Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class/Upper middle class most frugal with money (in a good way!)

538 replies

Montana7 · 06/01/2022 10:01

Out of our friends with dc the same age as ours the most middle class & upper middle seem to be the most frugal & love a bargain.. Many are very high earners yet dc wear second hand clothes, uniforms, the families are very good with food & pride themselves on zero waste... Have great holidays think safaris, multiple ski trips pre covid but always prided themselves on getting the best deals... I think its bloody brilliant & after realising how much disposable cash DH & I fritter away especially around Christmas I aspire to be more frugal... Aibu to suggest the mc/umc appreciate the value of money more or is it just the ones we know...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Montana7 · 14/01/2022 10:39

@CSJobseeker

I mean, even the cake example is crazy. Someone with not much money is likely to buy their kids party snacks at Aldi or Tesco.

Most wealthy people, if they want a 'luxury' cake, would not buy one at the supermarket. They go to a nice local bakery, or Bettys, or the farm shop etc. The person buying the 'nice' cake at Tesco is probably at the mid/upper end of middle income. Comfortable enough to afford the Taste The Difference range or whatever, but not 'rich'.

The most mc or umc mums I know would "throw" a masterpiece of a cake together themselves insisting it only took an hour & it's so basic & offer to whatsapp the recipe Grin
OP posts:
RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 16:53

Less in relative terms. Basically a much smaller proportion of disposable income.

PattyPan · 08/01/2022 16:50

@CSJobseeker

In terms of charities, all the evidence shows that wealthier people donate less overall. They may donate to different charities, but they also donate less.
Do you know if it's less in relative or absolute terms? I'm assuming relative but which could still be more in absolute terms?

Giving What We Can/Founders Pledge type approaches are relatively popular in my circle (urban, highly educated) but have yet to go more mainstream in the wider UMC/MC I think. I need to get more evangelical Smile

RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 15:20

@CSJobseeker I totally agree that the whole point of the rules is to keep people out.
I remember The Crown when Thatcher and her husband appeared dressed for dinner far too early. That was widely ridiculed as unlikely, but Thatcher's closest aides said the feel of The Crown in how Thatcher was treated was correct. I wondered if Thatcher and her husband were judged by the RF for a so-called faux pas that would have gone over the heads of most watching the programme. So instead the programme used a more obvious example so people could "get it".

CSJobseeker · 08/01/2022 15:14

We have a market, but it's better for meat (which is pricy) than fresh veg. We don't have a Heron either, despite being up north.

CSJobseeker · 08/01/2022 15:13

[quote RoyalFamilyFan]@CSJobseeker I dont move in the circles to know UC types properly. But I do remember in the village where some of my family grew up people who had made money started to buy up some of the large houses in the area that had traditionally being owned by people who inherited their wealth.
And although I am sure it is not just down to this, I do remember being aware of certain sneering from UC people at people they saw lower down the scale than them, being able to afford the property they could not.
So not as simple as jealousy. But outrage more that people they saw as social inferiors, could buy things they could not.
The aristocracy and Royal Family as well traditionally sold the idea to poor people that they were better than them. The Queen even believes that she is anointed by God. So if anyone can live their life if they make enough money, that rather challenges the idea they are inherently better than us. This the regular sneering at "new money" who does not how to behave properly - or so the myth goes.[/quote]
This makes sense. Also, the emphasis on certain types of behaviour being signs of 'class' makes it more of a closed shop - it puts up walls to protect their status.

I.e. Anyone can earn money and be well off, but they won't threaten the elevated status of the upper classes for as long as the UC can maintain etiquette/behaviour/accent distinctions. This is why it is impossible for ordinary people to properly fit in when mixing with the UMC and UC, because as soon as you learn one set of rules they will add new ones. Literally the whole point of the rules is to keep people like you out - an insurmountable barrier.

RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 15:07

Thanks. In my city we have ethnic independent supermarkets. They are cheaper for some things such as fresh herbs and dried pulses, and more expensive for other things.

CSJobseeker · 08/01/2022 15:07

In terms of charities, all the evidence shows that wealthier people donate less overall. They may donate to different charities, but they also donate less.

PattyPan · 08/01/2022 15:04

@RoyalFamilyFan I think Farmfoods has stores in some parts of the south but don’t think there is one in my county. There is Home Bargains and B&M but my local ones seem to mostly sell snack foods like biscuits and pot noodles and things rather than actual food for meals. So where I live it’s pretty much Aldi, Lidl, Iceland. We have Food Warehouse as well but I’ve never been so not sure what that’s like. The Home Bargains and Food Warehouse are too difficult to get to without a car. We also have a lot of ethnic/independent supermarkets in my town but they are actually generally more expensive than chain supermarkets. We don’t have a market.

RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 14:55

@PattyPan that was me and I dint know Heron did not exist in the south. So what other cheap food stores do you have?

PattyPan · 08/01/2022 14:53

I’ve only just read this thread so a bit behind. But I think a few posters have misunderstood the purpose of charity shops. They are not there to provide charity in the form of cheap goods to poor people. They are there to raise money for their charities, and they have a duty to maximise the amount they raise. So of course they are going to try to sell things for as much as they can, and if that means targeting fancier stuff to better-off areas then that’s just good business sense.

The charity donation point was an interesting one and got me thinking about whether different classes donate to different charities. I would imagine working class people are more likely to donate to charities like Help for Heroes or charities set up for local sick children and things like that as there tends to be a stronger sense of community. Personally I would not donate to those or Dogs Trust because I don’t see them as an effective use of money within my set of values, so I donate primarily to highly effective malaria and tropical disease charities in developing countries.

To the poster who wondered why Heron doesn’t get mentioned much on here compared to Aldi - it doesn’t exist in the south.

RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 14:30

@CSJobseeker I dont move in the circles to know UC types properly. But I do remember in the village where some of my family grew up people who had made money started to buy up some of the large houses in the area that had traditionally being owned by people who inherited their wealth.
And although I am sure it is not just down to this, I do remember being aware of certain sneering from UC people at people they saw lower down the scale than them, being able to afford the property they could not.
So not as simple as jealousy. But outrage more that people they saw as social inferiors, could buy things they could not.
The aristocracy and Royal Family as well traditionally sold the idea to poor people that they were better than them. The Queen even believes that she is anointed by God. So if anyone can live their life if they make enough money, that rather challenges the idea they are inherently better than us. This the regular sneering at "new money" who does not how to behave properly - or so the myth goes.

CSJobseeker · 08/01/2022 14:20

It is just envy IMO

Interesting. The people that tend to do the sneering are the established UMC / gentry (i.e. inherited wealth). Do you think they envy the ability to earn your own money through your own merits (as opposed to through getting a leg up from your connections)?

I know that non-wealthy people sometimes also sneer at 'new money' (you see it plenty on MN), but I think that it all has its origins in the fact that the gentry have traditionally looked down on the trade/mercantile class due to feeling threatened by them. (The way the Middletons were treated is an example.)

The MC and lower MC try to curry favour with the gentry, and therefore adopt/espouse their prejudices.

RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 13:35

I think working to earn money is better than inheriting it. Inheriting money is an accident of birth, nothing more.

CharSiu · 08/01/2022 13:03

I am a British born Chinese, education is valued above everything by Chinese families. I married a beautifully spoken Englishman who did grow up with ponies, servants and went to a famous public school.

Over the last 30 years due to his Fathers financial decisions they have fallen on harder times. His Mother will now be downsizing and moving near us. She still has a few ancestral portraits and some family silver.

So that generation due to the shocking decisions of his Father lost the actual money. MIL is as a person still a very gracious human who glides about and treats every single person she meets well but is not in the least bit practical. I think she was sent to a finishing school.

MIL ancestry is French Huguenot. FIL ancestors are English and they have an ancient Anglo Saxon name, one of DH paternal ancestors was a signatory on Charles I death warrant.

We are quiet studious types that were so clever as children our contemporaries found us a little odd. That oddness is what made us a match though we have such differing backgrounds.

We are careful with money but it is a choice not a necessity and I’m grateful for that having had a financially tough childhood.

From what I can gather it’s the aspiring middle classes that are obsessed with class indicators. It seems to show a fragility in the sense of self.

Lampzade · 08/01/2022 11:09

@SleepingStandingUp

I don't get the sneering at new money. Some will be lottery wins etc but surely for most it means they've worked to earn it, not just inherited money someone else worked to earn?
Exactly It is just envy IMO
RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 10:40

Everyone knows if you buy quality it lasts longer. But first, not everyone can afford to. And secondly, not everyone wants things to last.
When younger I always used to buy clothes that would last, plus every year one or two fashion things. I knew I would be unlikely to wear the fashion things any longer than a year or two at most, so they didn't have to be quality that would last for twenty years.
Similarly cheap paperbacks that I read once don't have to be excellent quality. Just last long enough for me to read them.

SleepingStandingUp · 08/01/2022 05:59

I don't get the sneering at new money. Some will be lottery wins etc but surely for most it means they've worked to earn it, not just inherited money someone else worked to earn?

GoLittleRockstar · 07/01/2022 19:33

@cam22. Doesn’t that just show the merits of that approach though? That you have things that last and can pass on? Including relationships.

Also my granma, ultra working class to the point of being revolutionary (literally) used to say “buy cheap; buy dear”. DH’s mum says a variation “buy cheap; buy twice”.

xnowayout · 07/01/2022 19:12

@forcedfun agreed no looking down for me. Everyone was “new money” at some point.

Cam22 · 07/01/2022 17:49

@GoLittleRockstar

Hmm. I once knew a Lord of the realm (by birth rather than elevation). He was both old and old school.

He was judicious in his spending but never skimped. He only ever bought what he needed, but when he needed something he always bought the best and never short-changed a retailer or service provider. Never, ever stinted it’s spoiled the ship for a ha’penny worth of tar.

So first class rail/air tickets, best quality of everything, always tipped very well, never haggled. He was a very loyal repeat customer in many cases.

I trust he didn’t have constant renovations done to his property and exchange one set of antiques for another at regular intervals, though. (Bought in, naturally). I imagine his possessions were inherited or were gradually acquired.
forcedfun · 07/01/2022 17:45

Also @xnowayout I don't like the "looking down on " element of the way people talk about new money. I don't see one way as better than the other. Our neighbours are very "new money" - constant renovations, new everything, huge SUVs, etc. But they are genuinely lovely people who helped me care for our elderly neighbors and I genuinely enjoy their company.

xnowayout · 07/01/2022 17:15

It’s fine saying new money has no class, they are all about showing off, real wealthy people don’t spend any money etc. those ancestral homes were considered very bling when they were built, and certainly didn’t have threadbare carpets.

GoLittleRockstar · 07/01/2022 17:05

Hmm. I once knew a Lord of the realm (by birth rather than elevation). He was both old and old school.

He was judicious in his spending but never skimped. He only ever bought what he needed, but when he needed something he always bought the best and never short-changed a retailer or service provider. Never, ever stinted it’s spoiled the ship for a ha’penny worth of tar.

So first class rail/air tickets, best quality of everything, always tipped very well, never haggled. He was a very loyal repeat customer in many cases.

CSJobseeker · 07/01/2022 16:44

@Cherryana

Oh I've got another good one.

Genuinely said to my Father in law (a gardener)... 'Why don't you just sell a painting?'.

Why not in deed.

Grin
Swipe left for the next trending thread