Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class/Upper middle class most frugal with money (in a good way!)

538 replies

Montana7 · 06/01/2022 10:01

Out of our friends with dc the same age as ours the most middle class & upper middle seem to be the most frugal & love a bargain.. Many are very high earners yet dc wear second hand clothes, uniforms, the families are very good with food & pride themselves on zero waste... Have great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips pre covid but always prided themselves on getting the best deals... I think its bloody brilliant & after realising how much disposable cash DH & I fritter away especially around Christmas I aspire to be more frugal... Aibu to suggest the mc/umc appreciate the value of money more or is it just the ones we know...

OP posts:
gogohm · 06/01/2022 14:33

I know what you mean because I'm really tight with money in many ways but splash out on certain things, nice but unusual holidays for instance. My kids had second hand clothes, we had cars for 12+ years but took 3 week tours around Europe etc.

vivainsomnia · 06/01/2022 14:32

Amazing how often the word 'decent' has been mentioned in this thread? What classifies something as 'decent'? The label? The popularity? My experience is that quality is sometimes associated with price but often isn't at all.

Whatinthelord · 06/01/2022 14:31

@PenguinIce

I do find it strange how:

Middle class people who buy their children second hand clothes but go on fancy holidays are frugal and something to aspire to. Yet lower class people who buy their children second hand clothes but have an iPhone haven’t ‘got their priorities right’ and should be shamed.

Yes. I think we need to be very aware of how our perceptions of people are shaped.
ChunkyKnit · 06/01/2022 14:30

A friend is mine is a very high-earning non-NHS surgical consultant.

She often posts on Facebook asking if anyone has a spare secondhand school tie, or asking to borrow an item to use for a Halloween costume or World Book Day etc.

I think it’s the confidence that wealth brings. Everyone knows she can afford that stuff so isn’t asking out of need. Whereas if someone less well-off asked, they may be afraid that they’re perceived as being in need.

BlondeDogLady · 06/01/2022 14:29

Honoured to be the first to present Sam Vimes’ theory of economic inequality:

It's like Brighthouse isn't it? People who can buy a washing machine outright will pay £300, the people who don't have £300 will buy it from Brighthouse and end up paying over £500 for the same appliance due to the high interest rates.

Same for Mortgages - the higher the LTV, the higher interest rates you pay.

This is not to mention pay day loans with extortionate interest rates, for people who are refused a loan by a Bank with more reasonable interest rates.

I know someone who plays poor, whereas in reality they have 8 properties - I'm guessing his wealth is mainly tied up in property which makes him cash poor. I don't understand why he doesn't sell some.

NdujaWannaDance · 06/01/2022 14:28

It’s diścussed a lot on this site because class and class distinctions absolutely do matter in the UK, and they matter a lot. Class drives everything, on every level, whether one as an individual subscribes to it or not.

That's true. It permeates everything, obvious and not so obvious.

The thing that irritates me is when people try to pretend it's a singularly British thing. It's not. There isn't a country on the planet that doesn't operate its own version of the class system. Maybe the rules and indicators are different but they still exist.

onlychildhamster · 06/01/2022 14:27

@RoyalFamilyFan The clothes really don't tell how rich a person is. Anyone with a credit card can buy expensive clothes. My cousin's wife who lives in a condo with a spa, swimming pool, tennis courts adores primark. Someone who wears cheap clothes might just be a lover of fast fashion, they buy clothes to discard after 1/2 wears. Or they might just wear the same badly made clothes multiple times, there is no rule. So their coats will be badly made.

More reliable indications are:

  1. When they bought their property and for what price- banks have affordability criteria
  2. their job
  3. what schools the kids go to- - even the bursary pupils at private schools nowadays tend to be above average/whether there is a nanny
  4. Talk of investments

Basically you can't tell from first glance. But if you must make a guess, accent/education/job (if it is an english person) are more reliable indicators of wealth. For a foreigner, many recent immigrants tend to be more affluent due to stricter visa regulations but not always.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 06/01/2022 14:26

It’s a good job some people are what a lot of posters are describing as thick and wasteful , and spend money on decent trainers/boots/coats/clothes .. otherwise you wouldn’t be able to buy these second hand at all!

Camembear · 06/01/2022 14:25

You. Not “guy”

EleonorBronte · 06/01/2022 14:25

On a serious note, i am very boring MC but did not prioritise housing. I did prioritise education, travel and art. I am not like the rest of my ilk, and have always valued being a free spirit over money. Many people who share a similar background to me think i am a bit odd but seem to respect my choice not follow a prescription lifestyle. However, the only people who have ever remarked that this is 'weird' have been WC, who seem to find my values suspicious Grin

Not all MC value the same things or share the same beliefs.
However there are traits I have perceived as WC that tend to be more 'solid' and less flexible, which remind me of the rigidity of UC.

I don't make my ethical position public, it seems such an odd thing to do, sharing details of your income and spending habits online. Nor do i care for performative 'boasting' concerning values. It all seems a bit insecure and competitive. MN is teeming with this, but since it is the internet, no one really cares how you spend, postulate or compete with your peers. No one cares what you prioritise or whether or not you spend money on ski holidays, expensive weddings or horses.

How you spend does not define you as a person, it is a very mixed bag, part imitation, partly passed down and generally put into you via the culture you were born into. I find it disturbing that there is so much attention and fixation upon class insecurity and 'performative spending' (my values are superior to yours, etc) on MN.

Camembear · 06/01/2022 14:25

If you keep horses and go on ski trips I don’t think frugal is the right word even if you try to save money on everything else. That’s just spending your money on the things you think are important. To me frugal means guy don’t have any habits which will burn thousands per year.

I think this is more flattery of perceived poshness/class status than anything else.

Nevermakeit · 06/01/2022 14:25

@Montana7

No not a lazy journalist at all just a mum wondering where I can start clawing back... An example would be school teacher collection, I gave 20 quid to put in pot as it was an "open" amount, had coffee after with one of the high earning mums & she asked me to pass on a fiver to the mum who was collecting... Also grumbling about having to give 3 other fivers for her other kids collections... I put 20 into each of my kids collections as I assumed that's what the others would do.. ( v affluent state school)
That is not being frugal. That is just being tight when it comes to spending on other people, not themselves!
Ariela · 06/01/2022 14:24

[quote RoyalFamilyFan]@ariela Surely the vets bills alone are high?[/quote]
No. Horse vets are amazingly cheap compared to dog/cat vets, when you consider they come to you.
Once a year annual jab (no call out fee as we're local) is just over £30, wormer you get online twice a year £40. If you're unlucky you'll get to need to call the vet out for something, but native ponies are quite hardy creatures generally. We found, for example, leg xrays were £150 vs £500 at the vet (requiring anaesthetic for a dog to keep still, horses are quite good at that and only a standing sedation needed if that because a horse can lock the knee to sleep standing up). Our natives were unshod - shoeing can add £80-90 every 6-8 weeks - and unshod effectively self trim their hooves much of the year due to road work, a trim if tied in with other horses on a farrier visit can come in about £15-£20, maybe 2-3x a year depending on the pony.

Give me horse vet costs over dog every time!

Blueeyedgirl21 · 06/01/2022 14:24

@Silverswirl what do your neighbours think when they pass you perfectly good shoes that they could sell on because they think you can’t afford them and then see you go off spending thousands on an ‘experience’? 😲

Floundery · 06/01/2022 14:23

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

vivainsomnia · 06/01/2022 14:22

you may not mean this, but it sounds awfully like a white person saying they don't see race
I'm talking about myself, not society but I know I'm not unusual and many feel the sane. Yet a cording to some posters, all those who are well off yet frugal or not interested in status are just hypocrites. Many are, many are not.

Ninkanink · 06/01/2022 14:21

It’s diścussed a lot on this site because class and class distinctions absolutely do matter in the UK, and they matter a lot. Class drives everything, on every level, whether one as an individual subscribes to it or not.

midsomermurderess · 06/01/2022 14:19

This site and its obsession with class. It's preposterous. Can't you recognise that you suffer from some deep social anxiety and work that out yourself? You must bore the arse out of people with your inadequacy, or invite deep pity.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 14:17

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips

How is this frugal?

It’s easy to save on clothes and food if:

  1. You’ve got things like holidays to look forward to,
  2. You have wealthy mates:/ family giving away good quality clothing
  3. You have a big fridge freezer to store things in and get the BOGOF etc deals without wasting anything,
  4. You’ve got money to buy in bulk and in advance

Especially re the holidays - you’ve got more chance of getting the deals if you buy well in advance, pay all in one go (sometimes but Jonny always cheaper I accept) and can snap things up as and when you see them.

You’ve basically described me tbh - we buy second hand clothes, shop fairly frugally, drive a modest car, have a modest tv but go on a few trips per year (not safari or skiing, mainly U.K. breaks), but I’d describe myself as an absolute spend thrift!

Yes I thought this. All these people getting good quality second-hand clothes handed down. I don't know anyone who could pass on stuff like this.
RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 14:16

@vivainsomnia you may not mean this, but it sounds awfully like a white person saying they don't see race.
I know I am judged and looked down on by some people because I am poorer. That is something I have been aware of my whole life and am fairly frequently reminded of it. I know nothing about brands, but I can still tell if a coat looks well made or cheaply made.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/01/2022 14:15
  • not, not Jonny

I don’t even know anyone named Jonny, but I can imagine Jonny going on lots of trips!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/01/2022 14:14

great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips

How is this frugal?

It’s easy to save on clothes and food if:

  1. You’ve got things like holidays to look forward to,
  2. You have wealthy mates:/ family giving away good quality clothing
  3. You have a big fridge freezer to store things in and get the BOGOF etc deals without wasting anything,
  4. You’ve got money to buy in bulk and in advance

Especially re the holidays - you’ve got more chance of getting the deals if you buy well in advance, pay all in one go (sometimes but Jonny always cheaper I accept) and can snap things up as and when you see them.

You’ve basically described me tbh - we buy second hand clothes, shop fairly frugally, drive a modest car, have a modest tv but go on a few trips per year (not safari or skiing, mainly U.K. breaks), but I’d describe myself as an absolute spend thrift!

vivainsomnia · 06/01/2022 14:13

But I do wonder why you can't see others social status? Are you autistic or really bad at understanding social cues?
I don't see because I don't look. I can't tell you whether my friends jackets and boots were bought at Asda or Berghaus because I don't pay attention to their jacket.

I also never judge someone based in their house or cars because it's very deceiving. My friend who lives in the nicest house is far from the wealthiest of my friends.

All this doesn't interest me. I only buy things on the basis of my needs. It doesn't cross my mind to ever contemplate what others might think of it.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 14:09

@vivainsomnia I think it is good not to care, although it is a luxury as well because discrimination is real.
But I do wonder why you can't see others social status? Are you autistic or really bad at understanding social cues?

Blinkingbatshit · 06/01/2022 14:09

I completely agree with you @JustAnotherPoster00 - the point I’m making it that we have a choice to do this, many others don’t.