Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ENCANTO - we are obsessed!

185 replies

Jacarandamanda · 06/01/2022 00:08

Our family love it (but biased as South American’s!)

Opinions!?

I know a lot who have said they think the story is quite weak

OP posts:
Nosetickle · 06/01/2022 17:31

My DDs are obsessed with it! It’s been on every day since they watched it on NYE and the songs are so catchy they’re going around and around my head all the time. We especially love we don’t talk about Bruno! After a few days I made an effort to sit down with them and watch it properly all the way through and I still don’t quite understand the plot!

CatOfTheLand · 06/01/2022 17:30

Controversial opinion: their powers weren't that good. And everyone was a dick to Luisa, Bruno and Mirabel. Why did Luisa have to carry the donkeys when their owners were literally a metre away from the donkey parking?!

Mirabel should have been given a power at the end - or it made clear that she was the new guardian of candle/ future matriarch of the clan

BertieQueen · 06/01/2022 17:26

My 12 year old son who is very much past the Disney stage wanted to watch it over Christmas, he has watched it 4 times now! He says it’s one of his favourite films ever. He knows the words to every song. Grin

Helocariad · 06/01/2022 17:26

Our guess is that her gift is to see the cracks in the family dynamics that no-one else wants to see. She's a truth teller who helps people to discover what they really want. Because of talking to her Luisa realises she doesn't always want to be the strong one and Isabella doesn't want to have to be perfect.

Like a PP said, the grandma has narcissistic traits but it's Mirabel who helps her realise this and who brings about healing of the family.

A bit trite maybe but I liked it.

I agree though that she should have got her own room in the end.

Do you think that the rest of the family sort of knew that Bruno was still living there but were in denial?

TruffleShuffles · 06/01/2022 17:25

I didn’t think it was great, I think now we have disney+ they think they need to put out new films with too short a gap to produce something really special. I thought Luca was quite weak too, Soul though was fantastic.

CatOfTheLand · 06/01/2022 17:24

We watch it about x3 a day💖✨🇨🇴

I wasn't that keen at first, but it's grown on me.

My DC will only eat 'Colombian' food now 🤣. I am very much not Colombian so if anyone has any recipes or tips would be much appreciated!

Liathroid · 06/01/2022 17:22

Found it very disappointing. No depth to the characters or their relationships. Songs could’ve been good but the singers were terrible - low voices and monotone, especially Luisa and Mirabel.

Thought from the trailer there would be some adventure to find the mysterious uncle who would help her - instead he was mentally disturbed and hiding in the house. Confused

Terrible relationship with her sister but a 5 min conversation and 2 min song and suddenly they were besties. It took running away ten mins from the house and a five min chat with her grandmother to fix everything else.

Compared to character development in Moana or relationship repair in Brave which took the whole movie. And the excellent sound tracks in those.

CaveMum · 06/01/2022 17:18

I enjoyed it, though think “Coco” is better.

My two (4 & 7) preferred Ron’s Gone Wrong - they run around the house singing the “Dikka, dikka, dikka” song 🤣

Tayegete · 06/01/2022 17:17

I love a Disney film but struggled to get through this one. DS was not massively impressed either.

Averyglitteryturd · 06/01/2022 17:10

Our guess was that she was already able to serve the community without a gift (seeing as they got them to help the town/create a better place) , she was so kind and special already that she didn’t need one?

Sparticle · 06/01/2022 17:05

We watched it on Boxing Day and really enjoyed it. Definitely heard echoes of Hamilton and Moana in the music but I think the soundtrack is great!

The only thing we didn't understand (and perhaps need a second viewing to work it out), was why Mirabel didn't get a gift in the first place. It seemed really cruel. DD and I tried to think that perhaps her gift was hidden until the moment at the end but we didn't think that made any sense. Can anyone please explain?

Tobchette · 06/01/2022 16:44

We are watching it for the god knows how many times now and every time I find things I love and hate.

Love: the songs
The animation - very detailed and some very realistic facial expressions, especially during the pressure song
The colors
The general idea of a magic/family house
Think Pepas dh is my fave character

Hate:
Some aspects of the storyline. Toxic family, narcissistic gran scapegoating her son and grandchild and then golden child Isabella. But in the end Mirabel has to forgive and hug because well they're family. Probably goes over most kids heads and those who do understand receive totally the wrong message that it's okay to be downtrodden by your own relatives.
Plus so many plot holes, they got all this magic but Bruno was just able to hide in the walls, the cousin heard him but didn't say anything, yet she couldn't keep her mouth shut about anything else. Then the idea that Mirabel was the gift all along. Well why was there a need for all the drama in the first place? Seems like the movie should have been longer but they just cut bits out and some of the story is missing.
Arranged marriage for Isabella but then he ends up with the cousin just like sloppy seconds.
Mirabel could have at least got her own bedroom. She just gonna live in the nursery forever?

3scape · 06/01/2022 10:20

It's not great. They don't really go into WHY Mirabelle is so great (surely we need to see her support for her family more than one handhold and some jazzy flower explosion). They don't express adequately the handing of the torch (candle) from one matriarch to another.

But just as lack lustre as every other Disney. It doesn't stand out to me.

Username916 · 06/01/2022 10:13

My girls are obsessed with it. I loved the characters and quite deep stories surrounding them (intergenerational traumas, the pressures of being the eldest etc) really brilliant film. It definitely grew on me though watching it a second time and I felt I understood it a lot more.

Helocariad · 06/01/2022 10:09

@roundtable

We loved it too. I don't agree about the storyline being weak. I thought it was quite deep for Disney. Not so many stories for children about intergenerational trauma. Explaining certain bits to my DC led to some quite thought provoking conversations.
^This.

A really good film about family dynamics and changing family constellations. Also about self worth: the difference between feeling worthy only as long as you bring something exceptional vs feeling worthy because of yourself. Conditional vs unconditional love.

Apparently the film is being used by therapists who work with refugees.

Anxietyhell21 · 06/01/2022 09:57

We don't talk about Bruno no no no

Love it 😀 took our Brownies group to see it at the cinema. I've watched it another 3 times since. My LG is eyeing up the toys / dolls on the disney store website!

rocketmanshine · 06/01/2022 09:56

We are equally obsessed here! Encanto songs on repeat on Spotify and it's been watched endlessly over the holidays.
The songs are so good!
We don't talk about Bruno being our favourite. Dd 8 and Dd5 love it!

puffyisgood · 06/01/2022 08:26

@UnionistMum

My daughter loves it. I love it. This has helped us doing Covid isolation in Portugal.

The dos uruguitas song is beautiful and and always makes me cry.
Also love Isabella’s song as well as Colombia , mi encanto.
It’s a nice movie and Bruno’s song is fab too.
Bruno is such a caracter with his superstitious rituals like knocking on wood, throwing Salt and sugar.

We don’t talk about Bruno, no, no, no.

dos oruguitas is a straightforward rip-off of little mermaid's 'under the sea', no? agree that the Bruno song is v strong, though.
WakeUpLockie · 06/01/2022 08:10

Cannot stop singing We Don't Talk About Bruno

(No clouds allowed in the skyyyy!)

Mummadeze · 06/01/2022 08:09

I enjoyed it, but probably as a one off. I prefer traditional story Disney movies with animals in! Tangled is the most recent one I really loved. I wasn’t even a massive fan of Frozen to be honest. I love the really old ones still like Cinderella, Robin Hood and 101 Dalmations.

Vallmo47 · 06/01/2022 08:00

We LOVE it.

I NEED to know about Bruno… yes yes yes.

Great tip about subtitles.

makingmiracles · 06/01/2022 08:00

All I hear everyday at the moment is shouts of “we don’t talk about Bruno” 😂

GougeAway · 06/01/2022 07:54

My kids 14 and 11 loved it but not obsessively. I don’t like musicals so found it boring. The animation was beautiful though. The dysfunctional family story was quite disturbing and I found it uncomfortable viewing.

crazyjinglist · 06/01/2022 07:40

I'd never heard of it but we watched it the other day after dd(16) had seen it at a friend's house and loved it. She wanted to watch it in Spanish, so we did (with subtitles) - I speak decent Spanish and both dc are studying it.

I quite liked the music and enjoyed the opportunity to practise my Spanish but I thought it was quite weak for a Disney film.

Terminallysleepdeprived · 06/01/2022 07:37

Dd is 8 and liked it. She can't have loved it though as it has only been on once unlike other films that have pretty much been on repeat. I can't say I was that impressed.

The story was very weak, the songs weren't all that good either.

Not one of Disneys better films