Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re the call for a retrial for Ghislaine Maxwell

90 replies

FluffyBooBoo · 06/01/2022 08:56

Apparently the defence are calling for a retrial because one of the jurors was a victim of child sex abuse - they had to answer questions, one of which was (I am paraphrasing) 'have you, your family or friends experienced sexual abuse, sexual harassment or sexual assault'

AIBU to think that there are very few women out there that haven't experienced some form of sexual harassment, and the chances of anyone (male or female) not knowing someone affected by one of these things is highly unlikely? And that the people on the jury therefore are likely to be men that don't talk about these things? Not convinced that's ideal tbh.

OP posts:
AdmiralCain · 06/01/2022 10:49

A juror was perverting and coercing the jury during deliberations. She 100% has the right to a retrial with an impartial jury.

Brainwave89 · 06/01/2022 10:23

As was the case before the trial, her defence team will look for every opportunity to appeal her case or get it thrown out. However small the opportunity an appeal will come. There are real risks in this. Cosby was released on a technicality and rich and powerful people have opportunities to subvert justice. What I would say sadly is that the US does better in bringing the rich and powerful to justice. I fear in the UK a) she would never have come to trail b) if she did she would have been acquitted.

PigeonLittle · 06/01/2022 10:10

@Littlecaf

I thought in the States jurors are allowed to share their experiences once the verdict is given?
Good god this is depressing.

I agree with the OP as well. A lot of women I know have been assaulted as a child, even if they dont categorise it as such.

DisforDarkChocolate · 06/01/2022 10:02

I doubt anyone would be able to say no to that.

FluffyBooBoo · 06/01/2022 10:01

I don't think the wording on the pre=trial questionnaire would eliminate a lot of people (especially women) from being on the jury in these kind of trials

Don't you? You don't think most people have a friend or a family member that has been subject to some form of sexual assault, abuse or harassment? You are very fortunate. I wish I thought the same.

OP posts:
Cam77 · 06/01/2022 09:57

One good thing about this dragging out longer is that it might give the media a chance to do their job and start asking questions about other famous British and American politicians who seemed to have very close relationships with Epstein.

CurzonDax · 06/01/2022 09:40

I don't think the wording on the pre=trial questionnaire would eliminate a lot of people (especially women) from being on the jury in these kind of trials.

There was another thread on here a few days ago, about how most women have been harassed at some point, and it had a list of things that would define harassment.

Have I been cat called and wolf-whistled at, and been looked up and down by men when out before? Yes. Have any of these men ever continued to approach me, and harass/pressure me to perform sexual acts on them? I'm incredibly grateful to be able to answer no to that question.

Whilst, I am no belittling the looks and cat calls (and agree these should not happen), but there is a difference between those happening, and a man then coming up to you and trying to persistently persuade you to have sex with him (and by consistently, I do not mean long-term, this could happen at a single event, say in a pub, where the same person keeps trying to com over and approach you).

I also think that abuse and assault are a bit more clearer in the statement, than harassment is.

However, I would have answered no to that question, based on how I interpreted it.

girlmom21 · 06/01/2022 09:36

@appleturnovers

YANBU and I've seen this brought up as an issue in rape trials before.

The potential jurors are often asked if they have been the victim of rape/sexual assault, and excluded if they answer yes, but they are not asked if they have perpetrated or enabled rape and sexual assault, making it more likely that the jury will be comprised of people who identify themselves with the defendant.

Nobody who hasn't been convicted will admit to it and nobody who has been convicted is allowed to serve on a jury
appleturnovers · 06/01/2022 09:33

YANBU and I've seen this brought up as an issue in rape trials before.

The potential jurors are often asked if they have been the victim of rape/sexual assault, and excluded if they answer yes, but they are not asked if they have perpetrated or enabled rape and sexual assault, making it more likely that the jury will be comprised of people who identify themselves with the defendant.

appleturnovers · 06/01/2022 09:30

@ZenNudist

Well it's not true that most people have experienced sexual abuse as a child. Or necessarily know anyone who has. If the juror lied that's bad news.
1 in 4 girls and 1 in 6 boys are sexually abused. If it hasn't happened to you, you definitely know someone it has happened to, although they might not have told you.
girlmom21 · 06/01/2022 09:28

@TheReluctantPhoenix she'll be killed when she gives evidence against the wrong person

Alexandra2001 · 06/01/2022 09:27

@girlmom21

Who knows? but knowing who else was involved and also her side of the events can only be a good thing.

For too long the rich and powerful have treated laws and not applying to them.

Why seek a retrial just hear the same evidence presented and get the same result? it wasn't a split verdict.

Tanith · 06/01/2022 09:26

I remember a similar case in the US, where a juror used his experience of sexual abuse to convince the jury that a daycare owner and his wife were guilty of mass sexual abuse, I think it was in North Carolina.
The owners were found guilty and sentenced to years in prison.
Later the charges were dismissed: there were a lot of problems with the prosecution case.

GM should certainly have the right to appeal her conviction if something similar has happened here.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 06/01/2022 09:24

@Alexandra2001

If i were GM i would be seeking a tell all deal and get a reduced sentence, its inconceivable she acted alone nor that JE was the only abuser.

I wonder if she regrets not giving evidence herself.

I suspect like most of the people involved, she doesn’t accept that she’s done anything wrong.
TheReluctantPhoenix · 06/01/2022 09:22

@girlmom21,

Yes, I think a deal could massively benefit her (although not really what this thread is about). Ambitious U.S D.As want big scalps. I am not a real expert but their position seems a combination of legal and political (and something that does not seem a good idea to me).

If Ghislaine could deliver up some famous scalps on a platter, she might get her sentence considerably reduced and negotiate serving it in a ‘club fed’ jail, rather than serving any ‘hard time’.

Not doing this makes one either admire her loyalty or think she is more frightened of those she might give up than the jail time.

girlmom21 · 06/01/2022 09:17

@Alexandra2001

If i were GM i would be seeking a tell all deal and get a reduced sentence, its inconceivable she acted alone nor that JE was the only abuser.

I wonder if she regrets not giving evidence herself.

Do you honestly think it'd benefit her in any way?
AlternativePerspective · 06/01/2022 09:16

As you say many people have experienced sexual abuse, mainly women. And their experience is important and should not be seen as invalid. Are others really saying that if you have experience of a crime your opinion has no value? Will definitely skew juries. And are potential jurists asked if they have ever raped assaulted or harassed women? no, it doesn’t. The trial is about other people, not a platform for the jury to give their own experiences, especially when you haven’t declared those experiences and have then used them to influence a verdict.

user1471447924 · 06/01/2022 09:16

As frustrating at it is, if someone has done something that means she has not had a fair trial, she should be allowed a retrial.

AlternativePerspective · 06/01/2022 09:14

The point is that the jury must convict based on the evidence that they have witnessed in court, not based on the experiences of others who use their own situations to influence them.

It wasn’t relevant that this particular Jura had been sexually abused because he wasn’t abused by GM, and it was not about him, it was about her victims.

Alexandra2001 · 06/01/2022 09:14

If i were GM i would be seeking a tell all deal and get a reduced sentence, its inconceivable she acted alone nor that JE was the only abuser.

I wonder if she regrets not giving evidence herself.

Totallydefeated · 06/01/2022 09:14

@TheReluctantPhoenix

There seems, these days, and a lot on this forum, to exist the opinion that a fair trial under the law is not that important for certain crimes. In fact, the opinion seems to be that a trial merely exists for the humiliation of the defendant and justice for the victims.

Show trials are very popular in repressive regimes, for just the above reasons, with the outcome never in doubt.

A retrial is not being called for because a juror shared their experiences, it is being called because the juror failed to declare a bias when specifically asked (they said that they ‘rushed through’ the form).

If the trial was flawed, there should be a retrial. In fact, the more heinous the crime, the more justice should be seen to be fair and even handed.

Agree
catzwhiskas · 06/01/2022 09:13

As you say many people have experienced sexual abuse, mainly women. And their experience is important and should not be seen as invalid. Are others really saying that if you have experience of a crime your opinion has no value? Will definitely skew juries. And are potential jurists asked if they have ever raped assaulted or harassed women?

girlmom21 · 06/01/2022 09:13

@drpet49

Why on earth did he go public? Stupid man
Because there's an awful lot of money to be made out of such a huge trial
FluffyBooBoo · 06/01/2022 09:12

[quote sweetbellyhigh]@FluffyBooBoo

The jury selection isn't the reason for the retrial call (as you have stated in your OP)

And it is normal to try to assemble a biased jury, that is entirely the point of the defence team.[/quote]
The news report that I saw stated that this was the reason. And as I've said, that isn't related to the question.

Which is basically AIBU to think that most women have been subject to some form of sexual harassment and so there's a tiny number of people that don't know someone affected by one of these things.

OP posts:
TheReluctantPhoenix · 06/01/2022 09:11

There seems, these days, and a lot on this forum, to exist the opinion that a fair trial under the law is not that important for certain crimes. In fact, the opinion seems to be that a trial merely exists for the humiliation of the defendant and justice for the victims.

Show trials are very popular in repressive regimes, for just the above reasons, with the outcome never in doubt.

A retrial is not being called for because a juror shared their experiences, it is being called because the juror failed to declare a bias when specifically asked (they said that they ‘rushed through’ the form).

If the trial was flawed, there should be a retrial. In fact, the more heinous the crime, the more justice should be seen to be fair and even handed.