Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class/Upper middle class most frugal with money (in a good way!)

538 replies

Montana7 · 06/01/2022 10:01

Out of our friends with dc the same age as ours the most middle class & upper middle seem to be the most frugal & love a bargain.. Many are very high earners yet dc wear second hand clothes, uniforms, the families are very good with food & pride themselves on zero waste... Have great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips pre covid but always prided themselves on getting the best deals... I think its bloody brilliant & after realising how much disposable cash DH & I fritter away especially around Christmas I aspire to be more frugal... Aibu to suggest the mc/umc appreciate the value of money more or is it just the ones we know...

OP posts:
EleonorBronte · 06/01/2022 14:08

another class thread, i only see this stuff on MN so it's always a fun read Grin
the only people ive met in real life who discuss such things are very insecure, non-benefit-claiming working class. Their idea of hell is being culturally demoted to a council flat - the horrors!! Shock

vivainsomnia · 06/01/2022 14:07

I think what this thread has highlighted is how much people care about how the are perceived by others, whatever their financial situation.

I've been poor and quite comfortably off but in either situation, I have never cared for how people perceive me. I only care for people who see me as I really am the sane way I look at them. I couldn't care less what house, car, clothes my friends buy, they are my friends for who they are. I don't waste time trying to identify the social status and financials of strangers, neighbours, other parents, coworkers.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 06/01/2022 14:04

It’s not being frugal it’s just prioritising really

Some priorities can only be made when you have the money to do so no matter how frugal youre being

Blinkingbatshit · 06/01/2022 14:02

Ok, I’m probably one of those your basing your assumptions on😬….currently wearing 2nd hand jeans (eBay) and jumper (relation with a penchant for good stuff and knows I’ll always take their cast offs!). My kids wear 2nd hand mostly too - hand me downs from friends & relations…when I’m done with them I hand them on to another Mum (obv only the stuff mine haven’t worn through!). We don’t go for meals out (maybe twice a year) or have takeaways or go to the cinema, we have 2 uk weeks for holidays BUT we live in a big house with space outside for our pets (yes, those😆) - it’s not a choice to be ‘frugal’ we’re just choosing to spend on what matters to us….A family ski holiday would be pretty much a years upkeep for said pets - and to us they’re more important! It’s not being frugal it’s just prioritising really🤷🏼‍♀️. I certainly know we’re incredibly lucky…

onlychildhamster · 06/01/2022 14:02

I don't really think its about MC or WC

My DH and his sister are from the same family. His sister spent over £20k to 30k on her wedding and is now renting in an area with a huge prostitution and crime problem (not in the UK) cos she can't afford to spend more. her dress alone was over £1500.

My DH and I married in the registry office and bought our flat in London before even organizing a wedding celebration for the family. Which is why we have been married for 6 years but thanks to covid, have not had our wedding celebration. I would not spend £20k on a wedding, esp if I knew that my housing budget was on the low side. I would even prefer to spend the money to rent in a better location than on a single day. But to some people, weddings are very important. Having a gorgeous wedding is way more impressive than having a 2 bed flat in London, no one is that impressed at you buying a flat, its not like its a £1.4 million 4 bed house.

Different people prioritize different things.

bowlingalleyblues · 06/01/2022 14:00

I think having more than enough means you can make more effective use of your money. For example:

Have a bigger house, so can afford to buy in bulk, save baby things to hand on (and store second hand things from friends), wait to find what you need in Charity shop/ebay, pay for insurance upfront instead of installments (often 10% cheaper), not buy things on credit, have good credit so get cheaper interest rates when you do borrow, buy things when they are cheaper even if you don't need them right away, better financial literacy including within your family and friends.

I have a friend who is wealthy but always grew up with make do and mend so wears clothes till they wear out, saves tea bags to make another cup - doesn't waste, but is also generous giving to charity/others. No safaris though.

PegasusReturns · 06/01/2022 13:59

@BillyCongo

You didn’t afford to prioritise property and education by giving up spending on magazines and forgoing the occasional manicure. Don’t be so absurd Hmm

WeWashEverythingExceptLaundry · 06/01/2022 13:59

@CallMeNutribullet

Listen up plebeians! If you didn't spend your money on spray tans and tattoos, you too could have a couple of horses and send frogmella to boarding school!
It's (clearly) exaggerated for effect, but I do think this gets to the heart pf the issue, which is that financially comfortable people have a tendency to cast their own lifestyle as deserved (due to 'hard work' or, on this thread, 'wise choices', etc. etc.) and the struggles of the less well-off similarly as just deserts, in order to feel more comfortable with benefiting from inequality (and perhaps let themselves off the hook of doing anything about it).
RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 13:58

@NdujaWannaDance

Listen up plebeians! If you didn't spend your money on spray tans and tattoos, you too could have a couple of horses and send frogmella to boarding school!

Don't be silly, of course you couldn't.

You might be able to pay your rent though.

Fuck off!
AliceAldridge · 06/01/2022 13:58

The most frugal person I know is my DH, and it is just an inbuilt mentality thing from his childhood. He loves a bargain and doesn't like waste but nor is he stingy so he will be generous when necessary and never doesn't pay his way or not tip etc. His jumpers are neither expensive nor from Asda; they are usually many years old. He is generally in the same old fleece and he has about three pairs of of identical trousers which he wears til they get holes in then gives them to his mum to patch up

Sadly for him I am terrible with money! We are from a similar background, parents teachers, normal comp school etc. We do live in a fairly large house thanks to his saving habit but nor do we take expensive holidays (or eat other people's sandwiches!)

I know the perception is that very well off people don't spend much money and have old sofas etc but I personally think this notion is outdated among the under 50s at least. The people I know with enough money just buy what they want and up to date home furnishings seem to be a big part of that.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 13:57

@vivainsomnia

But plenty on here is talking about wearing £300 boots and a holey jumper. No one would mistake them for not having money But why define anyone and whether they have money or not based on what they wear?

I can as much wear expensive clothing one day (outdoor clothes because I'm out a lot in the rain, wind and cold) and be in jeans, trainers and jumper from Asda the next.

I'm still the same person, one who was counting every penny one day and now not having to ever look at my account balance to make a purchase.

No one is saying you are not the same person. But pretending like some people are doing that they don't care about status in terms of clothes because they wear scruffy old clothes when they are wearing old worn harbour coats or £300 boots with a holey jumper, is simply disingenuous.
JustAnotherPoster00 · 06/01/2022 13:57

Im currently being very virtuous and frugal my electricity has just alarmed to make me switch into emergency credit ignore the fact i dont have the money to top it up until tomorrow

Fimofriend · 06/01/2022 13:57

vivainsomnia I'm arguing against posters who insists that those who can afford things don't spend the money on them just because they can feel pride in it. I do it because I don't see the necessity of it and would be a waste of money, that's all. I don't require validation for my choices.

Exactly! Why would we spend money on something we don't see the value in owning? I like having a mobile phone, but it adds nothing to the value for me if it is an Iphone. My present phone can do everything I need a phone to do as well as many things I don't need.

The SIL who spends a lot of money on clothes and her hair actually doesn't have anyone in her life who appreciates it. She is doing it to brag to people who don't even realize she is wearing something it is worth bragging about. When her oldest was a baby she was in a mummy group with a lot of rich women as she lived close to an expensive area. They were not impressed either as they knew she couldn't actually afford to have the habits she had. I guess that is why I find it to be such a waste of money. If she spent the money because the items would give her joy even if she was all alone on an abandoned island then it would be money well spent. But she is obviously doing it to brag and it isn't even working, which is sad.

On the other hand, some of our frugal habits are still there because we lived below the poverty line for 8 years and now the habits are ingrained. My DH does try to get me to spend money on myself because we can afford it and he wants me to have nice things and I am getting better at it, but the fact of the matter is that if it is something just for me and not for the house or the children then I can't really seem to find the wallet. Yesterday I finally ordered the pinking shears, which have been on my wish list for years as I didn't get them this Christmas either and that felt like a very frivolous thing to do. So if someone asks me a question here on Mumsnet it might take awhile before I answer, as I might be busy admiring my pinking shears while whispering "My precious" Grin

NdujaWannaDance · 06/01/2022 13:55

Listen up plebeians! If you didn't spend your money on spray tans and tattoos, you too could have a couple of horses and send frogmella to boarding school!

Don't be silly, of course you couldn't.

You might be able to pay your rent though.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 13:55

@Peregrina

Charity shops like Oxfam move stock around to where they know it will sell best - so the Oxfam shop in a more upmarket area gets the designer label stuff, not the one in the poor area.
Which means if poor people want to be "frugal" by buying good quality second hand clothes, they have to pay out for a bus fare first.
WrittenInGold · 06/01/2022 13:55

@Peregrina

Charity shops like Oxfam move stock around to where they know it will sell best - so the Oxfam shop in a more upmarket area gets the designer label stuff, not the one in the poor area.
I have noticed this everywhere too.
WeWashEverythingExceptLaundry · 06/01/2022 13:54

Great posts from CSJobseeker and others.

It also struck me that the poster who listed her spending priorities (insurance, horses, pensions) and non-priorities (everyday clothes, 'general groceries') - clearly intending to demonstrate her wisdom and forethought with money and her middle-class values - could be spending some of that money on fairly produced food and clothes, so is literally profiting at others' expense. If we want to make society more sustainable all round, it occurs to me that some of these extremely selfish MC 'priorities' are going to have to change.

vivainsomnia · 06/01/2022 13:53

But plenty on here is talking about wearing £300 boots and a holey jumper. No one would mistake them for not having money
But why define anyone and whether they have money or not based on what they wear?

I can as much wear expensive clothing one day (outdoor clothes because I'm out a lot in the rain, wind and cold) and be in jeans, trainers and jumper from Asda the next.

I'm still the same person, one who was counting every penny one day and now not having to ever look at my account balance to make a purchase.

NdujaWannaDance · 06/01/2022 13:53

Don't forget the big screen tv, weekly takeaways and fags

I have no issue with big screens. As TVs got thinner and lighter it's easier for them to be bigger and the price of TVs has gone down over the years, even big ones. It's not 1958 and we don't all have to huddle around a TV with a screen the size of an A4 piece of paper.

But excessive takeaways and cigarettes, yes absolutely I will judge if you can't pay your rent or your gas bill.

LaBellina · 06/01/2022 13:53

Frogmella 🤣🤣🤣🤣

IntermittentParps · 06/01/2022 13:53

You're not being frugal if you keep horses ffs

The OP clearly says 'frugal in every other way'
But I guess you like to deliberately miss the point.

It sounds like they prioritise and spend on what they find important, and scrimp on what they don't. I don't know if that's a trait of a particular class or classes but I think it's a sensible one.

We had little money when I was a kid but I remember things at Christmas like my mum buying dates, nuts etc that people would have a token nibble at and then the rest would end up thrown away. She'd just say, 'I don't know why I buy them but you just do at Christmas, don't you?' Confused

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 13:53

@didihearthatright123456

My grandma used to collect the egg money years and years ago. She said it was always the "middle/Upper Classes" who she had problems getting money out of. The poor people who had nothing/not much would always try to give her something if not all of it.

I doubt much has changed

It is why when I was a cleaner I insisted on cash from well off people. Not because I want to cheat on my taxes as so many people claim on threads here. But because they always "forget" to transfer the money. Whereas if the cash wasn't there, I just walked and didn't do the clean.
CallMeNutribullet · 06/01/2022 13:53

Listen up plebeians! If you didn't spend your money on spray tans and tattoos, you too could have a couple of horses and send frogmella to boarding school!

WrittenInGold · 06/01/2022 13:52

I'm not upper middle class, probably lower middle class although on a very tight income, but I will say that buying nice stuff second hand is nice but harder when you're in a fix. E.g. kids school shoes broke recently. While normally I try and plan ahead and look around for second hand decent long wearing ones, I had to buy worse ones for more money because I didn't expect the shoes to break and hadn't had a chance to plan.

So. When I am a bit better off I spend time on Ebay and buy e.g. a decent winter coat second hand for the kids (two years big so it gets a lot of wear, than handed down!), but when I'm on a tight budget I can't make those kind of speculative purchases, and sometime find I HAVE to spend more when something is actually needed. And on a lesser quality item. So buying second hand isn't exactly just frugal, it's more a nice way to save money when you have a bit of extra money to spare. You can't guarantee the charity shop has your child's size of school shoes at the very moment their shoe sole unexpectedly falls off!

Midlander88 · 06/01/2022 13:51

I recently worked for an aristocratic family, at their enormous country house. The silk carpets and feather-stuffed furniture were indeed threadbare, and the crockery was old and chipped. They didn't even have a TV, and it looked like they hadn't decorated in 100 years, very frugal.

I came back to my extravagant rented 1-bed flat, turned on my 60" tv, sat in the living I just wasted £50 on repainting because I was bored of the previous colour, and felt very ashamed of myself indeed.