Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New recruit pregnant before job starting

536 replies

FlimFlamJimJams · 04/01/2022 16:24

I've started a new business, it'll open to the public around April time.
It's a very small, community focused business with only 4 staff members initially.
I recruited all the staff within the last few weeks and are finalising contracts. Everyone has formal job offers, no one yet has a job contract.

The roles require training on the job resulting in a nationally recognised qualification, probably achieved within 12 months or so. The business is paying for this.

I have had meetings with everyone individually this week to go through bits and bobs, start dates etc - and at the end of a meeting with one lady yesterday, she tells me that she's 12 weeks pregnant and anticipates starting her Maternity leave around mid-July. She said she found out at 5 weeks - so she'd have known she was pregnant at interview.

I'm now stuck in a difficult position - the business is already going to struggle financially for the first few years (it's not quite a non-profit, but it's close) and I'm now facing having to extend someone's training at least 6 months past everyone else's as well as find temporary cover, which is expensive. She may well choose not to return after her maternity. I turned down other applicants who applied after her job offer was made.

I guess there isn't a AIBU, because I'm not going to do anything, but I feel really deceived and a bit stressed about the whole thing.
I know everyone is entitled to get pregnant etc. But I wasn't anticipating someone going on ML before they'd even qualified, or finished their probation.

OP posts:
Abigail12345654321 · 05/01/2022 16:02

@BethTTC

Given the workplace is a market where one trades labour for money, it’s reasonable that the buyer expects they are purchasing labour of the variety the business requires. As opposed to the other type of labour. Nothing deceptive about that.

However if the seller knows that they won’t be able to work for long before needing extended leave, that is less than ideal. It’s unreasonable when it’s a small startup covering major training overheads and childbirth will exclude you from even attending the training.

Anyone who thinks their manager was ‘thrilled’ at their pregnancy is deluded. Though my staff all likely think I was ‘super thrilled’ too…….

Blossomtoes · 05/01/2022 15:59

@BethTTC

It seems like employers on this thread are annoyed they aren't given the opportunity to discriminate against pregnant women at interview. Is it any wonder they don't tell you, when they know full well you would do so?

I'm not sure how that's manipulative or deceptive, when their argument is the employer wanted to be deceptive first.

Employers don’t want to be deceptive. How on earth did you manage to extrapolate that?
BethTTC · 05/01/2022 15:40

It seems like employers on this thread are annoyed they aren't given the opportunity to discriminate against pregnant women at interview. Is it any wonder they don't tell you, when they know full well you would do so?

I'm not sure how that's manipulative or deceptive, when their argument is the employer wanted to be deceptive first.

Abigail12345654321 · 05/01/2022 14:57

@McOrange

I agree that employers would commonly make pregnant women or women in mat leave redundant if they could legally do so. It’s right and proper that protections are in place. Also I agree that women should be allowed to take new employment while pregnant. But better they select a role where the impact will be minimised and where they plan to dedicate significant time once back, as doing so benefits all women. We are far from sex equality and it sets us all back when individuals behave badly.

Mind you I would also prefer to be able to talk to all my staff about their broad life plans (albeit plans don’t always work out) so that we can plan the team accordingly over many years. It would make life much easier and would mean women aren’t discriminated against from 18 until they have their second child, or reach 45 - whichever comes first. Would be far better to be able to discuss openly with managers; if only both managers and women could be trusted to not take the piss or misuse the information.

McOrange · 05/01/2022 13:35

@LetHimHaveIt

'No way will any employer dismiss a pregnant woman from her job'

Rubbish.

Indeed. It happened to me. I was shown a very detailed org chart of what the new structure would look like, but was the only person in my team made redundant. I was offered a decent settlement agreement to leave but basically told if I didn’t take it then my role would be made redundant.

I spoke to Pregnant Then Screwed who said this happens a lot. So much in fact that that’s why the organisation was set up.

I have also been made redundant while pregnant that my employer didn’t know about. I’d have been fucked if I didn’t take a new job while pregnant.

The other interesting thing here is the level of loyalty that so many posters are showing to an organisation who has zero loyalty to them. Being absolutely clear, if a business needs to make a decision they will do so for the best reason. They won’t be polite and show loyalty to employees. Why should employees not do the same to businesses, and put themselves first, while acting legally?

LetHimHaveIt · 05/01/2022 13:29

'No way will any employer dismiss a pregnant woman from her job'

Rubbish.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/01/2022 13:14

No way will any employer dismiss a pregnant woman from her job

Not at all; it happens all the time and in fact I've done it myself, admittedly under some pretty extreme circumstances

Nobody pretends it's easy though, and nor should it be, but what happens all too often is that employers "let things go" for fear of getting tied up even in hopeless cases because they know it'll cost money and effort better spent on the business

And unfortunately this is something the minority of genuine pisstakers take advantage of

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/01/2022 13:05

Parenthood isn’t a protected characteristic. We seem to have begun conflating sex based discrimination with inconveniences inherent with having small children. The former is the employers issue. The latter is, and should be, the parents issue

Exactly this

Fortunately nobody's argued that women should have no maternity rights, but as I've said it's a question of balance and the bigger picture, which for most rational people involves not shouting "discrimination!!" the instant something doesn't suit

Incredibly, though, there are those who press for parenthood to be made a protected characteristic - presumably the same ones who wanted leave extending because some baby classes had been missed during lockdown - and it really doesn't bear thinking about

Pigsears · 05/01/2022 12:58

LittleRoundRobin unfortunately many women get made redundant while pregnant.

I don't buy this. ^ As has been said on here already, many women will take an employer to court for getting rid of her whilst she is pregnant. No way will any employer dismiss a pregnant woman from her job. Only if she has a 0 hours contract, would they be able to dismiss her from the job.

@LittleRoundRobin- whether you buy it or not, it does happen. It happened to me. I was a permanent employee and pregnant. Yes, employers can absolutely do this and do do this. Do you know how stressful it is to take an established company to court? And expensive? And when you are about to give birth or have just given birth?

You are so pathetically naive to think it doesn't happen.

whynotwhatknot · 05/01/2022 12:53

thats a point op what if you support her delay her training then she decides she doesnt want to come back after all

Oblomov22 · 05/01/2022 12:23

I can both sides. As McOrange says a woman can't sit around for 7 months, if made redundant once pregnant.

But a business can't afford to keep someone who can't complete the training and might not even return.

Starcaller · 05/01/2022 12:20

I'm talking about the comments that have been made about women in general being pregnant and starting for jobs, not the specifics of this case. But higher salary aside, presumably the woman will then have X number of months of low or even no pay, as it's unlikely a country that doesn't have robust maternity discrimination laws will also provide excellent benefits for new mothers. And at 18 I am dubious as to how high this supposed wonderful salary could be in the first place. It seems a bit of an odd set-up in general.

But at the end of the day, our ultimate responsibilities are to ourselves and our families because it's our lives, and work is not the sum of our existence. Businesses can and will get rid of employees as it suits their business needs, that's just the way it goes. If you have a chance to better your own life and that of your children and reach your potential then you should take it because that opportunity might not come around for you again Maternity leave is a drop in the ocean if you work for a company that values people and makes them want to stay. Good companies tend to retain staff for a long time.

McOrange · 05/01/2022 12:18

@Aderyn21

They may not be looking to fiddle a company out of money deliberately but they do cost a company money in training and wasted time. The employer needs a return on their investment asap - not a year down the line. If you aren't in a position to do the job you were hired for, then you shouldn't take the job. In this case the employee can't complete the training in time and won't be generating any value for the employer but the employer can't replace her
Genuine question. If you think someone who is pregnant should not take the job, what should they do instead?

I got made redundant when I was 8 weeks pregnant. What do you think I should have done in between that time and when my baby came? I’m highly qualified in professional services, do you think I should have just sat around for the next 7 months waiting for the baby to arrive so as not to put out any company?

girlmom21 · 05/01/2022 12:16

@Aderyn21

They may not be looking to fiddle a company out of money deliberately but they do cost a company money in training and wasted time. The employer needs a return on their investment asap - not a year down the line. If you aren't in a position to do the job you were hired for, then you shouldn't take the job. In this case the employee can't complete the training in time and won't be generating any value for the employer but the employer can't replace her
But this employer actually can replace her. She doesn't want to.
Aderyn21 · 05/01/2022 12:13

They may not be looking to fiddle a company out of money deliberately but they do cost a company money in training and wasted time. The employer needs a return on their investment asap - not a year down the line.
If you aren't in a position to do the job you were hired for, then you shouldn't take the job. In this case the employee can't complete the training in time and won't be generating any value for the employer but the employer can't replace her

ChampagneLassie · 05/01/2022 12:11

I'm sure many of us are wondering where you're based and what the company is and that fully paid 12 months training for an 18 year old sounds very unusual. As you are planning on still making the offer why don't you discuss the situation with her in so much as you can within the legislation of the country you are in. Explain your predicament and ask about her long-term ambitions and plans. She might just want to get paid for a few months and then plan on being a SAHM. She may not have thought about the implications for you. On the other hand she may be very determined to train with you and pursue a career and this may reassure you.

Abigail12345654321 · 05/01/2022 12:10

But in the specific case on this thread, the applicant is joining a startup on an incentivised salary. So several months of high pay without any of the stress others will bear in terms of building the business, then off to have baby, with a guaranteed higher-than-normal salary to return to when it suits. The higher salaries in startups are to compensate for the risk of the business failing and the fact that staff need to be flexible and dynamic. It does nobody any favours having women take the proverbial in this situation. I would say the same if someone with a chronic illness took the role knowing they were likely to need substantial time off. Driving startups to fail isn’t in anyone’s interests.

Starcaller · 05/01/2022 11:59

There's a lot of misunderstanding on this thread about how maternity pay works. Women who start a job already pregnant aren't entitled to SMP. The employer pays nothing in terms of maternity pay. The woman has to claim Maternity Allowance from the government.

If a woman gets pregnant X number of weeks after joining, the employer has to pay SMP - which they then claim back from the government.

Enhanced maternity packages where you get stuff like full pay/half pay for X number of weeks are almost universally for employers with 1 year + service. With the exception of a PP's very unusual setup, pretty much no business offers enhanced mat pay from day 1 regardless of whether you join pregnant or not.

So women who join a company pregnant are not looking to diddle the company out of money because they can't. There's no mechanism to do so. In fact, if you leave a job and take a new one, you are more likely to lose out in terms of mat pay than gain anything.

Blossomtoes · 05/01/2022 11:59

If you’ve been unlucky @MabelsApron, so have I. It gets very stale having to carry people who think parenthood confers special status and an entitlement to special treatment.

Abigail12345654321 · 05/01/2022 11:53

Indeed. There are rare cases I’ve experienced of women who have become very valued later and who appreciated the support through the tough years - including children and caring for terminally ill partners or parents - but with the vast majority (men and women) that isn’t the case. I’m very mindful of being fair to the other staff.

Chocaholic9 · 05/01/2022 11:52

I think it's selfish to accept a position like this knowing you're pregnant. Someone down thread mentioned that women cannot put their lives on hold in case of pregnancy loss. If the rate of pregnancy loss was 50-80% I could understand that but it isn't.

MabelsApron · 05/01/2022 11:49

I’m also intrigued by the way that on these threads, posters always say that if treating pregnant employees well leads to retaining people who are more loyal and hard-working. It’s so at odds with where I work, where parents with kids younger than teenagers won’t do a single thing that isn’t convenient for them. They won’t do extra hours, they won’t attend meetings during the school run, they won’t work Christmas, they want priority leave in the summer, and they won’t do any emergency cover rotas. Possibly I’m just incredibly unlucky and have managed to get in with some awful people but I do chuckle a bit when “parents are the most hardworking” inevitably gets trotted out.

Abigail12345654321 · 05/01/2022 11:43

@Freecuthbert

Oh look another thread about pregnant women devastating a small business and acting deceitfully and maliciously. Hmm
Yes that’s right. And lots of women with senior management experience explaining why that behaviour is doing womankind a disservice.

I agree with @MabelsApron

Maternity protection was created to ensure a women could come back to work after having a baby. Jobs don’t exist in order to provide maternity payments to women who have never worked. Likewise I would be hacked off at an 18 year old man wanting 6 months paternity leave immediately upon arrival in a job.

By all means have as many children as you like, when you like. Just act like a reasonable person when doing so, rather than an entitled twat! That goes equally for men and women.

Freecuthbert · 05/01/2022 11:29

Oh look another thread about pregnant women devastating a small business and acting deceitfully and maliciously. Hmm

MabelsApron · 05/01/2022 11:26

It’s a woman’s right to have a child. Don’t tell me otherwise.

Nobody has a right to have a child. I should know - I’m infertile. Maternity rights are there to protect women from being unable to access the employment market. They’re a shield. Unfortunately many women are using them as a sword, arguing that they have a right to have a child and a right to burden anyone they so choose with the consequences.

I work with some extraordinarily entitled people, who talk about their rights like this all the time. With rights come responsibilities, though, and I’ve yet to identify anyone who believes in this right and can name a single responsibility that goes alongside it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread