Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
DollyDingleberry · 06/01/2022 08:06

@Sesnania14

You literally admit your own answer in your OP.

But clarify women are routinely abused. its not a minority. They are frequently victims of various forms of obstetric violence. In fact people in homebirthing and freebirthing groups are also doctors are not held accountable when they assault women and their babies (see the Laura Galazzi case). Some women would rather risk freebirthing and all that comes with it.

Women are grown adults and may make their own choices. Women have bodily autonomy. Birth rights are actually very much enshrined in UK law for example (S v St George NHS trust) where a woman may freebirth to the point of death for her and her baby. Birth is an acr of sovereign and women can make what society 'deems' a bad choice. Some women would rather die or risk a stillbirth than be abused and medically raped in a hospital.

You said yourself you were coerced into an induction and that obscetricians lie by omission by not presenting options. I don't think its dangerous at all. Women are not stupid. Also probably address that misygony. Women have no ability to prevent stillbirth or guarantee pregnancy outcomes by their location. Where I am we had 6 babies die in the space of a year at a hospital during labour. These women were surrounded by doctors and had CTG monitors on them. Doesn't matter where you are, home or hospital,. medical professional or no.

This might also be hard for you to contemplate. Some women believe nature should take its course. Legally speaking once the baby is out they would need to commence infant ressuss, but if they wanted to risk that outcome with a premature baby that is their choice.

Im not sure why you are confused, upset or shocked about it? It seems misplaced. Perhaps you should be more angry at the maternity system that has driven women to take these risks.

You contradict yourself here and it needs addressing. You present your argument as if freebirthing has exactly the same level of risk as hospital birth but that is not even remotely true. You recognise this in your final statement where you say the maternity system drives women to take these risks.

Risk isn’t absolute. There are levels and degrees of risk. Hospital birth is significantly more likely to produce a good outcome in pregnancies where there are increased risk factored like IUGR, prematurity etc. In both free birth under these situations and hospital births there is a level of risk, but saying the 2 situations are therefore the same is wildly inaccurate.

Also, it is not misogyny to suggest some women are not aware of the full risks of freebirthing before they decide to follow that path. I’d argue it’s misogyny to suggest women are expected to know everything despite our education system not teaching critical thinking and therefore should be held totally responsible for birth outcomes. The way the Facebook groups present freebirthing is as if you will definitely have a terrible experience if you have a hospital birth and that freebirthing is somehow the best and only option for the ‘enlightened’. That’s a powerful bit of manipulation thats currently in use across all kinds of things at the moment that’s led to so many misguided decisions in everything from anti-vax to Brexit. I’m not comparing freebirthing to either of these things before you jump on that, I’m simply showing that the ‘our way or you’re wrong’ messaging of these groups is incredibly powerful.

This whole post isn’t about the rights or wrongs of freebirthing, it’s about the rights and wrongs of unqualified people online giving out medical advice as facts that they themselves heard 3rd hand from someone else unqualified. It’s not just birthing groups, it’s everywhere.

RedRobyn2021 · 06/01/2022 08:00

Some of the comments in this thread are absolutely disgusting and anti feminist. Honestly if any one of you said this to my face I would struggle not to slap you. Come at me if someone has a problem with that. I'm fuming.

RedRobyn2021 · 06/01/2022 07:53

@Sesnania14 this is beautifully put

HardbackWriter · 06/01/2022 07:30

The way I see it, I don’t challenge my dentist, or the orthopaedic doctor who fixed my broken elbow because they’ve trained for a long time and know a hell of a lot more about it than I do, who is doing this for the first time (in the case of birth and broken bones) so why would I be so arrogant as to assume I know better. Don’t get me wrong, I asked a lot of questions and clarified a lot of things and ultimately made my own decision but it was based on listening to what the professionals had to say based on their expertise and years of training.

I agree entirely. I planned a home birth and then the midwife went from supporting/encouraging it to advising against (because of covid, not anything specific to me) and so that was the end of that for me - I didn't consider for half a second proceeding once it wasn't medically advised.

But I would note here how different the MN narrative is if you want a homebirth vs if you want an elective CS. If your midwife is resistant to homebirth then that's sacrosanct medical advise that you must not question, even if it doesn't fit NICE guidelines about birth choices. If she's resistant to elective CS then that's just medical misogyny and you should march in clutching stats and guidelines and insisting that you know best and that it's entirely your choice.

Sesnania14 · 06/01/2022 00:05

You literally admit your own answer in your OP.

But clarify women are routinely abused. its not a minority. They are frequently victims of various forms of obstetric violence. In fact people in homebirthing and freebirthing groups are also doctors are not held accountable when they assault women and their babies (see the Laura Galazzi case). Some women would rather risk freebirthing and all that comes with it.

Women are grown adults and may make their own choices. Women have bodily autonomy. Birth rights are actually very much enshrined in UK law for example (S v St George NHS trust) where a woman may freebirth to the point of death for her and her baby. Birth is an acr of sovereign and women can make what society 'deems' a bad choice. Some women would rather die or risk a stillbirth than be abused and medically raped in a hospital.

You said yourself you were coerced into an induction and that obscetricians lie by omission by not presenting options. I don't think its dangerous at all. Women are not stupid. Also probably address that misygony. Women have no ability to prevent stillbirth or guarantee pregnancy outcomes by their location. Where I am we had 6 babies die in the space of a year at a hospital during labour. These women were surrounded by doctors and had CTG monitors on them. Doesn't matter where you are, home or hospital,. medical professional or no.

This might also be hard for you to contemplate. Some women believe nature should take its course. Legally speaking once the baby is out they would need to commence infant ressuss, but if they wanted to risk that outcome with a premature baby that is their choice.

Im not sure why you are confused, upset or shocked about it? It seems misplaced. Perhaps you should be more angry at the maternity system that has driven women to take these risks.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 05/01/2022 23:49

@Franca123

I remember a woman in my NCT group saying, sheep give birth without help so why can't we? I just left that one as didn't even know where to start. Plus she looked terrified so I wondered if she was trying to convince herself not me.
Watching Clarkson’s farm would set her right on that.

Sheep and cows need help. Very hard work and stressful for the farmers.

BlueberryJam123 · 05/01/2022 23:29

When did people become so obsessed with "natural birth experiences" and breastfeeding? Birthing is just a means to an end. Same with breastfeeding. A healthy thriving baby is what matters.

I had a c-section and combi-fed from the beginning, and don't have an ounce of guilt about it. Grin Didn't even know some people feel guilty until I read the forums.

elliejjtiny · 05/01/2022 22:37

I was thrown out of a homebirth group on facebook after my 4th baby was born by c-section. Very upsetting at the time although I find it mildly amusing now. My eldest was born at home and we live less than 10 minutes from the hospital but I had prolonged rupture of membranes with my others and my youngest 2 were early as well so the rest were hospital births.

Some of the people on those groups promote really dangerous advice. I have to admit that I found it really difficult to trust the registrars/junior drs at the antenatal clinic when I walked in with dc2 and they said "2nd baby then?" when it had how many pregnancies/births I'd had in big black letters on the front page of my notes. I got really excellent, personal care from the community midwives and the fetal medicine consultant. And most of the midwives at the hospital were really lovely and kind too, as was the registrar who delivered dc5. A lot of the time I felt as if I was on a conveyor belt though and I got the impression at times that they wanted me to give birth and get out as quickly as possible so they could bring in the next woman.

I have to agree with a previous poster who said about the women centered care that was around in the past. I often watch call the midwife and it's so lovely when some of the nuns have delivered multiple generations of babies and they really know the women they look after. Sadly I don't think my younger 2 would have survived in that era. I wish there was a way of replicating the kind of care they had in the 50's and 60's and combining it with the life saving technology we have now.

Breastfeeding support is also awful in those kind of groups. I had a failure to thrive baby and got some shocking advice and was made to feel like a failure for giving high calorie prescription formula. I got so many "cows milk is for baby cows" and "aww is he a calf then?" followed by a tinkly laugh when I said that I thought it would be best to supplement breastfeeding with the formula that had been prescribed by the paediatrician. I had some really good support from some professionals, especially the nicu staff with dc5.

nolongersurprised · 05/01/2022 21:52

I was on an Australian breastfeeding group for a while and there was a subset of prolific posters who went down the free birth path. It seemed very competitive to me.

The whole site was a bit nuts - formula was the devil’s work and if a poster described, for example, a FTT baby who was 6 weeks and hadn’t regained birth weight supply issues were never ever the problem and all medical advice about top ups were to be ignored.

The births had a particular pattern - most women had 3-4 children and the first birth would be a vaginal delivery but with some kind of intervention, such as pin relief or an episiotomy. The subsequent birth would be a home birth with an experienced home birth midwife followed by a free birth. There would then be posts about “born into my hands at home” and the like and pictures of the first breastfeed. It did feel like some posters were motivated by the cheerleading of others and the ability to record a “good” birth story.

I remember one woman in particular who was having her 4th boy, in a blow up pool in the garden. She had previously had straight forward births but with this one she was in agony, to the point when she wanted to drown herself in the pool at one point. She did transfer for pain relief but only needed gas and air but there was radio silence when she posted her “story”. I don’t think those groups are as interested in the outcome (the baby) as they are in the process

MrsGaskthrill · 05/01/2022 21:29

I agree it’s a consequence of NHS care being underfunded and therefore rushed and impersonal. I know so many women with really serious trauma from births who are repeatedly told ‘as long as the baby is ok that’s the main thing’

No it’s not the main thing. Women matter too. Sometimes they feel they have to back themselves into very extreme positions to protect themselves

Sleepyteach · 05/01/2022 21:26

I found the narrative pushed by my NCT course to be terrifying. I already had complications which were likely to require intervention of some sort, as were several others in the group. And yet the group leader pushed a frankly dangerous agenda which encouraged us to question and challenge any intervention suggested by medical professionals. At our meet up once the babies arrived when I said I’d been induced her response was “oh never mind” as if I should have been upset by this. I pointed out to her that I’d met with the consultant and discussed my options (at 38 weeks) which were CS, induction or wait and see although they didn’t recommend that I went over 40 due to baby having a head like a basketball. I chose induction and found it to generally be a positive experience. If I’d done what she suggested then it would be highly likely my daughter would have suffered shoulder dystocia and the associated complications. The way I see it, I don’t challenge my dentist, or the orthopaedic doctor who fixed my broken elbow because they’ve trained for a long time and know a hell of a lot more about it than I do, who is doing this for the first time (in the case of birth and broken bones) so why would I be so arrogant as to assume I know better. Don’t get me wrong, I asked a lot of questions and clarified a lot of things and ultimately made my own decision but it was based on listening to what the professionals had to say based on their expertise and years of training.

Goldilocks99 · 05/01/2022 21:14

I can only talk about my own experience. My asd traits led me to be very black and white with the hypnobirth philosophy, so in my experience I was "easy prey" although that may not apply to others.

Orarewedancer · 05/01/2022 21:09

I am in an area with an absolutely fantastic dedicated home birth team led by an amazing midwife who's opinion I trust implicitly. She is extremely supportive of a women's wish to home birth, but also very good at encouraging medical tests/screening and having those results to ensure her patients are as informed about their choices as possible. If she told me there was significant risk to my baby, or myself, in giving birth at home I wouldn't hesitate to take her advice and give birth in a hospital.

It's just so sad that this level of care isn't available everywhere, then no one would feel so untrusting of the health service and more trusting of strangers on the internet with little to no qualifications.

betwixtlives · 05/01/2022 21:07

@inheritancetrack

My body, my choice, does not include the baby's body as it has no choice in the matter. Personally anyone with a failing to thrive prem baby being denied medical help, needs reporting to social services. You are not at all unreasonable OP.
In your opinion. Legally, the baby has no rights before birth and social services would do fuck all. Are you anti reproductive choice too?
Rootinetea · 05/01/2022 21:04

I've been in a few home birth groups. I would like a home birth. I am still appalled by the content of these groups. Women do need support in childbirth, and sure some medical research is biased in terms of medical intervention mostly because that's what is being looked at... but the amount of judgement these women have given others who had to transfer is appalling. It's been eye-opening, as a first time mother, to explore how many of these groups exist.

I am appalled at the implication that people with mental health difficulties or other diagnoses are "easy prey" or lack capacity. I have a history of severe mental health issues which I'm fortunate to have been able to largely overcome, and I'm autistic. My decision to have a home birth is still backed by evidence... Which is why I've recently left the cult-like group a few of you have described. What a hurtful and judgemental comment.

4pmwinetimebebeh · 05/01/2022 21:03

@Goldilocks99 I’m so sorry I can’t imagine how stressful that must be and how easy it would be to blame yourself. As you’ve said we all make decisions in life good and bad and often don’t know whether they were the right choice until it’s too late. There’s no telling whether there would have been issues with the induction or your baby could have had CP anyway.
Sending lots of love and well wishes to you and your beautiful baby.

Orarewedancer · 05/01/2022 21:03

It’s always wise to think carefully about the advice of anyone who has many more opinions than they have responsibilities.

@MissTrip82 I absolutely love this!

dittymcdit · 05/01/2022 21:03

@BiscuitLover3678

Maternity care is shocking and that’s why homebirths are actually encouraged for healthy women. Childbirth isn’t actually a medical event. It can become that way, which is why help should be nearby. In reality it’s actually a really natural, intense event. A lot of what goes wrong and the pain is due to fear and hospital environment. Birth trauma js HUGE and completely unacceptable.

There is a middle ground here.

I think everyone agrees with that. But the issue here is encouraging women that accepting care and from midwifes / doctors is somehow wrong
Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 20:59

Oh @Goldilocks99 I’m so sorry for what happened! It’s not your fault. You were given some really terrible advice and you did what you thought was best at that moment in time. That’s why I think groups/ individuals that post and routinely give out dangerous advice obscuring the risks are flipping dangerous and can lead some women down a path they might regret later.

As I said in a PP I’ve felt drawn to certain things especially when you’ve had a previous bad experience In the nhs, which unfortunately all too many have. I do also think there is no other medical field where patients are routinely treated so poorly as maternity/ obstetrics so I don’t blame you at all for being afraid. I’m just very sorry you were let down on all fronts Flowers

OP posts:
Goldilocks99 · 05/01/2022 20:54

Asd*

But the point being no one picked up how vulnerable I was in pregnancy. Looking back I had insane anxiety which could have been managed better. I actually did the hypnobirth course because I was trying to deal with the anxiety and control the situation.
I believe if someone from the NHS had provided the same service my baby would have a different path now.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 05/01/2022 20:52

@BiscuitLover3678

I agree with you and that’s why I went for homebirth, ultimately. But it’s not safe for everyone!

inheritancetrack · 05/01/2022 20:49

My body, my choice, does not include the baby's body as it has no choice in the matter. Personally anyone with a failing to thrive prem baby being denied medical help, needs reporting to social services. You are not at all unreasonable OP.

Goldilocks99 · 05/01/2022 20:49

@BiscuitLover3678 thank you, I am taking it each day as it comes.
As can be seen on this thread though, most people very ready to blame the mother for making the wrong decision in fear and ignorance.
I would obviously change my decision now I know the cost. But at the time I wanted a natural birth as the best thing for my baby and the 'success' stories of those that had delayed convinced me it would be fine. You don't think it will happen to you anyway.
Just wish they'd look at why these decisions are made rather than automatically judging. I've been informally diagnosed with add myself since the birth so that may be why I was easily led down a black and white path.

BiscuitLover3678 · 05/01/2022 20:46

@lemondrop21

I totally agree.

I was very lucky and had a very wonderful homebirth in April. Easy low risk second pregnancy enabled this.

If there had been any worry, concern or risk of harm to me or my baby and potentially leaving my dd motherless it would not have happened.
But I was also part of these groups leading up to the birth and honestly some of the advice was absolutely horrific.
Homebirthing seemed more like a badge of honour to a lot of them even when the safety of the baby or mother is at risk. Even down to suspected preeclampsia and women advising the mother to refuse any further medical treatment or testing and free birth instead. Absolutely mind blowing.

I would never jeopardise my child's life just to say 'oh look at me, I gave birth at home with no drugs'.

People I know who homebirth don’t expect some ‘badge’. Confused There is research that shows that homebirth for a normal, healthy mother and baby is actually much better for both of them. People do it as they want the best for their baby. And usually hospital transfer happens the second there is even a hint of an issue.
BiscuitLover3678 · 05/01/2022 20:43

@Goldilocks99

I had some poor advice from a doula, after several weeks of having the natural method in hypnobirth course. I was scared of surgery and pain so clung to the hypnobirth natural way etc. Anyway, I delayed my induction by 48 hours. I got an infection. My baby has all the signs of cerebral palsy now. It makes me angry it's not regulated as if I had been under NHS care or doula I would likely have made a different decision.

Worst decision of my life. Trust the professionals. Wish I had.

I’m so so sorry. You must NOT blame yourself. Inductions have their own issues. You can never know which way it would have gone and you did why you thought was best for you and your baby.