Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
Gindrinker43 · 06/01/2022 12:00

And don't forget if the worst happens, Paramedics are not trained midwives and as a rule, never want to have to deliver a baby, some may never have done it if they turn up in am emergency. Make sensible decisions.

ThatLibraryMiss · 06/01/2022 11:47

the prevailing consensus is that babies should be born in a hospital with lots of medical professionals telling you what to do. This is who we are a society. This is the expectation. This is what all antenatal care and your mother in law and your annoying neighbour will be telling you (uninvited) all day long. No one goes on a "UK homebirth" Facebook group to be told yet again that if you're not tied up to a hospital bed your baby will diiiiie.

From second-hand experience of three NHS trusts in 2021, this is wrong. All three encouraged home births in circumstances they, with their years of experience and qualifications, deemed safe. As it turned out, the one set of midwives who said homebirth wasn't a good idea were right and hospital was the place that particular birth needed to take place to deliver a healthy baby and save his mother. He just would not have been born without intervention.

As for being tied to a hospital bed, that's just ridiculous hyperbole. Yes, if you need an epidural to cope with the pain you will be immobilised, and certainly if the baby is a bad presentation and needs intervention to save its and its mother's life you won't be wandering around, but that's at the far end of a whole spectrum that starts with breathing and includes measures like birthing pools and gas and air.

HardbackWriter · 06/01/2022 11:36

I always think that the posts about how dangerous home births (often conflated with free births) are compared to having 'the attention of doctors and all the medical care you need on tap' are so rosy about the reality of hospital. One of the reasons I wanted a home birth for my second is that my first was essentially a free birth on a maternity triage ward because I only got any care for the final 20 minutes of pushing, as that's when they finally conceded that it was possible that I was in active labour and to examine me (at which point they realised I was near crowning). They told me off for coming in when I arrived as they'd told me to stay at home - if I had it would have been entirely unassisted. And that was despite being told I was high risk and so couldn't use the MLU, pool, etc. I really, really didn't feel that hospital was a place where all the care and expertise I could possibly need was on tap.

Patapouf · 06/01/2022 11:31

@Hoping4second

First, doulas get paid the exact same amount for a homebirth or hospital birth. Part of their usefulness lies in keeping you calm through the birth so some might say they're more useful in hospitals.

Second, the prevailing consensus is that babies should be born in a hospital with lots of medical professionals telling you what to do. This is who we are a society. This is the expectation. This is what all antenatal care and your mother in law and your annoying neighbour will be telling you (uninvited) all day long. No one goes on a "UK homebirth" Facebook group to be told yet again that if you're not tied up to a hospital bed your baby will diiiiie. People go there specifically to discuss why and how they can avoid hospital.

...so again, what's the issue with women discussing things between them without oversight and control?

If homebirth is something you find is not in line with what you want, leave the group. I hate vegan food, so I haven't joined any vegan recipe sharing groups. It's that simple. And there are so many non vegan recipes all around in families, restaurants etc etc that I really cannot claim these groups' mere existence is forcing anyone into veganism.

Presumably not if they can't attend hospital births? Most hospitals have limited the number of birth partners due to Covid have they not? Is the doula going to get full whack if she can't go?

I think you are wrong that the goal is to avoid giving birth in hospital, it seems the goal is to avoid any and all medicalisation which in many cases includes scans, tests and routine vaccinations in pregnancy. I agree in most cases pregnancy and birth is not a medical event and I totally understand the desire to avoid a hospital environment but a home birth ought to be attended by a qualified midwife. If there is something wrong with the baby or the pregnancy is high risk the birth should take place where it is safest; hospital.

Hoping4second · 06/01/2022 11:15

First, doulas get paid the exact same amount for a homebirth or hospital birth. Part of their usefulness lies in keeping you calm through the birth so some might say they're more useful in hospitals.

Second, the prevailing consensus is that babies should be born in a hospital with lots of medical professionals telling you what to do. This is who we are a society. This is the expectation. This is what all antenatal care and your mother in law and your annoying neighbour will be telling you (uninvited) all day long. No one goes on a "UK homebirth" Facebook group to be told yet again that if you're not tied up to a hospital bed your baby will diiiiie. People go there specifically to discuss why and how they can avoid hospital.

...so again, what's the issue with women discussing things between them without oversight and control?

If homebirth is something you find is not in line with what you want, leave the group. I hate vegan food, so I haven't joined any vegan recipe sharing groups. It's that simple. And there are so many non vegan recipes all around in families, restaurants etc etc that I really cannot claim these groups' mere existence is forcing anyone into veganism.

TheOriginalEmu · 06/01/2022 11:14

@CoalCraft

I’d much rather be in the care of specialist professionals who have medical qualifications, years of experience and who believe in evidence-based medicine. Maybe part of the reason some women feel like they’re on a conveyer belt is that the professionals have dealt with the exact situation they’re presenting with many times before. That is a good thing.

So much of this. I am hugely reassured by an air of competent efficiency. I want to be quickly informed of how things are progressing and, in the same breath, have a recommended course of action presented to me.

And if that is what makes you feel safer: fine. For me the conveyer belt means they are not treating me as a person with my own wants and needs and doing ANY job by rote leaves you wide open to making catastrophic mistakes.
TheOriginalEmu · 06/01/2022 11:13

@Hoping4second

These groups are the canary in the coal mine. Don't get angry at the canary. Of course it's a stupid idea to bring an animal in a coal mine - it could die!

But why do women, intelligent human beings who have their babies' interests at heart, do it anyway? What is causing them to make these choices you disagree with?

The first cause of maternal deaths in the olden days was sepsis, not obstetric complications. The improvement in maternal survival rates of late is due to antibiotics, not to making women lie on their backs with their feet up like trussed up chickens.

One of the first causes of maternal death is postpartum suicide. If you know a hospital environment is likely to cause mental health complications, it is a perfectly rational decision to avoid it for your own survival.

I chose a hospital birth for myself so don't fall on me like a ton of bricks but the crux of the argument here is : are women to be trusted to discuss their own health? Is it unreasonable to allow women to talk about what's best for them? How do we coerce women into making the decisions we think are best for them?

As opposed to - whatever is wrong with the system that people feel safer outside of it? And how do we fix that? If coal mines never blew up no one would even think of bringing a canary down there.

If you don't see the misogyny on this I really can't help you.

👏👏👏👏
CoalCraft · 06/01/2022 10:52

I’d much rather be in the care of specialist professionals who have medical qualifications, years of experience and who believe in evidence-based medicine. Maybe part of the reason some women feel like they’re on a conveyer belt is that the professionals have dealt with the exact situation they’re presenting with many times before. That is a good thing.

So much of this. I am hugely reassured by an air of competent efficiency. I want to be quickly informed of how things are progressing and, in the same breath, have a recommended course of action presented to me.

Patapouf · 06/01/2022 10:51

@Hoping4second

These groups are the canary in the coal mine. Don't get angry at the canary. Of course it's a stupid idea to bring an animal in a coal mine - it could die!

But why do women, intelligent human beings who have their babies' interests at heart, do it anyway? What is causing them to make these choices you disagree with?

The first cause of maternal deaths in the olden days was sepsis, not obstetric complications. The improvement in maternal survival rates of late is due to antibiotics, not to making women lie on their backs with their feet up like trussed up chickens.

One of the first causes of maternal death is postpartum suicide. If you know a hospital environment is likely to cause mental health complications, it is a perfectly rational decision to avoid it for your own survival.

I chose a hospital birth for myself so don't fall on me like a ton of bricks but the crux of the argument here is : are women to be trusted to discuss their own health? Is it unreasonable to allow women to talk about what's best for them? How do we coerce women into making the decisions we think are best for them?

As opposed to - whatever is wrong with the system that people feel safer outside of it? And how do we fix that? If coal mines never blew up no one would even think of bringing a canary down there.

If you don't see the misogyny on this I really can't help you.

I don't think the issue is with the groups existence. Women should absolutely have a safe place to discuss and share thoughts and ideas (hey, isn't that what we are all doing on MN right now?) but there is a very real problem with the culture in some of these groups that there is only one right way to birth a baby.

Women should be encouraged to question, research and consider; not to just ignore any and all medical advice. Especially when the encouragement comes from unqualified people with an agenda. After all, a doula wants to be paid to attend a home birth doesn't she? She doesn't want women to go into hospital to seek the help they may well desperately need to survive.
Group members brandish terms like 'informed consent' and 'evidence based' without actually understanding what they really mean. There seems to be competition about how little pain relief is accessed, how long they managed to leave it before cutting the cord, how bad the pph was before they agreed to transfer etc. It's toxic.

Hoping4second · 06/01/2022 10:43

These groups are the canary in the coal mine. Don't get angry at the canary. Of course it's a stupid idea to bring an animal in a coal mine - it could die!

But why do women, intelligent human beings who have their babies' interests at heart, do it anyway? What is causing them to make these choices you disagree with?

The first cause of maternal deaths in the olden days was sepsis, not obstetric complications. The improvement in maternal survival rates of late is due to antibiotics, not to making women lie on their backs with their feet up like trussed up chickens.

One of the first causes of maternal death is postpartum suicide. If you know a hospital environment is likely to cause mental health complications, it is a perfectly rational decision to avoid it for your own survival.

I chose a hospital birth for myself so don't fall on me like a ton of bricks but the crux of the argument here is : are women to be trusted to discuss their own health? Is it unreasonable to allow women to talk about what's best for them? How do we coerce women into making the decisions we think are best for them?

As opposed to - whatever is wrong with the system that people feel safer outside of it? And how do we fix that? If coal mines never blew up no one would even think of bringing a canary down there.

If you don't see the misogyny on this I really can't help you.

SlipperTripper · 06/01/2022 10:34

I love in a fairly 'alternative' area and on my local FB page free birthing is definitely the preferred option.

The fact that ambulance wait times are at six hours here at the moment is not deterring people apparently.

After my last birth was somewhat messy, with haemorrhaging and emergency surgery required, I think it's absolute bloody madness. But you can't convince someone who doesn't want to hear it, and get accused of all sorts when you point this out 🤷🏻‍♀️

TheOriginalEmu · 06/01/2022 10:32

I would free birth before I ever gave birth in a hospital again. That’s because the trauma I suffered at the hands of medical professionals was so profound and terrifying I was too scared for a long time to even go for a scan.
I understand your point, but you also have to understand that hospital birth doesn’t mean things will be fine, and that actually what hospitals do can sometimes be life threatening.
My son suffered a life limiting birth injury and I nearly died due to the total lack of care. My son died at 5 months old because of it.

Patapouf · 06/01/2022 10:22

Sorry but there is space to be angry at both, both a broken maternity system and a toxic alternative one that spouts informed consent yet shuts down opposition and denies risk.

Absolutely this!

I think we can all recognise the flaws in maternity care:

Lack of continuity of care
Not woman centred
Rigid guidelines and pathways
Inadequate staff levels
Burnt out and busy staff
Horrible hospital environment
Lack of consent-seeking
Lack of information/education
Too few appointments
Obstetric violence
Cascade of interventions
Previous birth trauma that isn't addressed
Covid restrictions on support at scans
Conveyor belt approach
Culture of 'live baby is all that matters'
Gatekeeping of painkillers
Fucking inferno temperature on labour wards
Lack of practical support with newborn
Deep rooted misogyny informing medical care
Judgement about feeding choices

Have I missed anything?

The answer to these problems isn't freebirthing ffs. I think a straightforward home birth is a wonderful option and can be very healing for a woman that has suffered trauma in a previous pregnancy or labour but shouldn't be wantonly encouraged if it's not safe and appropriately supported.

These Facebook groups have such an us vs them mentality which just feeds the absolute goal of homebirthing no matter what. It really is a lack of critical thinking. If a doctor says it's a bad idea you need to have a think about why that is and meaningfully consider the risks, not just assume the doctor is evil and just wants to deprive you of a beautiful natural magical birth experience.

Namechangetimes100 · 06/01/2022 09:16

@Sesnania14

The contradiction is a yes and a no. Some women freebirth out of fear. And some a very highly educated and do it by choice and have herbs. illegally sourced drugs and taken neonatal ressuss courses. There are actually a lot of midwives and former medical personal in home and free birthing communities. Though yes a point on non medical people giving advice, but its up to you to educate yourself and read at the end of the day. Unfortunately women are told lies constantly by the medical system. My midwife threw a pamphlet at me on inductions and it literally downplayed the risks of what is a post partum haemmorage calling it 'a risk of a slight bleed.; I would argue the hospital presents more risk because technically its a germ infested building where sick people congregate and if you rea da lot of midwife researcg, most problems in birth are caused by interventions. 'Im still confused about what 'misinformation' you are claiming. Many times IUGR and macrosomia are wrongly diagnosed because ultrasound in the third trimester is often wrong. This is what those groups share. No accountability? There is also no accountbility to doctors who abuse women. Again look at what a doctor did to Laura Gallazi. Your complaints against these women misplaced. Be angry at the medical system for abusing women and less angry about women trying to give each other advice online because they get lied to and choosing to ignore medical advice. Leave them alone to their own devices and perhaps focus your efforts on the crappy maternity system.
Illegally sourced herbs? Not touching that one but surely an infant ressus or baby first aid course can’t be viewed in the same way as a suitable replacement for an actual medic who trained years in that specific thing.

Yes sometimes iugr is wrongly diagnosed, saving baby pathway should reduce this BUT many times it is diagnosed correctly, particularly with fetal med involvement and action is why those babies are here today.

Sorry but there is space to be angry at both, both a broken maternity system and a toxic alternative one that spouts informed consent yet shuts down opposition and denies risk.

In terms of accountability at least the mechanisms exist to put in a formal complaint healthcare wise.

OP posts:
Namechangetimes100 · 06/01/2022 09:04

@Sesnania14

You literally admit your own answer in your OP.

But clarify women are routinely abused. its not a minority. They are frequently victims of various forms of obstetric violence. In fact people in homebirthing and freebirthing groups are also doctors are not held accountable when they assault women and their babies (see the Laura Galazzi case). Some women would rather risk freebirthing and all that comes with it.

Women are grown adults and may make their own choices. Women have bodily autonomy. Birth rights are actually very much enshrined in UK law for example (S v St George NHS trust) where a woman may freebirth to the point of death for her and her baby. Birth is an acr of sovereign and women can make what society 'deems' a bad choice. Some women would rather die or risk a stillbirth than be abused and medically raped in a hospital.

You said yourself you were coerced into an induction and that obscetricians lie by omission by not presenting options. I don't think its dangerous at all. Women are not stupid. Also probably address that misygony. Women have no ability to prevent stillbirth or guarantee pregnancy outcomes by their location. Where I am we had 6 babies die in the space of a year at a hospital during labour. These women were surrounded by doctors and had CTG monitors on them. Doesn't matter where you are, home or hospital,. medical professional or no.

This might also be hard for you to contemplate. Some women believe nature should take its course. Legally speaking once the baby is out they would need to commence infant ressuss, but if they wanted to risk that outcome with a premature baby that is their choice.

Im not sure why you are confused, upset or shocked about it? It seems misplaced. Perhaps you should be more angry at the maternity system that has driven women to take these risks.

You can’t present a free birth under any circumstances to a birth with medical assistance as having the same level of risk, that’s ludicrous. A free birth of someone who has declined all ante natal care is not the same as low risk pregnancy home birth with 2 midwives or a delivery suite birth from a risk point of view. Birth has risks no matter what but there are things such as free broth and declining ante natal care that obviously increase the risk. Also, it may be worth bearing in mind the reason for those babies deaths ie. Conditions incompatible with life and extreme prematurity and additionally people going against medical advice. You later go on to say some women are happy to take such risks so you’re contracting yourself here.

I will not deny obstetric violence and birth trauma and coercive care exist and are fucking traumatising, I said that in my OP, I even said I’m sympathetic having somewhat gone through it myself. I’m also (probably quite scandalously for MN) all for knowing what to say to get a better outcome in the system; ie on paper refusing induction to reach a middle ground with a consultant for pessary induction in an MLU setting (which those groups are really good for). But what’s really sickening is the blatant denial of risk in those groups especially in the cases of iugr et al.

I also think it’s important to distinguish flat out patriarchy and misogyny in obstetrics from coercion to meet clinical guidelines, both are obviously wrong but the drive to meet guidelines are based on how the nhs views risk. Let’s use iugr or sga for example, this is a fictional example baby at anatomy scan measured 25th centile and then 28 weeks fundal height descreasrd, growth scan ordered baby 10th centile, 30 weeks follow up growth scan 3rd centile, referral to fetal med. 33 weeks fetal med scan baby 3rd centile and resistance in dopplers. Weekly dopplers and every other week appointments with fetal med. a clear care of iugr, doctor will recommend induction at 37 weeks due to iugr and possible placental failure and increased risk of still birth. They can’t say for sure it will happen but that if they deliver at term it’s less likely than if the pregnancy continues. It’s just how risk works in the healthcare system, the doctor in this instances ultimate goal is a live baby and a live mother, birth preferences don’t factor into it as frankly there are more important things at stake.

However there are some things routed in misogyny like the grotesque husband stitch that’s akin to fgm and any doctor performing that should be struck off.

I am angry at the birthing system that’s caused so many women my self included trauma but the answer to that isn’t to shun all medicine. Birth is a physiological event that can become a medical one and that shouldn’t be denied

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 06/01/2022 08:59

@elliejjtiny

I don't know about other people but personally I wanted a birth with as little intervention as possible to maximise my chances of post birth complications, longer recovery and pain. I knew that on the postnatal ward I would be expected to look after myself and a newborn including sterilizing bottles etc so I wanted to be as well as possible afterwards.

With breastfeeding I found it so much easier than bottles, especially in the night and out and about. I had to bottle feed my 4th and it was a massive faff. Also found sterilizing bottles etc really hard on the postnatal ward 1 day after my c-section. With my 5th I could just scoop him out of the cot and breastfeed him which was so much easier.

Nobody WANTS intervention. Everyone wants as straightforward a birth and as quick a recovery as possible.

But most of us would rather have intervention when it's necessary than a bad outcome that could have been avoided or improved by medical care.

elliejjtiny · 06/01/2022 08:54

I don't know about other people but personally I wanted a birth with as little intervention as possible to maximise my chances of post birth complications, longer recovery and pain. I knew that on the postnatal ward I would be expected to look after myself and a newborn including sterilizing bottles etc so I wanted to be as well as possible afterwards.

With breastfeeding I found it so much easier than bottles, especially in the night and out and about. I had to bottle feed my 4th and it was a massive faff. Also found sterilizing bottles etc really hard on the postnatal ward 1 day after my c-section. With my 5th I could just scoop him out of the cot and breastfeed him which was so much easier.

HerculesMulligann · 06/01/2022 08:51

To some extent I can understand the unease of pregnant women who feel that with NHS maternity care that they’re on some sort of conveyer belt with countless others and that their care lacks a ‘personal touch’.

But this is part of a - to me - reassuring picture. I’d much rather be in the care of specialist professionals who have medical qualifications, years of experience and who believe in evidence-based medicine. Maybe part of the reason some women feel like they’re on a conveyer belt is that the professionals have dealt with the exact situation they’re presenting with many times before. That is a good thing.

I’d much rather entrust my maternity care to experienced and busy trained medical staff. On the other hand if a doula or similar really did have endless hours available to listen to a pregnant woman waffling on about ‘curating’ their birth experience and how the birth would be unique and special this would raise red flags for me. There’s a reason doulas and random women on homebirth sites have more time to do this - they’re not in demand in the same way trained doctors and midwives are.

C8H10N4O2 · 06/01/2022 08:49

Wilful misinterpretation here, talk about a straw man.

No its simply reality. You think a group is dangerous? Take it up with the platform.

You want to virtue signal? Talk about it on another forum entirely which is generally anti home birth let alone free birthing and get that warm glow of echoes but change nothing.

Fruitcake was my word - its my experience of most free birthers.

Sesnania14 · 06/01/2022 08:49

Yes. Most of society unfortunately is misygonistic and have no respect for women's autonomy. Women are under no obligation to seek medical care in pregnancy or listen to healthcare providers and may birth as they wish, even risking death.

Sesnania14 · 06/01/2022 08:47

The contradiction is a yes and a no. Some women freebirth out of fear. And some a very highly educated and do it by choice and have herbs. illegally sourced drugs and taken neonatal ressuss courses. There are actually a lot of midwives and former medical personal in home and free birthing communities. Though yes a point on non medical people giving advice, but its up to you to educate yourself and read at the end of the day. Unfortunately women are told lies constantly by the medical system. My midwife threw a pamphlet at me on inductions and it literally downplayed the risks of what is a post partum haemmorage calling it 'a risk of a slight bleed.; I would argue the hospital presents more risk because technically its a germ infested building where sick people congregate and if you rea da lot of midwife researcg, most problems in birth are caused by interventions. 'Im still confused about what 'misinformation' you are claiming. Many times IUGR and macrosomia are wrongly diagnosed because ultrasound in the third trimester is often wrong. This is what those groups share. No accountability? There is also no accountbility to doctors who abuse women. Again look at what a doctor did to Laura Gallazi. Your complaints against these women misplaced. Be angry at the medical system for abusing women and less angry about women trying to give each other advice online because they get lied to and choosing to ignore medical advice. Leave them alone to their own devices and perhaps focus your efforts on the crappy maternity system.

BiscuitLover3678 · 06/01/2022 08:34

Some of you guys had hideous NCT groups!

Namechangetimes100 · 06/01/2022 08:32

@C8H10N4O2

there is a huge difference between accepting other people’s right to free birth and promulgating fucking dangerous advice

So you are fine with free birthing so long as nobody actually talks about it or does it?
My question, which you seem to have missed is "what are you wanting to achieve?"

On MN complaining about group full of fruitcake free birthers will bring you your own gratifying echo chamber without question. Its not even friendly to standard home births.

But what are you actually changing by rounding up support here? Have you reported the groups to FB (or other host platforms) for dangerous and incorrect medical advice? Asked for a warning to be put on the relevant groups?

Because posting about it on another platform where the opposite view is prevalent achieves nothing in itself and just fudges and confuses home birth and free birthing here.

Wilful misinterpretation here, talk about a straw man. Post isn’t about the rights and wrongs of free birth it’s about the giving out of incredibly dangerous advice that comes with peer pressure to follow it and vitriol when someone might question or even challenge their line of thinking. That’s equally as coercive as the medics those sort of groups oppose. There is also no accountability in terms of poor advice given, as it’s inevitably going to lead to an adverse outcome at some point (a few posters have shared their stories on this)

Never used the term fruitcake either.

Now that you mention it, that’s a wonderful idea! Fb does put ‘ fact checker’ on people who share fake news, dangerous medical advice should carry the same sort of disclaimer.
Although how hard would it be for someone to point out the risks say for instance in an iugr pregnancy before ultimately telling the woman it’s her choice to continue or follow medical advice or third options. That’s is real informed consent which is what a specific group claim is their ethos

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 06/01/2022 08:22

@dittymcdit

I agree with the privilege thing. It's similar to the anti-vax movement. In the west we have no memory or lived experience of common diseases such as measles killing people or causing serious harm largely because of vaccinations. We also have a relatively very low maternal mortality rate because of modern obstetrics and access to anti-natal and perinatal care. But some have chosen to ignore or forget this and harp back to natural immunity and how women have been giving birth for millennia. They chose not to read heartbreaking stories of women in less developed countries dying in childbirth because they don't have access to the care that we do, or kids dying of measles because they don't have access to affordable vaccinations. We really don't know we're born do we?
How old are you? I'm a 60s baby and I certainly remember the rare deaths but commoner damage from measles, death from diptheria and the misery sometimes left by whooping cough and other illnesses for which we now have vaccines.

Vaccine hesitancy in general is much more complex that simply a generation growing up taking them for granted.

Maternity choices are more likely to be related to the quality of care available to pregnant women within a country. In the UK a common reason for choosing home birth or IMW is the quality of care available.

C8H10N4O2 · 06/01/2022 08:14

there is a huge difference between accepting other people’s right to free birth and promulgating fucking dangerous advice

So you are fine with free birthing so long as nobody actually talks about it or does it?
My question, which you seem to have missed is "what are you wanting to achieve?"

On MN complaining about group full of fruitcake free birthers will bring you your own gratifying echo chamber without question. Its not even friendly to standard home births.

But what are you actually changing by rounding up support here? Have you reported the groups to FB (or other host platforms) for dangerous and incorrect medical advice? Asked for a warning to be put on the relevant groups?

Because posting about it on another platform where the opposite view is prevalent achieves nothing in itself and just fudges and confuses home birth and free birthing here.