Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 05/01/2022 19:37

I had a home birth for my second, after the worst hospital experience with my first. I had always been very anti home birth but it’s amazing how you learn and change your mind when you actually read about it and learn the statistics. I’m
Planning one for my third as it was the best experience BUT I haven’t been on these groups. They would annoy me too much. Home birth only works with 2 midwives there, with a textbook healthy pregnancy at full term and having had all the relevant scans and check ups. Otherwise it’s so fucking dangerous. I don’t love how medicalised birth is but it’s understandable given that the desired outcome is a healthy baby and there can be so many problems!

3cats4poniesandababy · 05/01/2022 19:36

I hold the NHS partially responsible. The lack of midwives for home births currently, ill informed and often judgemental medical staff. If the NHS supported woman better thalen they wouldn't end up pushing desperate woman towards these fringe groups.

I had a terrible traumatic time at a midwife unit due to negligent midwives. Rather than blame these woman the NHS needs to provide better than the crap it is currently. I do not advocate pre-term labour alone, going weeks over due or even giving birth without a midwife but I do believe the NHS needs to do better to support women. For starters treating women as people not statistics and textbooks and providing support to woman both during and after labour.

ThatLibraryMiss · 05/01/2022 19:31

For anyone who thinks doulas have some sort of medical training, I have a surprise. You, too, could become a doula! For only £1000 (discounts and payment plans available) you could take a four day Zoom course covering:

• Human microbiome [no, I don’t know what this means in this context]
• Supporting women in labour
• “Risk” [ quotes not mine]
• Obstetric scenarios
• Intervention
• Birth physiology
• Active listening
• How to set up a doula business
• A history of childbirth
• Human rights in childbirth
• SEO training
• Active listening [listed twice so, err, we know it’s covered. I hope the listening is better than the proofreading.]
• 6 human needs
• Changing your relationship with money to build a business
• Freebirth
• Post natal care

Four days. Four days. Over Zoom. And that includes setting up your business and the all-important SEO to bring in the punters. Then you have to attend five births with a mentor, after which you are a certified doula. But actually, doula is not a protected term in the UK so you don’t even need the certificate.

Compare and contrast with the three years it takes to train as a midwife.

I am not making this up. I wish I were.

C8H10N4O2 · 05/01/2022 19:27

You might consider reading the posts on this thread because this isn't an echo chamber like your groups. The views expressed here are no less valid, are they?

If I joined a group which stated as part of its remit that belief in the flying spaghetti monster was something I signed up to then I wouldn't join the group. Nor would I join it, thereby lying and the complain on a completely different forum that a random group elsewhere promotes belief in the flying spaghetti monster.

I might generate a lot of personally gratifying echoes and reaction from the other forum but it wouldn't get a damned thing changed.

If you believe a group is giving medically dangerous advice then the people to take it up with are the platform owners if its in contravention of their guidelines. Everything else you do is just noise.

BatshitBanshee · 05/01/2022 19:26

Oh dear @SamanthaDoula this really isn't going to go your way. Facebook rules aren't legally binding by the way so your echo chamber members are free to question your group ethos whenever and wherever they choose.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 05/01/2022 19:22

@SamanthaDoula

I admin the group you are referring to.

Firstly - please leave my group because you are not welcome in it, the group and the birth stories in it are not there to feed your sense of drama.

We have stillbirth stories, in there, trauma stories in there, transfer stories in there during and after birth, alongside changed pathway before birth stories, premature birth stories in there and pph stories. You are lying in your suggestions we only have positive stories, that is the opposite ethos to how the group works, which is that every birth matters, wherever and however it takes place and all birth stories are welcome.

I am not going to discuss someones birth story - in a clearly identifiable way (it must be identifiable as a member has brought this to my attention and knows exactly who you are referring to as she could tell) on mumsnet.

When you joined the group you agreed to the rules, RESPECT FREEBIRTH is in the group questions, if you do not then you should never have joined - you confirmed you did before you were accepted, precisely because of the judgement thrown at freebirthing women a and people we have experienced in the past.

Rather than judging the group - perhaps you should look at your own motives in joining a group whose fundamental ethos you disagree with and then splashing a birth story, from a group that bans journalists, into Mumsnet, which is used as tabloid fodder on a regular basis, with no respect for the woman who has given birth (and in incredibly empowered way as it happens).

Where did that preemie birth you are referring to actually take place - in a hospital which negates your faux outrage.

I think you're admin of the group is appalling and reckless. I think allowed unqualified medical advice and advocates of freebirth you are directly respinsible for any horror stories that may occur. Shame on you.
BiscuitLover3678 · 05/01/2022 19:10

With all due respect @SamanthaDoula, if you are admin to this group then you should be taking the concerns of you users seriously and using your role to protect and support women and babies. These posters obviously joined these groups for a reason. You could try to win them over and get others to understand your ethos instead of acting so defensive.

GraceJonesBiggestFan · 05/01/2022 19:10

@SamanthaDoula

I admin the group you are referring to.

Firstly - please leave my group because you are not welcome in it, the group and the birth stories in it are not there to feed your sense of drama.

We have stillbirth stories, in there, trauma stories in there, transfer stories in there during and after birth, alongside changed pathway before birth stories, premature birth stories in there and pph stories. You are lying in your suggestions we only have positive stories, that is the opposite ethos to how the group works, which is that every birth matters, wherever and however it takes place and all birth stories are welcome.

I am not going to discuss someones birth story - in a clearly identifiable way (it must be identifiable as a member has brought this to my attention and knows exactly who you are referring to as she could tell) on mumsnet.

When you joined the group you agreed to the rules, RESPECT FREEBIRTH is in the group questions, if you do not then you should never have joined - you confirmed you did before you were accepted, precisely because of the judgement thrown at freebirthing women a and people we have experienced in the past.

Rather than judging the group - perhaps you should look at your own motives in joining a group whose fundamental ethos you disagree with and then splashing a birth story, from a group that bans journalists, into Mumsnet, which is used as tabloid fodder on a regular basis, with no respect for the woman who has given birth (and in incredibly empowered way as it happens).

Where did that preemie birth you are referring to actually take place - in a hospital which negates your faux outrage.

It’s on your publicly accessible Facebook page with all identifying details including the woman’s name. I’m not even on Facebook and could read it… so maybe instead of berating the OP for sharing a vague story, you need to look at your own sharing of far more identifying personal information.

The story you shared also clearly shows the mother was advised to go in to hospital in premature Labour and declined until the last moment. It has a big list of “highlights” at the beginning including all the medically indicated monitoring and treatments that were declined.

That baby survived because the medical staff saved it. It survived in spite of, rather than because of, your unregulated “advice”.

Patapouf · 05/01/2022 19:06

@SamanthaDoula

I admin the group you are referring to.

Firstly - please leave my group because you are not welcome in it, the group and the birth stories in it are not there to feed your sense of drama.

We have stillbirth stories, in there, trauma stories in there, transfer stories in there during and after birth, alongside changed pathway before birth stories, premature birth stories in there and pph stories. You are lying in your suggestions we only have positive stories, that is the opposite ethos to how the group works, which is that every birth matters, wherever and however it takes place and all birth stories are welcome.

I am not going to discuss someones birth story - in a clearly identifiable way (it must be identifiable as a member has brought this to my attention and knows exactly who you are referring to as she could tell) on mumsnet.

When you joined the group you agreed to the rules, RESPECT FREEBIRTH is in the group questions, if you do not then you should never have joined - you confirmed you did before you were accepted, precisely because of the judgement thrown at freebirthing women a and people we have experienced in the past.

Rather than judging the group - perhaps you should look at your own motives in joining a group whose fundamental ethos you disagree with and then splashing a birth story, from a group that bans journalists, into Mumsnet, which is used as tabloid fodder on a regular basis, with no respect for the woman who has given birth (and in incredibly empowered way as it happens).

Where did that preemie birth you are referring to actually take place - in a hospital which negates your faux outrage.

You might consider reading the posts on this thread because this isn't an echo chamber like your groups. The views expressed here are no less valid, are they?
Blahhdeblahh · 05/01/2022 19:05

I am also a part of these groups and regularly mention to my OH just how dangerous the “advice” is.

They are completely cult like and should any mention of opposing views be made, you get shot down and vilified.

I am only still in the groups as I’m yet to have my baby and I have precipitous labours and so I’m having to plan for a homebirth as I have been advised I may not make it to hospital in time. I am there purely for practical advice on equipment etc.

I genuinely hate the tone set in these groups and the topics often make me feel very uncomfortable. I am totally with you OP and I’m glad I’m not the only one Who feels this way!

Melroses · 05/01/2022 18:45

I remember my MIL talking about the 3 weeks she spent in a maternity home with each of her children (1960s). She was of the opinion it was far better that most women can go home quickly now.

My Grandma gave birth in a maternity home, having stayed there for some time beforehand, during the war. However, she was away for weeks which caused problems at home.

My mother had the 2nd and 3rd at home in the 1960s. This was totally normal after the first as long as things were ok (number 4 was prem, so she went into hospital). Not long after, all women were expected to go into hospital, be processed (exam, shower, shave, antenatal clinics that gave shared appointments ) and there was backlash against this.

When I had mine, they were into Domicillary In and Out, where you had your baby in hospital and were discharged into the care of the community midwives instead of the postnatal ward. However, they cut down community midwife postnatal care in the early 2000s.

I had a rubbish time in hospital, as they would not listen to me about my fast births and I gave birth to twins, mostly unaided whilst the Registrar was in bed. Thankfully they were mostly self delivering. If I had another I would have gone for a home birth. Better to have midwives on the way than to give birth in the car on the way to the hospital.

The history of obstetric care in this country seems to be a continous fight between pushing every woman into an institutionalised system or pushing them back out into the community, with lots of cost cuttings in the process.

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 18:43

My OP is about several HB groups, not one in specific although one does routinely have dangerous advice.

I’ve seen women question whether going into labour at 36 weeks means you should go in, most say no in these groups. Any doc would tell you that’s playing with fire.

Another who laboured at home for as long as possible with a prem baby to get transferred last min and the rest was a litany of risk taken by the mum.

Encouragement to avoid intervention in iugr too, that’s deadly.

OP posts:
BiscuitLover3678 · 05/01/2022 18:36

@SamanthaDoula

I admin the group you are referring to.

Firstly - please leave my group because you are not welcome in it, the group and the birth stories in it are not there to feed your sense of drama.

We have stillbirth stories, in there, trauma stories in there, transfer stories in there during and after birth, alongside changed pathway before birth stories, premature birth stories in there and pph stories. You are lying in your suggestions we only have positive stories, that is the opposite ethos to how the group works, which is that every birth matters, wherever and however it takes place and all birth stories are welcome.

I am not going to discuss someones birth story - in a clearly identifiable way (it must be identifiable as a member has brought this to my attention and knows exactly who you are referring to as she could tell) on mumsnet.

When you joined the group you agreed to the rules, RESPECT FREEBIRTH is in the group questions, if you do not then you should never have joined - you confirmed you did before you were accepted, precisely because of the judgement thrown at freebirthing women a and people we have experienced in the past.

Rather than judging the group - perhaps you should look at your own motives in joining a group whose fundamental ethos you disagree with and then splashing a birth story, from a group that bans journalists, into Mumsnet, which is used as tabloid fodder on a regular basis, with no respect for the woman who has given birth (and in incredibly empowered way as it happens).

Where did that preemie birth you are referring to actually take place - in a hospital which negates your faux outrage.

🙊
5keletor · 05/01/2022 18:36

I was recommended to join the group @Patapouf mentioned too and my goodness I'm so glad I'm not the only one who thought the "doula" running it was... not the best person to be advising pregnant women, shall we say!
I decided against a home birth in the end, but that group was full of dangerous (and sometimes plain nuts) advice.

WhatNoRaisins · 05/01/2022 18:28

I think maybe a more privacy and more individual care could be good starting points.

SamanthaDoula · 05/01/2022 18:27

I admin the group you are referring to.

Firstly - please leave my group because you are not welcome in it, the group and the birth stories in it are not there to feed your sense of drama.

We have stillbirth stories, in there, trauma stories in there, transfer stories in there during and after birth, alongside changed pathway before birth stories, premature birth stories in there and pph stories. You are lying in your suggestions we only have positive stories, that is the opposite ethos to how the group works, which is that every birth matters, wherever and however it takes place and all birth stories are welcome.

I am not going to discuss someones birth story - in a clearly identifiable way (it must be identifiable as a member has brought this to my attention and knows exactly who you are referring to as she could tell) on mumsnet.

When you joined the group you agreed to the rules, RESPECT FREEBIRTH is in the group questions, if you do not then you should never have joined - you confirmed you did before you were accepted, precisely because of the judgement thrown at freebirthing women a and people we have experienced in the past.

Rather than judging the group - perhaps you should look at your own motives in joining a group whose fundamental ethos you disagree with and then splashing a birth story, from a group that bans journalists, into Mumsnet, which is used as tabloid fodder on a regular basis, with no respect for the woman who has given birth (and in incredibly empowered way as it happens).

Where did that preemie birth you are referring to actually take place - in a hospital which negates your faux outrage.

OvaHere · 05/01/2022 18:16

@scottishnames

RobotValkyrie It was exactly this sort of experience that my post upthread was about. Seriously, do you think that there's any way in which we can get the NHS to adopt features of my late mother's woman-centred experience over 50 years ago? I honestly think that it would be a good idea. But how?
I remember my MIL talking about the 3 weeks she spent in a maternity home with each of her children (1960s). She was of the opinion it was far better that most women can go home quickly now.

I'm not sure though because it depends on what support a new mother has at home. Current hospitals are nothing like yesteryear maternity homes though and you couldn't really run them as such.

I don't know what the answer is. Going back to a maternity home set up (3 days to a weeks stay per woman) would require huge investment and infrastructure.

On top of that how many women would actually want it in reality now? In the 50s/60s life was simple enough to create a quiet environment and structured routines. Now there would be expectations of having a TV each, access to wifi, plugs for devices, visitors, take out food deliveries etc...so I can't see the peaceful atmosphere happening.

Women as a group I think are less compliant than our mothers or grandmothers (not a bad thing) so I just don't see 20/30/40 somethings taking to the idea of lengthy matron run mother and baby recuperation.

So I don't really know what the middle ground would look like if we were to go back to the drawing board for the 2020s.

YourVagesty · 05/01/2022 18:00

the ridiculousness of that persons statement is that most sheep can’t give birth without human assistance.

This is a modern phenomenon though, because of the way we've bred them. Iron age sheep breeds are much more able to self-birth.

Patapouf · 05/01/2022 17:54

@Namechangetimes100

I’m on that one too *@Patapouf*, i think why it’s so concerning is that there are a large amount of women with social services involvement or quite severe mental health issues all of whom are being encouraged to not engage with ‘the system’. I’m often tempted to comment esp around iugr and the bonkers things I’ve read about premature hb but I know I’ll get machine gunned
You may as well talk to a brick wall about any risk. I don't even bother engaging because I think I'll get booted out 😅 The posters and the admin don't want actual information and statistics on risk or practical advice on how to be assertive when you're in labour if you need medical intervention they just want affirmation and vindication of the choice to birth at home no matter what the risks or cost.
OvaHere · 05/01/2022 17:52

YANBU. I've had two home births and they were fantastic but they were attended by two community midwives, the hospital was no more than 10 minutes drive away and they were my 3rd and 4th babies. A big part of my decision was because baby 2 was a fast (2hr labour) delivery.

There's always an element of risk but things did play out as anticipated with both home births being quick and uncomplicated.

Some of the scenarios mentioned in the thread seem very risky indeed. Home births (with midwives) are a nice to have if the odds are on your side and you have some idea of what to expect.

Unattended birthing is taking it way too far unless you happen to be one of those women who accidentally gives birth in 20 minutes flat on the bathroom floor or back of the car. Most women do not plan for that though!

MrsColon · 05/01/2022 17:52

@Changechangychange

Yep. An ex friend decided to free birth, from listening to stuff like this about how she was “a goddess” and her body would instinctively know what to do etc. Went 6 weeks overdue. Baby clearly died at some point, though she insisted he was still kicking. Eventually became septic, and delivered a black rotten baby (I’m also friends with her sister, who was absolutely traumatised by seeing his body). Ended up having an emergency hysterectomy, almost died. All the fault of the doctors, of course, nothing to do with her refusing all obstetric care.
Oh gosh, I think I know that family - in the Cotswolds? An awful, awful outcome.

I believe the mother attempted to pursue a claim against the obstetric team, they had to go through it all again and again until it was dropped. Heartbreaking for all concerned Sad

JustLyra · 05/01/2022 17:51

But sadly what some (pro homebirth) midwives are promising women in the context of ambulances is factually incorrect and not something that they have any authority over.

@EgonSpengler2020 The problem there isn’t the women though - it’s another example of poor maternity care.

Women are being told, simultaneously, that they absolutely should listen to the professionals because they know best whilst equally being expected to ignore the ones giving wrong information…

Orarewedancer · 05/01/2022 17:51

@RobotValkyrie spot on

CaMePlaitPas · 05/01/2022 17:50

@RobotValkyrie I couldn't agree more. I was so so tired on the ward I was crying to go home, it felt like prison. I couldn't get any rest and because I was anxious the baby was too, so they didn't get any rest either. Post natal "care" just doesn't exist.

scottishnames · 05/01/2022 17:49

RobotValkyrie It was exactly this sort of experience that my post upthread was about. Seriously, do you think that there's any way in which we can get the NHS to adopt features of my late mother's woman-centred experience over 50 years ago? I honestly think that it would be a good idea. But how?