Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
AHobbyaweek · 12/01/2022 12:53

I resonate with the post from @Teaandcakeordeath83 as I am also a scientist and work in pharma and shock horror one of the products I work on is an induction agent.
I am also not a fan of the woo of anything in general but used the home birth group mentioned to get all the evidence links find the newer studies and support from AIMs.
I had a home birth VBAC after weighing up the increased risk (scar rupture) and it's outcomes and deciding that the risk was worth the lower risk if I was induced, interfered with or pushed to follow the standard VBAC protocol in hospital.

I do understand where people are coming from with any misinformation, any anti HCP commentary and the like but it has swung the other way here with a lot of people getting personal and attacking groups in general.

Unfortunately there is very unlikely to be truly unbiased information coming out of the NHS, pharma content or other healthcare organisations as having worked with all of them for years they all have their own agendas or laws preventing them giving you all the information. They all try but a hospital policy might stop you getting information about the risks of induction for instance or the laws around patient information from a pharma company might stop you getting information about the options for induction in case they accidentally push you to request a certain thing.
To be truly making informed decisions as a patient in any disease area you have to be able to understand health information and do your own research. I have seen patients in almost every disease area get better results and care, just by having their own research and asking the right questions of their HCP. Maternity services are no different other than you then have the complexity of your babies life as well and suddenly everyone calls you names if you question HCPs about anything. Even if just asking for the evidence.

Namechangetimes100 · 12/01/2022 12:19

@NightGinn

It’s been mentioned on FB, so prepare for incoming traffic
@NightGinn what did I miss?
OP posts:
Namechangetimes100 · 12/01/2022 12:17

@Mumofthree4210

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.
@Mumofthree4210, please unlike all your peers that have been ‘set on us’ read the thread and understand what’s being said but numerous posters. I’ll summarise for you below in case you’re struggling:
  • home birth is a lovely option for a lot of women especially those who have had traumatic previous births. Low risk and some of those sitting in the more arbitrary high risk categories (being over 35 etc)
-Certain groups often have useful info like where to buy birth pools and twinkly lights BUT there is also encourage some really dangerous choices (declining all obstetric care, Prem home delivery without medics, refusal of extra monitoring and early delivery for iugr) I can list how It’s dangerous if you like -rejecting all medical advise is dangerous - this is common sense
  • birth is a physiological event that can become a medical emergency
  • obstetrics in the uk needs reform
-as you and your group Mates have demonstrated there’s a real sectarian mentality in that group us v them. Some of the comments that MN hq have thankfully deleted have been really threatening. -Initially no individual group or person were referenced just an overall theme that was until a certain individual entered the thread, made it l about herself, rallied the troops (you included) with some inflammatory propaganda (that perfectly fits us v them narrative) and then set them to attack.

Hope that helps before you call any more names!

Take care

OP posts:
AliceAll · 12/01/2022 12:17

@Lifeisnteasy "Can you please tell me why homebirth as a standard would be so great for first time mums, given half of women would need to transfer (I’m guessing an emergency ambulance ride wouldn’t do much for their mental state or birth trauma?)."
The majority of homebirth transfers are non-emergencies, and the transfer rate is lower for trusts where more homebirths are carried out (birthplace followup study). I literally just explained all the reasons why it would be better - reductions in intervention rates are shown directly in the birthplace study including for FTMs. This is replicated in Reitsma 2020. Birth trauma hasn't been studied by intended place of birth as far as I know so that was conjecture but 3x lower EMCS, instrumental birth and episiotomy rates are likely to reduce trauma don't you think?
I also should clarify that I don't think home-birth should be forced on anyone who thinks they would feel safer in on OU. I think a lot of the fear around birth is disproportionate and unhelpful but hospital is always going to be the better choice for some people even without medical risk factors - eg stressful home environment, past trauma at home, domestic abuse, past medical emergencies, or even just people who work in hospitals and feel more relaxed in that environment. I really wouldn't want a situation where it's pushed on women as the best (in the generic breast-is-best style), without the option for them to just say - no it's not for me don't mention it again.

"Why would homebirth make tearing & haemorrhage less likely? These are unforeseeable events, and the latter is a common reason for homebirth transfers as it is."
In the birthplace study there were lower incidences of both at home but it's not statistically significant. Nove et al 2012 find significantly fewer PPH at home in the UK. Reitsma 2020 also found significant reductions at home but I know you don't like international studies. I just looked again at the data - I misremembered the stats on tears for FTMs (by the time that paper came out I'd already had my first so it wasn't as relevant to me). Overall it's lower at home but no difference for FTMs so tearing rates might not change. I don't know the reasons for the lower risk of PPH - maybe because women at home are more relaxed, and have less disruption to the hormones that drive labour. How would you explain the statistics?

"How do you know intervention is usually needless, as opposed to sometimes needless?"
I don't believe that intervention at the point that it happens is needless - however the much lower rate at home compared with hospital (where the consequences of watchful expectancy should be lower) strongly suggest that the majority (2/3) would have been unnecessary at home and are an indirect consequence of the cascade of intervention. The rates of intervention are ~3x higher in hospital (in low risk women incl FTMs). So 2/3 of them wouldn't have been necessary at home. How do you explain the tripled intervention rate?

"What would you do if you were me out of interest? I’m a type 1 diabetic with a previous VB. Would you consider me suitable for a homebirth despite guidance?" I don't know anything about the specific risks of type 1 diabetes but I think you should ask what the specific risks are, what the likelihood of them occuring at home and hospital are, compare them with the relative risks of other complications and make an informed decision from there. I certainly don't think the policy should be, "oh you have a health-condition - lets put you into a pathway with a 3x higher rate of intervention without your consent." I imagine you'd be pretty annoyed at being treated like that in any other area of life or healthcare just because it's easier than treating you as an individual. There may well be reasons why homebirth would be riskier for typr1 diabetes on balance but I don't know anything about it.

Rachael4210 · 12/01/2022 12:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

NightGinn · 12/01/2022 11:13

It’s been mentioned on FB, so prepare for incoming traffic

MeganJames101 · 12/01/2022 10:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Lifeisnteasy · 12/01/2022 10:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ as it quotes a deleted post.

Mumofthree4210 · 12/01/2022 10:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Mumofthree4210 · 12/01/2022 10:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Teaandcakeordeath83 · 12/01/2022 00:20

I haven't read through them all but I suspect I am a member of the home birth group in question. I think most people on here would have a shit fit at my home birth decisions- I had a home birth after 2 sections with maternal medical conditions alongside a suspected small baby- that turned out to be 2.5lbs heavier than predicted and ironically now puts me under the pathway for monitoring for "big babies" should I have a fourth ...

Personally I found the group useful. I'm a scientist by trade and like seeking out evidence and anecdote. I could do without the woo but that's my approach to all woo- not just birth. There aren't just successful stories on the group- you get to see the entire spectrum of births and outcomes which I found more informative than the outright coercive spiel I got from fellow NHS HCPs. You get to find new resources (aims, mbrace studies, Cochrane library, evidence based midwives etc etc etc) and evidence based papers which allow you to make a decision based on your knowledge of your body, your HCPs advice and what the literature says (and the quality of that). Would I leave my personal medical decisions to a Facebook group?- no. Would I use a home birth group as a place to find out information that in turn leads to other resources?- yes. Do I agree with every decision a mother has made about their pregnancies and births on any Facebook group I'm on?- no. But it's not my body, baby or decision to make- and that goes from decisions ranging from free birthing to repeat sections. 🤷🏼‍♀️

@lifeisnteasy "Part of the issue is that fanatical natural birth advocates talk about ‘evidence’, which is statistical averages & likelihoods, but then complain that women aren’t treated as individuals & instead lumped in with everyone else. Which is it?"

You've answered your own question there. Statistical averages and likelihoods are a useful decision making tool. They shouldn't be the decision nor presented as the only possible outcome nor skewed to fit personal bias. For example I was quoted (without any evidence other than the consultants "gut instinct") "a 1 in 5 chance of killing my baby" if I had a home birth. Yet when I said to the consultant using exactly the same rationale of gut instinct that I believed my risk of killing my baby was in line with the risk of such an event happening in hospital I was instantly dismissed- only consultants are allowed gut instinct apparently. Another statistic I was given was that my chance of uterine rupture would be 1 in 200. A statistic that was repeatedly hammered into me as though it was a certainty it would happen and result in instant death for me and my baby. Well that statistic shows that 199 vbacs don't rupture. It doesn't even begin to breakdown the outcomes of the rupture (a vanishingly small percentage of those ruptures are catastrophic) yet it's one of the main reasons that consultants push for repeat sections. My consultant couldn't even produce the statistics on rupture for our incredibly busy maternity hospital. They don't collect them as it's so rare- this is a hospital with more than 8000 births per year and a monthly section rate of roughly 35%- yet repeatedly I was told how irresponsible I was being as I would almost certainly experience a catastrophic rupture. Informed consent is just that- if a woman knows the risks and is happy to accept them then the HCPs providing that care should treat them individually.

Birth is emotive but HCPs do themselves and the pretty shoddy evidence base they work on no favours by presenting data as gospel and lumping all women together.

Lifeisnteasy · 12/01/2022 00:04

[quote AliceAll]@Lifeisnteasy "What do you think would happen if home birth became the norm among high risk or first time mothers?"

For FTMs I would expect to see a massive drop in emergency Caesareans (I think the rate is around 15% when it ought to be around 3%), episiotomies and bad tears, postpartum haemorrhage, birth trauma, postpartum depression, and birth complications leading to women being classified as high-risk for all future pregnancies. According to Birthplace cost analysis, increasing homebirths would save the NHS loads of money. I'd also expect to see a massive increase in babies being born vaginally, being breastfed and a reduction in babies being born instrumentally, admitted to neonatal units, and exposed to antibiotics in early life. All of which would then result in reduced infant mortality and morbidity, reduced hospitalisation for infection, reduced allergies/asthma and may even result in health benefits lasting into adulthood. As a trade off for this there may be a slight increase in perinatal mortality - although further research is needed into why this is only seen in one uk study and not replicated in other similar health systems and whether it would still be the case were homebirth for FTMs to be normalised and not-treated as inherently risky.

In the case specifically of high-risk pregnancies it's not as clear cut - the Birthplace further analyses surprisingly found that homebirth significantly reduced serious harm to the baby for high risk pregnancy. These results are difficult to interpret - they didn't have enough data to separate out the many types of high-risk so there are a lot of confounding variables although they tried to account for these. When they looked only at the most serious outcomes, home was slightly higher than hospital but this was insignificant, whereas overall home was safer for the baby. I'm not sure how much weight you can place on this but it definitely implies that we should be much more individualised and open-minded about what is actually high-risk and what is increased risk but not necessarily prohibitively high-risk.

For example borderline low iron is enough to classify someone as high risk and they are recommended not to birth at home when moderately low iron does not increase the risk of PPH, does not increase the risk to the baby, and only increases the chance that you will need a transfusion if you have a PPH. Given homebirth is known to reduce the risk of PPH, informed consent should involve women having this explained to them and being allowed to choose their place of birth not being told (and I quote my midwife) "unless your iron is above the threshold by 38weeks, you won't be allowed to have a homebirth".

I do see advice on the group to ignore classification as high-risk and choose to birth at home anyway. The birthplace study would seem to agree with this advice - although I would personally be uncomfortable with drawing this conclusion from the data. I think where there are elevated risk factors the actual statistics should be given to the women to enable her to make as informed a decision as possible about place and mode of birth.

Since that is a million miles from the current situation it isn't surprising that occasionally people go to the opposite extreme when trying to fight against what is usually needless intervention. It doesn't make it right, and it doesn't mean that it won't occasionally result in a dangerous outcome, but it does make it likely that the groups do more good than harm. Which cannot be said of current obstetric units. I'm definitely not in favour of spreading misinformation. But I'm also in favour of free speech. And I'm very in favour of informing women of their rights and encouraging them to question their HCPs in situations where they are not being given the information needed or the even the opportunity to give informed consent. That doesn't mean the best choice might not be what the HCP recommended in the first place. But it does mean the woman should be given the numerical risks of the different options where that is available, the best guesses of the relative risks otherwise, and then allowed to make an actual informed choice. Since that isn't happening by default, it is on the whole helpful for other people to question whether listening to the medical professionals is truly the safest course of action.[/quote]
That is an incredibly assertive essay given it lacks any factual support.

Can you please tell me why homebirth as a standard would be so great for first time mums, given half of women would need to transfer (I’m guessing an emergency ambulance ride wouldn’t do much for their mental state or birth trauma?).

Why would homebirth make tearing & haemorrhage less likely? These are unforeseeable events, and the latter is a common reason for homebirth transfers as it is.

How do you know intervention is usually needless, as opposed to sometimes needless?

What would you do if you were me out of interest? I’m a type 1 diabetic with a previous VB. Would you consider me suitable for a homebirth despite guidance?

Jemily04 · 11/01/2022 23:25

Hmmm. I don't know why any of you lot are even in this FB group, there seems to be some kind of agenda going on as the experience I've had of being a member is far removed from the diatribe you are spouting.

I've had a tremendous amount of support through both of my pregnancies from Samantha, the doula you are sounding off about. I was induced at 39 weeks with my first and her advice and support was invaluable for making that a positive experience even though I was as terrified and facing a highly medicalised birth. I had many interventions and tests, all of which I received her advice and help with when posting publicly and messaging her privately.

I had my second at home and again her support was invaluable. Both of my full birth stories are in there , induction and home birth, neither is more important/relevent than the other. The group is a fabulous resource for birthing women to gain knowledge and insight into making choices for themselves. As I know firsthand, Samantha is a doula who supports a woman's right to choose how she wishes to birth. If you don't understand that, you obviously are only seeing what you want to see

nolongersurprised · 11/01/2022 23:18

I maintain that 'advice' from a 'goddess' does not promote the health or safety of babies and labouring women

It’s a self-selecting group, isn’t it? Anyone who finds a self-professed “goddess” inspiring is already well at the fringes of mainstream

AliceAll · 11/01/2022 23:06

@Lifeisnteasy "What do you think would happen if home birth became the norm among high risk or first time mothers?"

For FTMs I would expect to see a massive drop in emergency Caesareans (I think the rate is around 15% when it ought to be around 3%), episiotomies and bad tears, postpartum haemorrhage, birth trauma, postpartum depression, and birth complications leading to women being classified as high-risk for all future pregnancies. According to Birthplace cost analysis, increasing homebirths would save the NHS loads of money. I'd also expect to see a massive increase in babies being born vaginally, being breastfed and a reduction in babies being born instrumentally, admitted to neonatal units, and exposed to antibiotics in early life. All of which would then result in reduced infant mortality and morbidity, reduced hospitalisation for infection, reduced allergies/asthma and may even result in health benefits lasting into adulthood. As a trade off for this there may be a slight increase in perinatal mortality - although further research is needed into why this is only seen in one uk study and not replicated in other similar health systems and whether it would still be the case were homebirth for FTMs to be normalised and not-treated as inherently risky.

In the case specifically of high-risk pregnancies it's not as clear cut - the Birthplace further analyses surprisingly found that homebirth significantly reduced serious harm to the baby for high risk pregnancy. These results are difficult to interpret - they didn't have enough data to separate out the many types of high-risk so there are a lot of confounding variables although they tried to account for these. When they looked only at the most serious outcomes, home was slightly higher than hospital but this was insignificant, whereas overall home was safer for the baby. I'm not sure how much weight you can place on this but it definitely implies that we should be much more individualised and open-minded about what is actually high-risk and what is increased risk but not necessarily prohibitively high-risk.

For example borderline low iron is enough to classify someone as high risk and they are recommended not to birth at home when moderately low iron does not increase the risk of PPH, does not increase the risk to the baby, and only increases the chance that you will need a transfusion if you have a PPH. Given homebirth is known to reduce the risk of PPH, informed consent should involve women having this explained to them and being allowed to choose their place of birth not being told (and I quote my midwife) "unless your iron is above the threshold by 38weeks, you won't be allowed to have a homebirth".

I do see advice on the group to ignore classification as high-risk and choose to birth at home anyway. The birthplace study would seem to agree with this advice - although I would personally be uncomfortable with drawing this conclusion from the data. I think where there are elevated risk factors the actual statistics should be given to the women to enable her to make as informed a decision as possible about place and mode of birth.

Since that is a million miles from the current situation it isn't surprising that occasionally people go to the opposite extreme when trying to fight against what is usually needless intervention. It doesn't make it right, and it doesn't mean that it won't occasionally result in a dangerous outcome, but it does make it likely that the groups do more good than harm. Which cannot be said of current obstetric units. I'm definitely not in favour of spreading misinformation. But I'm also in favour of free speech. And I'm very in favour of informing women of their rights and encouraging them to question their HCPs in situations where they are not being given the information needed or the even the opportunity to give informed consent. That doesn't mean the best choice might not be what the HCP recommended in the first place. But it does mean the woman should be given the numerical risks of the different options where that is available, the best guesses of the relative risks otherwise, and then allowed to make an actual informed choice. Since that isn't happening by default, it is on the whole helpful for other people to question whether listening to the medical professionals is truly the safest course of action.

Patapouf · 11/01/2022 22:05

@Reasonablewoman

Looking after mothers would be good but separating the babies from them, putting them in night nurseries and only letting them feed on schedules as they often did is horrific and permanently damaging to the babues' brains, nervous systems, developmentvand health and not helpful for breastfeeding at all. So I'm glad they dont usually go that in maternity wards anymore.
What is the relevance of this ramble? Modern maternity care in the UK isn't like that at all.

I think we all need to recognise that different women want different things from labour and birth. Different women have different priorities too; it seems there are women who want a home birth so desperately that they would freebirth and are consequently unable to prioritise the wellbeing of the baby above their own wishes and birth preferences. I understand that those wishes may be rooted in previous trauma, and for that the maternity services in the UK has a lot to answer for.

What makes these groups dangerous is the clear bias and agenda of the admins. I maintain that 'advice' from a 'goddess' does not promote the health or safety of babies and labouring women when it is centred on encouraging women to not be 'mainstream' and not listen to medical professionals.

Energy would be better used to campaign for reform in maternity services.

Reasonablewoman · 11/01/2022 20:36

Looking after mothers would be good but separating the babies from them, putting them in night nurseries and only letting them feed on schedules as they often did is horrific and permanently damaging to the babues' brains, nervous systems, developmentvand health and not helpful for breastfeeding at all. So I'm glad they dont usually go that in maternity wards anymore.

Namechangetimes100 · 11/01/2022 19:33

. Thank god for the enthusiastic amateurs I say. They have no vested interests unlike professionals and from what I see that dont tend to try to impose their views on women either, unlike professionals. .

Even the ones who’ve made it a small business and charge for their ‘expertise’ have no vested personal interest in promoting their opinion above all else right?

Also I’ve bullied no one. Someone came on to the thread with an identifiable username, the thread at that point was quite general not aimed as a specific person or group, that person then made it all about themselves and then riled up her following and sent them after me and other posters by making a series of social media posts making herself the martyr

OP posts:
Reasonablewoman · 11/01/2022 19:26

Hi. I have not read all 19 pages but I have seen people dismissing home birth generally and I have seen bullying behaviour towards those disagreeing with the general thrust of the thread or seen to be part of an undesirable group.

So I don't know what to tell you, except its not you I'm really speaking to in my comments, but people who might benefit from them and from some balance in the discussion.

The books I mention are written by people critical of the system who openly declare that. They nevertheless have professional backgrounds, are learned and knowledgeable and evaluate the evidence. They do not dismiss all medical intervention and nor do most of the people in home birth groups. They are a good antidote to the absent or biased info given by professionals with undeclared interests and agendas and a very medical biased two dimensional.approach to birth.

I disagree with all bullying, gaslighting and brow-beating, including that routinely done by professionals and including yours.

Reasonablewoman · 11/01/2022 18:57

"Deferring to somebody with professional medical knowledge" is not "overwhelmingly the smarter option" when it comes to being pregnant and giving birth. This is the problem. Interesting that you like it to having your appendix out. This illustrates the problem with many 'professionals' in the field of maternity. I see that you neither approve of women referring to 'amateur facebook groups' nor of them independently consulting available evidence, both of which you poor scores upon. Again all or nothing thinking assuming that one could not consult and evaluate evidence and also reflect upon how it applied in their own case. Worrying as that is what medical professionals are supposed to do. Which is it? Both and more, because not all evidence is equal and we need to decide what weight to give it based upon how valid we think it is - again something that maternity professionals could and should help us with but don't. The 'amateur Facebook pages' I know of generally encourage people to do their own research and consider all that is important in their decision, providing links to those eminently qualified to comment and advise including those such as Dr Rachel Reeves, Dr Sara Wickham, etc as well as organisations that can advise them on their rights when they are being coerced. I dont know if you are a maternity professional. I hope not. But being pregnant isnt an illness and having a baby isnt nor should it be like having your appendix out. There is a medical principle around only doing as much as necessary and not more. There is an ethical imperative to facilitate and respect patient choice. There is of course also the important duty to do no harm. These things are routinely violated by professionals in maternity care every day.

There is no honour or value in being "somebody with professional medical knowledge" if you are ethically and institutionally compromised, if you work for a system that prioritises it's own safety above that of women and babies, if you are part of a discipline that ignores or selectively cherry picks evidence and guidelines and if you routinely use other coercion tactics in order to coerce women.into doing what is deemed best for you and the organisation.

Thinking that women should not listen to other women or do their own research about pregnancy and birth but should only defer to professionals sounds pretty fanatical to me. But if you wish to condemn people who give their time and support freely to support other women, be they 'amateurs', doulas, midwives or highly qualified academics with backgrounds in obstetrics and midwifery, that is your prerogative I guess. Thank god for the enthusiastic amateurs I say. They have no vested interests unlike professionals and from what I see that dont tend to try to impose their views on women either, unlike professionals. Strange that people trying to empower others to think critically and make their own decisions can inspire such outrage and scorn. I guess some people feel quite threatened by that kind of thing and others have had a real number done on them by people like you.

I wouldn’t blame somebody for dying during surgery to have their appendix out, but I would think they were silly if they refused the surgery & became very ill or died.

Part of the issue is that fanatical natural birth advocates talk about ‘evidence’, which is statistical averages & likelihoods, but then complain that women aren’t treated as individuals & instead lumped in with everyone else. Which is it?

crosstalk · 11/01/2022 18:56

@JustLyra The unfortunate thing is that we have too few midwives. So every midwife who goes to a home birth spends hours out of hospital and travel time. Leaving hospitals understaffed. And, if s/he has to call an ambulance if the delivery is more complicated for both mother and baby than expected, that's another ambulance out of commission.

It's a tough call. Of course women used to drop babies - but many had ripped perineums - and many died in childbirth when birthing at home, even fit, young and healthy ones.

Reasonablewoman · 11/01/2022 18:18

Nope. No lack of logic. perhaps careless reading or clouded judgement on your part. As I said, having medical care available is part of the picture. It isnt all or nothing. People can transfer but rarely need to. But all I am doing is rewriting my comment. So maybe you should just reread it instead. It might be a challenge because it contradicts your assumptions and prejudices. As for other countries. That is a straw man argument. We were talking about this country. Many things are different in other countries like general health, living conditions, hygiene, and all kinds of resources. Emergency medical care IS available to people in our country having a home birth and if any midwives attending cant provide it then there is usually time to get to hospital. That contingency is part of everyone's birth plan so, again, straw man argument. The fact is that it is as safe according to extensive research, in the country we are in and talking about, whether you like it or not. 'Low risk' people are not the only people who birth at home at all. Lots of people and growing numbers do it against advice having been labelled high risk for dubious reasons. It has become harder and harder to 'qualiry' as low risk as services have become more and more defensive in their practice. They are defending themselves against being sued for not doing enough, not protecting us from harm, especially all the harm they cause by doing too much. They are unlikely to be successfully sued for that. That is the bottom line. They are primarily concerned with covering their arses, not caring for us, and so are most of their staff). So aggressively do they defend their own arses that they trample over peoples rights and cause harm left right and centre. And their self-fulfilling risk labels only make them more aggressive towards the women they are supposed to be committed to do no harm to and to respect. Therefore, and increased risk that may occur for those labelled at risk needs to be balanced against an increased risk of IATROGENIC HARM. I am explaining this for those who might be reading this and be affected by it whose minds are open to consider the issues. I fear that you on the other hand only want to argue with me about things I didn't say and defend your prejudices and professional arrogance by suggesting I must have a logic defecit if what I believe contradicts that.

For anyone interested in evidence that home birth is just as safe and that even intending to have one can improve outcomes for you, here is a link and a extract. Remember that it is also worth critically evaluating why you have been labelled high risk if you have, how valid it is and how much it applies to you. 99% of the time you will probably find that it is either nonsense or exaggerated or is based on things that dont apply in your case. It is also worth weighing up the iatrogenic risks to you and your baby and how they will increase if you are viewed as a high risk ticking time bomb that could get someone in trouble if they dont throw everything at you.

Findings
16 studies provided data from ~500,000 intended home births for the meta-analyses. There were no reported maternal deaths. When controlling for parity in well-integrated settings we found women intending to give birth at home compared to hospital were less likely to experience: caesarean section OR 0.58(0.44,0.77); operative vaginal birth OR 0.42(0.23,0.76); epidural analgesia OR 0.30(0.24,0.38); episiotomy OR 0.45(0.28,0.73); 3rd or 4th degree tear OR 0.57(0.43,0.75); oxytocin augmentation OR 0.37(0.26,0.51) and maternal infection OR 0.23(0.15,0.35). Pooled results for postpartum haemorrhage showed women intending home births were either less likely or did not differ from those intending hospital birth [OR 0.66(0.54,0.80) and RR 1.30(0.79,2.13) from 2 studies that could not be pooled with the others]. Similar results were found when data were stratified by parity and by degree of integration into health systems.
Interpretation
Among low-risk women, those intending to birth at home experienced fewer birth interventions and untoward maternal outcomes. These findings along with earlier work reporting neonatal outcomes inform families, health care providers and policy makers around the safety of intended home births.

www.thelancet.com/journals/eclinm/article/PIIS2589-5370(20)30063-8/fulltext

Alyosha · 11/01/2022 18:07

The group is actually pretty anti-hypnobirthing actually...!

Anyway I do see misinformation - in the direction of promoting homebirth on that group. But I also see mounds of misinformation on mumsnet, typically in the direction of intervention.

I chime in to provide a different perspective from most now and then, but neither MN nor an FB group are the place to go for unbiased information. Nor is your HCP tbh: take GAP GROW charts. Completely unevidenced (apart from a study done...by the private company that owns GAP GROW) yet women are pushed into using them. Sadly maternity and obstetrics is too often an evidence free zone.

Fortunately there are a number of good quality studies going on to try and change this (the one on Carboprost comes to mind).

Lifeisnteasy · 11/01/2022 17:59

@Reasonablewoman

Oh yes it sounds like you'd be nothing but supportive! Hmm

So if your friends baby had been killed by an unnecessary induction, forceps delivery, epidural or caesarian would you also be blaming her for her choice to birth in hospital and go along with what they wanted to do to ger and her baby and slagging her off on mumsnet about it? You dont seem very scientifically minded for a HCP. Shouldnt you be basing your opinion on evidence rather than anecdotal examples and your own prejudice?

Well no because deferring to somebody with professional medical knowledge is overwhelmingly the smarter option - not bulletproof, but certainly more sensible than deciding you know better from reading some amateur Facebook pages.

I wouldn’t blame somebody for dying during surgery to have their appendix out, but I would think they were silly if they refused the surgery & became very ill or died.

Part of the issue is that fanatical natural birth advocates talk about ‘evidence’, which is statistical averages & likelihoods, but then complain that women aren’t treated as individuals & instead lumped in with everyone else. Which is it?

Reasonablewoman · 11/01/2022 17:44

Oh yes it sounds like you'd be nothing but supportive! Hmm

So if your friends baby had been killed by an unnecessary induction, forceps delivery, epidural or caesarian would you also be blaming her for her choice to birth in hospital and go along with what they wanted to do to ger and her baby and slagging her off on mumsnet about it? You dont seem very scientifically minded for a HCP. Shouldnt you be basing your opinion on evidence rather than anecdotal examples and your own prejudice?