Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class/Upper middle class most frugal with money (in a good way!)

538 replies

Montana7 · 06/01/2022 10:01

Out of our friends with dc the same age as ours the most middle class & upper middle seem to be the most frugal & love a bargain.. Many are very high earners yet dc wear second hand clothes, uniforms, the families are very good with food & pride themselves on zero waste... Have great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips pre covid but always prided themselves on getting the best deals... I think its bloody brilliant & after realising how much disposable cash DH & I fritter away especially around Christmas I aspire to be more frugal... Aibu to suggest the mc/umc appreciate the value of money more or is it just the ones we know...

OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 06/01/2022 12:01

DH and I have relatively higher incomes and I'm always astonished ~horrified~ by how much some people spend on things like:

  • redecorating, replacing sofas, carpets, curtains, bedding and furniture as often as every couple of years
  • takeaways, meals out and pre prepared food
  • hair/beauty/grooming eg spending hundreds every month
  • masses of presents for kids at every occasion
  • masses of clothes for kids
  • stuff bought on monthly payments - expensive brand new cars, iPhones & tablets

The only things I would say we probably spend more than average on are:

  • childrens books. Our local library isnt great, the better one is further away and I struggle to find time to get there locally, so do tend to buy a lot. But I'm good at hunting for good value sets, second hand etc.
  • I do buy brand new school uniform. It gets worn 5 days a week, so to me its an expense that is worth it and I buy fewer other kids clothes so I dont mind. I buy with growing room though and try to get a couple of years out of a jumper etc and I wash carefully and expect things to be passed down to sibling.
OneTC · 06/01/2022 12:01

It’s much easier and more palatable to be frugal when it’s a choice

👍

CharSiu · 06/01/2022 11:58

Some people just don’t buy in to luxury items even if they can afford them because they do not want them. Have you contemplated that?

What items would you buy if you could buy anything at all. I don’t mean items that only the really wealthy can afford such as full time staff or a private jet.

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 11:54

@PenguinIce

I do find it strange how:

Middle class people who buy their children second hand clothes but go on fancy holidays are frugal and something to aspire to. Yet lower class people who buy their children second hand clothes but have an iPhone haven’t ‘got their priorities right’ and should be shamed.

Well said.
nettie434 · 06/01/2022 11:54

I am lowering the tone here but I was once watching Through the Keyhole. One of the houses had a grand entrance hall and reception rooms and a very ordinary kitchen with quite dated appliances and units. The panel were completely bemused but I knew immediately it had to be someone 'posh'. It was actually the home of Lady Colin Campbell (the one who was on I'm a Celebrity and writes biographies about the Royal Family). There was no need to have a luxury kitchen - she wasn't the one cooking - but the rest of the house needed to be grand.

Upper and middle class people are much more careful about keeping resources in the family, perfectly summed up in Montana's example where she gives £20 for the teacher's leaving present and the other person who gave a fiver. You only need to read some of the inheritance threads here to see this thinking in action.

I also completely agree with those posters who have pointed out that many people on average wages could never go on skiing holidays even if they made packed lunches every day.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 11:53

@BerthaBlythe

Isn’t it just about being clear on your values rather than a class thing per se?

My dps were over extended on their mortgage and prioritised our education and we grew up in a cold house, making do and mending and living the now trendy eco friendly lifestyle because we hadn’t two pennies to rub together.

I spent my summer holiday wages on a laptop for college back before they were standard, and a friend was moaning about not being able to afford one but was buying new clothes, drinking every weekend like it was a religion and eating take aways. Her family drove high end cars and went skiing.

I think it is worth considering carefully what’s important to you and realising that even billionaires can’t have it all (they can suffer from a lack of privacy and peace of mind). But it’s ok to spend your money however you want - I don’t think it’s a moral issue; just a financial one

My boyfriends family at school were like this. Nice house, but no other money. No or very frugal days out, no money to decorate the house nicely, battered old furniture, no money for kids activities. It seemed a totally depressing way to live and a depressing way of life to choose for your kids.
CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 11:51

@BerthaBlythe

Isn’t it just about being clear on your values rather than a class thing per se?

My dps were over extended on their mortgage and prioritised our education and we grew up in a cold house, making do and mending and living the now trendy eco friendly lifestyle because we hadn’t two pennies to rub together.

I spent my summer holiday wages on a laptop for college back before they were standard, and a friend was moaning about not being able to afford one but was buying new clothes, drinking every weekend like it was a religion and eating take aways. Her family drove high end cars and went skiing.

I think it is worth considering carefully what’s important to you and realising that even billionaires can’t have it all (they can suffer from a lack of privacy and peace of mind). But it’s ok to spend your money however you want - I don’t think it’s a moral issue; just a financial one

By 'prioritised our education', do you mean 'paid for private school'?
SlamCrump · 06/01/2022 11:50

In my experience some of the truly rich are often like that because they are quite mean!

And yes upper middle and middle class frugality is either (a) because they are asset rich and cash poor (b) school fees (c) horses.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 11:50

@Cam22

Even if I were attempting to get a gold medal in frugality, however, I would draw the line at buying supermarket clothes.
Sigh. Such snobbery.
randomsabreuse · 06/01/2022 11:50

More prosaically with a bigger house and less constrained budget you can buy in bulk when on offer (or buy direct eg get a whole lamb from the farmer) and get more for a fraction of the unit price.

Hollyhead · 06/01/2022 11:48

@mowglika ah reading that back that’s not what I meant although I can see how that’s what you took away.

What I meant was is that there is no shame in scrimping, cutting open the toothpaste tube to get the last 10 servings out, wearing 2nd hand etc. I’d never judge someone for it and neither would any of the people I know who have more money. All I meant was that everyone should know that it’s normal for many people to do this even if they have pots of money.

BerthaBlythe · 06/01/2022 11:48

Isn’t it just about being clear on your values rather than a class thing per se?

My dps were over extended on their mortgage and prioritised our education and we grew up in a cold house, making do and mending and living the now trendy eco friendly lifestyle because we hadn’t two pennies to rub together.

I spent my summer holiday wages on a laptop for college back before they were standard, and a friend was moaning about not being able to afford one but was buying new clothes, drinking every weekend like it was a religion and eating take aways. Her family drove high end cars and went skiing.

I think it is worth considering carefully what’s important to you and realising that even billionaires can’t have it all (they can suffer from a lack of privacy and peace of mind). But it’s ok to spend your money however you want - I don’t think it’s a moral issue; just a financial one

FanGirlX · 06/01/2022 11:48

leaving the oven door open after you cook a meal so you can heat up the house.

Doesn't everyone do this? You've paid for the heat, so you may as well use it.

randomsabreuse · 06/01/2022 11:47

I think that people with money can often be in a position to make economic decisions based on cost per wear rather than being constrained by limits on absolute cost.

My parents bought me a really nice wool coat in the sales when I was 18. It is still in decent condition over 20 years later although I had to get the lining replaced once. Coat cost £100 from £300, lining replacement cost £90 but it is still my go to for smart winter use. When I got it relined I couldn't find a nice coat for the relining cost...

If they'd not had the money to give me that coat at 18 and I'd not had the £90 6 years later I'd probably have needed to buy 10 coats for £20-£50...

Likewise with shoes, especially for men (see Vimes above).

Also furnishings, carpets etc. Spend a bit more and they last multiple times longer!

I was dubious about the value of Sweaty Betty leggings, bought some as a reward for improving my running in lockdown and they have lasted me so much longer than the leggings they've replaced. Easily more than the difference in cost - I think it's something about the seams and my substantial thighs - so I can buy 1 pair in the sale for £40 and they've lasted 3 times longer (and counting) than a pair from Amazon or Matalan bought for £20...

Cam22 · 06/01/2022 11:45

Even if I were attempting to get a gold medal in frugality, however, I would draw the line at buying supermarket clothes.

Quietstreets · 06/01/2022 11:45

It's nothing to do with knowing I could buy it again if I wanted to. It's nothing to do with driving with my head high because I know I could buy a nice car. I couldn't care less what other people think. I just don't like having nice things for the status when it is not needed, that's all

You misunderstand. Its not about what other people think. Its about what you feel about yourself when you know you life has gone to the shit and the shame and failure arising from that.

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 11:45

@Doubledoorsontogarden

I know people like this, get really excited about a clothing charity shop purchase, expect me to be really impressed yet bought a 40k brand new car.

Supermarket own branded food but order really expensive wines.

And so what? They prioritise their spending, just like you do. Obviously they care more about wine than food, and more about cars than clothes.
Cam22 · 06/01/2022 11:43

Haven’t read the whole thread. Suffice to say it’s predictable. Lol

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 11:43

Also, buying fewer clothes and soft furnishing, but only buying cashmere/wool/silk or other natural fibres isn't frugal - those things are a lot more expensive than Primark!

Cam22 · 06/01/2022 11:42

The OP appears to have successfully got the response she wanted.

Fimofriend · 06/01/2022 11:40

Exactly, @vivainsomnia. Both DH and I have good incomes and we just don't care about brand name clothes or what the latest gadget is. This is why we could afford a nice, big house. If we spent money on our clothes, hair and gadgets like two of my SILs we wouldn't have been able to afford the nice house.

One of my SILs has straight out complained that it is unfair, but while we got master's degrees in hard core very tough academic subjects and spent 60-80 hours a week studying, she studied to become a nursery nurse and it was only for two years and not even 20 hours a week. (Cue her whining about how boooooring we were). Now she spends £150 a month on her hair, at least £200 on clothes and always need to have the latest gadgets and it is so unfair that she can't afford a big house. Meanwhile, no one in our family has ever owned an iPhone. I cut everyone's hair. We have several items of clothing that is approx. 20 years old. My old laptop was 8 years old before I got a new one.

The other SIL likes to comment on our vacation with a bitter remark about how they can't afford vacations. She has a kitchen that is practically science fiction! It is always the latest new gadgets in there. In some cases things we didn't even know existed. They have a big house in a cheap area but have spent a lot on improving and decorating it
And she still buys lots of brand name clothing and new gadgets for their children even though they are in their twenties and haven't lived with them for years.

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 11:40

This is just complete nonsense. They will be spending their money on different things, but they'll still be spending plenty.

Keeping horses / going on skiing trips etc. is not frugal. They will also have top of the range gear for other hobbies, I'm sure - bikes, hiking gear etc. (all wholesome outdoor activities that the MC love)

Also, I bet their food shopping is all organic, artisan, local specialists etc - good for the planet maybe, but not frugal.

mowglika · 06/01/2022 11:40

However I think there should be more awareness that lots of wealthy people are tight with things to help people with less not feel embarrassed about 2nd hand etc.

You seriously believe this @Hollyhead? Wealthy people are tight to help the lower classes feel better? Grin

Twillow · 06/01/2022 11:38

I think when you're wealthy you know that you have options, more choice in how and on what you spend. Eg being frugal in some areas in order to be able to afford horses. It's a generalisation but when you are really poor your disposable income is so limited that it may feel like there's no point in saving a few pennies, why not spend it all on whatever you like.

I would say I'm middle class by education and housing status, currently working class by profession (nature of my job, not that I work!). So I have been a lot wealthier, and I do love to be frugal, always have. But I do that in order to, for example, make more expensive purchases that the working class probably would never consider - most recent, a wool duvet that I didn't 'need' but I wanted and I love.

In my job, I see what various people spend on. People that look obviously 'poor' spend what I would consider quite lavishly on things like crisps, fizzy drinks and similar snacks. They speak of their huge hauls from Primark, which will be worn for literally weeks then binned. They like on-trend sports label clothing, which to me are ridiculously priced for what they are and for how long they will be enjoyed. I am literally that person who would be so excited to get a Boden item in the charity shop!

CorrBlimeyGG · 06/01/2022 11:37

You're talking about privilege, not frugality. Time and money are something those less fortunate do not have.

Swipe left for the next trending thread