Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
BiscuitLover3678 · 10/01/2022 19:14

For all those going apeshit over medical advice, you do realise it varies across different nations, including those with very good medical systems e.g. France.

The uk used to advocate putting babies on their fronts to sleep when other countries didn’t.

You can actually be smart and question things your local trust is doing. It can also vary across trusts.

AliceAll · 10/01/2022 19:12

@Liathroid The US has a crazy health system and no it’s not remotely generalisable to the UK but, if you read the papers I cited, I did not do that. The Hutton and Reitsma papers are based on studies from around the world and include data from the UK, the Netherlands, Canada, Iceland and New Zealand.

The authors are Canadian. I'm surprised you'd confuse Canada and the US while trying to make a snide point about geographical context :-p (Joke by the way - not trying to get at you - but humour is hard to convey by text)

rosettesforjill · 10/01/2022 19:08

I've found this really interesting reading and I am definitely on one of the home birth groups mentioned Grin

I definitely think that the medical profession have a lot to answer for in terms of making women want to birth on their own. It was definitely a fucking awful induction experience with DC1 that was behind my decision to have my second at home (highlights included the - female FWIW - obstetrician bringing in a group of medical students 48 hours deep when I was basically delirious with exhaustion and suggesting they "have a go" at examining me but fortunately the brilliant MW told them where to go). Vowed never to be induced for post dates again but I would have complied with all monitoring recommendations to avoid it. But I can totally understand why women who had similar experiences would be driven to avoid medical professionals.

As it turned out, I was one of those who called the midwives and nobody was available - I of course demanded somebody came out immediately Wink

But only because it was too late and DD ended up being delivered by two fantastic paramedics!

Namechangetimes100 · 10/01/2022 19:00

A lot of the info is evidence based, and it’s great to share the stats for each trust which is also see a lot of. It’s not about censorship it’s about moral and ethical responsibility and laymans can be wrong about certain things but admin need to make sure that they aren’t supporting dangerous practices. Prem home delivery with no medic present is flat out dangerous, maybe baby won’t need nicu but there’s a good chance they will.
Growth restriction is different and it is intrinsically difficult to be 100% sure of as an arterial doppler gives a snapshot of a moment in time.
So to clear things up - sga stands for small for gestational age which translates as less than 10th centile on personalised charts or less than 9th centile on who redbook charts.
Low birth weight is a birth weight of less than 2.5kg and less than 2nd centile in who redbook charts
Fgr or iugr is fetal growth restriction or inter uterine growth restriction where there is a pathological factor hindering the baby’s genetic growth potential (genetic abnormality, maternal lifestyle such as substance abuse or malnutrition or anxiety and depression to a lesser extent, infection or most commonly a placenta issue). A baby can be growth restricted at any birth weight but most are low birth weight.
7/10 sga babies are what’s defined as constitutionally small ie they are petite and low on the charts but there is no pathological reason as to why.

3/10 are growth restricted.
The rcog old guidelines used to recommend induction at term 37 weeks for all babies under 10th centile as they couldn’t be sure which small babies were truly growth restricted, these guidelines were released in 2013 and superseded in 2019 with the saving babies pathway which recognises that babies who measure between 3rd and 10th centile (in the absence of other concerning factors ie elevated dopplers, genetic condition, soft markers of anything on a scan, elevated or reduced liquor, or significant reduction in growth velocity etc) are likely to be consistutionally small and mothers are to be offered an induction at 39 weeks as that’s the week that correlates to the lowest rate of still birth and there is still a relative degree of ambiguity in if baby is growth restricted.

So now you know.

OP posts:
AliceAll · 10/01/2022 18:36

@Namechangetimes100
Yes fair call, I also find it annoying when people throw their qualifications around as if that gives their opinions more weight, so sorry about that. :-) I did feel a need to rebut the narrative that everyone posting in the group is either aggressively anti-medicine or uneducated and vulnerable. There are several highly experienced midwives who post in the group too and much of the information shared is evidence based.

Regarding misinformation in such groups it's a tricky one, it would be unethical and dangerous for free-speech to attempt to close such groups and the fact is that medical professionals are often not up to date with the research, often give misinformation and/or use coercive language and sometimes make genuine mistakes so it's really important to have a forum in which to question statements made by medical professionals - and this is most important for those who are not otherwise going to go and read up the papers to inform themselves. There is a huge power-imbalance here and in general people are more likely to believe doctors than a random person on the internet - even if the doctor is talking rubbish. In real life I know several people who have been coerced into things they didn't consent to and which ultimately caused them or their baby harm. I think if they had been more informed beforehand it is likely they would have had a better outcome.

Re the small babies thing; you are obviously more informed on small babies than I am. I only briefly looked it up when I got referred for an extra scan due to one inconsistent measurement (by a student midwife). I wasn't convinced that they were following the RCOG guidelines in recommending this as it was only one inconsistent measurement and not by my usual midwife but I was at 36 weeks by this point and I wanted a presentation scan before a homebirth anyway so just went along with it. The research I read at the time was that induction for small babies (without other signs of growth restriction) caused more complications with no improvement in outcomes. Maybe this has been superseded. In real life I know several people who have been mistakenly (and against RCOG guidelines) put on a high-risk pathway for growth which impacted their future care. On the group I haven't noticed people saying to ignore abnormal artery readings and mostly people are saying that you need two scans to diagnose growth restriction - which I believe is in line with RCOG (unless

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 18:25

it goes tits up and it's radio silence from everyone apart from the NHS who were still there even though I'd been such a dick.

Quite. I wonder how many people would really ‘put their faith in nature’ if they knew an ambulance wouldn’t come rushing to their aid the moment the luck turns. Not many I expect. Thank goodness you’re both ok. Those people have a lot to answer for.

BananasOfTheWorld · 10/01/2022 18:04

I'm here because a certain doula with a god complex is bragging about how amazingly crazy all her supporters are on facebook and I forgot I still follow her.

I'm not sure why I'm still beating myself over the head with these birthing groups. Everyone in them was behind me when I was trying to have a dangerous freebirth after multiple c sections - until it went wrong. Radio silence. Zero support. Stories like mine don't fit the narrative, when we've done everything "right", seen the chiropractors, bought the crystals, had the independent midwife and doula and affirmations and refused all interventions and then it goes tits up and it's radio silence from everyone apart from the NHS who were still there even though I'd been such a dick.

I am grateful every single day that me and my baby are ok. That my selfish desire for that birth that everybody says all women are able to achieve didn't happen, because I would have died - not because of a cascade of intervention, but because of my own idiocy. I am thankful for a hospital that gave me a repeat c section and my beautiful baby is here with me right now, and I'm still able to have more babies if I want to (who will all be elective c sections from now on).

I saw the same thing in VBAC groups, where the stories where people defeat all odds get millions of likes. The repeat c sections more often than not get quietly dismissed. HBAC groups, where people don't acknowledge the posts about rupture or people who just can't birth vaginally. I'm so sick of the praise these groups give to stunt births, and I think it's incredibly dangerous and toxic and not supportive at all (unless your story fits the narrative of course).

Sorry this is rambly. Thank you for creating this thread. I don't see these opinions very often because my world is so "crunchy". I'm so sick of the language of achievement people use, and the narcissism it creates. I remain proud of my body, because I realised that it can do many other things despite not getting a vag badge, and thank god I'm alive to realise that.

EatDrinkEatDrink · 10/01/2022 17:55

@mothertomore believe it or not I've not watched videos from "badassmotherbirther" I just let the midwives and doctors crack on and do their jobs during my births. Are you the woman out my group 🤣 you sound a lot like her? She trained her husband how to deliver a breech baby via 10min YouTube video 😆, "watch this jobs a good'un", was probably your badassmotherbirther video she used too.

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 17:40

[quote Mothertomore]@lifeisnteasy they pick and choose which data to use. Who guidelines are for the world yet the nhs don't mention them when giving you information. Infact they barely if ever inform you of your rights or evidence[/quote]
And you’re not doing that by ignoring a study relevant to our health system and the country we live in 🧐 righto

Mothertomore · 10/01/2022 17:30

@lifeisnteasy they pick and choose which data to use. Who guidelines are for the world yet the nhs don't mention them when giving you information. Infact they barely if ever inform you of your rights or evidence

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 17:16

@EatDrinkEatDrink that woman was stupid and reckless and is proof that underneath all the statistic waving and talk of ‘informed choices’, deep down some women are just happy to gamble the health of their unborn child to impress their lentil weaving birthing goddess overlords.

Liathroid · 10/01/2022 17:15

@AliceAll what are the exact differences between a home birth in the U.K. and in the US in terms of midwife support etc? Given vastly different healthcare systems - private insurance being the main one - it’s disingenuous to use these studies to imply the results are consistent with U.K.

I’m surprised you are so highly qualified yet conflate different country contexts. Fairly rudimentary mistake. In my PHD country context was important when discussing results of my own work vs others findings and how they differ. A good researcher doesn’t just find studies that back their own views and ignore this important dimension.

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 17:14

[quote Mothertomore]@aliceall you just can't be heard over those who believe "medical professionals know best"

@lifeisnteasy you said a vba2c sounds really risky. No more risky than a vbac.

@EatDrinkEatDrink breech is just a variation of normal have you not seen badassmotherbirther videos on Facebook?[/quote]
Badassmotherbirther 😂 are we supposed to take that seriously?

Are you going to respond to my point about the Birthplace study proving FTM homebirth is riskier for babies?

And vbac isn’t necessarily risky but hba2c is. That’s why it isn’t recommended.

Mothertomore · 10/01/2022 17:11

@aliceall you just can't be heard over those who believe "medical professionals know best"

@lifeisnteasy you said a vba2c sounds really risky. No more risky than a vbac.

@EatDrinkEatDrink breech is just a variation of normal have you not seen badassmotherbirther videos on Facebook?

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 17:09

@AliceAll but how can you make the categorical statement that it is?

Surely the study relevant to the U.K. is the most valuable?

AliceAll · 10/01/2022 17:08

@lifeisnteasy
www.thelancet.com/journals/eclinm/article/PIIS2589-5370(19)30119-1/fulltext
www.thelancet.com/journals/eclinm/article/PIIS2589-5370(19)30119-1/fulltext
You are correct that the birthplace study did find a small but statistically significant increased risk to the baby for FTMs but still showed that home was safer for the mother. The review and meta analysis I posted above includes the data from the birthplace study along with several other large studies and did not find this effect. Arguably the birthplace study is the most relevant data to the uk but I do think the fact that it isn't replicated in other studies is important to consider when making categorical statements that it isn't safer for FTMs.

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 17:04

[quote AliceAll]@lifeisnteasy
The Hutton and Reitsma papers in the Lancet I was referring to find that there is no difference in safety for first babies, and improved safety for first time mothers at home.[/quote]
Well, the Birthplace study says that isn’t the case 🤷🏼‍♀️ And this is the study used by the NHS.

AliceAll · 10/01/2022 16:57

@lifeisnteasy
The Hutton and Reitsma papers in the Lancet I was referring to find that there is no difference in safety for first babies, and improved safety for first time mothers at home.

EatDrinkEatDrink · 10/01/2022 16:17

I'm in a fb group of women with the same due date. When we had our babies one of the mums shared her "amazing" birth story. She wanted a free birth but her husband didn't so the compromise was a home birth. She started to do bizarre things on the group like advising other mums to turn down scans to monitor the baby in the final trimester (😱) because she had and she goes with her "gut" rather than go for a scan. It all came out why she was refusing scans after the birth. Turns out the baby was breach and she clearly knew as she got her husband to watch a video on delivering a breach baby just a week before the birth - funny eh? So she went into labour and kept telling her husband not to call the midwives. Got to the point of pushing and it was obvious her baby was breach. At this point the husband rang the midwife, the midwife told him there was nothing she could do it was an emergency and he needed 999. The woman was fuming that the midwife wouldn't ring 999 for them (must have disturbed her zen birth). She thankfully got the baby out and the paramedics got wires crossed and thought the woman just needed transferring to hospital not an active (breach) birth so they only arrived nearly an hour later. The woman hadn't delivered the placenta, it was stuck. They told her she needed help or she could bleed to death. Again she fumed and didn't want to go in. They took her in after promising she could leave as soon as it was sorted. The first midwife that saw her in hospital was frosty and told her how silly she had been, they didn't allow her out for a week as they were concerned about what had happened, she wanted to complain and probably did.

She told this birth story on the group and was met with applause, I was flabbergasted people were telling her how amazing she was. Her baby could have died, if it'd got stuck on the way out, it could have been completely starved of oxygen. Instead they all told her what an "amazing mama" she was. This woman also refused to vaccinate her baby too, again trusting that gut of hers. I feel sorry for the child and husband, it seems this woman's need for a natural zen birth completely trumped the life of her unborn baby. Still makes me angry now thinking about it, I had to sit on my hands not to comment on how stupid she was at the time!!!

Namechangetimes100 · 10/01/2022 16:09

But the problem is on those groups they aren’t being informed the risk is glossed over, that’s the point

OP posts:
Namechangetimes100 · 10/01/2022 16:08

[quote Mothertomore]@Namechangetimes100

I don't get it. You know the system is messed up so why can't women choose a free birth? As long as they are aware and well informed of the possible risks then send them luck.

All the advice isn't for everyone. Some are willing to stand their ground more than others and that's fine too.[/quote]
I mean you can, doesn’t make it safe or wise and it’s not something that should be blindly encouraged as it’s not without risk. Even more so if you’ve shunned all scans and medical care.

Reason why it shouldn’t be encouraged

My friend and I gave birth a week apart, both hospital births. Mine, had some pethedine for the b2b birth but it was complication free so I could have free birthed. Fantastic
My friend however dilated super quickly and then went on to tear up down and side and everywhere and then had a severe bleed and nearly died, all really quickly, if no medic was there she’d be dead. No external risk factors just one of those things.

Both low risk second babies.

OP posts:
Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 16:05

[quote Mothertomore]@lifeisnteasy I've had 3 vba2c's[/quote]
🤷🏼‍♀️

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 16:05

Quote:

For women having a first baby, a planned home birth increases the risk for the baby. For nulliparous women, there were 9.3 adverse perinatal outcome events per 1000 planned home births compared with 5.3 per 1000 births for births planned in obstetric units, and this finding was statistically significant.

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 16:03

@Mothertomore

Most of the transfers are for pain relief or "long labour" they are rarely for emergencies. *@lifeisnteasy*
Read the nearest paragraph to the bottom of the screenshot. Adverse outcomes for first babies are nearly doubled in home births.
Mothertomore · 10/01/2022 16:01

Most of the transfers are for pain relief or "long labour" they are rarely for emergencies. @lifeisnteasy