Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ENCANTO - we are obsessed!

185 replies

Jacarandamanda · 06/01/2022 00:08

Our family love it (but biased as South American’s!)

Opinions!?

I know a lot who have said they think the story is quite weak

OP posts:
TheWitchersWife · 07/01/2022 16:18

Thanks everyone.
Been discussing it and thinking about it for a few days and hearing other people's thoughts and perspectives have been very interesting and I see all your points :)

Helocariad · 07/01/2022 16:15

@HPandTheNeverEndingBedtimeP I also think her green glasses were a foreshadowing for Bruno whose eyes go the same shade of green when having a vision

Ooh, I like this!

HPandTheNeverEndingBedtime · 07/01/2022 16:12

@thewitcherswife
As others have said I assume Mirabels mums cooking works more like an A&E and fixes accidents not genetics.

I also think her green glasses were a foreshadowing for Bruno whose eyes go the same shade of green when having a vision.

CurzonDax · 07/01/2022 13:58

I loved it (but then again, I do love most Disney and Pixar movies ...)

My only issue with the room is that I hope they allowed Mirabel to move from the nursery, even if she doesn't get her own magical room. Yes, she is fantastic with children (her younger cousin, and the town's children following her about at the start, and then helping to search for her etc), but it makes her seem like a glorified babysitter to be permanently in the nursery. I mean the grandma had no magical powers (other than being the matriarch), yet she seems to have had her own private sleeping arrangements.

Also, Dolores power seems rubbish - other than to possibly be able to hear if future invaders/attackers come again, how does her power help the rest of the town - I'd be too worried that she could hear all my secrets. It also freaked me out that she would have received her powers as a child (I believe they got them at 5?), and from that age onwards was able to hear the private situations in her parents, and aunt/uncle's bedroom. She must also have heard so many secrets over the years, and been able to keep them to herself (the biggest one being able to hear Bruno, of course!), then why did she suddenly get so freaked, at the engagement dinner party, after hearing Mirabel and her dad talk about the prophecy?

1winterblues · 07/01/2022 13:12

Also South American so biased so was ridiculously excited about another Latin American Disney film. I dragged my entire family out to see coco at the cinema.

I loved it, the colours and songs etc. But felt slightly disappointed in the story line. The kids and I have watched it a few times but not one of the strongest films.

MrPoppysParka · 07/01/2022 12:40

Actually I have one criticism of the film! I don’t like the way that the only sister to have straight hair is the ‘perfect’ one 🙄

3scape · 07/01/2022 09:58

Probably because her eyes have changed shape due to genetics. That is not an ailment. She's young. Noone suggests it's a degenerative eye condition.

Laiste · 07/01/2022 09:39

@SpacePotato

Needing glasses isn't usually a result of injury or illness though which is what I assume she can heal.

Bit like no one fixing harry potter's eyesight despite all the potions, spells and Phoenix tears!

I've just had a flashback to years ago, the first time i watched the first Harry Potter film - when Hermione fixes Harry's glasses on the train - i thought she was going to heal his actual eyesight! I'd forgotten that :)
Laiste · 07/01/2022 09:37

I agree with a pp that it'd have been more magical if the magic hadn't come back and the house had stayed being simply the one the whole village came together to make.

I had the 'Why are they all still more special than everyone else?' question in my head after grandma had freely admitting being a controlling old sod Grin

It was ok. DD (7) has watched the Croods more often over the holidays. She would have that on repeat if she could! We've had Encanto on 3 times i think.

It's pretty - all the colours.

DD loves Bruno song and asks Alexa to play it.

I think it's a rather long deep issueto fit into a disney film with so many songs. The wrap up, with sister ect, does feel rushed.

SpacePotato · 07/01/2022 09:12

Needing glasses isn't usually a result of injury or illness though which is what I assume she can heal.

Bit like no one fixing harry potter's eyesight despite all the potions, spells and Phoenix tears!

TheWitchersWife · 07/01/2022 06:41

Question:

If Julieta's meals can heal all, including Mirabel when her hand gets cut, why does Mirabel need glasses?
Are they simply a fashion choice?

I read Mirabel is only the 4th Disney character to have glasses and the first ever female character. I like that they meet branching out in terms of diversity but the plot hole!

Still love the film though.

steff13 · 07/01/2022 01:03

I love Bruno

MomOfTwoGirls2 · 07/01/2022 00:50

Watched it with Dd17 this week. We both loved it!!! We are both BIG Lin Manuel Miranda fans, and musical theatre fans.

It was so charming, just loved it 💕

MrPoppysParka · 06/01/2022 23:50

We LOVE it here. My DD was also so happy to see a character with her skin tone and curly hair (Dolores). First time ever in a Disney film for her.

Comtesse · 06/01/2022 23:20

Pixar and Disney are essentially the same organism now. Disney is the brand for “princess” like films and Pixar covers everything else. The Pixar crew were so brilliant it was basically a reverse take over of Disney (on the movie side at least). I don’t think Encanto is a 5* film but we all liked it at the cinema and some of those songs are sticky!

MizzFizz · 06/01/2022 22:36

I loooved it! Watched it a few days ago and cried like a baby (pregnancy hormones?). It's so relatable... Breaking those intergenerational cycles 😭😭😭. I would definitely watch it again.

Phrowzunn · 06/01/2022 22:35

We love it! 2 and 4 year old DDs, we’ve had the soundtrack on repeat since we saw it in the cinema. My 2yo asks repeatedly for ‘the pressure song’ and dances around very dramatically.
I disagree with those saying the storyline is ‘weak’, I think it is so much more relevant than lots of others, pretty much everyone can relate on some level to the family dynamics that they explore in the film. The pressures and expectations that can be put on us by having a certain ‘role’ within our family, sibling rivalries and comparisons, not understanding things from someone else’s perspective, trauma being unwittingly passed down generations. I think there are so many interesting issues that are explored in this film that can start conversations within families and make us all think. I’m surprised that most on mumsnet don’t seem to recognise that one of the themes is the whole golden child / scapegoat dynamic that is so often discussed here!
I like that Mirabel doesn’t have a ‘gift’ but is the one that ends up saving the magic. When the house starts to fall and they are trying to save the candle, everyone else fails because they rely on their magic and it lets them down. Mirabel is the only one who reaches the candle using her grit and quick thinking because she hasn’t ever relied on a gift. I think that’s a lovely lesson for kids who maybe feel they don’t have a particular strength or talent, especially compared to their siblings or friends.
And those saying the music is no good have not heard it enough! We don’t talk about Bruno is an absolute work of art! Surface Pressure is really so deep and relatable if you listen properly to the lyrics. And Dos Oroguidas is just stunning.

elp30 · 06/01/2022 22:29

@Jacarandamanda

I don't have young children around my house anymore so this film has passed me by completely. However, I looked up a preview and it looks interesting.

I'm a Mexican-American so movies with Spanish language and characters that are representative of me and my Hispanic culture ("Coco" especially, was about someone like me and I too, have a father who was a mariachi for sixty years!!) are a joy to me! It's wonderful to see and hear Latino voices in films and elsewhere.

Thank you for mentioning it as I will be seeing it this weekend.

Bimblybomeyelash · 06/01/2022 22:15

I love Moana so much, and I’ve never been a Disney fan, so now I compare all Disney films to Moana. And none of them are as good!

BurntToastAgain · 06/01/2022 22:12

My toddler adores encanto. Absolutely adores it.

FourSeasonsTotalLandscaping · 06/01/2022 22:08

@DontKnowWhatToThink7

My DD loves it. She is Autistic and rarely watches films but she sat through and watched the whole thing which is a big deal in our house. The only other film she has watched and enjoyed that much is Moana
Interestingly we've had the same experience here. My autistic 5 year old has never sat with such rapt attention through a whole film before, and she certainly hasn't wanted to watch anything that long all the way through as many times.
Hotcuppatea · 06/01/2022 22:03

It's all right. Not brilliant. Wouldn't watch it again.

ShortColdandGrey · 06/01/2022 22:01

My DD 5 loves it. She goes about singing "We don't talk about Bruno" constantly. She went to see it at the cinema with her class at Christmas. I think that has made it feel a bit special to her.

CasperGutman · 06/01/2022 21:55

Glad I saw it in the cinema because I'm not sure if have 'got' it if I hadn't focused on it. As it was, we really liked it here (DS9+DD6). Not quite as good as Coco, which we LOVED - and which always makes me cry at the end!

WeNeedToTalkAboutBruno · 06/01/2022 21:53

Another one here for wanting to watch it again when the children have gone to bed. Love the songs.