Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
Disobedience101 · 07/01/2022 11:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Lifeisnteasy · 07/01/2022 11:37

There’s definitely a lot of dangerous breastfeeding ‘advice’ around, and in many cases the unquestioning devotion to breastfeeding is vastly disproportionate to the benefits it actually has.

I saw one particularly horrifying post on here, a poster’s 6 month old baby weighed nine pounds because she was adamant she wouldn’t formula feed & battled the medics at every turn. People responded encouraging her, saying the baby was obviously constitutionally small! Then when OP posted saying her baby had doubled its weight within a few months of weaning, she was all ‘I wonder why baby has suddenly had a huge growth spurt’. Clearly trying to avoid admitting she had underfed the baby at any cost.

Horst · 07/01/2022 11:35

Even if hospital care was better funded no I wouldn’t want to go in.

My issue wasn’t the birth itself that was straight forward it was the care and attitudes on the midwifes on ward, it was the not believing anything I said about my own baby and basically letting him starve for over 24 hours because they knew better than me and wouldn’t let me give him formula or get a consultant down to visit. I was left at 3am with a screaming baby who hadn’t fed since 2pm on the phone to my dh in tears while midwifes just said it was my fault my baby wasn’t eating.

Turns out it wasn’t my fault at all but their ignorance and lack of carrying out a full check on him when I finally got a consultant gone 4pm the following day who at first still tried to blame me then found the issue.

I also labour fast and prefer to actually be treated like a human being and listened to which you get with home birth midwifes who care for you, your entire pregnancy rather than a string of random midwifes.

Namechangetimes100 · 07/01/2022 11:12

@Draineddraineddrained

As an aside the very best bf support group in know on Facebook is Breastfeeding Support and Information UK. The admins are all ABM trained peer supporters as a minimum, they always correct and where necessary delete when posters advise each other in contravention of medical advice and guidelines, they ensure that an admin clearly marked as such gives substantive advice and ongoing support to the mum asking a question. They never slate medical professionals (even when it is tempting to do so as advice is plain wrong) and instead signpost back to the relevant guidance and advise the mother to discuss this with their HCP. No mother is made to feel ashamed for using formula - advice is given on combi feeding and safely weaning from the breast. What they don't allow is recommending particular brands of formula, bottles, pumps etc as that's not within the remit of the group It's a really really wonderful supportive evidence based group and they got me through two difficult bf journeys.
@Draineddraineddrained actually disagree a little bit, I’m on that group too. Whilst most of the advice is fantastic, the whole ‘dangers of formula’ is vastly overstated and I had such a difficult journey with my first im glad I didn’t see that when I had to combi feed her, would have tipped me over the edge, but I was in a very fragile place.

I’m all for breastfeeding, currently breast feeding my second child and did my first for 21 months, but they do overstate the benefits of it. That’s not necessarily on them though as the nhs website does too. Same with the introducing solids but, ‘food before 1 is for fun’ yes don’t get hung up on quantities but babies do need iron.

OP posts:
Sesnania14 · 07/01/2022 11:05

@ThatLibraryMiss

There are heaps of studies on it on pubmed,NIH, BMJ if you type in birth trauma. This article quotes several studies and mentions the statistics with a link. But of course we all know these are subject to criticism and limitations. Hope it starts as a guidance. This focuses on the UK, but I believe both Australia and America had the same rates of birth trauma. Apologies for missing, lots replied. Hope that is a starting point. Some Australian midwives recently made a documentry on the issue called 'Birth Time.'Worth the watch.
www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00056/full#B2

Namechangetimes100 · 07/01/2022 11:04

@KeflavikAirport

Those of you preferring home birth to crappy hospital births, would you go for hospital if the service was properly funded? It doesn't have to be like it is in the UK. Other places fund their hospitals adequately and make it a much more pleasant and safe experience.
So @KeflavikAirport for me one of the main motivation was actually being at home, we don’t have reliable childcare and i wanted my husband at the birth. My first was an induction and the quality of care, specifically as you weren’t allowed birth partners unless in active labour was really terrifying to me, i was genuinely worried about going overdue and the possibility of an induction. My experience on the post natal ward contributed massively to my pnd first time around. Knowing that those issues would be fixed would have made me feel much more relaxed about the possibility.

As it stands I had an MLU birth, and it’s sad to say but there is a huge difference in how you are treated there v delivery suite

OP posts:
ThatLibraryMiss · 07/01/2022 10:47

@Sesnania14 I think in your haste to respond to the latest posts you may have missed my post in which I asked for the source of your assertion that “Western countries have up to 30% of women suffering birth trauma, most of which is caused by obscetric [sic] violence”. I’d be fascinated to read it - could you post it, please?

Draineddraineddrained · 07/01/2022 10:21

I'm really glad to hear it all was ok in the end 😊

Mothertomore · 07/01/2022 10:19

Check out this www.instagram.com/p/CWpncWAs4-Y/?utm_medium=copy_link

Indoctro · 07/01/2022 10:12

[quote Draineddraineddrained]@indoctro that's not a home birth or a free birth, that's a BBA (birth before arrival) and I understand they can be utterly terrifying and can result in PTSD, I'm so sorry you had to go through that and I hope you and your baby are both doing well now. But there is a world of difference between s precipitate labour resulting in an unplanned unattended birth and a planned home birth attended by midwives, or even a planned and wanted free birth (not that I'd recommend one of those either).[/quote]
Ah ok I see

Yes very much not what I would of planned I'm very much for hospital birth.

Baby had other ideas though , all turned out ok in the end thankfully

CrumpledCrumpet · 07/01/2022 10:06

@Sesnania14

GOD forbid women want to put themselves first and must be self sacrificial
But it’s not as simple as being selfish or selfless though, it’s how we frame the process and the outcomes were are most focused on. The desire for a healthy baby is ultimately selfish but sometimes that can get a bit lost in the focus on the birth itself (which is often driven by fear of the process).

I was really focused on having a “good” birth / avoiding a bad one with my first. Terrified of the pain, the unknown, terrified of ending up with a c-section. And it was an awful birth but the swift action of a crash team saved DS.

With my second I totally reframed my own desires as being about the birth outcome, not the birth itself. I still think of that as a selfish choice, not a sacrifice, I had simply shifted the focus of what was most important to me.

I

Draineddraineddrained · 07/01/2022 10:02

@indoctro that's not a home birth or a free birth, that's a BBA (birth before arrival) and I understand they can be utterly terrifying and can result in PTSD, I'm so sorry you had to go through that and I hope you and your baby are both doing well now. But there is a world of difference between s precipitate labour resulting in an unplanned unattended birth and a planned home birth attended by midwives, or even a planned and wanted free birth (not that I'd recommend one of those either).

Indoctro · 07/01/2022 09:56

I had a home birth by myself on bathroom floor and quite frankly it was utterly terrifying.

Not something I would recommend to anyone

Maybe I should join the group and give my experience.

Baby arrived in less than 2 minutes which put me and baby both at high risk of death.

I live 45 minutes from nearest hospital so nothing would of saved us.

Draineddraineddrained · 07/01/2022 09:38

A really good book by the way is "Why Human Rights In Childbirth Matter" - it's a very well researched and informative book that's short and easy to read. It really helps to understand the way "risk' is misused in maternal health care as a binary thing rather than as a specific statistical indicator that should be part of, but not the whole of, the medical decision making process. And it covers some of the medical abuse stories luridly described in a post above in a far more considered but nonetheless shocking fashion.

Draineddraineddrained · 07/01/2022 09:31

@TheOriginalEmu

Absolutely agree. It shouldn't be necessary. But in my sad experience it is. The trouble is I think HCPs are by their profession educated people,more so that the avg member of the population. So they more often than not find themselves dealing with people less informed than they are so consider themselves best placed to make decisions for them. Which tbh is often true! Even with my information finding and comprehension abilities and my confidence to express what I knew and wanted and didn't want (all privileges) I don't pretend I know as much as a qualified midwife! But some HCPs have probably hot into the habit of thinking "this will be difficult to explain properly, they won't understand anyway, and I know what the "right" decision is - I'll just shortcut to the bit where they agree with me". When informed consent actually requires that the patient understands both what's recommended and why and the alternatives, and is aware of their right to say no. If they don't have the knowledge themselves, it is incumbent on the HCP to inform them. Which got too many just seems to be too much of a ballache. I understand they are overworked, and often working in highly stressful and occasionally urgent situations. But the requirement for informed consent is still there.

TheOriginalEmu · 07/01/2022 09:18

@KeflavikAirport

Those of you preferring home birth to crappy hospital births, would you go for hospital if the service was properly funded? It doesn't have to be like it is in the UK. Other places fund their hospitals adequately and make it a much more pleasant and safe experience.
That’s a good question. I’m not sure I would. But that’s only with the benefit of hindsight in that I had one catastrophic hospital birth followed by 3 lovely homebirths.
TheOriginalEmu · 07/01/2022 09:16

@Draineddraineddrained

Empowerment totally makes a difference to the care you receive as well in my view (apart from really severe cases of medical abuse where people are held down and harmed whilst shouting no, which sadly do happen but rarely). So often it's just a case of things being presented to patients as "so we're going to do this" as if there are no other options or right of refusal. Knowing a LOT about birthing and understanding that it is incumbent of THEM to have your informed consent, and your iron plated right to refuse any treatment you don't want, and that YOU are the patient with priority not your baby (not that many women would put their own interest ahead of their baby during labour), gives you the ability to hold your own in these situations, or even know you have an "own" to hold.

In my second birth once I was hospitalised, I made sure to use certain medical terminology about my condition and options; and to question the reasons and alternatives for everything they wanted me to do/do to me. This may have made me look like a PITA but it did set s tone straight away that I was not to be done to. That I knew my stuff and I knew my rights. And it made a massive difference to the quality of my care because it was clear I would not be trifled with. Groups can be really good for building that knowledge and confidence. But only if it's the right group.

I agree with everything you’ve said, but you really shouldn’t need to have all that knowledge in order to be treated like a human being. It’s a privilege to be able to have that knowledge and power, that not everyone has.
Indoctro · 07/01/2022 09:09

You can't argue with stupid.

Draineddraineddrained · 07/01/2022 09:09

And another thing...! Mobile monitoring is a bit of a con tbh. They'll say they offer it then it won't be available on the day, or thru do have it but despite bring wireless it still doesn't work properly unless you stay pretty much still which is surely what one is seeking to avoid. Continuous monitoring of any sort is always going to inhibit an active mobile labour. Which isn't to say it isn't sometimes needed. It was in my case, and picked up my baby's heart rate dropping and not recovering between contractions leading to me choosing a section. But the idea you can have permanent monitoring and it not affect your labouring is a bit of a lie in my experience. Maybe the midwives doing mine just didn't know how to use them properly!

DockOTheBay · 07/01/2022 09:08

Yes I think I know which group you're referring to and I have seen a lot of similar sentiment. Things like if they don't send a midwife out to a home birth, due to short staff etc, then refuse to come in and they will have to send a midwife out to you. Dangerous and selfish.

There is also quite an overlap with anti vax, anti scans etc. I left the group.

Lifeisnteasy · 07/01/2022 08:53

My colleague chose a stand-alone MLU for her first baby. She was a picture of health and very low risk throughout her pregnancy, so it seemed a good choice. Labour started well but baby got stuck in second stage, she had a two hour wait for an ambulance & was eventually transferred to hospital for an instrumental delivery. She said on reflection she was given the impression that low risk = a straightforward birth, when the two aren’t really linked.

Lifeisnteasy · 07/01/2022 08:49

I agree they need to relax the MLU rules. They’ve spent a ton of money on these lovely facilities and nobody’s allowed to use them!

It seems mad that a second or third time mum with a history of straightforward births has to go to the labour ward for something like BMI when a first time mother with no idea how she labours has the option of the MLU (if low risk).

Draineddraineddrained · 07/01/2022 08:28

Another thing that would increase women's willingness to go for hospital births would be a reduction of the strictures on access to MLUs, alongside ones in hospitals to mean. A lot of women are scared of the clinical environment, and the postnatal ward is almost invariably fucking hell on earth when you've just had a baby and desperately need comfort and sleep. The room I was put in (in the obstetric ward) for my second labour was the most dismal, cold, joyless hellhole, completely barren of any comfort whatsoever - even the birthing ball was deflated. I asked for something to go on the floor so I could kneel as this was how I was most comfortable labouring and was brought a stinking rubber mat of the sort you used to get for PE at school. I was freezing but they couldn't turn off the air con because it was operated across the whole building. It was a horrible, horrible place to give birth. I was only there due to meconium in waters, apart from that I was labouring well and rapidly. To have been in a room equipped for birth as well as for clinical assessment would have made a huge difference to me. But because I was indicated as too risky due to meconium that was that - the horrible butchers back room it was. Flexibility on this would prevent a lot of women turning to home and free birth.

Draineddraineddrained · 07/01/2022 08:18

Empowerment totally makes a difference to the care you receive as well in my view (apart from really severe cases of medical abuse where people are held down and harmed whilst shouting no, which sadly do happen but rarely). So often it's just a case of things being presented to patients as "so we're going to do this" as if there are no other options or right of refusal. Knowing a LOT about birthing and understanding that it is incumbent of THEM to have your informed consent, and your iron plated right to refuse any treatment you don't want, and that YOU are the patient with priority not your baby (not that many women would put their own interest ahead of their baby during labour), gives you the ability to hold your own in these situations, or even know you have an "own" to hold.

In my second birth once I was hospitalised, I made sure to use certain medical terminology about my condition and options; and to question the reasons and alternatives for everything they wanted me to do/do to me. This may have made me look like a PITA but it did set s tone straight away that I was not to be done to. That I knew my stuff and I knew my rights. And it made a massive difference to the quality of my care because it was clear I would not be trifled with. Groups can be really good for building that knowledge and confidence. But only if it's the right group.

Draineddraineddrained · 07/01/2022 08:08

As an aside the very best bf support group in know on Facebook is Breastfeeding Support and Information UK. The admins are all ABM trained peer supporters as a minimum, they always correct and where necessary delete when posters advise each other in contravention of medical advice and guidelines, they ensure that an admin clearly marked as such gives substantive advice and ongoing support to the mum asking a question. They never slate medical professionals (even when it is tempting to do so as advice is plain wrong) and instead signpost back to the relevant guidance and advise the mother to discuss this with their HCP. No mother is made to feel ashamed for using formula - advice is given on combi feeding and safely weaning from the breast. What they don't allow is recommending particular brands of formula, bottles, pumps etc as that's not within the remit of the group It's a really really wonderful supportive evidence based group and they got me through two difficult bf journeys.