Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re the call for a retrial for Ghislaine Maxwell

90 replies

FluffyBooBoo · 06/01/2022 08:56

Apparently the defence are calling for a retrial because one of the jurors was a victim of child sex abuse - they had to answer questions, one of which was (I am paraphrasing) 'have you, your family or friends experienced sexual abuse, sexual harassment or sexual assault'

AIBU to think that there are very few women out there that haven't experienced some form of sexual harassment, and the chances of anyone (male or female) not knowing someone affected by one of these things is highly unlikely? And that the people on the jury therefore are likely to be men that don't talk about these things? Not convinced that's ideal tbh.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GrimDamnFanjo · 02/04/2022 12:54

Is it correct that she won't learn her sentence till June?

Motherdare · 02/04/2022 00:46

No retrial. Conviction stands.

Viviennemary · 22/01/2022 09:45

If the other girls recruited why are they not being prosecuted.

sweetbellyhigh · 22/01/2022 09:27

@melj1213

It really isn't. That's what the words say but look at the reality. The justice system is set up to protect the privileged and endorse systemic abuse of the vulnerable. Words don't change that.

melj1213 · 08/01/2022 10:36

@JanuaryBluehoo

It would be an insult for the victims to do a re trial.

This isn't like finding out someone is a kkk member or something.
Why is it something that needs disclosure it's deeply personal?

It would also be an insult to the justice system not to have a retrial.

The entire justice system is set up on the premise that everyone - regardless of the crime - deserves the right to a fair and just trial. That means not having people on a jury who have a bias that means they cannot impartially judge the accused on the evidence alone.

It needs disclosure so that the defence and the prosecution can ask the juror more questions to ensure the accused gets a fair trial. Just answering "yes" to being the victim of sexual abuse or rape does not mean that you would be automatically removed from the jury pool, but it would mean you were flagged for extra questioning to ensure that your personal experience would not impact you to the point that you could not make an impartial decision based on the facts of the case alone. If you could assure the prosecution and defence that you may have been raped in the past but would not use that experience to make a judgement, or use that information to influence any of the other jurors decisions, then you would be allowed on the jury.

In this case, the juror didn't make the defence and prosecution aware of their history but then went on to use it in the jury room to influence the other jurors decision - this means that the judgement may not have been made on just the facts and evidence of the case, and therefore was not a fair trial.

Blossomtoes · 07/01/2022 23:03

Why is it something that needs disclosure it's deeply personal?

Because it makes it almost impossible to be objective.

JanuaryBluehoo · 07/01/2022 21:43

It would be an insult for the victims to do a re trial.

This isn't like finding out someone is a kkk member or something.
Why is it something that needs disclosure it's deeply personal?

Cosmos123 · 07/01/2022 21:23

I believe she will still be found guilty.

Traumatic for victims though.

Cosmos123 · 07/01/2022 21:22

It will be a retrial.

Also likely to appeal against the fact she didn't get to call her 35 witnesses to the stand.

Motherdare · 07/01/2022 21:15

Those who think it’s a conspiracy… wouldn’t it have been easier to get the bent juror to persuade the rest of them to find her not-guilty? This seems a long-winded way of doing it.

HeddaGarbled · 07/01/2022 00:52

How would they find the jury

Public audition, which is pretty much what they do anyway. Perhaps the audience could vote a juror off every week.

daretodenim · 07/01/2022 00:35

How could they possibly do a retrial? Who hasn't heard of this case now and didn't hear the verdict! How would they find the jury?

daretodenim · 07/01/2022 00:33

@BlwyddynNewydd2022

Call me a tinfoil hat wearing conspiracy theorist, but how timely that a person has spoken out knowing it could cause a re-trial. Wonder if any money's post trial has crossed hands ....
My thoughts exactly.

There's a Netflix documentary about two Miami drugs kingpins. They managed to tamper with the jury quite successfully. For the right amount if money, some people are willing to perjure themselves. The one in the documentary was only found out because police noticed he was spending a lot of money suddenly. He was a security guard, so shouldn't have had much.

Blossomtoes · 06/01/2022 18:32

@DerAlteMann

It was obvious from day one that a Guilty verdict would produce an appeal or a demand for a re-trial. This isn't over by a long way.
It is if a mistrial is declared and her defence successfully makes a claim that a fair trial is now impossible.
DerAlteMann · 06/01/2022 18:20

It was obvious from day one that a Guilty verdict would produce an appeal or a demand for a re-trial. This isn't over by a long way.

User342354252 · 06/01/2022 17:48

I think the more likely scenario is that the DM somehow got a tip regarding the jury deliberations (ie two mentioning sexual abuse). They knew it would be an absolute powder keg and deliberately approached the juror(s) offering a huge amount of money to waiver anonymity. Wouldn't be surprised if they assured him that nothing could change the verdict and that the juror wasn't aware about the seriousness of the situation. His quote regarding the questionnaire sounded quite naive and almost forgetful, he clearly didn't realise what a huge deal it would be. The DM are making a huge fanfare out of their "exclusive" story.

Either the juror was a really clever plant or a stupid, greedy guy who was set up by the press and thrown to the wolves.

SpaceshiptoMars · 06/01/2022 17:14

Even if the juror was bribed, whodunnit? Any of Epstein's customers could be in the frame for that. She's less likely to talk if she's free.

Malibuismysecrethome · 06/01/2022 16:50

I don’t think conspiracy theories are ridiculous but that it’s ridiculous to believe everything you are fed by the media.
Jeffery Epstein’s suicide for a start.

AndAnotherNewOne · 06/01/2022 16:45

Conspiracy theories are ridiculous. Tin hats all round.

sweetbellyhigh · 06/01/2022 16:41

@Tanith

I think everyone does have their own personal opinions and biases. What should not happen - and seems to have happened - is the juror using his or her biases to sway the other jurors. They're there to reach a verdict based on the evidence presented, not because Juror X was once the victim of a similar crime to the one being tried.
That's a bit too simplistic.

The issue was memory. The defendant used a notorious memory expert who specialises in getting sex offenders off by saying memory is rarely accurate.

When this point came up in deliberations, the juror shared his own experience of memory recall and how it both matched the expert's yet was also accurate as a means of making better sense of the defence evidence. Eva use if you drill down on the research, it is accurate of course, but it is repeatedly cherry picked by defence teams to bamboozle juries.. (It's complex)

RoseSmithe · 06/01/2022 16:21

Hmmm. Leetle financial incentive?

melj1213 · 06/01/2022 16:19

@lightnesspixie

As I said in the other thread: a very clever Maxwell plant was that juror ...
Except he wasn't the only one, there aretwo under investigation, but this one was just dumb enough to waive his anonymity so he could sell his story after the trial ended.
Douchebaggette · 06/01/2022 16:18

@lightnesspixie

As I said in the other thread: a very clever Maxwell plant was that juror ...
Very possibly....
Douchebaggette · 06/01/2022 16:17

That bloody juror! Both for the initial action of 'presuading' the others using his own experience rather than the facts of the case and then for blabbing about it at the first opportunity.

What an absolute tool.

Blossomtoes · 06/01/2022 16:06

@Alexandra2001

If i were GM i would be seeking a tell all deal and get a reduced sentence, its inconceivable she acted alone nor that JE was the only abuser.

I wonder if she regrets not giving evidence herself.

Even with a reduced sentence she’d be in prison until she was over 80. I reckon if she’d given evidence she’d have condemned herself. Her mental state must be appalling after spending so long in solitary.