Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class/Upper middle class most frugal with money (in a good way!)

538 replies

Montana7 · 06/01/2022 10:01

Out of our friends with dc the same age as ours the most middle class & upper middle seem to be the most frugal & love a bargain.. Many are very high earners yet dc wear second hand clothes, uniforms, the families are very good with food & pride themselves on zero waste... Have great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips pre covid but always prided themselves on getting the best deals... I think its bloody brilliant & after realising how much disposable cash DH & I fritter away especially around Christmas I aspire to be more frugal... Aibu to suggest the mc/umc appreciate the value of money more or is it just the ones we know...

OP posts:
79andnotout · 06/01/2022 12:52

I've got loads of disposable income (six figure salary in the north with no kids), but wear secondhand clothes, drive an old beemer, have a small house, rarely go abroad on holiday, and have never had my nails done. None of these things really hold any value to me, and as I can easily afford them, the appeal just isn't there. I'm not tight, just don't really see the point in wasting money on shite I don't need.

PeeAche · 06/01/2022 12:52

I realise that me and my type are tedious. Other users are right: It's a nice little hobby to be frugal when you don't have to be. 😕

FanGirlX · 06/01/2022 12:52

TBH class really confuses me.

The two ends of the class spectrum are pretty obvious, Aristocracy at one end and those on benefits in temporary housing at the other. The big bit in the middle is a lot more of a grey area though.

Enzbear · 06/01/2022 12:52

I know this type - live in a big house with flash cars and holidays but not a scrap of decent food in the
fridge..."we're not that rich" is how they speak condicendingly to the little people like their cleaner, nanny etc
Everything is for outward show without actually having to say anything to brag. They're aren't actually that rich because they are slaves to their incomes. If they lose their jobs they can't compete with other social climbing brayers like themselves.

Tinsellittis · 06/01/2022 12:51

@Ninkanink

It’s much easier and more palatable to be frugal when it’s a choice. It’s also much easier and more palatable when you already have everything you need and an abundance more. Frugality in the little things feels really good when you can comfortably afford to pay for the big things.
This with bells on. It’s very easy to be frugal when you have money.
NannyGythaOgg · 06/01/2022 12:51

I have a brother and a sister like this.

Both millionaires in assets (plus houses worth more than a million) and both have more coming in each month than they spend. Both retired but were well off before retirement.

Both can be very generous, so long as it is on their own terms - which is fair enough.

Both can account for every penny they spend.

I will never have much money, I'm retired on state pension and a very small private pension. Following their example of accounting for every penny spent I have succeeded in saving small amounts each month (though how much of that is down to covid restrictions I am not sure). I never had time to do that before retirement though (or thought I didn't anyway)

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 12:49

I agree that some rich people are simply mean.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 06/01/2022 12:49

Why have I now got Common People by Pulp going round in my head? Hmm

PeeAche · 06/01/2022 12:49

Oh dear. I think I'm one of the people you're describing. (No horses though).

We stretched ourselves very, very thin to get our beautiful old house but we all walk around in second hand everything, we shop in Lidl (apart from when I simply must go to Waitrose, darling) and I regularly find myself rinsing out jars and old butter tubs because I can't bear to throw something away until it's falling apart. 😳

It's not our fault. It's how we were raised. I spent my childhood freezing to death in an underheated 5 bedroom Victorian country pile. We ate a lot of jam sandwiches and my school uniform came from the car boot.
My parents used to think those little aluminium tins that pies came in were superb and saved them all for reuse.

I'd just like to add that I've never been on safari. Apart from the ones that charge you £20 per car and have a fun fair at the end.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 12:49

We eat out as a family once a week. It costs us £30-£40 in total. Sounds like some of you would sneer at us eating out so regularly. But it really improves our family life having that time out every week for a long relaxed meal - teenagers, not little kids.
Quality of life matters too.

Guacamole001 · 06/01/2022 12:48

The rich live as if they are poor. The poor live as if they are rich.

I heard this online. Quite possibly mumsnet!

jfhguseorjgijaerigjarfgj · 06/01/2022 12:48

The other problem with this 'frugality' people are talking about here...if everyone with decent incomes poured money into assets and spends nothing else, what about the local economy and high streets? I rather like our local independent pubs, cafes, restaurants, takeaways, shops. I'm happy to use disposable income to support them.

I consider much middle class frugality to be stinginess, sorry.

FanGirlX · 06/01/2022 12:47

5 plus years old is not really old to many people
a pedicure is not really a basic
ditto brows possibly even hair ( although I draw the line at that 😂 )

I'm too clumsy to do my own hair and brows, really wouldn't be worth the distress...

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 06/01/2022 12:47

@Comedycook

Being frugal is a nice hobby unless you have no choice but to be frugal...in which case, it's bloody miserable!
Exactly - Poverty Tourism as Sleaford mods put it.
onlychildhamster · 06/01/2022 12:46

@IamGusFring I can see my mortgage balance decreasing when I overpay every month! That feeling is better than getting a new eyelash serum (not even sure it would actually make my eyelashes grow!). DH and I both like our consumer goods, but I took DH to a viewing for a 3 bed flat in a lovely area yesterday and we both knew this could be ours v soon if we earned more and continued overpaying. We knew more trips to Aldi and going to waitrose less would facilitate that; honestly once the food is in the fridge, we can't tell the difference; Waitrose is just often in more 'convenient' locations. I love my second hand dresses just as much as my new dresses. I can tell the difference between my expensive makeup and cheap makeup sadly, i wish that wasn't true, but have given up on posh skincare as its all the same really. I don't need an Iphone, my xiaomi works very well.

But if you are living hand to mouth, you probably don't have such a worthwhile goal to look forward to.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 12:45

@onlychildhamster I have an old house, although not grand. Buying older was cheaper than new build and larger rooms. But I want to be comfortable. So i want carpets, rugs, sofas that are comfortable. I don't care about trends or latest fashions, but I don't want to live in a dump either.

LaBellina · 06/01/2022 12:42

I come from an UMC background and I agree with you, OP. It’s not really a matter of actually being frugal, they will spend money on things that are important to them and that they see as worthy to actually spend money on. They also don’t give a shit about what others might think of them because they have nothing to prove. One of my relatives will happily spend what is for some people a months salary on antique books because he loves them but would walk around with holes in his shoes if his wife didn’t step in and buy him new ones. Just an example.

Winebottle · 06/01/2022 12:42

I think if you are used to spending all your income because you live hand to mouth and then come in to a bit of money, you are more likely to "fritter" it away than people who grew up with money.

Footballers and lottery winners tend to live less frugal than the upper classes.

On a smaller scale, my uncle who has been skint his entire live inherited a couple of hundred thousand and spend it quickly.

I'm not sure it is better or worse. A lot is different spending preferences. I drive a cheap car and fritter money away over Xmas because that's how I prefer to spend my money. If I was an extreme couponer for five years, maybe I could buy a range rover but I don't want a range rover.

Similarly, there is more of a dynastic attitude to leaving money behind among upper classes which is understandable if you have inherited a lot of money yourself.

Gwenhwyfar · 06/01/2022 12:41

"My impressions of things are that the less money people have the more they seem to be sucked into buying loads of temporary crap - THE trainer of the moment , THE hoodie , THE eyebrows , THE eyelash lift , THE brand clothing , THE phone. What is it that this stuff brings them?"

Status. Satellites are an example. They brought status at the beginning, but then became something that everyone in working class areas had and were then something others looked down on.

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 12:41

@onlychildhamster

*few hundred saved from buying old clothes for the kids.

Compelling argument that kids can't tell the difference between old and new clothes, but would remember the holiday... Poor people can't really afford the fancy holiday.

This is true.

If you are skint, it's a choice between nice clothes for the kids or spending that money on other essentials. You're not choosing between nicer clothes or a holiday.

bananabuddy3 · 06/01/2022 12:40

The kind of frugal that the OP is describing doesn’t sound like actual frugality to me -;it’s being frugal in order to get something else as well.

If I analyse myself and my spending.
My salary pays all my bills and I have an automatic direct debit into my savings account each month. I live alone and don’t have a credit card, I live off what I have.
I certainly can’t afford everything I want in life though, I have to make choices like everyone does.
Life can be cut short with no warning and there’s things in life I want to do and places I want to see. So this is what I aim for and in order to do that I have to be frugal In other places.
So I shop at Aldi mostly, and I search eBay high and low for clothes brands I love on the cheap. I’m much better now at FB market and have sourced remaining household items I need from there and so forth. I’ve made good money selling my unwanted items. I go running instead of the gym, I meal plan carefully to avoid overspending. I stock up on things when they go on offer.
So to many, I look like a nice and sensible frugal person looking after their money.
Except it’s so that I can afford to go on holiday and do things I want to do. The money I save from the above means I can travel to see my friend who lives further away, I can afford some day trip and I can save to go on holiday each year. Any money left in my current account the day before pay day is transferred to my savings, so I aim for this to be as much as possible.

So I’m not really frugal in the right sense and I don’t think many are. It’s a means to an end for many. Owning a horse and going skiing and on safaris is not frugal, it’s just a choice of where to spend money.
I don’t ski or safari or have any animals. My holidays are certainly not 5 star. But it’s what I like to do and to do that I have to save somewhere. I could buy all my clothes brand new from the shops I love and shop in M&S food and have the best Sky package etc but then I wouldn’t be able to travel or see friends anywhere near as much.

Middle class and upper middle class that OP describe aren’t so much being frugal as they are just making choices to enable the, to have everything they want in life.

Actual true frugal living is not having enough to live in 5he first place and making it stretch to cover what you need. I admire it and copy many ideas but ultimately it’s so I can put some money away, not for survival sake. Not anymore anyway. The last year is the first time in my life I’m bringing home more than £18k in income and I can definitely breathe better now.

So no I don’t think the upper middle appreciate money more necessarily. I might now count as middle as a newly qualified teacher and I certainly appreciate every penny I have!

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 12:39

I don't understand that, the reason that anyone without unlimited income affords anything is because they don't spend their money on something else.

How is that anything other than stating the obvious?

I agree that it's obvious, but plenty of people on this thread don't appear to understand it.

Plenty of people seem to be labouring under the delusion that making one spending choice (spending on skiing holiday and private school fees, but spend less on clothes) is somehow more frugal or more virtuous than another spending choice.

sst1234 · 06/01/2022 12:38

@MrsWalrus

I know a lot of people who are wealthy and with it have a sort of carelessness towards how others view them.

The headteacher at my last school was extremely posh - an ex public school boy. He would regularly turn up with unwashed hair, holes in his ratty jumpers, drove an ancient fiesta.

I think it stems from having nothing to prove.

This is exactly it. They don’t feel like they need to show they have money so they make more frugal choices on things that clogger people can see.
onlychildhamster · 06/01/2022 12:37

*few hundred saved from buying old clothes for the kids.

Compelling argument that kids can't tell the difference between old and new clothes, but would remember the holiday... Poor people can't really afford the fancy holiday.

GiveMeMyKeys · 06/01/2022 12:36

@Montana7

As my DH always says "that's why they can afford to go skiing because they priortise this over other luxuries"..
I don't understand that, the reason that anyone without unlimted income affords anything is because they don't spend their money on something else.

How is that anything other than stating the obvious?