Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
MimiDaisy11 · 11/01/2022 17:40

@TwittleBee

I remember when I took a hypnobiryhing course, the course leader plainly said that those women who do not succeed in having a natural birth fail because they had not practiced enough with the breathing techniques and had failed to see the "surges" as natural and helping (and not painful)
Did anyone challenge it? It’s amazing how ridiculous some people can be. My baby was too big and physically stuck. I’m not sure what breathing techniques would have done 😂
MimiDaisy11 · 11/01/2022 17:38

@Reasonablewoman

You conclude that home birth is as safe as hospital birth for all women based on the current situation in a developed country where only low risk women really do it and even then a lot go into hospital. Do you honestly not recognise the failure in logic there? Why not look at countries where women don’t go to hospital as much to make your case like developing countries. Only problem is hundreds of women die everyday due to pregnancy and childbirth. Those women are mostly in poor countries where they don’t go into hospitals.

TwittleBee · 11/01/2022 17:22

I remember when I took a hypnobiryhing course, the course leader plainly said that those women who do not succeed in having a natural birth fail because they had not practiced enough with the breathing techniques and had failed to see the "surges" as natural and helping (and not painful)

Namechangetimes100 · 11/01/2022 16:58

But @Reasonablewoman you, like every other member of a certain group who’s commented on this thread, has missed the point. No one is really writing off home birth entirely. In fact it was my plan a (same as others here) it’s the dangerous advice and encouragement of dangerous practises that are the problem not to mention the bullying behaviour of certain group members that we’ve seen on this thread. If you can’t see that after 19 pages, then I don’t know what to tell you

OP posts:
Lifeisnteasy · 11/01/2022 16:52

Anyone who wants to know more and decide what they think for themselves could read Dr Sara Wickham's excellent books, especially those on induction. Also a book like Why Home Birth Matters will explain the evidence around that.

So people should decide what they think by reading books by home birth advocates?! That’s not deciding what ‘they’ think, that’s deciding what Sara Wickham thinks Hmm

Lifeisnteasy · 11/01/2022 16:35

The ratio of key adverse outcomes like death at home and in hospital is THE SAME. It is just as safe to birth at home.

That’s because the majority of women who choose home birth are low risk and have already had a straightforward delivery.

What do you think would happen if home birth became the norm among high risk or first time mothers?

Reasonablewoman · 11/01/2022 16:08

I cant speak for every group or every comment made in them but on the whole these groups are invaluable for empowering, informing and supporting women to make their own decisions in the face of a deeply misogynistic, abusive, incompetent and non- evidence- based maternity system. They even up the balance a little in a world where women are not only inadequately informed about their rights, their options and the pros and cons of each option but are frequently misinformed, coerced, abused, threatened and assaulted during pregnancy and birth by those who allegedly know best and are there to care for them.

A third of you reading this were dissatisfied with and traumatised by your births, usually because of medically unnecessary interventions or the way you were treated by staff.

I have seen at least one doctor in this thread chiming in on this. She began by introducing herself as a doctor. She then gave a figure on how many people die in childbirth. She then claimed that the only sensible place to give birth is in hospital and concluded that not many die in our country because they do go to hospital. This demonstrates perfectly why people are learning not to trust maternity professionals and why they shouldn't. Her argument has so many holes in it and so little evidence to support it that is laughable, but because she says she is a doctor, mentions death and danger and then presents her view on what should happen as the only sensible and safe thing to do she expects us to be shocked and awed into accepting her word as gospel and doing what she says. These are the casual coercion tactics that are used every day by all kinds of maternity professionals. Look behind the bluster, self- deception and pure bullsh*t and you will find very little of value and substance in these kinds of persuasive statements. But they are good at it and it usually works, because people mistakenly but understandably think that there is no reason not to trust and believe a professional, have confidence in their knowledge and ability or doubt that they have our best interests at heart.

The truth is that at least a third of births are an unpleasant or traumatic experience, usually because of staff behaviour and unnecessary interventions. The ratio of key adverse outcomes like death at home and in hospital is THE SAME. It is just as safe to birth at home. Yes, the availability of emergency medical care is useful and does help to prevent bad outcomes when it is needed, but if people start at home they usually birth at home and even if they transfer their experience and outcomes are better. However, medical involvement is usually unnecessary and causes a lot if damage and harm, inclydongbdeath of mum or baby. The figures on how many deaths are caused by or even just associated with medical interventions in birth simply arent available. But just like some here can tell if friends who avoided medical interventions and had bad outcomes, so can I tell if people I know whose babies were killed during unnecessary procedures like inductions and forceps deliveries. I also know tonnes of people who were permanently damaged physically and mentally and whose children were permanently damaged as a result of medically unnecessary medical intervention. Each intervention carries risks, usually including death of baby and/ or mother. They are most often performed because of an abstract statistic about risk of stillbirth rising by a fraction of a percent because of things like length of pregnancy or age. People need to know that they or their baby could die unnecessarily and that they or their baby could be disabled or otherwise scarred for life if they consent to the medically unnecessary interventions being foisted upon them. They rarely do know and often don't even know they have a choice. If they do then it is usually from other women who have learned the hard way that they hear of these things, often through home birth groups.

The dominant narrative, as demonstrated in this thread, is that doctors and midwives know their stuff, are basing advice on evidence and have our best interests at heart, that we should do what they say and that we should birth in a hospital. Thank god there are groups and people spreading the message that birth can and often does work well without medical intervention and at home, that people have choices and rights and should do their own research, that medical care is always available and sometimes useful but does not have to be our first pirt of call when giving birth and that we may regret blindly trusting medical professionals to take charge of our births.

Many of those who go for home births do so at least partly because they have had a bad experience in hospital and realise how many risks and down sides that there are with medical intervention. They have also learned that birth is not as generally dangerous as they have always been led to believe and that they and their bodies arent as incapable of taking charge of and successfully carrying out their birth as they have been led to believe.

Yes it is not good if people tell others to do truly dangerous things or reject medical help if it is truly needed, but whether it is needed is usually debateable.

Yes, medical care is important to have available and sometimes needed to save life byt it also causes a lot of harm and is usually not needed.

Yes, things sometimes go wrong and extra action is sometimes needed and people should not feel that they failed if they do, but it is rare in natural birth.

A lot of people get Stockholme Syndrome and feel grateful to the medical staff who harmed and abused them and people are often convinced it was all necessary when it wasn't. People become numb and feel pressured to be grateful they and their babies are alive. Like anyone withbteauma they may not realise the experience was traumatic or that they are carrying trauma. Like many abuse victims they may not realise immediately or ever that they were abused. There may be people reading this realising they are carrying trauma from birth. There is help available. Trauma informed birth trauma therapy is available. Puck a Doula or birthkeeper or other practitioner who recognises the harm the system can do and will not invalidated your experience. Discussing your experience with those who were involved at a birth afterthought meeting may lead to gaslighting and retraumatising.

I am shocked to see people saying things about what can be done about home birth groups! The system is oppressive enough without wanting to stamp out the small chunks of light and critical voices and places to go to get support and the antidote for all the lies and harm and coercion. Presumably people saying that would feel it was sinister if people were wondering what could be done about womens net forums to bring them into line. I'm sure people may occasionally give careless or duff advice in home birth groups but the overriding message is to do your own research and make your own decisions considering whatever seems relevant. They are a voice of reason that is desperately needed and all women likely to give birth ir support those who do need to think more critically and be much more sceptical about 'medical advice'.

You dont need to take my word for everything I have said. Anyone who wants to know more and decide what they think for themselves could read Dr Sara Wickham's excellent books, especially those on induction. Also a book like Why Home Birth Matters will explain the evidence around that. Those two sources would provide you with the evidence to back up all I have said and more.

Happy birthing everyone.

Namechangetimes100 · 11/01/2022 15:42

Exactly @TheHairyDinosaur death the ‘great mother’ will claim who she wills apparently such is the circle of life, so if you or your baby die as a direct result of the advice of certain groups then that’s the way the ‘great mother’ intended it, and nothing at all to do with incredible amounts of peer pressure to conform to a certain ideology.Confused

You’re absolutely spot on @Ikona no one mentioned anyone by name, or actually any group by name it was only when she entered the chat that she made it all about herself and her username is her actual name sooo… Hmm.
The info shared whilst altered slightly is still enough to be potentially outing i suppose, that poster also used the fact that my child is undergoing genetic testing to make a point which is ableist and disgusting to victimise a toddler. Basically this woman entered the chat, made a general conversation all about her and then set her followers on us. I do wonder what some of these people are capable of. It’s remarkable really, she must feel very threatened.

OP posts:
Maranta · 11/01/2022 15:39

@TheHairyDinosaur

So basically what this woman is saying

I'm going to tell you everything, convince you that free birthing is the best for you as medical experts will abuse you, but if your baby dies that's not my fault, I just gave "advice" it was up to you to decide, despite the fact I've been a ear worm for the past however many months convincing you this will all be ok 😳 but don't blame me because I am a every day goddess ....

Yes, exactly that! And her followers can't see how awful that is!
Ikona · 11/01/2022 15:06

Glad that you didn't provide accurate information and the post is now gone @Namechangetimes100.

I may be wrong, apologies if I am, but I don't recall anyone specifically naming the group or doula before she posted, the first time I saw a specific reference, apart from her own post, was in response to a member asking which group was being discussed, maybe 2 or 3 pages ago. In fact I don't think the doula has been named by anyone apart from herself, in her username.

TheHairyDinosaur · 11/01/2022 15:03

So basically what this woman is saying

I'm going to tell you everything, convince you that free birthing is the best for you as medical experts will abuse you, but if your baby dies that's not my fault, I just gave "advice" it was up to you to decide, despite the fact I've been a ear worm for the past however many months convincing you this will all be ok 😳 but don't blame me because I am a every day goddess ....

Namechangetimes100 · 11/01/2022 14:49

@Lifeisnteasy

I think the doula writing those posts is scoring a massive own goal. Unprofessional, hostile & petty. If you run a ‘business’, you have to expect feedback on it, both good & bad. The fact she has one of her ‘followers’ trawling the threads on her behalf just makes it look even worse. Seeing her posts as a potential client, she would strike me as very thin skinned and intolerant of anyone who doesn’t share her mindset. I get that reading threads about yourself isn’t very nice, but if you make yourself famous in certain spheres, you have to expect controversy.
Completely agree and the thing is, the thread wasn’t started about her, so it’s a remarkable degree of narcissism too. The thread was about these sort of support groups/ pages on Fb and Instagram that glamourise dangerous practices and advise, not all examples came from her page, yet she’s made it all about herself and turned herself into the home birth martyr
OP posts:
Namechangetimes100 · 11/01/2022 14:45

It’s really scary actually how far some of these people will go to prove they’re way is the right way. It’s even more scary because actually I’ve not said a word against any specific person in general more just the culture that that specific poster instantly proved with her post.

They accuse the medical establishment or coercive behaviour, in many instances it’s true but what they’re doing is trying to bully people into submission. Really scary and deranged behaviour, yet not one of them has acknowledged the fact that routinely dangerous advice has been given, classic deflection.

Think this sort of behaviour proves PPs point about the cultish level of behaviour.

Luckily MN HQ took it down.

OP posts:
BananasOfTheWorld · 11/01/2022 14:45

[quote Lifeisnteasy]@ElvenMoonwings

I think it’s disingenuous to pretend that alongside the ‘helpful’ narrative there isn’t an element of ‘home/free birth at any cost, and anything else is a failure’. The need amongst some to prove their ‘birthing goddess credentials’ is more important than medical risk or the safe delivery of their baby.

It’s funny, I actually think these groups cause just as much birth trauma as they claim to solve - I’ve seen quite a few posts on here by new mums upset that they didn’t have the all-natural homebirth they wanted, saying they feel like a ‘failure’ and ‘my body is meant for this, so why did it let me down’. They’re baffled that the affirmations and candles didn’t work, and as PP said, the groups are quick to shut out any woman whose story doesn’t fit the narrative.

With regards to taking ownership of their decisions, I’ve seen quite a few posts where women have chosen homebirth against medical advice, it went wrong & now they are looking to sue the hospital/midwives. Or they take the tack that ‘if the hospital hadn’t done XYZ I wouldn’t have felt forced to choose a homebirth, so it’s their fault anyway’. Hmmmmm.

I didn’t know anything about such groups when I was pregnant, I just wasn’t the internet research type. I had a forceps delivery & I remember feeling so proud of myself afterwards and like I had ‘done it’ Grin I had no idea at the time that such a delivery would be regarded as such a failure by some people. I just felt that I’d had one hell of an experience & here I was with a healthy baby, I’d done it!

So yes I am quite sceptical of these groups being ‘all about informing and supporting women’, I feel there’s also a strong narrative of ‘how much can you impress us by rejecting medical advice’.[/quote]
agree with this wholeheartedly.

I'm also seeing people who say that they've "seen" posts being supported and well received no matter the mode of birth, and that they're grateful because they feel the groups gave them wonderful homebirth experiences. I wonder how many people who have had difficult deliveries would genuinely say that these communities have supported and empowered them? In my experience, and from anecdotal experience from other women who have had similar experiences, it's been the evidence based communities that have been there to empower and strengthen them for motherhood - not so much the supposed "sisterhood" of these groups.

Maranta · 11/01/2022 14:44

Also - and I have to share this because it sums up the ethos of the groups, or at least the vocal majority - here is a comment on one of the Facebook posts about this thread:

"We are fucking nutters because we have Potent Powers 💥 of DISCERNMENT knowing Fiction Fallacy and Theory from FACTS, Living Truth and embodied cognition. Yay to us your brains Logic calculator is a magical creation you really need s YouTube channel on it and lecture and book 📕 on Amazon on it."

Enough said.

Lifeisnteasy · 11/01/2022 14:42

I think the doula writing those posts is scoring a massive own goal. Unprofessional, hostile & petty. If you run a ‘business’, you have to expect feedback on it, both good & bad. The fact she has one of her ‘followers’ trawling the threads on her behalf just makes it look even worse. Seeing her posts as a potential client, she would strike me as very thin skinned and intolerant of anyone who doesn’t share her mindset. I get that reading threads about yourself isn’t very nice, but if you make yourself famous in certain spheres, you have to expect controversy.

BananasOfTheWorld · 11/01/2022 14:36

@Namechangetimes100 I am not surprised this has happened, but I'm really sorry because I think your thread is really important and it proves an important point. There's a real darkness and callousness alongside the toxic positivity that so many of these "natural" communities promote, I was so indoctrinated by it all for a really long time and it's only now I'm out the other side that I can see it.

Maranta · 11/01/2022 14:30

@Namechangetimes100 WOAH. Not sure what I've missed here but I can gather and I'm really sorry a member of the cult has come here to try to doxx you. Just proves us right about the group and many of its members.

Namechangetimes100 · 11/01/2022 13:56

@Proudnutter you’re a piece of work! This is some really disgusting behaviour, especially seeing as I’ve never personally attacked any member of any group personally nor shared any personal info on them. Vile, truly bullying behaviour.

Firstly that’s assuming that all info provided to MN are 100% accurate and not been tweaked so they aren’t outing. Some have been tweaked for anonymity yet the spirit and essence is the same. You’ve got the place I live wrong, age, cause of death for my father wrong (can’t blame you for that though the death certificate named 4/5 causes).

It’s really fucking low to use someone’s dead relative to make a flimsy point.

But you do you.

OP posts:
Proudnutter · 11/01/2022 13:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Redflower2 · 11/01/2022 12:57

I was pursuing a homebirth and recommended to join this group. I did and found so much of the information posted by other members to be amazing - advice on what I’d need, when to fill birth pools, and I enjoyed reading the birth stories (I read many, not just the homebirth ones; there are lots available including induction, c section and hospital birth stories which are fully supported by the members).

The issue I have with the group is the moderation of if. The doula and other admins are letting a significant amount of false and dangerous information be posted in response to posts. While I understand that everyone should be responsible for what they believe and the decisions they make, it’s evident from some of the posts that there are a lot of vulnerable women on there who are willing to believe anything that is posted. It’s scary to me what some people post (mostly things like all medical professionals are liars 🤯) and it frightens me that there are people out there who’ll be reading the posts as facts and making decisions around their baby’s health based on them.

Lifeisnteasy · 11/01/2022 12:12

@ElvenMoonwings what happened with you if you don’t mind me asking?

ElvenMoonwings · 11/01/2022 11:35

[quote Lifeisnteasy]@ElvenMoonwings

I think it’s disingenuous to pretend that alongside the ‘helpful’ narrative there isn’t an element of ‘home/free birth at any cost, and anything else is a failure’. The need amongst some to prove their ‘birthing goddess credentials’ is more important than medical risk or the safe delivery of their baby.

It’s funny, I actually think these groups cause just as much birth trauma as they claim to solve - I’ve seen quite a few posts on here by new mums upset that they didn’t have the all-natural homebirth they wanted, saying they feel like a ‘failure’ and ‘my body is meant for this, so why did it let me down’. They’re baffled that the affirmations and candles didn’t work, and as PP said, the groups are quick to shut out any woman whose story doesn’t fit the narrative.

With regards to taking ownership of their decisions, I’ve seen quite a few posts where women have chosen homebirth against medical advice, it went wrong & now they are looking to sue the hospital/midwives. Or they take the tack that ‘if the hospital hadn’t done XYZ I wouldn’t have felt forced to choose a homebirth, so it’s their fault anyway’. Hmmmmm.

I didn’t know anything about such groups when I was pregnant, I just wasn’t the internet research type. I had a forceps delivery & I remember feeling so proud of myself afterwards and like I had ‘done it’ Grin I had no idea at the time that such a delivery would be regarded as such a failure by some people. I just felt that I’d had one hell of an experience & here I was with a healthy baby, I’d done it!

So yes I am quite sceptical of these groups being ‘all about informing and supporting women’, I feel there’s also a strong narrative of ‘how much can you impress us by rejecting medical advice’.[/quote]
I don't see any of the negatives you say happening in the group's. If people actually are blaming the health service for their bad outcomes,
personally I can sympathise with that sometimes because feeling forced to freebirth or whatever because of the inadequacies of the NHS isn't a free choice really. In an ideal world there would be good, personalised, respectful care from the NHS and actually there usually very much isn't, so if I did hear that, I'd be sympathetic. Not sure why you think that should be a problem.

Incidentally but pertinently I think if people do think and feel that they've failed for not having an all natural free birth, or whatever birth they wanted, they're totally entitled to think and feel that way. Not to be gaslit. I failed to freebirth, and that is what I think about myself. It is what it is. To think that others have failed if they don't free birth and all natural, likewise and to not understand how anything else can mean success, that's simply human nature.
To be nicer and more equalitarian about how I personally feel a failure, I no doubt also would be a total failure at coping with a caesarian or with additional childbirth interventions I didn't get forced on me.

Namechangetimes100 · 11/01/2022 11:34

It’s a very entitled and sort of high school way of looking at things ‘ so and so doesn’t like me (in this case agree with me) so they MUST be jealous of me’ such a shame

OP posts:
Ikona · 11/01/2022 10:48

@Namechangetimes100

I quite enjoy how she’s given everyone a little dictionary definition of certain words including the phobics.. Hmm

Oh my, she’s very triggered by being called overzealous isn’t she. Not responded to the fact that the group routinely encourage really dangerous practices though which is why I started the thread (wasn’t sure If I was the only one given how much of an echo pool that group is)

I noticed that. I've also noticed others saying things along the lines of it's because posters disagreeing didn't get the birth they could have had, had they trusted their body, etc. I opted for a hospital birth, it was lovely and my child arrived safely, which wouldn't have happened had I waited for birth to start on its own at home. Home birth is a fantastic option, but it was one I absolutely didn't want and would have been distressed and anxious if I hadn't been given the MLU/hospital option.