Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
Changechangychange · 05/01/2022 17:46

@Waitingfirgodot ethically I completely agree with you, but legally they have every right up until the baby is born.

Laws attempting to give the fetus “rights” are generally used to harass and imprison women who miscarry (plenty of cases in El Salvador and the US). So while I agree pregnant women have a moral responsibility to protect their unborn child, I wouldn’t want it written into law.

RobotValkyrie · 05/01/2022 17:44

Women giving birth are stuck between a rock and a hard place.

Hospital birth are often atrocious, due to poor staffing levels and downright stupid policies... How are women supposed to get any rest on your average postnatal ward? Who on hell ever thought leaving a woman who's just given birth in sole charge of her newborn for the next few nights would be a good idea?

Hospitals are inhumane environments. They feel like battery farms.
On the other hand, natural birth groups are downright cultish.

MrsColon · 05/01/2022 17:43

@Franca123

I remember a woman in my NCT group saying, sheep give birth without help so why can't we? I just left that one as didn't even know where to start. Plus she looked terrified so I wondered if she was trying to convince herself not me.
That's hilarious - she has clearly never been a sheep farmer! Grin

Sheep are the stupidest, most ornery creatures imaginable - they randomly kill or maim themselves at the drop of a fecking hat, and plenty of them die or have their lamb(s) die during the birthing process.

Jesus wept.

EgonSpengler2020 · 05/01/2022 17:43

@Campfirewood

Man they’d all be horrified with my births! The first was a general anaesthetic c section, the most medical you can get! (I wanted a natural water birth). I think groups like those make women feel like they’ve failed some how, by simply needing medical intervention of any kind.
A closed friend of mine is an obstetric horror story. Baby 1 - sepsis causing preterm labour at 25 weeks. Baby 2 - episiotomy and forceps. Baby 3 - full term stillbirth (placental abruption and crash c section). Baby 4 - elective c section booked in but but baby had other ideas and came early when her obstetrician was away at a conference so she had the on-call OBS/gyn instead.

When I was pregnant she firmly and kindly told be that the only thing that matters is that you walk out of hospital carrying a healthy baby. Anything else is just a bonus. It really helped me approach my labour with an open mind, and go with the flow, not get caught up in this obsessive idealised perfect birth idea.

Waitingfirgodot · 05/01/2022 17:42

@betwixtlives

the point I was making was that women are autonomous beings and it’s their CHOICE to take the risk of free birth if they choose to do so. It might logically be a monumentally stupid risk to take but that’s irrelevant. It’s her choice. Ideally all these women would have read lots of robust research and reviewed the evidence of safety (or not) before making the decision to free birth but even if they haven’t…that’s their choice. It’s their baby they’re risking and not anyone else’s business. Which is the way it should be
I completely disagree with this. The baby being born is not the possession of the mother. They have no more right to risk that baby than I have a right to put my already born children at risk.
Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 17:38

I’m on that one too @Patapouf, i think why it’s so concerning is that there are a large amount of women with social services involvement or quite severe mental health issues all of whom are being encouraged to not engage with ‘the system’. I’m often tempted to comment esp around iugr and the bonkers things I’ve read about premature hb but I know I’ll get machine gunned

OP posts:
Changechangychange · 05/01/2022 17:37

@Namechangetimes100 yep, didn’t even register with an obstetrician. She was in the US, and I suspect finances played a part, though she is very new age and anti vaxx, works as a Reiki practitioner etc, and insisted it was 100% a lifestyle choice (her parents offered to pay for obstetric care and she turned them down). Planned to meditate silently through labour in the Arizona desert etc. This was pre-Insta, but there was definitely an element of promoting her own brand as a spiritual healer going on. I genuinely don’t think she expected her son to die though.

It was fucking awful, it all played out over FB and tonnes of us were screaming at her to go and get medical attention (in real life), but she was just listening to people blowing smoke up her ass about what a wonderful mother goddess she was, and what an uplifting spiritual experience she was looking forward to. Absolutely horrific.

Campfirewood · 05/01/2022 17:34

Man they’d all be horrified with my births! The first was a general anaesthetic c section, the most medical you can get! (I wanted a natural water birth).
I think groups like those make women feel like they’ve failed some how, by simply needing medical intervention of any kind.

CrazyCatLover · 05/01/2022 17:34

Oh my gosh you are definitely not being unreasonable. I work in NICU and have seen some babies come in to us in terrible conditions as a result of home births not supported by midwives. Few term babies with hypoxic brain injuries. Those groups should Deffo not be allowed.

Thelnebriati · 05/01/2022 17:30

Its not just birthing groups and imo is part of a wider problem of some social media accounts promoting DIY health as fact instead of a luxury belief.
They are in absolute denial of reality. Its like the woo crystals and essential oils craze of a few decades ago, but at least they never pretended it was safe for all women to free birth.

scottishnames · 05/01/2022 17:28

Like earlier farming posters, I have seen sheep die in/after childbirth and it's not pretty. For heaven's sake, even my favourite cat - and her 7 kittens!! - would have died without urgent subcutaneous calcium administered by trained, very highly medically qualified, vet.

I can remember my mother - who would be getting on for 100 if she were still alive - talking quite fondly about old-style (early NHS) maternity care. Of course, there were not the life-saving medical devices/tests available (for which we should all be incredibly thankful) but for 'normal' births, the experience, she said, was a good one. Rather like a nursing home. And almost entirely female. Experienced midwives were in charge. (Of course some had nicer personalities/better patient skills than others, but they all had time to be with mothers.) Peace and quiet and privacy were seen as absolutely essential - no visitors, even husbands/partners for just a couple of hours per day. (If it's relevant - and I think it is - animals almost always seek a quiet and dark place to give birth.) Good food. Lots and lots of rest (this was said to help breast feeding. My mother would not even go into the room where favourite cat was feeding the kittens - she said that she needed peace. ) Babies were taken to a night nursery, staffed by trained midwives, so that mothers could sleep. Dim lights only in wards. Five days 'rest and recuperation' in maternity home were seen as totally standard.

Now, of course, a lot of this will sound utterly horrible to many people today, but - I think- we can see where it is coming from. The idea was to support mothers as much as possible.

I don't know - I genuinely don't know - but can we learn anything from this today?

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 17:27

@Changechangychange

Yep. An ex friend decided to free birth, from listening to stuff like this about how she was “a goddess” and her body would instinctively know what to do etc. Went 6 weeks overdue. Baby clearly died at some point, though she insisted he was still kicking. Eventually became septic, and delivered a black rotten baby (I’m also friends with her sister, who was absolutely traumatised by seeing his body). Ended up having an emergency hysterectomy, almost died. All the fault of the doctors, of course, nothing to do with her refusing all obstetric care.
6 weeks overdue!

Those groups are full of you can’t be pregnant forever, you’ll give birth eventually. Well evidently not. I’m surprised she didn’t get septic before that point. I’ve read about phantom kicks and how the water sloshing around can still feel like movements.

I can’t get my head around 6 weeks overdue! Did she refuse all ante natal care from the beginning? I’m horrified reading this, your poor friend

OP posts:
Patapouf · 05/01/2022 17:25

@Namechangetimes100

That’s actually the group I’m on about *@Patapouf*

The things I read and that are actually being encouraged, birthing a premature baby at home! Most likely that baby will need nicu or wait out an iugr pregnancy. As my baby was sga I’m on iugr support groups and Christ, it pisses me off that the danger of it is completely obscured from vulnerable women. It’s one of the first groups that come up when you type home birth into Fb too so it’s gets a lot of traffic

They are a bunch of fucking nutters. I'm glad there are other rational but silent member of the group because sometimes it makes me worry about the current generation of new mothers Grin the sister group focussed on parenting is even more crackers but I do think there's a certain type of person who is more likely to post in and seek advice in a group like that...

I think our NHS needs a lot of funding and support so that women have better continuity of care and consent is sought for all interventions but I don't think the wholesale rejection of medical input is going to bring about any change. Give birth like a feminist is a really good book for anyone looking to make more informed decisions.

EgonSpengler2020 · 05/01/2022 17:24

@JustLyra

They would just keep saying "but the midwife said..." and believe that over the word of a paramedic with over a decades experience.

They’re not taking the word of a midwife of a paramedic though - they’re taking the word of the midwife they’re entrusting with their care (and are being implored on this thread to do so) over the word of a person on a group… that’s exactly what this thread is saying people should do.

The problem there isn’t the pregnant women, it is - once again - poor quality maternity care.

But sadly what some (pro homebirth) midwives are promising women in the context of ambulances is factually incorrect and not something that they have any authority over.
BiscuitLover3678 · 05/01/2022 17:21

I agree with your op. But I also agree that a lot of people (including on this thread!) have a huge fear and misunderstanding of home births. Actually a home birth is often the best thing for a mother and baby. Even hospitals midwives will tell you that. Free births are something else…

Changechangychange · 05/01/2022 17:20

Yep. An ex friend decided to free birth, from listening to stuff like this about how she was “a goddess” and her body would instinctively know what to do etc. Went 6 weeks overdue. Baby clearly died at some point, though she insisted he was still kicking. Eventually became septic, and delivered a black rotten baby (I’m also friends with her sister, who was absolutely traumatised by seeing his body). Ended up having an emergency hysterectomy, almost died. All the fault of the doctors, of course, nothing to do with her refusing all obstetric care.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 05/01/2022 17:17

@EishetChayil

The Facebook madness doesn't end with birth. Breastfeeding groups are rife with "chestfeeding" and "birthing bodies" nonsense that gets you banned if you question it.
Wtf is chestfeeding
Orarewedancer · 05/01/2022 17:16

@Patapouf

Amen OP!

Some of these groups are frequented by quite vulnerable women with learning difficulties or social care involvement and I'm horrified by the cult like bleating on about free birth and how doctors know nothing. Im intrigued by the motives of a woman who is adamant on having a home birth to the detriment of her health or that of the baby.

I'm totally in favour of home birth for low risk pregnancies that can be attended by appropriate midwives and supported properly. Women should have this option open to them when there isn't a high risk of them needing a hospital transfer.

Telling a woman on her 8th child who has refused scans and monitoring during pregnancy because she's agoraphobic to carry on and free birth if necessary or saying that the hospital 'have to send someone' is dangerously irresponsible.

There's one particular group that gives me the major rage that's run by a charlatan doula who is always posting with her begging bowl for donations and one day she's going to be responsible for the death of a mother or baby with her cavalier attitude towards the advice of medical professionals.

I am definitely part of the same groups you are and know which one you are referring to at the end... I really feel for the HCPs responsible for some of these women, it would keep me up at night.
Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 17:11

That’s actually the group I’m on about @Patapouf

The things I read and that are actually being encouraged, birthing a premature baby at home! Most likely that baby will need nicu or wait out an iugr pregnancy. As my baby was sga I’m on iugr support groups and Christ, it pisses me off that the danger of it is completely obscured from vulnerable women. It’s one of the first groups that come up when you type home birth into Fb too so it’s gets a lot of traffic

OP posts:
jesuistot · 05/01/2022 17:10

I think some of us felt a bit lost when trying to make our choices though. Hospital drs who strongly discouraged us from a homebirth but wouldn’t ‘let’ us choose an ELCS, citing inaccurate and bias stats, who said ‘we will book you in for an induction on this date.’ as an order not a question. Then NCT leaders who wouldn’t even discuss the possibilities of intervention in birth, homebirth Facebook groups with completely anti-doctor anti-medicine mentalities.
I just wanted some clear, non-bias information that counted me as an individual person.

EishetChayil · 05/01/2022 17:03

The Facebook madness doesn't end with birth. Breastfeeding groups are rife with "chestfeeding" and "birthing bodies" nonsense that gets you banned if you question it.

cherrytopcake · 05/01/2022 17:03

Jesus Christ

Patapouf · 05/01/2022 17:03

@sjxoxo

..if you broke your leg would you expect different info and messages from each team you saw- paramedics, doctors, consultants, surgical team..? I wouldn’t and i don’t understand why the advice and narrative around birth is not more coherent and consistent x
Most legs are the same. Every woman's physiology, baby and pregnancy is different and different clinicians will have different experiences and methods and judgements on risks. A broken leg is relatively straightforward.
betwixtlives · 05/01/2022 17:01

the point I was making was that women are autonomous beings and it’s their CHOICE to take the risk of free birth if they choose to do so. It might logically be a monumentally stupid risk to take but that’s irrelevant. It’s her choice. Ideally all these women would have read lots of robust research and reviewed the evidence of safety (or not) before making the decision to free birth but even if they haven’t…that’s their choice. It’s their baby they’re risking and not anyone else’s business. Which is the way it should be

JustLyra · 05/01/2022 16:59

They would just keep saying "but the midwife said..." and believe that over the word of a paramedic with over a decades experience.

They’re not taking the word of a midwife of a paramedic though - they’re taking the word of the midwife they’re entrusting with their care (and are being implored on this thread to do so) over the word of a person on a group… that’s exactly what this thread is saying people should do.

The problem there isn’t the pregnant women, it is - once again - poor quality maternity care.