Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this restaurant Bill split should have been done differently?

339 replies

2020too · 04/01/2022 19:01

My Mom treated me to a restaurant voucher for Christmas as we tend to buy experiences rather than items.

She deliberately picked this restaurant as is a lovely place and I also get 33% off because of where I work - she saw this as stretching the money further.

We have an annually occuring meet up in the lull between Christmas and NYE with 2 couples from our hobby group non-specified as it might be outing

We meet up with them every few months for a meal and drinks at various places as well as seeing them frequently for hobbying. We rally enjoy their company.

It was one of other couple's pick of venue last week. They suggested this restaurant in the group chat, and I said great because my discount would apply and so we booked in mid December for last week.

As we sat down for the meal, I told my DH to remind me to use the voucher when the bill cane as I'm likely to forget - my menopause isn't serving my brain well . The others commented on what a nice present and then conversation turned to their Christmas presents etc.

Now for the sums

The bill for 3 couples was £450.

My discount brought it diwn to £300.

£345 with the tip.

£115 per couple.

One of the others reminded me about my voucher .

So to me that meant we had £65 to pay.

Someone spoke up and said, okay so that's 345 less the voucher = 295 to pay, let's call it £100 per couple, yeah.

So that's what we did

I bloody know I need to work in my assertiveness kills and I absolutely won't be addressing the issue, as I'm not a boat rocker. I also am aware that I didn't explicitly say that this was just for me and DH, because in no way would I have thought anyone would have thought elsewise.

YANBU: most people wouldn't have included the voucher as a joint contribution?

YABU they were totally reasonable to deduct the voucher off the total bill before dividing into thirds.

Never had any Bill splitting problems before with these, and £35 inequality wouldn't stop me socialising with them again. I'm just a very bit Confused

OP posts:
HandWash · 04/01/2022 20:09

I wouldn't use a voucher, I was only using for myself, during a group meal. It just makes things messy and a bit awkward.

hotsouple · 04/01/2022 20:09

Fully agree with @SenselessUbiquity

hotsouple · 04/01/2022 20:08

Eh OP I would chalk this one up to a misunderstanding about the bill between friends, probably after drinks. Are you hurting for the money? If not, let it go and certainly don't bring it up to anyone, no one likes a miser or to feel like their friends are accusing them of theft over a split bill.

Eddielzzard · 04/01/2022 20:07

Well I definitely wouldn't have assumed you would use your voucher to subsidise my meal! And then again I think you should have saved the voucher for another time if you didn't want to share it tbh.

SenselessUbiquity · 04/01/2022 20:06

btw I am not one of these cavalier bill-splitters in general and there are people I will never go out with again because they order everything in sight and then split the bill. I don't think you should have paid for their dinner - but I think suggesting the place, and bringing the voucher, and then keeping its value to yourself is ... well, I just wouldn't.

Also presumably the present is to give you the experience - which you would have had anyway if you would have happily gone with those people and just paid?

Darbs76 · 04/01/2022 20:04

Sorry I voted wrong! I meant your friends were out of order

ChateauMargaux · 04/01/2022 20:03

Your friends are dicks! There is no way that should have done anything other than been very grateful that your discount reduced the cost of their meals by £50!!

I would reply on the group chat.. ‘So whose turn is it to share their Christmas present next week???’

Zilla1 · 04/01/2022 20:03

That sounds perfectly fine, OP, provided you get a third usage of whatever new iphone, car, jewellery, holiday or other present your friends might have received for Christmas from their family membersthat you like the look of.

SenselessUbiquity · 04/01/2022 19:57

I think they were wrong to assume you were paying for them (essentially) but I think it was a bit weird to take the voucher along to that event. I realise I am in the minority here. If it was me, I would only have used the voucher if it had appeared completely unnoticeable.

I think my squeamishness about it is this (this is not logical and I realise no one else thinks so): you are muddling two relationships, that with the person who gave you the present with the people you are out with. There is an air of "efficiency" about it - which is almost as if you are killing two birds with one stone - eating out with one group, while being treated by someone else who isn't there and isn't treating them, feels weird to me.

Like if your mum came to your house with one amazing cupcake as a present for you, and you invited everyone in for a cup of tea and ate it by yourself in front of them. You'd eat it later when they'd gone.

BlusteringBoobies · 04/01/2022 19:56

@EmmaH2022

OP "They suggested this restaurant in the group chat, and I said great because my discount would apply and so we booked in mid December for last week."

I would think you were offering the voucher to the group. If not, you'd go without the group?

Two separate things here

OP has a discount for that restaurant of c30% which she mentioned in the chat and was happy to share

In between booking and attending, she also received a gift voucher from her mum (NOT the discount) for £50.

The friends were told about the gift voucher in conversation at the table and it was made clear this was a gift from her mother for Christmas.

So the friends used a combination of OPs discount (which she was happy to share) and assumed they could all use her Christmas present too (which she didn't intend to share)

The total saved by the OP for the group was £200!! Combination of discount and voucher. That's £66 a couple she has saved them. But rather than letting the Op pay less, they then assumed the OP, on top of her discount and voucher combination would share splitting the rest evenly.

OP, you are not unreasonable BUT you know you should have spoken up!

Fireatseaparks · 04/01/2022 19:55

YABU. Don't tell your friends you have a voucher if you're only planning to use it yourself. Very confusing message.

Hotyogahotchoc · 04/01/2022 19:54

OP gets a discount which would apply to everyone

But she also got a gift voucher which was her Christmas gift and not intended to be shared

ifonly4 · 04/01/2022 19:54

Hate to say it, but if it didn't sound fair I'd have tried to explain why and if no one go it, I'd have then said I'd like to keep it for a treat with a member of my family.

EmmaH2022 · 04/01/2022 19:52

Sorry, now I'm muddled with discount and voucher

But basically, if you told a group you could get them a discount on a meal, that applies to everyone, otherwise why would you tell them you had a discount or a voucher?!

Hotyogahotchoc · 04/01/2022 19:51

That was cheeky of them but i think you must not have been clear

I think you should have all calculated who owes why (after your discount) and then used the voucher towards your share.

TolkiensFallow · 04/01/2022 19:51

I think it was totally reasonable to share your discount but the gift voucher should have been yours only.

I imagine in the bill paying confusion is just got jumbled up and your friends didn’t account for the fact that the voucher was yours only.

phoenixrosehere · 04/01/2022 19:49

YANBU

I wouldn’t expect you to have paid for everyone with your voucher after there had already been a discount. I’m surprised no one thought to clarify with you instead of taking the other person’s word who didn’t have the voucher. I would have asked for clarification. Saying that, I agree with another poster why the bill just wasn’t split in three so you all could pay separate bills and you could have used your voucher then.

EmmaH2022 · 04/01/2022 19:48

OP "They suggested this restaurant in the group chat, and I said great because my discount would apply and so we booked in mid December for last week."

I would think you were offering the voucher to the group. If not, you'd go without the group?

Borland · 04/01/2022 19:47

Should have learned my lesson years ago when DH missed the birth of one DC as I was too polite to tell the midwife that she'd misheard me asking her to phone DH to come in for me talking about the busyness of the ward

Wait, you did what?! Surely that can't be true?

Enough4me · 04/01/2022 19:47

They don't sound like CF normally, so I think they didn't really take in what was going on and thought you were bringing the cost down for everyone. I wouldn't ask or the money back now, but take this as a valuable lesson learnt. Next time say just a minute, talk with your partner to confirm the discount amount and voucher amount so you have it clear in your mind. Then explain the discount is 33% only, the other part is specifically for you as a couple.

Next time, pause before going along with something that doesn't feel fair.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 04/01/2022 19:46

I think it would have been nicer to use thr discount another time. It seems a bit wierd getting a personal large discount while others pay normally. However. You are right it was your discount. But I think being in a group may have led to confusion.

OP wasn't getting a personal large discount - she was gladly getting them all a large discount. After which, each couple had their own (heavily discounted) share to pay - which they should have done using their own bank card, their own cash, their own voucher or any combination of those.

They clearly understood that it was OP's present, but they remind me of the kind of CFs who will 'help you to use something up' as if it's a troublesome burden to you, rather than a very nice asset to have.

Nobody would have dreamt for a second of asking the other couples to bring one of their nice Christmas presents to see if the restaurant would take it in part-payment of the bill for the whole group, as that would have been howled down as completely unfair (which it would be); but this is no different with OP's voucher, which was her present.

I'm not saying they should do, but what a lot of people would have done would have been not to mention the discount at all (or maybe claimed it was just 5% off, if pushed, when insisting on handling the transaction on behalf of everybody), then used the 33% off the whole group's meals to score a free meal.
Thus:
Meal costs £450 - £518 including 15% tip
Discount card-holder asks each other couple to give her £173, thus getting in £346.
DCH then uses discount to reduce cost to £300 - £345 including tip.
DCH hands over the money from the other two couples and eats completely free.
DCH could also have used her personal voucher to 'liquidate' the voucher into £50 cash in her purse.
Some ultra CFs would also keep the money intended for a tip and only hand over the £300, thus eating free and making a profit of £46 on the meal, at the expense of the waiting staff.

godmum56 · 04/01/2022 19:45

Can I suggest that even though you told them it was a gift, they may have thought that you wanted to share it with the group? Not voting but it could have been a misunderstanding

Chely · 04/01/2022 19:45

They shared your gift... CF's
The discounted rate you got them should have been treat enough.

Heronwatcher · 04/01/2022 19:42

Sorry another one saying you should have spoken up or, if you considered it less awkward, say you planned to use the voucher on a different occasion. No one else will do this for you I am afraid, you have to learn to politely say no.

jimmyjammy001 · 04/01/2022 19:40

A gift voucher is treated as cash, so you have basically paid for most of their meal, should of not mentioned the voucher at all and when it came to pay put the gift voucher down plus the cash, they obviously saw the gift voucher as free money with no value, but a £100 gift voucher will cost £100 to buy