Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class/Upper middle class most frugal with money (in a good way!)

538 replies

Montana7 · 06/01/2022 10:01

Out of our friends with dc the same age as ours the most middle class & upper middle seem to be the most frugal & love a bargain.. Many are very high earners yet dc wear second hand clothes, uniforms, the families are very good with food & pride themselves on zero waste... Have great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips pre covid but always prided themselves on getting the best deals... I think its bloody brilliant & after realising how much disposable cash DH & I fritter away especially around Christmas I aspire to be more frugal... Aibu to suggest the mc/umc appreciate the value of money more or is it just the ones we know...

OP posts:
RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 13:36

Upper class and middle-class people also advertise their status, just in different ways. I can tell from looking at people who in my area has money from the clothes and haircuts. Yes a jumper may have a hole in it. But you can still tell it is an expensive jumper and not from ASDA. You can tell someone has had a good haircut and not cut their hair themselves.
I cut not own hair and have an ASDA jumper with a hole in it I wear sometimes. No one has ever mistaken me as a member of the aristicracy.

Scottishskifun · 06/01/2022 13:36

@JustAnotherPoster00 it depends where you get second hand from though really! Not many mums I know go to charity shops all use Facebook, vinted or ebay! Still secondhand still cheap!

wombleflump · 06/01/2022 13:35

I’m like this at the moment. I earn over three figures. However, I’m waiting to relocate though in a overpriced rented house. It looks awful and the furniture is all second hand and falling apart. I go to the school run looking a complete bag lady as feeling a bit down and WFH! I run a tiny car now 7 years old with a couple of dents. I swear people at the school think I’m on the bread line. The reception ladies all look at me with pity and ask about free school meals etc. On saying that may depend on your background if you grow up not in money per say what actually makes you middle class?

username30473 · 06/01/2022 13:34

I kind of agree OP. This is a mass generalisation but one thing I have found is those with middle/upper class it's not that they are more frugal/value money more. But they have had better financial/general education. They end up in the best schools/ mix with the 'right people'/taught more about how to earn money/savings/investments/ how to run a business/ see a wider job market from their parents.

I have friends from both economic backgrounds. Many of my less financially well off friends are in debt/low paid jobs never went to Uni/college. One recently shocked me by her lack of understanding of mortgages how to get one. I agree from a PP above who works in debt management they spend a fortune they don't have at times like Christmas.
My well off friends all went to uni/parents in well paid jobs and just seem to make smarter decisions financially.

CallMeNutribullet · 06/01/2022 13:33

@NdujaWannaDance

Trust me, no one is more frugal than the person who lives on benefits or a zero hours contract and doesn't know how they're going to pay their next electricity bill.

No. That's a person who should be frugal. Not necessarily a person who is frugal.

How patronising. Bit hard to splurge when you literally have nothing.
vivainsomnia · 06/01/2022 13:32

I don't see that as particularly a thing to boast about
It's nothing to do with boasting. It's not something I discuss in real life.

I'm arguing against posters who insists that those who can afford things don't spend the money on them just because they can feel pride in it. I do it because I don't see the necessity of it and would be a waste of money, that's all. I don't require validation for my choices.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 06/01/2022 13:32

The problem with buying 2nd hand because its seen as a virtue by the middle and upper classes means that charity shops have on average upped their prices, this has priced a lot of the genuinely needy out, so its all well the 'virtuous' making a stand on fast fashion but without Primark a lot of families would be in a worse situation

Gwenhwyfar · 06/01/2022 13:32

"If I were to summarise it he spends more on stuff that other people see, whereas I spend on the things I want to do."

So it's a search for status for him.
Don't other people see your expensive holidays though?

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 13:31

These threads always bring out the worst of MC sneering.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 13:31

@JorisBohnson2 Just to say most people could not afford a 5 house in Camden back then either. I know it has increased in price out of proportion to its cost back then, but it still wasn't affordable to most people.

rookiemere · 06/01/2022 13:30

I grew up in a middle class environment and DH in a working class one and it's interesting to note our different attitudes to money - we're upper middle earners now I'd say.

So he likes to have a flash car ( maybe this is a gender rather than a class thing) and reasonably up to date iphone etc. He also doesn't seem keen when I buy second hand clothes either for me or DS ( but DS won't accept the neighbours hand me downs any more anyway). He doesn't want to spend much on food and feels we should eat cheaply whereas I'd rather pay more and eat higher quality stuff. He's also continuously looking for ways to improve our house.

I like to spend money on holidays and anything that DS needs and that's about it. I'm much more wedded to having savings than he is - although a lot goes into his pension.

If I were to summarise it he spends more on stuff that other people see, whereas I spend on the things I want to do.

CSJobseeker · 06/01/2022 13:29

@Mountaingoat12

And the whole idea of buying a new pair of matching Christmas pjs every year for the family? Why? What a terrible waste of the worlds resources as well as cash!
But your hobbies and travel are obviously not wasteful of resources in any way?
Metabigot · 06/01/2022 13:28

Yes, my in laws are completely like this. They are generous but live fairly simply themselves in their £2m plus london town house. And their other house in the countryside. They were lucky enough to be boomers though and buy these properties for not very much compared to today's prices, in the 70s. No way could they have afforded a camden 5 bed house now on the jobs they did then!

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 13:28

Everyone I know who buys lots of second-hand clothes spends lots of time browsing charity shops. TBH unless it was a hobby I enjoyed, I don't have the time.

prettyteapotsplease · 06/01/2022 13:27

FWIW I used to help on a charity stall at events like 'Summer Fayres' etc and IME the hardest hagglers were in the poshest towns. Of course, it's equally true that they might have been struggling to keep up with the Joneses.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 06/01/2022 13:27

@CSJobseeker

People spend money on objects that lose value. SIL, spends a fortune on makeup (£250 pm), gadgets, etc. These expenditures have zero intrinsic value.

This month I've exchanged some current electronic goods, speakers and amp, upgraded by selling mine and buying second hand.

Why are your SIL's gadgets a waste of money, while yours are sensible purchases that you can sell on? This makes no sense, so it's just you being judgemental.

my vehicle is a business expense (Tax relief)

You must be aware that putting a car through your business simply isn't an option for most people.

Because hi-fi equipment holds its value, so for instance, I've sold one set of speakers for more than I bought them for and upgraded to another set that has found a new price point. It's cost me very little in up-lift.

The vehicle for a business expense doesn't happen by accident, it's by my own design or actions. You can either control your own earnings/tax liability or let the government and an employer decide.

They bought a brand new running machine to lose weight, why not buy a pair of used running shoes from eBay and go outdoors. The machine is just sitting there.
It's like her clothes, they make no difference to her appearance at all.
'Nicer' clothes for the kids are just a myth that exists in a person's head.

Freelady · 06/01/2022 13:27

PenguinIce to answer your question.. its because a middle class person who dressess dc in secondhand but goes to the ski slopes may be percieveing that as a value added thing.. a councoius tribe choice to be frugal / re cycling clothes .. and the holiday also value added.. sport/ new experiences / meeting people.. all seen as good .

When , as you say a wc person dresses dc in second hand ,and buys an i phone..( your eg not mine !) Its seen as less good is because an i phone has no added value of things that are valued (as in the middle class holiday..)as its sat on a phone rather than adventure/ sport/ fresh air .. therefore the judegement may come from and is a stament about what you value .. probably in both cases ?
For eg . I do not value phones or dishwashers. We did have a horse. All my money went on that horse .. no holidays , clothes etc. Its what yiu value. It was to provide dc with a passion, fresh air , delay her from.going off with boys (!)
Re the wc thing v mc thing.. i think some wc people get judged for their choices without understanding . I worked in public services for many years. Often the sterotype of the benefits mum with nails and lashes but no money for food was absouteltelty accurate.. that was , for some,because the more poor a person was the more pressure to appear extemally not to be was the case.
Wereas the circles i mixed in . Think... green party , veggi, trendy part of the city.. dc wore second hand as either they didnt need to prove anything/ were tribe signaling / virture signalling .. it was NOTcool at all to buy yr dc new clothes or phone s.. Dc at school all had violins etc.. in fact our dc was looked at a bit odd for liking football and wearing a football shirt.. most ds were rugby and skaters .
Intresting stuff. I only wanted to answer yr question but ranted on !

NdujaWannaDance · 06/01/2022 13:27

Trust me, no one is more frugal than the person who lives on benefits or a zero hours contract and doesn't know how they're going to pay their next electricity bill.

No. That's a person who should be frugal. Not necessarily a person who is frugal.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 13:27

@BeefSupreme perfectly possible. Not at all posh 0bviously, but it forces us all to spend time and talk to each other and that is its value.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 06/01/2022 13:26

@rookiemere I mean fair point, I didn’t mean at all to come off like I disapprove of buying second hand - I do it and I can afford new. I also give a lot away to charity shops and to a home start type charity that helps young mums. It’s more the self congratulatory buying second hand so we can spend more on the horses, that riles me a little bit- it’s the denial that it’s a privelege, not the difference between your kids having decent winter boots when it’s snowing by getting them for £2.50 in Oxfam and being able to put money on the electric.
My partner only buys clothes from Vinted now really. He does it because they have brands he likes for cheaper but he still pays more than if we were literally skint and he had no choice but to buy from charity shops or primark

CallMeNutribullet · 06/01/2022 13:25

Trust me, no one is more frugal than the person who lives on benefits or a zero hours contract and doesn't know how they're going to pay their next electricity bill.

When I went back to work as a single parent, paying a fortune in childcare I basically lived on lentils, walked everywhere and bought myself nothing. Bit insulting to say the UMC who have horses and go skiing, understand the value of money better than me just because they wear 2nd hand clothes. Goady even.

DeepaBeesKit · 06/01/2022 13:24

You should acquire furniture or buy decent stuff.

I'm terrible at buying furniture. We've had the same knackered sofas for ages!

DeepaBeesKit · 06/01/2022 13:23

Well, that is obviously because owning a library of books suggests you have a brain; holidays do not
No, its because I have a sentimental attachment to the uk place I was taken as a child and love to take my own children on holiday there.

Do you spend money on decent clothes? In otherwords do you still spend the money on how you look but in different ways that fits more with your social class?

Hmm. I'm not really sure what social class I am. I have 2 young kids so I live in inexpensive black leggings and quite old shirts. Blush

I suppose some people would think theres a class or income thing in that I can afford to buy (for example) a nice outfit for a wedding or a job interview if I should need one.

WrittenInGold · 06/01/2022 13:20

@PenguinIce

I do find it strange how:

Middle class people who buy their children second hand clothes but go on fancy holidays are frugal and something to aspire to. Yet lower class people who buy their children second hand clothes but have an iPhone haven’t ‘got their priorities right’ and should be shamed.

Quite.

I also think there is a class performance smugness involved with a couple of people I know who are like this. Eg "oh no we don't waste money on brand new labels like the foolish paupers, we CARE about the environment!" jets off on long haul holiday

BeefSupreme · 06/01/2022 13:20

@RoyalFamilyFan

We eat out as a family once a week. It costs us £30-£40 in total. Sounds like some of you would sneer at us eating out so regularly. But it really improves our family life having that time out every week for a long relaxed meal - teenagers, not little kids. Quality of life matters too.
£30 for a meal for a family of at least 4? I’m intrigued.
Swipe left for the next trending thread