Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re the call for a retrial for Ghislaine Maxwell

90 replies

FluffyBooBoo · 06/01/2022 08:56

Apparently the defence are calling for a retrial because one of the jurors was a victim of child sex abuse - they had to answer questions, one of which was (I am paraphrasing) 'have you, your family or friends experienced sexual abuse, sexual harassment or sexual assault'

AIBU to think that there are very few women out there that haven't experienced some form of sexual harassment, and the chances of anyone (male or female) not knowing someone affected by one of these things is highly unlikely? And that the people on the jury therefore are likely to be men that don't talk about these things? Not convinced that's ideal tbh.

OP posts:
lightnesspixie · 06/01/2022 15:59

As I said in the other thread: a very clever Maxwell plant was that juror ...

MrsWhites · 06/01/2022 15:56

I agree that a retrial is fair in this instance.

The juror didn’t only have his own opinions and experiences, he admits that he used his experiences as a way to sway other jurors and that it did change the direction that the jury deliberations were going in.

All very suspicious though that he would openly admit to this!

Lazypuppy · 06/01/2022 15:24

Proesecutors are obviously worried as they are suggesting appointing a lawyer for the juror. The questionnaire to become a juror ia a huge document and asnwering yes to that specific question doesn't mean you won't be a juror, just more questions will be asked to check suitability.

This juror has screwed up big time and could be the sole reason the conviction is overturned

2Gen · 06/01/2022 15:06

@appleturnovers

YANBU and I've seen this brought up as an issue in rape trials before.

The potential jurors are often asked if they have been the victim of rape/sexual assault, and excluded if they answer yes, but they are not asked if they have perpetrated or enabled rape and sexual assault, making it more likely that the jury will be comprised of people who identify themselves with the defendant.

I didn't know that and I'm horrified. It does explain how too many sex offenders go free or are given unjustly lenient sentences though. OP I suspect most women have experienced some sort of sexual harrassment or even assault, even if it's just having their bums grabbed by some drunken letch. A young fella who is not rebuked and corrected for such behaviour, which is a sort of misogyny and sexual deviance, only gets worse as he get older. There are men who think they have the right to women's bodies regardless of what WE want all over the planet, they're like a disease!
Hereward1332 · 06/01/2022 15:02

But you are saying that the point of a jury is that all jurors come with experience, and should judge accordingly. You cannot distinguish between prejudice you may agree with and that you don't, as per your differentiation. In this specific case, it seems the juror's thought process has been to add to witness testimony on the assumption that the defendant is guilty of a crime similar to that he suffered, and attempt to influence other jurors on that basis.

melj1213 · 06/01/2022 15:02

@PigeonLittle

There's a difference between the prejudice of "A person of that look once hit me"

And "I was once hit"

But whether you have the former or the latter prejudice you should not be using it to make a decision in someone else's trial, and you definitely shouldn't be telling the other jurors about your experience
BlwyddynNewydd2022 · 06/01/2022 14:58

Call me a tinfoil hat wearing conspiracy theorist, but how timely that a person has spoken out knowing it could cause a re-trial. Wonder if any money's post trial has crossed hands ....

PigeonLittle · 06/01/2022 14:56

There's a difference between the prejudice of "A person of that look once hit me"

And "I was once hit"

Hereward1332 · 06/01/2022 14:52

@pigeonlittle

Not really. Jurors are expected to make a judgement based on the evidence presented in court, not on their prejudices. In this case, a juror has claimed he tried to influence other jurors based on his own bias. Hypothetically, let's say a juror in an assault trial claimed that they had been assaulted by someone who looked like the defendant so thought he was guilty; that would clearly not be fair as the defendant has no opportunity to answer.

Jurors should make judgements purely on the evidence produced in court, not on their own pre-judgements. They may have bias, but should not seek to influence other jurors on this basis.

Tanith · 06/01/2022 14:50

I think everyone does have their own personal opinions and biases.
What should not happen - and seems to have happened - is the juror using his or her biases to sway the other jurors.
They're there to reach a verdict based on the evidence presented, not because Juror X was once the victim of a similar crime to the one being tried.

melj1213 · 06/01/2022 14:48

The reason why we have jurors is to have a verdict of your peers. It would be impossible for most criminal trials to remove all personal experience etc.

Nobody expects jurors to remove all personal experience but they also cannot use that personal experience to influence other jurors when they are meant to be making an impartial judgement.

The jury is meant to judge the case on its evidence alone, if you have a juror saying "When I was in X scenario similar to Y scenario in the case, ABC happened" to the other jurors that experience is irrelevant to the case, but may influence other jurors as to an outcome they may not have come to if they only looked at the case evidence alone.

PigeonLittle · 06/01/2022 14:29

@Hereward1332

Jurors are expected to judge a case purely on the evidence laid out and examined in court. This juror stated that he adduced evidence from personal experience that could not be challenged by the defence. No matter what the crime, a fair trial means that the defence should have the opportunity to challenge any evidence which may be used to reach a verdict. It's not about bias but the inability of the defence to address that bias.
The reason why we have jurors is to have a verdict of your peers. It would be impossible for most criminal trials to remove all personal experience etc.

If ee wanted purely independent and objective verdicts trials would only have a judge, surely?

Hereward1332 · 06/01/2022 13:42

Jurors are expected to judge a case purely on the evidence laid out and examined in court. This juror stated that he adduced evidence from personal experience that could not be challenged by the defence. No matter what the crime, a fair trial means that the defence should have the opportunity to challenge any evidence which may be used to reach a verdict. It's not about bias but the inability of the defence to address that bias.

melj1213 · 06/01/2022 13:29

@appleturnovers

YANBU and I've seen this brought up as an issue in rape trials before.

The potential jurors are often asked if they have been the victim of rape/sexual assault, and excluded if they answer yes, but they are not asked if they have perpetrated or enabled rape and sexual assault, making it more likely that the jury will be comprised of people who identify themselves with the defendant.

If you asked the question it would be redundant - anyone who has been convicted of rape or serial assault is not allowed to sit on a jury and anyone who hasn't been convicted is hardly going to admit it on a jury selection form.

At the end of the day the juror lied on their selection form and then used their own experiences to influence the rest of the jury - that is not allowed. Juries are supposed to be impartial and judge purely on the facts of the case, they aren't supposed to bring their own personal situation into the jury room. Nobody can stop personal internal biases and experiences but if they are going to affect your ability to judge the case purely on its facts then that means you are not suitable to be on that particular jury.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 06/01/2022 13:26

@TheReluctantPhoenix

There seems, these days, and a lot on this forum, to exist the opinion that a fair trial under the law is not that important for certain crimes. In fact, the opinion seems to be that a trial merely exists for the humiliation of the defendant and justice for the victims.

Show trials are very popular in repressive regimes, for just the above reasons, with the outcome never in doubt.

A retrial is not being called for because a juror shared their experiences, it is being called because the juror failed to declare a bias when specifically asked (they said that they ‘rushed through’ the form).

If the trial was flawed, there should be a retrial. In fact, the more heinous the crime, the more justice should be seen to be fair and even handed.

I agree completely with this, although God knows I don't want to see GM exonerated (I, too, as a rape victim have a vested interest in justice for the Epstein victims, recognise that this does not make me an impartial bystander, and therefore would also be biased and unsuitable to sit on that jury). But justice has to be clear, impartial, transparent, and as far as possible infalliable.

At the very least this loose-lipped juror has made the case vulnerable to appeal. If due process is not followed now in terms of answering the objections of her lawyers, she could end up getting off scot-free.
That's not to say similar issues don't go on in UK jury deliberations too. The difference here is that we never get to find out about it.

This juror really is an utter tool.

Malibuismysecrethome · 06/01/2022 13:14

And so it begins ....

VeryLongBeeeeep · 06/01/2022 12:30

If having previously experienced sexual abuse or harassment caused jurors to influence verdicts routinely, we'd see a much higher conviction rate of rape cases here.

This sounds like the juror was completely unable to separate their experiences from the facts of the case and attempted, if not succeeded, to unduly influence his peers. In that situation, a retrial is absolutely appropriate.

MorningStarling · 06/01/2022 12:08

@Tobleroney

I don't get why jury members are giving interviews to the daily mail - the source of this - a short while later TBH! Should have known it could jeapordise it
In America jurors are free to discuss the case afterwards. With a high-profile case being on the jury can lead to life-changing sums, especially if the other jurors don't want to speak.

The juror in question knows that he needs to cash in as soon as possible. One, the issue is hot and he needs to sell his story whilst people are interested. Two, if all the other jurors sell their stories, he will earn less.

This contrasts to the British system for example where jurors are not allowed to discuss a case in this manner.

MorningStarling · 06/01/2022 12:04

The answers the jury gives don't prevent them being selected. Just because someone says "yes I've been raped" doesn't bar them from being chosen, it just leads to further questions to assess their suitability - whether they can judge a case on its merits, not on their own personal opinions.

From what I've heard the Maxwell case is clearly deserving of a retrial. A juror has to judge a case on the evidence, nothing more. Experience or opinion (e.g. that victims often get facts wrong or forget things) is not usually relevant. The jury listens to the evidence and decides what the truth is most likely to be.

A juror who is a victim of abuse might have behaved in a certain way or have certain gaps in their memories. That doesn't mean that every victim's experience is the same.

If the prosecution call an expert witness who testifies that victims often forget things, that's evidence and can be used by the jury.

If a juror could use their own personal experience in their deliberations there would be no reason to bar someone connected to the defendant from being in the jury. "I've known the guy for years and he's never attacked me, so he must be innocent."

sadpapercourtesan · 06/01/2022 12:00

OP I said exactly the same thing: "Aren't there any women on the jury, then? Because if there are, they will almost certainly have been sexually assaulted at some point"

I don't know any women who haven't been subject to some form of vile sexual behaviour from men.

IMO having the victims of sexual assault represented on the jury is par for the course, given how common it is. I'll be disgusted if she ends up with a mistrial over it.

x2boys · 06/01/2022 11:54

Is it ever possible to have a completely impartial,Jury ,in a cross section of society ,all the jurors are going to have, their own experience,s ,and their own morals etc particularly in such a high profile case.

Tobleroney · 06/01/2022 11:28

I don't get why jury members are giving interviews to the daily mail - the source of this - a short while later TBH! Should have known it could jeapordise it

FluffyBooBoo · 06/01/2022 11:06

@AdmiralCain

A juror was perverting and coercing the jury during deliberations. She 100% has the right to a retrial with an impartial jury.
But is it possible to have an impartial jury, if impartiality is based on neither them nor any friend or family member having experienced sexual abuse/assault/harassment?
OP posts:
Suzanne999 · 06/01/2022 10:58

@GrimDamnFanjo

It's very frustrating that her lawyers appear to have found a reason to appeal the verdict.
They’ll find any reason —— there was a y in the day, one of the jurors wore glasses / had curly hair / straight hair/ was tall/ short. They don’t care what the reason is, or how far fetched it is, it keeps their payments coming, keeps them in work.
Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 06/01/2022 10:53

Yes, most women have experience of sexual abuse, harassment or know someone who does. I work in mental health and have found that it is so so common.

For the jurors - as well as the form, in the states both sides get to question potential jurors and reject them - this is what jury consultants get paid a lot of money to advise on. Maxwells team used all their challenges when the jury was being selected.

Of course her defence will try to use this.