Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
Patapouf · 05/01/2022 16:55

Amen OP!

Some of these groups are frequented by quite vulnerable women with learning difficulties or social care involvement and I'm horrified by the cult like bleating on about free birth and how doctors know nothing. Im intrigued by the motives of a woman who is adamant on having a home birth to the detriment of her health or that of the baby.

I'm totally in favour of home birth for low risk pregnancies that can be attended by appropriate midwives and supported properly. Women should have this option open to them when there isn't a high risk of them needing a hospital transfer.

Telling a woman on her 8th child who has refused scans and monitoring during pregnancy because she's agoraphobic to carry on and free birth if necessary or saying that the hospital 'have to send someone' is dangerously irresponsible.

There's one particular group that gives me the major rage that's run by a charlatan doula who is always posting with her begging bowl for donations and one day she's going to be responsible for the death of a mother or baby with her cavalier attitude towards the advice of medical professionals.

EgonSpengler2020 · 05/01/2022 16:47

@Goldi321

First time mum and medic here and I am finding a lot of these groups terrifying, there seems to be a real pack mentality and you get shot down if you try to be rational at all. FWIW all of my medic friends who have done either an O&G job or a NICU job have chosen to give birth in our local hospital. The NICU team are one emergency bleep away through a set of double doors, the alternative is a MLU with a 40+ minute transfer time (also taking into account how stretched the ambulance service is at the moment so you may be waiting for an ambulance- terrifying!). Our trust have also said for the last few weeks that they are unable to facilitate home births or births in the MLU due to staffing issues so I can predict a rise in free births.
Agree, I got shouted down at the positive birthing group for explaining the reality of the call coding/prioritising system in the ambulance service, and the reality of ambulance availability due to hospital delays (and this was pre covid). They would just keep saying "but the midwife said..." and believe that over the word of a paramedic with over a decades experience.
Greenmarmalade · 05/01/2022 16:43

@RavingAnnie But why on Earth would I want to ‘take back control’ from medical professionals who have years of training, specialist knowledge and expertise?**@HerculesMulligann because they often treat you really badly as a pregnant, birthing or postnatal woman. I can really see why people are responding in this way.

Goldi321 · 05/01/2022 16:37

First time mum and medic here and I am finding a lot of these groups terrifying, there seems to be a real pack mentality and you get shot down if you try to be rational at all.
FWIW all of my medic friends who have done either an O&G job or a NICU job have chosen to give birth in our local hospital. The NICU team are one emergency bleep away through a set of double doors, the alternative is a MLU with a 40+ minute transfer time (also taking into account how stretched the ambulance service is at the moment so you may be waiting for an ambulance- terrifying!).

Our trust have also said for the last few weeks that they are unable to facilitate home births or births in the MLU due to staffing issues so I can predict a rise in free births.

RavingAnnie · 05/01/2022 16:37

[quote HerculesMulligann]@RavingAnnie But why on Earth would I want to ‘take back control’ from medical professionals who have years of training, specialist knowledge and expertise?

Yes, doctors and midwives should of course be able to communicate clearly to patients, and treat patients as humans. But this can tip over into some people assuming they know better than the experts, partly due to misinformation or biased info on home birth sites.[/quote]
As I said in my post because medical professionals do not prioritise informed consent or seem to even like informed patients. And decisions are often pushed into patients when there are over options or that decision is not right for that patient. ELCS are a good example of this. Women are having to fight and fight fir options that should just be available to them.

I have been chronically ill for 6/7 years and have experienced the same treatment. I've been given wrong information and advice by med profs, twice that could have resulted in poor health outcomes, possibly death had I not done my own research and advocated for myself. I've had medical opinions pushed into he when other options were available. I've dealt with this by researching, advocating and ultimately seeking private treatment from well researched doctors. However what I am saying in my post if I wonder if the type of treatment by Ned profs that I have experienced and I know women experience around pregnancy and childbirth is partly the reason women are looking to free birth to take back some control of their own health.

I'm not saying it's a good idea. It's not. I think it's incredibly dangerous. However it could be a partial explanation of the cause. If people felt more involved and listened to and central ti their own healthcare maybe they wouldn't be taking it upon themselves to effectively DIY it.

BatshitBanshee · 05/01/2022 16:33

@CaMePlaitPas

I will always shout at people who say "your body won't grow a baby it can't birth" because it is nonsense. My second was 4.8kg (no gestational diabetes or pre eclampsia), got stuck, wouldn't move, no natural contractions after 10 days overdue, had to be pumped full of pictocin for my body to try to birth her. I was in labour for 16 hours and there was a moment where I didn't think she or I would make it. If I had been at home and refused care I'm not sure we would be alive today. Your body can and does play tricks on you.

I'm all for giving women information and the freedom of choice but not in spite of informed medical advice.

I had the exact same. 5.2kg baby, 2kg placenta, five days over, 18hr labour & baby got stuck. No diabetes or pre eclampsia and first baby so no previous birth to estimate size. Baby measured around 8lbs the week before. Had I not been in a delivery suite, one or both of us wouldn't have made it.
GrandmasterGlitchsMoustache · 05/01/2022 16:30

An NCT friend sent a photo of her 43 year old friend who had had her first baby at home. It was a breech birth. Thankfully all ended well. My friend was saying "it's so amazing, they would have forced her to have a C Section if she'd have gone to hospital". We were all expected to clap and cheer. I thought the whole thing was borderline negligent, to have a breech birth at home with your first child, esp. when you have no idea how your body will cope with childbirth. (I was sure I'd cope well with labour & childbirth but my body disagreed).

HerculesMulligann · 05/01/2022 16:27

@RavingAnnie But why on Earth would I want to ‘take back control’ from medical professionals who have years of training, specialist knowledge and expertise?

Yes, doctors and midwives should of course be able to communicate clearly to patients, and treat patients as humans. But this can tip over into some people assuming they know better than the experts, partly due to misinformation or biased info on home birth sites.

Veeveeoxox · 05/01/2022 16:26

@Comedycook

I've actually never seen the appeal of a home birth...what's so great about being at home? I wouldn't be more relaxed...I'd be an anxious mess in case anything went wrong!
I thought the same !!! With my DD I wasn't believed I was in labour they kept telling me to take deep breaths , and take a warm bath it got to to the point I was getting urges to push but I was so frightened I didn't want to. Finally got the hospital I had to walk into the ward as the midwives didn't believe me so no wheelchair and I felt like death warmed up . , I finally got examined and was 10cm DD came flying out 20 mins later . There was no benefit for me being in hospital just discomfort when I had done most of the labouring at home already. I will have a home birth if I have a second baby.
Amijustagrump · 05/01/2022 16:25

I've been seeing more and more of these! Including people saying "they have to send someone", well you might get a totally unqualified ambulance crew who have never seen a birth.. my DH is a paramedic who recently went to someone who stayed at home for a home birth- luckily it was the 5th baby he had delivered so he was one or the most experienced ones on shift that day! If something went wrong he would have had no idea what to do

RavingAnnie · 05/01/2022 16:22

This is terrifying but I wonder if this is in part a response to the way medical professionals, especially around pregnancy and birth, try to force decisions (often where they are other reasonable options medically) onto patients and patients feel not listened to and/or feeling like they have to aggressively advocate for an option that should be available to them.

Women want to feel in control of the health and birth experience and this sounds like a way of taking back that control or doing it all yourself! Very dangerous though as historically unassisted childbirth has a very high mortality rate.

CaMePlaitPas · 05/01/2022 16:22

I will always shout at people who say "your body won't grow a baby it can't birth" because it is nonsense. My second was 4.8kg (no gestational diabetes or pre eclampsia), got stuck, wouldn't move, no natural contractions after 10 days overdue, had to be pumped full of pictocin for my body to try to birth her. I was in labour for 16 hours and there was a moment where I didn't think she or I would make it. If I had been at home and refused care I'm not sure we would be alive today. Your body can and does play tricks on you.

I'm all for giving women information and the freedom of choice but not in spite of informed medical advice.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 05/01/2022 16:19

[quote Orarewedancer]@Letsallscreamatthesistene I wouldn't go as far to compare a home birth group to an eating disorder group, as that makes it sound like all home births are dangerous and against medical advice. It's more like a weight loss group which sometimes shows poor and dangerous dieting advice. The problem is that the admins/group leaders are happy to allow the poor advice but there don't seem to be any groups that aren't this way in some shape or form. If you are an individual of sound mind then you can see past those posts and take away the good stuff, but if not then that's where there's a problem.[/quote]
Im not comparing home birthing groups to eating disorder groups.

Im drawing a comparison between the medically unsound and dangerous advice given in each group.

So, as I said, any group allowing unsafe, dangerous medical advice should be shurt down.

EgonSpengler2020 · 05/01/2022 16:14

Via colleagues I am aware of a case within my health board where the mother wanted a home birth (during lockdown, so who can blame her). Midwives did a risk assessment of the property and were not happy with the access, so they asked the ambulance service to risk assess. Ambulance officer took an ambulance out and concluded that there was no way an ambulance was getting anywhere near the property. Midwives therefore advised strongly against homebirth but Mother still decided to go ahead.

Unfortunately, it all started to go wrong for both mum and baby, and apparently the whole situation became a very high stakes cluster f*CK.

Baby is reaching the age now where parents will find out how bad their decision truely was.

I think midwifery lead units attached to a full obstetrics/NICU unit are brilliant and if you are lucky enough to have one available to you, you would be crazy not to use it. I unfortunately had minor complications which meant I was on labour ward not MLU Sad

Franca123 · 05/01/2022 16:12

@irishfarmer your post had me stumped until. I noticed your name! 'I'm cattle' had a different meaning to me Grin

mindutopia · 05/01/2022 16:10

Unfortunately, there is a lot of dumb advice on all sorts of pregnancy groups. I've been a member of several home birth groups. I had all my babies at home. For me, it was a very positive experience and I really appreciated the support of being able to talk with people who were asking the same questions as I was and trying to figure out what was the right path for me. That said, no one should be so foolish as to seek medical advice from some random on Facebook. If people do that, it's not the group itself that's dangerous, it's people's lack of good sense and critical thinking skills.

But I don't think this is related to home birth specifically. There is lots of terrible advice on the internet, including on general pregnancy and birth groups, and people have traumatic, dangerous experiences in hospital as well. Birth at home is not necessarily more dangerous than birth in a hospital, but birth without proper support and clinical guidance is.

Cuddlemuffin · 05/01/2022 16:10

I've had 2 home births and have had similar experience of FB home birth groups. It wasn't for me so I left the group fairly quickly. Some people on there, seemed to me, no less bonkers than the anti vaxxers... but people are entitled to their choices. s
Some seemingly very dangerous advice from unqualified people that honestly think it is the best for mum and baby. I don't think anything can be done about these types of group tbh. It is quite scary though.

JustLyra · 05/01/2022 16:09

Also shockingly bad medical help with things like tongue ties add to the existence of the feeling that medical staff don’t listen and don’t know their stuff.

These groups aren’t the problem. The poor quality maternity care allowing them to flourish is the problem.

JustLyra · 05/01/2022 16:07

@Comedycook

I've actually never seen the appeal of a home birth...what's so great about being at home? I wouldn't be more relaxed...I'd be an anxious mess in case anything went wrong!
One-to-one midwife care for starters. Cleanliness for seconds (my local hospital has a terrible and not unfounded reputation).

The hospital birth before my HB was in a hospital so poorly staffed that my DH watched the head come out and prepared to deliver the rest of her while my MIL ran around trying to find a member off staff.
This was 20 minutes after I’d been fobbed off my an uninterested (likely through exhaustion) midwife who was convinced because of her experience I had hours to go and ignored my experience of my body.
The after care was non existent. The food horrendous. The 24 hour bright lights left me sleep deprived.The showers minging. And the staffs scarce, tired and ratty.

My HB was in a clean and relaxed environment. I had one-to-one care until shortly before birth then a second midwife for the birth. The food was good, the aftercare great (both from DH and the community care team). And I actually got sleep.
Also if there had been an emergency there was a mw with me - unlike in the hospital.

Babdoc · 05/01/2022 16:07

May I as a doctor point out that, globally, 800 women die every day from the complications of pregnancy and labour.
That's the equivalent of two fully laden jumbo jets crashing daily.
The reason the UK contributes very few deaths to these shocking statistics is because most mothers have the sense to listen to their obstetricians and give birth in a properly equipped and staffed labour ward.
And as a side issue, some of the pregnant women who did die in the UK last year were unvaccinated and died of Covid.
I wish patients would realise doctors are entirely motivated by patient safety and evidence based medicine. And listen to us instead of their hippy woo friends on Tiktok.

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 16:06

@GougeAway

At least you had the option of an MLU OP. Where I live it’s normal maternity unit in large teaching hospital with tiny, clinical rooms or home birth. After a hideous first birth in hospital I was booked for home birth with MW blessing. Unfortunately things became a little more risky so ended up in hospital again. I was bullied by the first MW who luckily went off shift before DC was born. Although not a choice I would make I can see why women would want to avoid a miserable birth in a huge impersonal delivery unit.
Oh yeah I can totally see the appeal of a home birth, heck I wanted one myself due to a similar experience to yourself with my first but it wouldn’t be in instances of premature labour, or iugr or breech, that’s an unnecessary risk
OP posts:
Orarewedancer · 05/01/2022 16:06

@Letsallscreamatthesistene I wouldn't go as far to compare a home birth group to an eating disorder group, as that makes it sound like all home births are dangerous and against medical advice. It's more like a weight loss group which sometimes shows poor and dangerous dieting advice. The problem is that the admins/group leaders are happy to allow the poor advice but there don't seem to be any groups that aren't this way in some shape or form. If you are an individual of sound mind then you can see past those posts and take away the good stuff, but if not then that's where there's a problem.

DollyDingleberry · 05/01/2022 16:05

[quote Namechangetimes100]@DollyDingleberry I’m sorry you went through that! I think the tone in those groups and the ‘it’s normal Hun, just feed feed feed’ message is incredibly damaging. I was so bad with it too, my daughter had a tongue tie that reattached and was slow gaining weight for a while and I couldn’t bring myself to pick up and put a tin of formula in trolley or pay for it at checkout because it felt like such failure. Dh had to go back around the supermarket when we were done to get it. So ridiculous looking back x[/quote]
I was the exact same for the first couple of months of formula feeding! I then started going to a mum and baby group locally and found that actually, loads of people were formula feeding/ combi feeding for all sorts of reasons and I wasn't a terrible mother afterall!

I think the most damaging thing for me was being told it was physically impossible for a woman not to be able to feed her baby and only ever as a result of very rare diseases, this was trotted out all the time - it made me feel like i was the worst woman in the world or maybe not even a woman despite the fact I'd just grown an entire human in my body and then given birth to him from my very womanly vagina Grin

Those first few weeks are enough of a headfuck without any of the additional nonsense!

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 16:05

@C8H10N4O2

Free births and home births are completely different things. Your title is quite misleading in that respect.

If a home birth group has been taken over by free birthers then its an issue to take up with that group or possibly the host if they have standards around dangerous medical advice.

It’s not been taken over by them, that’s the tone of the group, home Birth above all else, even if it means free birth.

My primary issue is the encouragement to ignore medical advice and have a home birth in exceptionally dangerous circumstances iugr, breech, lga baby, prematurity. I don’t think the title is misleading, these people still had home births and were encouraged to do so and to threaten to free birth if the hospital don’t comply with their wishes

OP posts:
oviraptor21 · 05/01/2022 16:04

@CrazyOldBagLady

I think so many women have had awful births where they haven't been given good advice, they have been coerced or had decision making power taken away from them. Informed consent seems to be quite far down the list of priorities of a lot of maternity care staff in NHS hospitals. This sort of group is the consequence of that. There are people out there giving good and balanced advice too but the NHS seem to not want anyone to deviate from their process or question what is happening to them or seek another route.

As any online space you will get the moderate and sensible and also the extreme and irrational types of people.

This. When you've experienced this kind of 'care' and you've experienced having lack of consent argued with and/or completely ignored you lose all faith in the NHS system.