOUSE?! It seems I am out of touch 😬.

woodhill · 07/01/2022 14:00

@tectonicplates

I always laugh at people who say "I'm not rich, just well off". Where is the line drawn? What does "well off" mean if you're not rich? It's totally ridiculous. I'm pretty sure a lot of people would see it as the same thing, and changing the words doesn't really make a difference.
Perhaps it's saving your money rather than spending it unnecessarily that leads to having the opportunity to build up savings
CSJobseeker · 07/01/2022 13:32

@Bluesarestillblue - Given the lifestyle you describe, I'm guessing you earn considerably more than the UK average. It's not uncommon to estimate that the average household income is a lot higher than it actually is.

CSJobseeker · 07/01/2022 13:29

We earn a reasonable amount (probably uk average)

Median UK household income for 2020 was £29,900 after taxes, if that helps. That equates to one PAYE earner on c. £38.5k, or two PAYE earners on £16.7k each.

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/personalandhouseholdfinances/incomeandwealth/bulletins/householddisposableincomeandinequality/financialyear2020

onlychildhamster · 07/01/2022 13:26

@tectonicplates I wouldn't use the words 'well off', i would use comfortable.' Comfortable' means after paying mortgage, bills and other essentials, you have enough to save for retirement, save for a rainy day, go to a restaurant without busting your budget, buy groceries without constantly defaulting to the cheapest option (you can of course be frugal, but the key is you don't need to and it wouldn't make a material difference to your savings). You can afford to save to upgrade to or live in a home that has enough bedrooms for your family- 2/3 beds for a small family/couple (not like my DH's friend who is sharing a 1 bed assisted living flat with his 90 year old grandma). You can go on 1 holiday per year. Maybe at a stretch, you can afford luxuries like private school if you are extra frugal. You generally have zero credit card debt (cleared at the end of every month) and you can buy tech/replace items when they break.

being rich would mean having liquid assets to invest i.e. a million pounds that is separate to your primary residence. A net worth of £10 million is the HMRC definition of high net worth individual

Bluesarestillblue · 07/01/2022 13:18

Isn’t it all about priorities that suit each family? None of them are right or wrong.

I’m not sure if we are WC or MC to be honest. We earn a reasonable amount (probably uk average) and live in a cheap area of the uk.

Our biggest expenditure is housing for a large house; mortgage, refurb, high council tax / utilities/ insurance. Our house is much bigger than we “need” but we love it: gives us lots of room for entertaining, and friends / family to stay over. In the future we will probably downsize: but that means we will have extra money for retirement and supporting DS to buy a flat.

If our priorities were for example, travel, we could have bought a small flat outright and spent all our spare cash on that.

There are loads of things we spend money on that are not “needs” but help us enjoy life, such as kindle unlimited membership (I love books) Netflix and cinema subscription (DH loves film), activities and clubs for DS (annual passes to local attractions, karate, swimming lessons) our pets (dog walking service) and other home services (cleaner, window washer, gardener) as we value our spare time. And of course going out for coffee and lunches as a family (usually cheap places mind). For clothes I only spend a lot on n winter jackets and boots: everything else tends to be cheap.

But there are other things that others spend money on that we don’t: cars (we bought a cheap car outright), designer clothes, lots of foreign holidays, following a football team, skiing, beauty treatments, nails, constant redecoration, gaming, horses, nights out, fancy restaurants, takeaway coffees, alcohol, gambling. It’s very much what each family enjoys and there is no right or wrong way.

I would say that it’s actually cheaper to be better off. DH bought an iPad a few years ago. We bought it for £250 interest free (paid over 6 months) as we have a decent credit rating. In bright house the same iPad was for sale at £700.

AgeingDoc · 07/01/2022 13:04

Wealth is always going to be relative. DH and I are both higher rate taxpayers so obviously compared to a lot of people we are rich. But compared to say, a premier league footballer, we are paupers. As someone said upthread, the extremes are easy to classify, but that's all really.
Most people judge their own wealth relative to those they mix with I suppose. My DH teased for being "poor" at his independent school, I got the same kind of treatment at my grotty comprehensive as I was perceived as "posh" as my Dad had a white collar job. In reality DH was a lot more privileged growing up than I was. He certainly wasn't poor and I wasn't posh - but in our environments at the time that's how we were seen.

tectonicplates · 07/01/2022 12:12

I always laugh at people who say "I'm not rich, just well off". Where is the line drawn? What does "well off" mean if you're not rich? It's totally ridiculous. I'm pretty sure a lot of people would see it as the same thing, and changing the words doesn't really make a difference.

Annaghgloor · 07/01/2022 11:56

[quote RoyalFamilyFan]@Annaghgloor they show the outside of the couples house on the programme. It is a thatched detached cottage. It would be expensive wherever they live in the country. It is a terrible financial priority to own a house that you can afford to maintain, and so it falls into disrepair. Much more sensible to buy a cheaper house that you can maintain, or to downsize of your financial circumstances change.
Mary always indicates that Giles has never really worked. So I don't know if they have inherited the house and just continue to live in it, rather than make sensible financial decisions.[/quote]
Yes, I know the house I have a friend who lived close by in Pewsey though I've never met them, and she only knew them slightly, but said you would run into Mary all the time in charity shops, and that the house was reputedly a dank hoarders' paradise, and they grew a lot of their own produce.

Obviously I can't comment on why they don't maintain their house better, but from what I gather about them from the extracts from their diaries which were excerpted in the press, neither is from a moneyed background, though Giles got a music scholarship to Shrewsbury, and they spent their 20s hanging around with UC types in London, and Mary (who is from NI, though doesn't sound it)had a job at Tatler. They've owned the cottage since the 80s, and it sounds as if it's always been in bad repair -- there was a reference somewhere to Giles repairing windows with car body filler.

They strike me as old-style bohos who are widely-read, well-travelled, probably far more concerned about the garden than the house, buy everything in charity shops, and that putting money into the house would be way down their list of priorities, if they had it.

I wouldn't see their UMC class markers as necessarily a sign of wealth.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 07/01/2022 10:57

@RoyalFamilyFan I’ve always asssumed they have inherited wealth
Fairly sure their daughters were at expensive private schools
He used to sell art for a lot of money

RoyalFamilyFan · 07/01/2022 10:56

@Annaghgloor they show the outside of the couples house on the programme. It is a thatched detached cottage. It would be expensive wherever they live in the country. It is a terrible financial priority to own a house that you can afford to maintain, and so it falls into disrepair. Much more sensible to buy a cheaper house that you can maintain, or to downsize of your financial circumstances change.
Mary always indicates that Giles has never really worked. So I don't know if they have inherited the house and just continue to live in it, rather than make sensible financial decisions.

CSJobseeker · 07/01/2022 10:52

@Skinnymimi

Guys I absolutely do not want to start an argument. I am just sharing my experience. Yes, i worked for a very long time in central London. Derelict council houses just next to million pounds houses, all served by one giant Sainsbury. When you walk the streets, you recognize your customers and see which house they come in. Yes, they all buy at the same place. Yes “Rich” people take the Tesco cake because they do not care what anyone will say/ think. Yes, private tutor is prioritizing eduction. I spent all of my life blaming my upbringing for my problems: Class I was born into, parents level of education deciding of mine, lack of family money so no property ladder, lack of holidays. My life changed when I realized that some people make better choices and I can’t always blame outside factors for my own poor decisions
If you think working at a Sainsbury gives you this level of insight into people's lives, you're deluded. It's a ridiculous claim.

You have absolutely no idea what the 'rich' people you see are spending their money on outside the supermarket. Not only that, but aside from overhearing a few phone conversations you have no real way of knowing the relative wealth of the customers you see. You talk about seeing who goes in and out of which house - are you constantly stalking the neighbourhood (both rich and poor areas) and taking notes?

10-20 customers spending every day in a central London supermarket is a minute proportion. It's too small to be representative of any one group, particularly a group as large as 'the WC'.

The 'poor' people you see who come in every day spending in small dribs and drabs - how much do they spend over the week? And how does that amount compare to the one weekly shop of a 'rich' person?

At a guess, I would imagine it's similar to your cake vs party snacks example.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 07/01/2022 10:49

@Annaghgloor well one is a well respected artist who makes good money off his art and who is personal friends with Boris Johnson and one of this siblings, the other was a model and from a less wealthy background but has been an journalist For the spectator for years (agony aunt type thing) so for me I’d assume that yes that are wealthy because of their jobs and who they associate with

Annaghgloor · 07/01/2022 10:46

@RoyalFamilyFan

So I dont see people criticising that posh couple on gogglebox who have an expensive house, but are supposed to have a damp mouldy kitchen and a house in total disrepair. That is terrible priorities and choices in how to use money.
But you’re assuming they’re wealthy because they speak RP and live in Wiltshire, and have an income from Gogglebox?
Inthesameboatatmo · 07/01/2022 10:39

Class doesn't equal income I've found. There can be frugality and frivolity in any social class you know. Depends on the people themselves.