Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
Mothertomore · 10/01/2022 15:59

@lifeisnteasy I've had 3 vba2c's

Mothertomore · 10/01/2022 15:59

@Namechangetimes100

I don't get it. You know the system is messed up so why can't women choose a free birth? As long as they are aware and well informed of the possible risks then send them luck.

All the advice isn't for everyone. Some are willing to stand their ground more than others and that's fine too.

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 15:56

University of Oxford birthplace study, @Mothertomore

And a vba2c sounds really rather risky.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**
Mothertomore · 10/01/2022 15:54

www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg190/ifp/chapter/choosing-where-to-have-your-baby

I've had a hba2c (home birth after 2 c-sections) 3 hours from my waters going to baby being born.

Mothertomore · 10/01/2022 15:49

@MimiDaisy11

www.nct.org.uk/labour-birth/deciding-where-give-birth/giving-birth-home/home-births-are-they-safe

@lifeisnteasy where's your proof?

Namechangetimes100 · 10/01/2022 15:40

I do agree that there is (in my opinion) no other field where ‘patients’ are so routinely treated so poorly, obviously it’s not every woman but it’s happening enough to be systemic.

I’m sympathetic to wanting to put middle finger up to the system and I do believe for a lot of women (not necessarily just the text book low risk ones) home birth is a fantastic option no more risky than an free standing birth centre. I think a free birth course just in case you have a bba is also fantastic. I also completely related and understand wanting to soundboard the info you’ve been given by so and so consultant / midwife. However that doesn’t mean that obstetric risks don’t exist and to shun all scans / bloods really really shouldn’t be encouraged, even though it’s the mums right. I don’t think free birth as the plan a should be encouraged either unless you’rr birthing with someone who knows what a crisis situation looks like and can act accordingly.

OP posts:
Shehasadiamondinthesky · 10/01/2022 15:36

I have a friend who has had four free births, she always said well I did it last time and it was fine. I think she's crackers, women used to die in childbirth all the time, anything can happen. You need proper medical support. 101 things can go wrong.

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 15:32

[quote Mothertomore]@lifeisnteasy
Home birth is safe for first time mums![/quote]
No it isn’t. Babies are almost twice as likely to suffer a bad outcome.

MimiDaisy11 · 10/01/2022 15:29

[quote Mothertomore]@lifeisnteasy
Home birth is safe for first time mums![/quote]
Source?

HereticFanjo · 10/01/2022 15:24

The worst treatment I ever had was on a maternity ward. Ofc YANBU but pregnant and birthing women are treated disgustingly in this country. No wonder some are trying to seize back control.

Namechangetimes100 · 10/01/2022 15:21

Also I should say by PhD I mean Dphil.

Point is dangerous information is dangerous information regardless of the source. No one should be cajoled into anything but equally risks shouldn’t be obscured because if they are they no matter how you dress it up, you aren’t making an informed decision

OP posts:
Namechangetimes100 · 10/01/2022 15:18

@AliceAll

I'm in that FB group. I also have a PhD in biomedical sciences and know how to find, read and critique medical and scientific literature and am fairly up to date on the current literature around safety and place-of-birth. FWIW I have seen non-evidenced-based advice given in the group but in general much less than I see given by HCPs. My most recent interaction with a HCP being a case in point : at a recent scan I declined to follow the sonographer's advice and explained that the medical research showed no statistical improvement in outcomes for the baby in my situation. Her response (and to be fair she was polite about it) was "well that's not true". I wasn't sharing my opinion - I was sharing the medical peer-reviewed data. She was sharing her opinion. The issue of course with freebirth of course is that there is very little research on which to base one's decisions. The peer-reviewed data on well-integrated home-birth v hospital is conclusive that home is equally safe for the baby and significantly safer for the mother (which also has knock on benefits to the baby). This was research published just before the pandemic in the Lancet. Obviously that is not the situation now. Supported home-birth services are being cut left right and centre. MLUs are mostly closed or so hard to get into that they might as well be. Hospitals are chronically understaffed and birth partners are not allowed until the very end of labour (Completely contradictory to what the research would suggest is best). Hospital was never the safest place for the majority of women and now it is even less safe than when the research was carried out. Obviously unsupported home-birth has higher risk than supported home-birth. But I was unable to find anything to support the idea that in my circumstances (previous fast homebirth) it would be less safe than hospital risks + the risk of an enroute car-birth. As it happened midwives were available but she was born before they got there. I would not have made it to hospital in time. Being prepared to freebirth if necessary was the safest thing for me. It won't be for everyone. But it really helps to be informed of one's options and to have people to support you, and to call out the blatant misinformation given by HCPs (usually due to ignorance rather than malice). In the group I do see some non-evidenced-based advice given, (I've seen plenty of misinformation on this thread also.) but also I see lots of linking to the research, lots of advice to make one's own decisions and no coercion. I've also seen lots of encouragement and validation of women's stories who have chosen to transfer, have induction or csections. These are less frequent - as they should be. Oh and the majority of posts suggesting ignoring advice about induction for small babies are referring to SGA babies, or suggesting IUGR has been misdiagnosed rather than someone suggesting one should actually ignore advice about true IUGR. This is actually evidenced based advice. SGA (but not IUGR) babies should not be induced according to the research. It's really important not to confuse the two.
I also have a phd and 2 masters degrees (research and taught) if we’re going to academically flex and sorry but the saving baby pathway which is based on the most up to date research does put forth the idea that a baby measuring under the 3rd centile is statistically more likely to be iugr (these things can’t always be seen on a scan). Also elevated arterial dopplers and declining growth velocity are the best indicators or iugr and there have been posts saying ‘scans are wrong all the time’ maybe at delivery birth weight wasn’t exceptionally low BUT that doesn’t prove the baby wasn’t growth restricted.

Also as the mother of an sga baby I’m very familiar with the distinction between small for gestational age and fetal growth restriction.

OP posts:
AliceAll · 10/01/2022 15:15

Oh and I think the group does far more good than harm and I think the admins do an excellent job of balancing free speech, evidence-based-information, anecdotal evidence and opinions in the many areas of pregnancy/birth where scientific research is lacking. It's a hard balance and she does it with compassion, wisdom, a huge sacrifice of her time and a respect for women that is often lacking in other areas of maternity care.

Mothertomore · 10/01/2022 15:14

@lifeisnteasy
Home birth is safe for first time mums!

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 15:09

The peer-reviewed data on well-integrated home-birth v hospital is conclusive that home is equally safe for the baby and significantly safer for the mother

Not for first babies it isn’t.

AliceAll · 10/01/2022 14:55

I'm in that FB group. I also have a PhD in biomedical sciences and know how to find, read and critique medical and scientific literature and am fairly up to date on the current literature around safety and place-of-birth. FWIW I have seen non-evidenced-based advice given in the group but in general much less than I see given by HCPs. My most recent interaction with a HCP being a case in point : at a recent scan I declined to follow the sonographer's advice and explained that the medical research showed no statistical improvement in outcomes for the baby in my situation. Her response (and to be fair she was polite about it) was "well that's not true". I wasn't sharing my opinion - I was sharing the medical peer-reviewed data. She was sharing her opinion. The issue of course with freebirth of course is that there is very little research on which to base one's decisions. The peer-reviewed data on well-integrated home-birth v hospital is conclusive that home is equally safe for the baby and significantly safer for the mother (which also has knock on benefits to the baby). This was research published just before the pandemic in the Lancet. Obviously that is not the situation now. Supported home-birth services are being cut left right and centre. MLUs are mostly closed or so hard to get into that they might as well be. Hospitals are chronically understaffed and birth partners are not allowed until the very end of labour (Completely contradictory to what the research would suggest is best). Hospital was never the safest place for the majority of women and now it is even less safe than when the research was carried out. Obviously unsupported home-birth has higher risk than supported home-birth. But I was unable to find anything to support the idea that in my circumstances (previous fast homebirth) it would be less safe than hospital risks + the risk of an enroute car-birth. As it happened midwives were available but she was born before they got there. I would not have made it to hospital in time. Being prepared to freebirth if necessary was the safest thing for me. It won't be for everyone. But it really helps to be informed of one's options and to have people to support you, and to call out the blatant misinformation given by HCPs (usually due to ignorance rather than malice). In the group I do see some non-evidenced-based advice given, (I've seen plenty of misinformation on this thread also.) but also I see lots of linking to the research, lots of advice to make one's own decisions and no coercion. I've also seen lots of encouragement and validation of women's stories who have chosen to transfer, have induction or csections. These are less frequent - as they should be. Oh and the majority of posts suggesting ignoring advice about induction for small babies are referring to SGA babies, or suggesting IUGR has been misdiagnosed rather than someone suggesting one should actually ignore advice about true IUGR. This is actually evidenced based advice. SGA (but not IUGR) babies should not be induced according to the research. It's really important not to confuse the two.

siestasiesta · 07/01/2022 21:24

We need the best of both worlds. A quiet, dark relaxing space to help with the hormone cascade required for labour to progress, with monitoring and a delivery suite and NICU if required. Sometimes intervention is necessary. Nature doesn't need every mother and baby to survive childbirth, just most of them. Luckily, we don't accept those odds and have the obstetric care available to make maternal death and stillbirth or neonatal death unusual. It wouldn't have been unusual a hundred years ago, we should never forget that. I wouldn't have a home birth, after a crash section and seeing how quickly things can go wrong, I would be very cautious. I wouldn't want to be further than a couple of minutes from theatre, in case a c-section was required. Things don't go wrong very often, but when they do, it can be catastrophic. I wouldn't want to risk that outcome to have a better labour. I do understand birth trauma, but when your baby nearly died during their birth like mine, you realise it isn't the most important thing. I was traumatised for years, but I'm so glad they made it and intervention made it possible.

Lifeisnteasy · 07/01/2022 21:08

And here’s another…

www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-10379581/Ashley-Graham-gives-birth-twins-home.html

lochmaree · 07/01/2022 21:04

someone recommended a home birth group to me (one of the main ones, its been mentioned on this thread) and I left really quickly. it seemed very extreme.

I've had one DC and pregnant with 2nd. I did a private hypnobirthing course with my first, prepared for MLU birth, low risk pregnancy, was very into the natural birth world however wouldn't have considered freebirth ever! hone birth maybe but MLU was my preference. in the end I was induced, typical cascade of interventions and ended in EMCS under GA with sepsis post op. although I found the whole experience terrifying, it also showed me how fast things can go wrong. this time I would like to push for an attached MLU vbac (if possible) but with a very low tolerance for c section. currently vbac in the MLU isn't "allowed" and I thought that group could maybe help. having read the posts I think it probably wouldn't help!

Theregoesmyhomebirth · 07/01/2022 20:23

I just wanted to add my voice to PPs before me that I think the driving force behind these groups is people scared of the rigidity of obstetricians. I've definitely felt drawn to them during my pregnancy as a source of comfort that my labour and delivery might not be traumatic, when my consultants only talk about risk, stillbirth and tell me what I WILL do (only one midwife so far has mentioned the word consent). I asked if there was any room for discussions around choices (for timing and mode of delivery) and was told in no uncertain terms that anything other than what is in their policy is inviting the risk of stillbirth. It hasn't given me any reassurance, it's made me disengage with any conversations around it until I have to. Otherwise it's just upsetting.

I don't feel overwhelmingly reassured by their years of experience like others do. When clinicians follow hospital policy blindly and without question, that in itself allows for dangerous practice. A decent medic should be able to discuss and weigh up options, using an evidence base and applying it to individual situations/patients. Treating everyone the same based on population data isn't good practice.

I won't be having another homebirth (obv!) as I'm pregnant with twins and who knows how they'll be growing/laying by then. But the experience of this pregnancy has been horrible compared to my first and I'm glad I won't have to do a consultant led one again. I do wish there was some middle ground/room for discussion on options that didn't just push you into binary places of freebirth vs. passively accepting anything without consent.

MimiDaisy11 · 07/01/2022 17:52

Wow that thread is worrying. Must be hard to deal with parents like that. Especially ironic as she talks about doctors not being knowledgeable like her.

Lifeisnteasy · 07/01/2022 16:57

That thread is proof some women do put their ambitions to be Mother Earth before the health of their child. There is no scenario in which inadequately breastfeeding a malnourished child is better than mix feeding a child of a healthy weight. Being that underweight is a health risk in itself.

Namechangetimes100 · 07/01/2022 16:50

I’ve just read it, it’s very hard to get through but that carrot is saying that she doesn’t believe that babies need to be on the same/ similar centile for head, weight and length. Erm yes they do, that’s how you can detect and underweight baby, 2 centiles either way shows proportionality aka a healthy child. Heads are often above length and weight but that’s babies for you.

She didn’t even need to introduce formula, she could have pumped but apparently that gives her clogs, most likely because it’s increasing the supply that baby just isn’t transferring. The baby was 100% living on the let down and the glib refusal and encouragement to keep going is the same ridiculous attitude and behaviour that drove this thread

OP posts:
Horst · 07/01/2022 16:48

That thread was a shocking read. She was just so so determined to be right that bf was enough that she didn’t have a supply issue. That poor poor baby and even once gaining like a super star once on solids she refused to see that the baby clearly needed more than just bf for all those months.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 07/01/2022 16:39

@Lifeisnteasy

I have an issue with her attitude of being far more intelligent and well read than her paedatrician, and everyone laughing along like people who don’t do things their way are idiots. It’s v shocking as a read. I can’t imagine a scenario where your child is soooo thin and you just continue.