Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be upset as I want another child.

111 replies

M2AL · 04/01/2022 20:52

Hey everyone dc is coming up to two. Me and dh been together 14 years. We had a bit of a traumatic birth ending in emergency c section and as it was around the times of covid dh was all alone while I was having the csection . I have got my mind set on trying for another baby in the next few months . Dh doesn’t want anymore. As the whole birth has put him off and we also own a two bedroom house which he is using as an example to why we shouldn’t have another child. I just want dc to have someone to play with. I am not angry at his decision. AIBU to feel upset that his decision isn’t the Same as mine.

OP posts:
DontWantTheRivalry · 05/01/2022 13:00

And you've said it's for your child to play with and because you have fond memories of playing with your brother. It's an awful reason to bring another human into the world.

So what is the allowed reason for wanting to bring another human into the world then?!

OP’s ‘reasons’ are very valid….and I’m definitely getting the sense that most importantly she actually wants another baby for her own reasons, not just for the sake of her existing child.

It’s not as though she’s revolted by the idea of having a second baby, or adamant that she doesn’t want any more children yet is still considering having one just for her current child to have someone to play with, is it?!

My decision to have a second baby was hugely focused on the benefits it would bring to my current son (and yes, those thoughts were based on my experiences of my own childhood) but underneath those reasons I did actually want a baby, just like the OP does.

thepeopleversuswork · 05/01/2022 12:51

I don't think either of you is unreasonable but the bottom line is if he doesn't want another child - for whatever reason -- you have to accept this or end the relationship. You have to decide whether not having another child is a dealbreaker.

Just as an aside though: you do know only children also do get people to play with, right? You likely have other reasons for wanting another child but stuck out a bit to me. You're not obliged to provide a child with a sibling and if this is your primary reason for wanting another child you may be overthinking a bit.

NameChange30 · 05/01/2022 12:47

OK. Park the idea of another child for now. The two of you still have time. Show/send him this:
www.makebirthbetter.org/support-for-partners
Ask the hospital for a copy of the notes and a debrief (just for him or for the two of you together), my hospital calls it "birth afterthoughts" and all of them should offer it.
I advise individual counselling for him and/or couple's counselling for the two of you together, to discuss what happened and how you both feel about it.
You need to tackle the residual birth trauma before you can start to address the idea of a possible second child. I would suggest that you "park" that idea for at least 6 months, while you try and work through what happened, and then revisit it, with the help of couple's counselling if necessary.

FWIW, my DH wasn't ready to consider trying for DC2 until a few months after DC1's second birthday (for various reasons that I won't go into) but he did get there in the end. We have DC2 now Smile

CatJumperTwat · 05/01/2022 12:44

Like I’ve said before I would love another child as It’s something I’ve always wanted not just for my dc to play with. I’ve always seen myself with having two children

And you've said it's for your child to play with and because you have fond memories of playing with your brother. It's an awful reason to bring another human into the world.

LJAKS · 05/01/2022 12:42

My DD is almost 7. She was a traumatic start due to her health complications and it was touch and go if she'd make it. I had anxiety and ptsd but still always wanted another child. We couldn't agree on it and it was always a source of upset and arguments despite the logical part of me understanding his view. You can't compromise on a child. We divorced when she was 4. One of you has to "lose" this one. Only you will know if that's something you can cope with Thanks

Nomoreporridge872 · 05/01/2022 12:38

I think you’re best off leaving it another 6 months until DC is around 2 and a half, when they’re getting a bit easier anyway. He may be more open to the idea then. The you both need to have a really open, honest, respectful conversation about whether or not to have another. I’m with you and would have been gutted not to have a second but you can only do it if both parties are 100% in

M2AL · 05/01/2022 12:35

@CatJumperTwat

I just want dc to have someone to play with

This is a terrible reason to have another child. I never played with my brother; we hated each other. He was the worst part of my childhood and would probably say the same about me.

@CatJumperTwat

Like I’ve said before I would love another child as It’s something I’ve always wanted not just for my dc to play with. I’ve always seen myself with having two children

OP posts:
CatJumperTwat · 05/01/2022 12:07

I just want dc to have someone to play with

This is a terrible reason to have another child. I never played with my brother; we hated each other. He was the worst part of my childhood and would probably say the same about me.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 05/01/2022 12:03

@user1471604848

I couldn't accept a flimsy excuse that the birth "put him off". If he expects you to accept his decision, he needs to talk through it a lot more.
It's hardly flimsy. Women still die in childbirth. The OP could die next time. Sorry I am being blunt but it needs to be said when people minimise this sort of thing. OP you were lucky to have an idyllic childhood with your brother (does he have kids, could your dc play with their cousins) but there is no guarantee a second child would get on with your first child.
Idontknowlondon · 05/01/2022 11:58

@Caiti19

"And would you at the same for a woman not wanting a child while her husband did? That she needs to talk it through a lot more before he should accept it?"

Um....yes! If one person is really cut up about something, the caring thing for a partner to do is to engage with that and talk it through? I am finding the attitude of "I shouldn't have to explain myself beyond no" really cold and weird! There is a huge range of possible reactions that live between "relenting" and "no, and that's the end of it". Crikey.

When DH and I had that talk though he just found my "but I just don't want another" infuriating. I couldn't give a "reason", I just had absolutely no desire for another child and no articulated reasons for or against we're going to magic up a desire I didn't already have.

Parental desire is completely illogical and emotionally driven. There's no amount of discussion, reasons, positives or negatives that will change it. The desire is innate, you either have it or you don't.

Darkstar4855 · 05/01/2022 11:04

YANBU to be upset. We were actively trying for a second when my partner decided he wanted to stop after having some health issues.

It broke my heart at first but it did get easier with time. My son is three now and we have the best bond. I think he has gained more from having my time and attention that I wouldn’t have been able to give him with another baby to look after, than he has lost through not having a sibling. We are also financially better off as holidays, days out etc. are cheaper and we don’t need a bigger house.

Briarshollow · 05/01/2022 09:58

I know I take a hardline approach to men like this, but the OP went through it all and did brilliantly. She’s processed what happened and would like to try for another baby. Has he taken any steps to process his trauma? Has he spoken with anyone? Or has he just said no? Has he made any attempts to understand that the unknown element could be removed entirely from the second birth by way of an ELCS? Or has he just said ‘nah, it was too scary’?

It’s absolutely the right of someone to say no to more children, but if it’s entirely down to a ‘trauma of my wife’s childbirth’, and they’ve made no attempt to work through that, then yeah, I roll my eyes a bit.

Just as I did to the man who recently told me, ‘we’re pregnant’.

Caiti19 · 05/01/2022 00:15

"And would you at the same for a woman not wanting a child while her husband did? That she needs to talk it through a lot more before he should accept it?"

Um....yes! If one person is really cut up about something, the caring thing for a partner to do is to engage with that and talk it through? I am finding the attitude of "I shouldn't have to explain myself beyond no" really cold and weird! There is a huge range of possible reactions that live between "relenting" and "no, and that's the end of it". Crikey.

sst1234 · 05/01/2022 00:01

@user1471604848

I couldn't accept a flimsy excuse that the birth "put him off". If he expects you to accept his decision, he needs to talk through it a lot more.
Flimsy? What excuse would be acceptable to you?

And would you at the same for a woman not wanting a child while her husband did? That she needs to talk it through a lot more before he should accept it?

The double standards on here.

Beseen22 · 04/01/2022 23:53

Oh its a really hard one. There is no compromise and I have been there.

For my DH he doesn't get the emotional urge to make babies. So if we were discussing it and my only response was but I want one kind of pales in comparison to his 10 reasons why we shouldn't have another. He does not appreciate the constant nags/ mentioning of dfuturr babies.

Why don't you set a date a couple months in advance to discuss it properly and come up with a decision. Dont discuss it at all before then and do your research, have figures prepared....can you afford it? Will you be able to give your children the life you want for them? Would you have a planned section? Would you have support for the few months while you recover? What would having 2 children sharing look like, what if you had the opposite and your two couldn't share past childhood? Would you consider moving house etc etc. And at the end of that conversation where you have rational reasons why you feel another baby would fit into the family well if he decides he can do it then great and if not you have your answer and can take it forward how you want. To be honest I would not leave my DH if he didn't want another but I would hold some sadness and his choice has caused that sadness.

My DH did agree to try one more time but it hasn't happened..just my luck!

DontWantTheRivalry · 04/01/2022 23:20

YANBU OP.

When our first son was just under 2 years old I got the craving to desire another baby. Part of that reason was so my son had a sibling but the main part was that I just wanted to have another baby and make our family bigger.

My husband was adamant he didn’t want a second one and I found it really hard to accept. We had numerous conversations about it which would usually end up with me in tears and he couldn’t give me a ‘proper’ reason why he didn’t want a second child. He didn’t have any reasons or no explanations to give to me.

We did eventually have a second child but I empathise with you completely regarding how much it can hurt to want something so desperately but to have someone deny you the opportunity to actually have it.

It’s a very difficult emotional place to be in for a couple who disagree on something so significant.

Idontknowlondon · 04/01/2022 23:19

Your desire for a child is perfectly reasonable. It's emotional and not logical. He may be able to articulate logical reasons for not wanting another but his reasons are probably emotional - he simply lacks the desire for another. And you can't give or create that urge if it isn't there. And when it is, all logical reasons to ignore it can be overcome.

A desire for a child, or lack of desire is illogical, emotional and unreasonable (in that it cannot be reasoned, not that it's inappropriate or wrong).

purpledagger · 04/01/2022 23:18

The standard MN response is normally that the person who doesn't want more children trumps the person that does.

Like the OP, I had an emergency caesarean under a general anaesthetic. I remember the absolute look of fear in OHs eyes as I asked him if everything was okay (I was high as a kite). It must have been awful for him seeing all those medics rush into the room and quickly wheel me out. It was 1am and he had to wait by himself, not really knowing what was going on. I can't imagine how scary that must have been and I don't think his experiences should be minimised (I joke that DC1s birth was more difficult for OH than it was for me, as I slept through it).

I think having a two year old is a difficult age and maybe your OH isn't quite ready to think about having another baby yet. Unless age is a factor, maybe you should keep the dialogue open and enjoy your child.

Idontknowlondon · 04/01/2022 23:16

@Caiti19

If you have overcome the trauma experienced by your own body and mind, as the one who actually went through it physically - general anaesthetic and all, it seems a little bit selfish/precious of him to put his memory of being "outside on his own" up as a reason for not wanting to have another child. I'd need better reasons.
The man almost lost his child and wife. I can understand why he wouldn't want to risk that a second time, particularly with a child already that could become motherless.
maddening · 04/01/2022 23:15

And current housing is not fixed forever, many people move from 2 to 3 etc bed houses, it is fine for at least the next 4 to 5 years surely.

maddening · 04/01/2022 23:14

I would suggest counselling to deal with the trauma from the birth, he should definitely look at at least approaching this to explore as this is something v important to you imo.

bollocksthemess · 04/01/2022 23:10

What would you do if the next baby was a different sex to the first? At some point it would become unfair to make them share.
What would you do if it was twins?
I say this as currently pregnant with boy/girl twins, in a 3 bed semi with one room being a box room. We were aiming for an only child.

nildesparandum · 04/01/2022 23:09

My DS1 and I almost died during his birth by EMCS under general anaesthetic. It was in the days before husbands were not allowed anywhere near theatre at all.Counselling was unheard of.We all had to get on with it.
My DH's reaction when I got pregnant again two years later?, he joined the Merchant Navy and stayed away util DS2 was two months old.This was another EMCS under GA.DH refused to talk about and it was a bone of contention between us for years and years.He refused to understand what I had gone through during my second pregnancy and having to cope on my own afterwards.
The man is not the one who gives birth, but some of their reactions will never fail to surprise me .This was the reason I had the tubal tie done with the second birth, as I never ever would go through it all again.
I can understand you wanting to give your child a sibling as this was the reason I went for another baby.

jackstini · 04/01/2022 23:08

Did you talk before the first dc about how many you wanted?
It's hard if you have always imagined having a sibling for them

Keep talking and try counselling if you think it will work for him

I had a horrendous emcs with dd and DH who originally wanted 3/4 dc was put off having another. It took time but we really wanted another and decided we would try. Had a MMC & a chemical but did go on to have ds by elcs - which was so much better!!

The hard thing is it's not about that one 'birth day' is it, it's reconsidering the way you always hoped/planned your family would be Thanks

WonderfulYou · 04/01/2022 23:08

Has he always wanted one or did he used to want more?

Are you at risk of having a high risk pregnancy/delivery again?

I can’t imagine what it must be like watching the person you love almost dying and I can completely see why he doesn’t want another for that reason. It sounds like he has a bit of PTSD.
However it’s a shame that he doesn’t one because he’s worried about you even though you want to go through with it.

I would speak to him about both going to see a doctor and talking to them about what happened and what are the risks next time etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread