Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women are often oppressed through the label of Emotionally Unstable Personality Disorder (also known as BPD)

140 replies

UndertheCedartree · 05/01/2022 14:46

I made a post recently asking a question which was answered by many posters and the thread gave me the help I needed. However, many posters cited that no one could help me and even did Advanced searches and from that claimed I couldn't be helped because of my mental illness. It was said noone could understand my post if they didn't know this although it was irrelevant to my question and this was proved by all those who helped without knowing that. This is not a TAAT - it is about the general ableism shown to those with EUPD who are mainly women.

The name of the mental illness itself causes people to think there is a problem with our moral character or our personality but that is not the case. EUPD is an illness of mood and how one interacts with others.

Women with EUPD are often described as manipulative. However, this is not one of the symptoms of EUPD. Sometimes a woman described as manipulative is simply trying to seek the attention they require.

Women with EUPD are often described as abusive. However, the truth is most women with EUPD have suffered trauma often as a result of all types of abuse. Of course anyone can be abusive but it is not a symptom of EUPD. Most of us are more at risk of being abused ourselves.

Women with EUPD are often called 'drama queens'. It is often this invalidating environment in childhood along with trauma and differences in the brain which leads to EUPD.

People think it can't be cured. It can, although most aren't cured but some learn to live with the illness. The Gold standard treatment is DBT. Most women are not able to access this.

OP posts:
TedMullins · 05/01/2022 16:56

I have a very different experience. I have been diagnosed with BPD/EUPD and honestly since my diagnosis my life and past has made so much more sense to me, and allowed me to thrive.

I have mixed feelings on the existence of BPD as a disorder –I don't doubt that it may have come about as a result of medical misogyny and misunderstanding of trauma. I believe it is wrongly given to some women with complex trauma whose behaviour is a reaction to that. But outside of the ethics of it, I do believe that for some people it is a helpful framework to understand why they feel like they do, and start taking steps to overcome the unhealthy behaviours that come with it.

Being diagnosed for me led to me being prescribed a medication – on top of my antidepressants – that made a huge positive difference to my life, and allowed me to feel stable and not have massive responses to my triggers in the first time in my whole life. It's possible I could've got to this point with a different diagnosis but I don't know as that's not what happened.

I'm afraid to say that for me personally, I do believe that it sometimes manifested with manipulative and abusive behaviour in romantic relationships. This was almost always in response to being treated badly (I was very drawn to people with mental health issues of their own, which usually made for toxic relationships) but I have done things in the past which I personally have no issue in calling abusive, such as threatening to hurt myself if someone dumped me, punching someone in the face during an argument, bombarding someone with endless verbally abusive messages when they'd asked me to leave them alone. Now, I'm not absolving the other people here of any wrongdoing – like I said, this was always as a result of being treated poorly. Since I've been on the new meds I have not had any urges to behave like this, and I feel much stronger in myself to recognise red flags from someone else and walk away before things get anywhere near that stage.

I'm very open about my diagnosis and I've honestly never received any negativity about it. I've had people message me to thank me for being open about it. I haven't lost any friends, I haven't been judged or wrongly ascribed behaviours by my therapist –if anything she's the opposite and encourages me not to be so hard on myself or label myself if I'm reacting to a negative stimulus.

So while I don't doubt it is a problematic disorder, for me it actually gave me a vital understanding of my behaviour. It is a result of trauma, and having psychodynamic therapy to explore the roots of it and the effect of childhood trauma has also been vital for me, but the BPD diagnosis gave me a framework in which to identify my triggers and start resetting my thought patterns so I have to say for me, the diagnosis has overall been a positive thing.

JessieLongleg · 05/01/2022 16:53

I have BPD and totally get why as was bullied from pre school about a birth mark on my face so it makes a lot of sense. But hate the way I get sterotyped as manipulative when many people are and probably why I did so well in sales support when was working. The mental health teams I've encountered mainly have so many misconceptions about it to the point I've been told I don't have a mental illness I'm just a social construct. When it you broke the symptoms down I would have anixety, Depression, PTSD, eatting disorder, previous addiction problems. they get classed as a mental illness. And really upset with the to mental health services that just seem to write me off. Recently got diagnosed with general anxiety disorder because I'm not coping with being of work with no mental health treatment, then further phsyical disabilities. No one even contacted my GP or keyworker to investigate why I was being dismissed over my physical problems. Can't help it was part of been labelled a attention seeker through BPD......now I'm pregnant been referred to the pregnancy mental health team so fingers crossed this team will at least start treatment for my OCD and can start felling like I have a future beyond diagnosis.....what really get me wound up is other women with anixety and depression use it to gain public familialarity for their blog, social media. Tell everyone help is out there if only you want it but have never been near the CMHT and don't get regected by affordable counseling/therapy as classed as high risk through the BPD label.

christmascharade · 05/01/2022 16:52

@Sunset999

I thought ptsd just related to ex army? see I am so uninformed?
PTSD can relate to any kind of trauma.

Prostitutes, for example, are more likely to suffer from PTSD from their "work" than soldiers are.

jb7445 · 05/01/2022 16:48

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

picklemewalnuts · 05/01/2022 16:45

What an interesting thread, thank you OP. I have some knowledge of attachment disorders, and CPTSD, and an awareness that girls with attachment disorders often get the BPD or EUPD diagnosis later.

There may also be a cross over with FAS, too. A trauma history does seem to lead to various diagnoses in adulthood, that could quite simply be understood as trauma responses.

ancientgran · 05/01/2022 16:43

@ancientgran

I used to work with someone with BPD but he was a man. He was really lovely but then would go off his meds and do very bizarre things. He also got into lots of debt when he was off his meds. I don't know if he had suffered abuse. Is it different in women?
Just to clarify he was lovely when he was on or off his meds, just that some of his behaviour was strange/dangerous when he was off his meds and seemed very vulnerable.
Sunset999 · 05/01/2022 16:41

I thought ptsd just related to ex army? see I am so uninformed?

ancientgran · 05/01/2022 16:35

I used to work with someone with BPD but he was a man. He was really lovely but then would go off his meds and do very bizarre things. He also got into lots of debt when he was off his meds. I don't know if he had suffered abuse. Is it different in women?

christmascharade · 05/01/2022 16:31

@Enb76

Dr Jessica Taylor has written a book on this - coming out in March 'Sexy But Psycho'

Lifted from the blurb
'Utilising decades of research, real case studies and new data from her own work, Dr Taylor's book will critically analyse the way we label women with personality disorders. Why are women and girls pathologized for being angry about oppression and abuse? How have so many women been duped into believing that they are mentally ill, for having normal and natural reactions to their experiences? Sexy But Psycho argues that there is a specific purpose to convincing women and girls that they are mentally ill, as the world avoids addressing violence against women and their centuries of ignored trauma.'

I was about to recommend Dr Jessica Taylor too, she speaks out about this a lot.

Do your follow her Facebook page?

www.facebook.com/jessicaforenpsych

coffeeisthebest · 05/01/2022 16:29

@ChateauMargaux has your Mum ever had access to long term therapy? She seems very clear on what she needs and I wonder if a stable therapeutic environment might help her more than/alongside medication.

Yummypumpkin · 05/01/2022 16:23

I absolutely commend you on this post.

I also note that yet again amongst some helpful comments are some very ignorant ones.

The trend now in psychodynamic therapy is not to focus on a diagnosis, and this partly due to the issues you raise.

It's a very broad spectrum. The diagnostic criteria are inaccurate and behaviourally bases rather than emotion based (which given the condition is very unhelpful).

I advise anyone with all but the most severe BPD not to ever publicise their diagnosis....because people will suddenly stop responding to you as a human. As EUPD stems from not having needs and validity acknowledged, the impact of this is even more devastating.

At the same time, if more people who suffer from issues of trauma, neglect and attachment could share this, attitudes would change.

I don't know what the answer this, but it is a thread I will watch with interest.

supercritter · 05/01/2022 16:18

Jessica Taylor's work might interest www.littlebrown.co.uk/titles/dr-jessica-taylor/sexy-but-psycho/9781472135490/

StationaryMagpie · 05/01/2022 16:17

i've spent the last 25 tears being mis-diagnosed with all kinds of shitty MH/personality disorders.. someone has finally referred me for ADHD diagnosis. :/

I do have c-ptsd from an abusive marriage, but women get dismissed and incorrectly diagnosed SO much.

Sunset999 · 05/01/2022 16:15

I have someone close to me who has BPD, Id never heard of it until recently, I honestly thought she was being a drama queen and making it up......

Mamajunebugjones · 05/01/2022 16:12

The new ICD11 will have complex PTSD as a diagnosis which includes emotional dysregulation.

Medication may be more likely to be used due to huge waiting lists for appropriate psychological support and lack of NHS DBT therapists and CPNs to support appropriate therapy.

I think also we do a disservice to people to make them think a medication will magically make them feel better.

Agree ADHD and autism also present with emotional dysregulation- but again - really long waiting times for diagnosis meaning patients treated with medication rather than understanding wider context.

TheOriginalEmu · 05/01/2022 16:03

@FlibbertyGiblets

I am sorry you felt you were met with unkindness previously.

I didn't know that EUPD/BPD is curable, that is really good news.

I’m not sure if this is your intention, but saying ‘I’m sorry you felt…’ is massively patronising and not at all helpful. What you’re really saying there is ‘you felt bad, but that’s not the fault of the people who were unkind’. Do better.
ChateauMargaux · 05/01/2022 15:59

My mother is diagnosed with BPD previously diagnosed with Manic Depression. She suffered childhood trauma and every single professional only offered medication as a solution. Many of her medications have interactions with each other which are poorly documented. These cause physical symptoms which required more medication. She has recently been in hospital for 4 months and without consultation with her psychiatrist, was taken off her ‘mood stabilizer’ and she is more stable that I have known her in 20 years. Many times, she has tried to stop her medication as she doesn’t like how she is in them and the only answer is to go back on them but it is only when she is off them she can really speak her mind. Yes she is angry when she does ... but she has every right to be... she has spent her entire life being silenced. She wants someone to take action, to tell her she is believed and to help her to heal or at least to learn to live with it but the only answer is to go back on the medication, get stable and then see how she feels.. so she does, goes back... she is stable.. so nothing more is done.

She is not perfect but I have very little respect for the psychiatrists that have treated her.

LakieLady · 05/01/2022 15:58

@eloquent

It's very true YANBU. Also, I would suggest any woman diagnosed with eupd/bpd push for autistic assesment, as autistic women are often misdiagnosed with eupd/bpd.
That's interesting.

I have two nieces, both young adults now. One has an EUPD diagnosis, the other has Aspergers. They have 2 half-siblings, one of whom also has an EUPD diagnosis, the other - Aspergers.

AssignedBlobbyAtBirth · 05/01/2022 15:55

I'm suspicious of any diagnosis given largely to women. Trauma is ignored far too much imo. Years ago I worked for a while in acute mental health. Most of our patients were there due to childhood trauma yet it was ignored
My DC hits most of the ACE points and will be high risk of PD diagnosis but I guarantee they will ignore that. They know which children are going to have mental health issues in adulthood yet there is no support to try to prevent that

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/01/2022 15:52

@eloquent

It's very true YANBU. Also, I would suggest any woman diagnosed with eupd/bpd push for autistic assesment, as autistic women are often misdiagnosed with eupd/bpd.
I was going to say exactly this.

I know several women who were originally diagnosed as having BPD who now have an autism diagnosis.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 05/01/2022 15:51

YANBU. I worked in mental health and all the women I supported with BPD had experienced awful trauma and had perfectly natural reactions reactions to said trauma, then labelled as BPD or similar and failed by the system.

I think there is a move towards a PTSD diagnosis rather than EUPD or BPD. Trauma informed care rather than victem blaming.

RavingAnnie · 05/01/2022 15:50

YADNBU. EUPD is terribly stigmatised sadly mostly by MH professionals. As other PPs have says it's also often misdiagnosed.

Enb76 · 05/01/2022 15:42

Dr Jessica Taylor has written a book on this - coming out in March
'Sexy But Psycho'

Lifted from the blurb
'Utilising decades of research, real case studies and new data from her own work, Dr Taylor's book will critically analyse the way we label women with personality disorders. Why are women and girls pathologized for being angry about oppression and abuse? How have so many women been duped into believing that they are mentally ill, for having normal and natural reactions to their experiences? Sexy But Psycho argues that there is a specific purpose to convincing women and girls that they are mentally ill, as the world avoids addressing violence against women and their centuries of ignored trauma.'

Flowersandhearts · 05/01/2022 15:37

I agree OP- wouldn't it be better if people with BPD/EUPD, with a history of trauma were instead diagnosed with Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder?

People with BPD/EUPD without a history of trauma are more likely to have misdiagnosed ASD or ADHD, as there is some overlap.

I don't have EUPD but I'm sure that I could be diagnosed with it under the care of the wrong Psychiatrist. I have ADHD and since early childhood have had great difficulty controlling my emotions. I had some trauma (non-abusive) in childhood, which added to my emotion lability but it is mostly caused by difficulties with my executive functions caused by ADHD.

I struggle with life because of my ADHD (and severe OCD) but have received a lot of Psychological support and would hate to be diagnosed with EUPD and then told that I was too complex to treat (as it the case for many BPD/EUPD sufferers).

Have you tried DBT at all? I've no experience of it - is it useful?

Comtesse · 05/01/2022 15:37

I don’t know much about it - I’ve learnt a few things from just reading this thread. Thank for starting this - it’s helped me understand more Flowers