Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- home birth social media support groups are f’ing dangeorus **Content warning - title edited by MNHQ**

513 replies

Namechangetimes100 · 05/01/2022 14:51

I’m in a few Fb home birth groups as I was planning to have one til the service got suspended, had an MLU birth instead and was absolutely fine! I’ve not left the group yet (probs should) but some of the advice given is fucking dangerous as hell.

The advice is free birth left right and centre. Birth at home for a pre term (35 week plus) baby, the woman did and the baby needed resus this was met with almost rapturous applause and more recently refuse induction or action for iugr. I mean ffs this advice can kill as well as the doctors = evil mentality.

I do totally believe and support informed consent and I do think that choice isn’t often presented to women in obstetrics and sometimes induction is made to seem like the only choice when it isn’t. I was coerced into induction with a ‘constitutionally small’ baby based on old guidelines so I’m sympathetic to a point to some of these opinions. But to even contemplate birthing a premature baby at home, fgs and a baby measuring under the 3rd centile and dropping and to refuse any sort of medical support in pursuit of the perfect home birth. I just don’t get it.

Any free birth or demanding midwives come out when there’s a national short staffing. It seems like a recipe for disaster.

I totally get my body my choice but seems like playing with fire In some instances to me-aibu?

OP posts:
KeflavikAirport · 07/01/2022 08:08

Those of you preferring home birth to crappy hospital births, would you go for hospital if the service was properly funded? It doesn't have to be like it is in the UK. Other places fund their hospitals adequately and make it a much more pleasant and safe experience.

mynameisnotmichaelcaine · 07/01/2022 08:07

I had a home birth for my second, and it was definitely safer than my first (hospital) birth. I agree that this whole "just ignore the medical people" mentality is terrifying, and definitely comes from a place of privilege.

WhatNoRaisins · 07/01/2022 08:03

[quote Draineddraineddrained]@whatnoraisins

All the more reason to refrain from being needlessly graphic.[/quote]
Yes I believe the term is macerated and no one needs to google if they will find it potentially upsetting.

I just hate all this. The NHS isn't always going to do it's best for you but this approach on blanket not use of medical care isn't going to help you navigate this either

Katieandthekids · 07/01/2022 08:00

Not the same but I was on some exclusively breast feeding and pumping for multiples groups when feeding my twins and people were booted out for giving their babies a bottle of formula once in a while. Some of the advice was downright dangerous IMO as these mothers were often clearly at the end of their tether and wanted support and validation but some of the other women would liken formula to POISON!

I just quietly took the useful advice while happily combination feeding my girls but I did often think it would be really hard for those needing support and wondered if some of the babies ended up being harmed from it all.

Draineddraineddrained · 07/01/2022 07:58

@whatnoraisins

All the more reason to refrain from being needlessly graphic.

WhatNoRaisins · 07/01/2022 07:42

To be fair I think it is fairly well known what happens medically in the case of an untreated stillbirth.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 07/01/2022 07:35

I’d much rather entrust my maternity care to experienced and busy trained medical staff

Can people stop conflating free birth and home birth? It’s as ignorant as it is irritating. Homebirth has 2 trained NHS midwives at your house. It’s excellent 2 to 1 care - certainly much better in the run up than I found the hospital care to be.

Free birth is alone with no help. Homebirth is not. Homebirth is statistically as safe as hospital birth when the mother and foetus meet the criteria. Free birth is batshit.

Draineddraineddrained · 07/01/2022 07:19

@Namechangetimes100

That post was also grim. The difference is those are named cases you can independently fact check and find out what is true and what is hyperbole. The other was someone graphically describing the experience of their unnamed, quite possibly fictional, ex friend, and no-one can do anything with that except be repulsed and traumatised.

Draineddraineddrained · 07/01/2022 07:17

@RagzReturnedUnwrapped

I'm so sorry this has tainted your memory of your baby. All babies are beautiful however they are born. I'm so sorry for your loss xx

Dontletthemuggglesgetyoudown · 07/01/2022 05:31

I saw a woman on TikTok tonight advocating for never registering with a midwife or telling the GP you're pregnant, not having scans and then having a 'free birthing doula' come and help at the birth Hmm

Namechangetimes100 · 07/01/2022 04:10

@Sesnania14

30% is way too high. You seem to be really dismissing these issues. Women are not obligated to listen to or follow medical advice. Does that upset you?
@Sesnania14 you have to be doing this on purpose now as I said 30% is way too high, the only acceptable number is 0%. But you’re making it seem like every woman who gives birth in hospital says they’re traumatised which by your own statistics isn’t the case. On that, do you have references for them btw?

You seem to be really dismissing the routine giving of dangerous advice, blatant encouragement of dangerous decisions and obscuring of risks in persist of home birth.

As I’ve said one million times now I’m pro home birth.

OP posts:
Alfixn · 07/01/2022 01:16

@Sesnania14

No Ireland dies perform D and C during the era of the 8th amendment for miscarriges. She was treated differently and it absolutely had to do with racism among other things
Honestly, I don't like to get into debates on the Internet, but you appear to have really got the wrong end of the stick with the Savita Halappanavar case. Her case was not ever reported, by any source, to be to do with her race.

What happened to Savita was horrendous, shameful, and shocking. It rightfully sparked such anger in the general population that it led to the overturning of the eighth amendment and full reform of abortion law in Ireland.

Savita will always be remembered by the people of Ireland. But what happened to her happened not because of race (I've never even heard that as a theory - ??), but because of rigidly draconian anti-abortion laws. I mean that was the literally whole point of the outrage.

Sesnania14 · 07/01/2022 00:27

GOD forbid women want to put themselves first and must be self sacrificial

Pensieve · 07/01/2022 00:01

Well I had a great experience in hospital - in that we both came home alive and were treated with respect. Some of it was traumatising but not because of the medics. It became medicalised because it had to be and it wasn’t totally individualised because it couldn’t/can’t be.

I had a monitor and never felt I had been ‘strapped to the bed’ and would never even consider using that language. ‘Wireless’ monitors sound great but can you hear yourself out loud, some serious first world privilege on this thread, ‘If it gets bad I’ll just call an ambulance and go to a hospital”, but anything a medic may do to prevent needing that situation is an ‘over-intervention’.

Services are woefully underfunded I agree but it does not mean they are riskier.

Lalliella · 06/01/2022 23:30

I had a textbook birth with DC1 and would have been an ideal case for a home birth the second time around, but the placenta didn’t come away properly and I haemorrhaged. As I was in hospital the midwife was able to press the emergency button and within seconds the room was full of people who sorted me out. God knows what might have happened had I given birth at home. My carpets would have been ruined for a start!

On a more serious note, friend of a friend had a home birth, baby had an infection that was missed and died 😢

Much better to have a safe birth in hospital with the best care available rather than having some hippy experience which is all about the mum, not the baby.

Sesnania14 · 06/01/2022 23:30

No Ireland dies perform D and C during the era of the 8th amendment for miscarriges. She was treated differently and it absolutely had to do with racism among other things

TheHairyDinosaur · 06/01/2022 23:29

Free Birth is a dangerous movement I agree, and it needs to be seperated from Home Birth with a midwife in attendance. Many women who are low risk actually benefit from home birth. And I agree it should be more widely available.

Unfortunately people will always spout unsafe advice on the internet. I mean you only need to look on here regarding "should I go to A and E with chest pain" and people say "nah pop a paracetamol and wait for morning" 🤦🏻‍♀️

My birth experience was not great. I honestly left the first hospital, I was in early labour and drove myself 40minutes to the next hospital, I also may or may not have started a mutiny at the first hospital leaving a whole ward of women screaming and shouting about how unhappy they were 😳

I wasn't the only woman to leave that night and head over to the next hospital having forcibly removed their maternity notes from a midwife's clutches.

Sesnania14 · 06/01/2022 23:27

30% is way too high. You seem to be really dismissing these issues. Women are not obligated to listen to or follow medical advice. Does that upset you?

JazzyBBG · 06/01/2022 23:16

@DollyDingleberry OMG exact same situation - but they would never acknowledge it was PCOS related with me. Reading this actually makes me feel better!

Adventsquirrel · 06/01/2022 22:56

I joined a few facebook homebirth groups after my midwife recommended that a homebirth was the safest option for my second baby after a traumatic first hospital birth.
I found them a really good source of support, some very useful information, lots of birth stories that helped me understand what to expect. There was also some questionable advice and some downright reckless (imo) freebirth encouragement. Also a repeated assertion to "stick to your guns, refuse to go in, and they WILL send a midwife out to you".
But having gone through a hospital birth involving poor care, I can completely understand why some women feel like it's the last place they would feel safe to have another baby. It's a tragedy that maternity care isn't better funded, less overstretched and more patient-centred. I'm lucky that my area has a dedicated homebirth midwife team and their outcomes are excellent, but I don't think this is yet available in all areas. Obviously it's a very emotive topic but we all want the same thing which is better care for pregnant, labouring and postnatal women.

Fidgetty · 06/01/2022 22:45

Goodness I'm glad I'm not pregnant reading some of these horrific comments... wholly unnecessary.

CrumpledCrumpet · 06/01/2022 22:31

I could tell many stories about how woefully inadequate the care was in hospital for both my births, but the fact remains that if I hadn’t been in hospital with monitoring, immediate availability of a crash team I would likely have lost one or both of them. The experience was rubbish but I have two healthy children - I will take that.

NatalHeart · 06/01/2022 21:56

Agreed. I was contemplating not going to hospital with my last labour. I mean it would have been quick but I was dehydrated and heart rate was awful on the trace. Had a bag of fluids and went into full blown labour. I had been drinking loads all day but it must have been coming out of me quicker. Baby was in distress by the time I pushed again, but he did come out safely. Who knows what would have happened if I hadn't had the IV fluids. Almost like my body knew it wasn't safe to go into labour yet, I'm sure without medical intervention I couldn't have carried on like that forever.

If I ever had any more I would love a home birth. No way would I feel comfortable planning to give birth on my own. Whole other level of gaga.

I do feel it is a woman's right to choose regardless of risk if it's really what she thinks is best; although I would never advocate for it to be unnasisted completely. Someone needs to at least know what is going on.

TheOriginalEmu · 06/01/2022 21:45

[quote sjxoxo]@Sesnania14 Tragic as those stories are, from a statistical point of view this is not a good strategy for rational decision making. When making informed choices about maternity care and any medical treatment, the overall statistics are very important- these cases are not typical (in a western healthcare setting like the NHS) and shouldn’t be interpreted as such. Some women have negative experiences; but this isn’t the norm & part of making rational choices is reducing you own risk, through informed decision making. That involves mass studies & statistics, not looking at a few very extreme examples out of millions. I think this is the op’s point- if you encourage women to make decisions in this way it is essentially spreading misinformation & it puts people at risk. x[/quote]
But for many of the women on free birth/home birth groups they are the reason they don’t want to be in hospitals. After my son died and I nearly did I went and researched ways I could have my next baby at home and many free birth mums are the same. Ultimately I had 3 home births with very minimal input from midwives and that was fine for me. But had anyone tried to push me into a hospital birth id have rather been alone.

Namechangetimes100 · 06/01/2022 21:45

@Draineddraineddrained

You don't think "the baby had died long before birth" wasn't horrible enough? They whole "black rotten baby" bit was totally necessary for cautionary purposes? Really?
It was graphic yes but no more so than the PP who listed 5 cases of obstetric violence to illustrate her point that a hospital environment =adverse outcomes ‘point’
OP posts: