Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
Mam91 · 10/01/2022 21:37

I haven’t managed to read this thread in full, but just in response to this for anyone else reading..

The Birth Place Study quoted here is now over 10 years old, and quite outdated in terms of home birth research.

The Birth Place study looked at 64,000 births, but since then in 2020 there has been a very large review of homebirth research looking at 500,000 births, which has shown no statistically significant difference in outcomes for babies (birth first born and subsequent births) when you compare home to hospital birth, but significantly improved outcomes for mothers (in terms of reduced rates of both complications and intervention) in the low risk population. The study is in The Lancet which is one of the worlds’ leading medical journals, so certainly a respectable source.

I hope that is reassuring for anyone who feels that home birth would be a good choice for them personally.

Smile
rosettesforjill · 10/01/2022 21:07

@Lifeisnteasy this was at the actual point of being in labour so it didn't feel like I had much choice! She was awful. I wasn't even arguing with her, just asking questions (honestly! I have massive respect for doctors normally) but she was speaking to me in the most condescending way.

The surgeon who did eventually drag my son out with forceps was great though, as was the consultant in another hospital who briefly looked after me when I had extra growth scans. It's just that first hospital experience that put me off for any future births.

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 21:03

Can someone tell me who this is please? I’m intrigued

Ikona · 10/01/2022 20:59

@Namechangetimes100 She's posting a few "highlights" from the replies on her page, apparently she definitely 100% hasn't read the thread 😉 and asked someone to send her the worst replies to post about... because she doesn't care at all, y'know. 🤭

PurpleRock · 10/01/2022 20:58

@Maranta

I'm all for evidence based home birth when appropriate, I had 2 myself. But I personally can't get my head around freebirth. And I think it's unbelievably unethical for a doula (not a medical professional) to be charging people for "advice" on how to have one. The admin of one of these groups is always rattling the tip jar, charges for phone calls with her, turns every post people make to being about herself and posted the other day saying "my groups are an empire and I am their dictator", which is... yikes. There was also a vote for "woman of the year" by a clothing brand. They asked people to nominate someone who deserved to win it. One of the nominees was a woman who volunteers to photograph stillborn babies, incredible stuff. But the admin of one of these groups asked all the group followers to nominate her, in multiple posts. Telling people "it's your last chance to nominate me!". She ended up with loads of nominations and likes from all her group members and won the competition. Kind of defeats the point of people nominating someone and that person winning organically.
I completely agree with you. It frustrates me that she is always begging for money. Her language is very high level narcissist as well. ‘Wouldn’t you love to vote for me’. For someone who is meant to be a doula, she doesn’t attend many births does she as she’s always on fb sharing her ‘R A F F L E S’. I do think if people give out ‘professional’ advice on Facebook, they should be liable if the worst happens. And I’m a massive (safe) homebirth supporter but I do draw the line at this doula. She had people post reviews on her trust pilot 🥲
Thevoiceofreason2021 · 10/01/2022 20:56

Iits flipping scary. I thought the NCT was bad …. I was told by my midwife to attend the NCT class as the ones run at the hospital were during working hours - deliberately to discourage working women from joining and thereby keeping costs down . They were aimed at unemployed and they provided only a service for those who couldn’t afford paid for classes. The lack of NHS finding is driving women to seek birthing courses from all sorts of questionable sources. I honestly couldn’t believe the bullshit I heard at the NCT.

Namechangetimes100 · 10/01/2022 20:45

@Maranta

I'd love to comment on it one day! But can only imagine the flying monkeys going crazy at me. I'm still in the groups because I like to watch the occasional dramas unfold sometimes during long night feeds 😆
Ha! I’ve left the group now but I’ve few friends in it and I’ve head the thread has created quite the stir in the group (absolutely not the intention) but all I can think is it must have hit a nerve for the admin to be so triggered. She must know she’s elevated to sainthood some risky decision making
OP posts:
Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 20:43

[quote rosettesforjill]@Lifeisnteasy when I was induced, I absolutely wasn't coerced into anything, but I was patronised, treated as a specimen to examined and generally treated like crap by one specific doctor and that 100% put me off being under consultant led care unless absolutely necessary.[/quote]
Why not just change consultant?

rosettesforjill · 10/01/2022 20:40

@Lifeisnteasy when I was induced, I absolutely wasn't coerced into anything, but I was patronised, treated as a specimen to examined and generally treated like crap by one specific doctor and that 100% put me off being under consultant led care unless absolutely necessary.

Maranta · 10/01/2022 20:38

I'd love to comment on it one day! But can only imagine the flying monkeys going crazy at me. I'm still in the groups because I like to watch the occasional dramas unfold sometimes during long night feeds 😆

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 20:31

@Theregoesmyhomebirth

I suppose my point is that often the advice of professionals/NICE guidelines are hailed as flawless and to be taken as gospel. But they're not perfect, have their own biases, and aren't always based on that great data, because well (for the reason you stated above) there isn't the data available.
I don’t think they are hailed as flawless. But it’s the best evidence we have, and based on the experience of people who see many many more births than we do from a few Google searches. It’s much better than no evidence, and there’s a reason why the advent of medicine has seen maternal and neonatal mortality drastically reduce.

I think MN can be… borderline paranoid when it comes to the intentions of medical professionals. It does feel slightly that women who do not have the exact labour/birth they want say they were ‘coerced’ or that the doctors had some kind of
malign determination to medicalise them as much as possible. It feels very much like a case of ‘shoot the messenger’ and medical staff being blamed for simultaneously ‘stressing mums out’ by telling them risks, and ‘not helping them make an informed choice’ by not telling them risks.

They can’t win really.

5keletor · 10/01/2022 20:18

@Maranta

I'm all for evidence based home birth when appropriate, I had 2 myself. But I personally can't get my head around freebirth. And I think it's unbelievably unethical for a doula (not a medical professional) to be charging people for "advice" on how to have one. The admin of one of these groups is always rattling the tip jar, charges for phone calls with her, turns every post people make to being about herself and posted the other day saying "my groups are an empire and I am their dictator", which is... yikes. There was also a vote for "woman of the year" by a clothing brand. They asked people to nominate someone who deserved to win it. One of the nominees was a woman who volunteers to photograph stillborn babies, incredible stuff. But the admin of one of these groups asked all the group followers to nominate her, in multiple posts. Telling people "it's your last chance to nominate me!". She ended up with loads of nominations and likes from all her group members and won the competition. Kind of defeats the point of people nominating someone and that person winning organically.
I saw that too, completely agree with everything you've said, @Maranta. 😔
Liathroid · 10/01/2022 20:17

[quote AliceAll]@Liathroid The US has a crazy health system and no it’s not remotely generalisable to the UK but, if you read the papers I cited, I did not do that. The Hutton and Reitsma papers are based on studies from around the world and include data from the UK, the Netherlands, Canada, Iceland and New Zealand.

The authors are Canadian. I'm surprised you'd confuse Canada and the US while trying to make a snide point about geographical context :-p (Joke by the way - not trying to get at you - but humour is hard to convey by text)[/quote]
I don’t find it funny. I may have misread where the authors were from but you are telling women on this board that risks of home birth are X when this is based on many different countries experience under vastly different healthcare systems rather than taking the official NHS advice and data based on the actual healthcare system where women are giving birth. While the different findings are interesting from an academic point of view it’s misleading information like this that puts women at risk.

Namechangetimes100 · 10/01/2022 20:14

@AliceAll yes that’s my understanding, unless baby measured 99th centile and then one week measured 15th and or had elevated dopplers but I don’t think elevated dopplers alone is cause enough for concern but I do imagine at the end of pregnancy it would be enough to recommend induction (but I’ve not read this in the guidelines)

15th centile in utero means different things for different people so will plot differently in the WHO charts but basically it’s all variations of normal.

I’d recommend a quick google of saving baby pathway, it’s the second edition you want. Very interesting read for me personally as my first was sga and it was terrifying but she was induced at 37 weeks based on old guidelines, the trust now follows this pathway so she was only 5lb at birth but would have be more like 6lb if induced at 39, so I did my research prior to my second pregnancy.

OP posts:
China007 · 10/01/2022 20:13

@BananasOfTheWorld sorry to hear about your experience. Glad you and baby are well.

Who is the doula?

LFalk1ner · 10/01/2022 20:06

I'm in the homebirth group of Sam's, I've always found that she and the group have celebrated all births regardless of how baby arrived be it c section, hospital or homebirth. I have seen Sam tell women to seek medical attention when necessary. Sam and her group gave me the confidence to speak to consultants and find a plan that worked for me and my baby.
After my first birth I can see why people wish to avoid a hospital birth. Not once was I listened to, after pushing for an hour a registrar walked in and told me I was having an episiotomy and forceps delivery. No mention of risks, no consent from me gained. I wasn't even told the reason why. After being told the episiotomy was a small incision I was cut to my fucking leg while I screamed in pain begging her to stop. I felt each part of the forceps go in and be clipped together. My memory from giving birth is me laying there screaming for her to stop and shouting no. As a rape survivor this is incredibly upsetting. After being stitched together (door open legs in stirrups and everything on show) I was walked to the postnatal ward where the midwife laughed at me because she walked so fast with my baby and I couldn't keep up. When I was pregnant with my second I spoke with my midwife who was horrified by what had happened, she arranged for me to have a birth debrief with a senior midwife. Turns out that there was no real reason for the forceps delivery, baby was 2cm from crowning and I'd probably have pushed him out in the 11 minutes the registrar took to set up (I'd been told I no longer needed to push so definitely not an emergency). I am in daily pain from the episiotomy scar 4.5 years later. Baby was born with perfect cord blood gasses and perfect apgar score.
After my first birth I was determined to have a homebirth but after a few things cropped up I decided to opt for the mlu, I was never once judged by the group for that. My entire pregnancy I was petrified at the thought of giving birth in hospital again. I spoke about it to every single medical professional I saw in my pregnancy. Thankfully the gd consultant I saw was brilliant, extremely supportive of my choices and worked with me instead of telling me what to do. She had to offer induction at 40 weeks per guidelines but even said herself that it was unnecessary and could see no danger in my declining it as I had an appointment at 40+1 to review. NHS care is not usually tailored to each woman and baby, it's blanket guidelines that can cause more harm than good. In a gd group I was in there were so many cases of people being told that baby was measuring big so induction was needed at 36/37/38 weeks to put a woman through a 4 day induction ending in c section only for baby to weigh 6lbs or less. My first birth experience very nearly put me off engaging with the maternity service's, not the homebirth group.

Theregoesmyhomebirth · 10/01/2022 20:01

I suppose my point is that often the advice of professionals/NICE guidelines are hailed as flawless and to be taken as gospel. But they're not perfect, have their own biases, and aren't always based on that great data, because well (for the reason you stated above) there isn't the data available.

Maranta · 10/01/2022 19:57

I'm all for evidence based home birth when appropriate, I had 2 myself. But I personally can't get my head around freebirth. And I think it's unbelievably unethical for a doula (not a medical professional) to be charging people for "advice" on how to have one. The admin of one of these groups is always rattling the tip jar, charges for phone calls with her, turns every post people make to being about herself and posted the other day saying "my groups are an empire and I am their dictator", which is... yikes. There was also a vote for "woman of the year" by a clothing brand. They asked people to nominate someone who deserved to win it. One of the nominees was a woman who volunteers to photograph stillborn babies, incredible stuff. But the admin of one of these groups asked all the group followers to nominate her, in multiple posts. Telling people "it's your last chance to nominate me!". She ended up with loads of nominations and likes from all her group members and won the competition. Kind of defeats the point of people nominating someone and that person winning organically.

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 19:52

@Theregoesmyhomebirth I feel like you’re trying to make a point, but I’m not sure what it is?

Theregoesmyhomebirth · 10/01/2022 19:45

@Lifeisnteasy Yes, Thankyou I am aware of that. But surely there must be some recognition the data itself is flawed? My clinical information is currently going to St George's to form data on modi twins, but I'm not convinced they will recognise the role the current practice has on it (coercive healthcare, treatments given based on existing guidelines). Certainly a question for the researchers, must remember to email them.

My point was that the evidence is pretty shaky in terms of how applicable it is given the differences in population and healthcare. But it's not that relevant to the point of the OPs thread so I won't continue.

Lifeisnteasy · 10/01/2022 19:31

@Theregoesmyhomebirth that’s because it’s unethical to experiment on pregnant women and put them in high risk situations for the sake of data collection.

AliceAll · 10/01/2022 19:28

@Namechangetimes100 Thanks for that. I might copy that info in case it comes up again this pregnancy. Just checking if I've understood correctly - for babies that are around the 15th percentile - they would be classed as normal and not recommended for induction (unless also showing a drop of percentiles over multiple measurements)?

Theregoesmyhomebirth · 10/01/2022 19:22

I've been looking at the NICE guidelines for twin pregnancy (mostly timing and mode of delivery this evening).

When you look at the rationale and data that the guideline is based on it tells you there wasn't enough data so it's all based on the committee's joint opinion/experience (which I'm sure isn't biased in any way Hmm). And the data? One source from Ireland, none from the U.K, South Korea, USA, Pakistan...

bozzabollix · 10/01/2022 19:21

My daughter who’s seven and the light of my life would be dead had I followed the advice of these cranks. As it was she was born with a crack team of paediatricians who saved her life.

Birth means nothing, yes great to have a straightforward one but the end game is a healthy baby and mother. That’s all I cared about. Thanks to expertise that’s exactly what I got.

BiscuitLover3678 · 10/01/2022 19:14

And you can look at relative risk vs absolute. And you know, the actual recovery and trauma of parents and babies afterwards.