Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New recruit pregnant before job starting

536 replies

FlimFlamJimJams · 04/01/2022 16:24

I've started a new business, it'll open to the public around April time.
It's a very small, community focused business with only 4 staff members initially.
I recruited all the staff within the last few weeks and are finalising contracts. Everyone has formal job offers, no one yet has a job contract.

The roles require training on the job resulting in a nationally recognised qualification, probably achieved within 12 months or so. The business is paying for this.

I have had meetings with everyone individually this week to go through bits and bobs, start dates etc - and at the end of a meeting with one lady yesterday, she tells me that she's 12 weeks pregnant and anticipates starting her Maternity leave around mid-July. She said she found out at 5 weeks - so she'd have known she was pregnant at interview.

I'm now stuck in a difficult position - the business is already going to struggle financially for the first few years (it's not quite a non-profit, but it's close) and I'm now facing having to extend someone's training at least 6 months past everyone else's as well as find temporary cover, which is expensive. She may well choose not to return after her maternity. I turned down other applicants who applied after her job offer was made.

I guess there isn't a AIBU, because I'm not going to do anything, but I feel really deceived and a bit stressed about the whole thing.
I know everyone is entitled to get pregnant etc. But I wasn't anticipating someone going on ML before they'd even qualified, or finished their probation.

OP posts:
j712adrian · 05/01/2022 17:57

With my hard business head on, you may be subject to a discrimination case - but if you do nothing you'll have no business from the sounds of it. At the same time as there is a right to certain maternity rights, there is no right for individuals' circumstances to collapse a business.

I'd document the circumstances, say that the individual has frustrated the contract because of the viability of the contract, check with legal, and then dismiss. Choose an HR legal person who deals with small businesses rather than large corporations. The FSB may have advice.

Bluefortytwohut · 05/01/2022 17:56

You see the double standard? Business's are ok to act this way, but women are not? I don't see any women mentioned in the thread acting outside the law, and they definitely don't have to consider their bosses feelings.

There's a slight difference though in that businesses are paying for the employee to provide a service, and employees are selling their time/skills to do said service. There's no double standard because they're not the same thing.

Put it into another scenario. Let's say you're planning to build a house and it will take 2 years to complete the project. You get several quotes from builders A, B, C, and D, and go for B. They seemed like the best out of the 4 but there wasn't much in it.

6 months in to the job Builder B informs you they are going off for a year and won't be available to work until they return, but they will most likely return. You won't have to pay them anything during their time off, and while you could simply terminate the contract it is difficult and you open yourself up to the possibility of legal action if you do. If you want to keep the job on track you are free to find another builder to take over in the interim and so have to get in Builder A, spend time, money and effort, bringing them up to speed and then again when B returns and you have to hand it over to them again.

If you'd known that B was going to be unavailable for a year in advance then the chances are you wouldn't have went with them in the first place. If builder B said they'd bd off because they were pregnant would that suddenly change your mind and you'd be happy to accommodate all the additional issues?

Abigail12345654321 · 05/01/2022 17:56

Yes - unless you have a lot of resource available in the early years Op, I would be wary of employing her. Explain the training costs and timeline and see if she can suggest a solution. But most likely she will want to work 2-3 days a week when she returns. That’s pretty standard!

cabbageking · 05/01/2022 17:55

You won't have to pay her SMP but just the cost of any cover.

Butchyrestingface · 05/01/2022 17:53

Not because I hate women, or that I'm a money-grabbing loon - but because this is going to put 3 other jobs at risk as well as my own.

Hope you don't live to regret that decision.

FlimFlamJimJams · 05/01/2022 17:50

A few people mentioning how she could return after Maternity and be an incredible asset to the business.

The odds of her returning to work full time after her Maternity are quite low statistically, I've just been looking it up.

www.understandingsociety.ac.uk/2019/10/22/how-womens-employment-changes-after-having-a-child

Fewer than one-in-five of all new mothers, and 29 per cent of first-time mothers, return to full-time work in the first three years after maternity leave.

7 per cent of women leave employment completely in the five years following childbirth, compared to four per cent of men

OP posts:
pmama · 05/01/2022 17:47

Well, with a new business, it is always difficult. Just as changing jobs while you are pregnant. It is reasonable to set the probation period for 6 months or maybe have a fixed term contract.

Abigail12345654321 · 05/01/2022 17:43

@girlmom21

To be fair I do agree women TTC or who know they're pregnant shouldn't apply for jobs with clear time-sensitive training programmes or anything else that would mean they can't actually do the job. We wouldn't apply for heavy lifting manual jobs in early pregnancy, would we?

OP, you say she knew at the point of interview but I'm guessing, as she was only 5 weeks then, she didn't know when she applied?

No she was 10 weeks and had known since 5 weeks
Abigail12345654321 · 05/01/2022 17:42

@girlmom21

And, to be fair, she's told OP before she's signed a contract, knowing OP could withdraw the offer. So she's not exactly done anything wrong.
She’s 18 and probably doesn’t realise the offer isn’t formal until a contract is signed
threatmatrix · 05/01/2022 17:40

Find someone else. I know small companies that have had to close because of maternity leave

Janesmom · 05/01/2022 17:36

Agree it’s v annoying.

Presumably because she’s already pregnant before starting the employment OP won’t be required to offer mat pay? That’s probably the saving grace here.

Leedsfan247 · 05/01/2022 17:28

You would be sued - and rightly so

Blossomtoes · 05/01/2022 17:26

Not hiring the best candidate for the job just because she's pregnant is deceptive, discriminatory and wrong

Pregnancy in many cases means she’s not the best candidate for the job. The best candidate is the person who’ll actually be present and doing the work.

Lifeisnteasy · 05/01/2022 17:17

[quote BethTTC]@Lifeisnteasy

*Because businesses aren’t benevolent organisations, a lot of people on this thread don’t seem to be able to process this fact.

They have zero duty to consider the woman’s feelings or affirm her life choices, only to act within the law.*

'Because women aren’t benevolent beings, a lot of people on this thread don’t seem to be able to process this fact.

They have zero duty to consider the business's feelings or affirm their business choices, only to act within the law.'

You see the double standard? Business's are ok to act this way, but women are not? I don't see any women mentioned in the thread acting outside the law, and they definitely don't have to consider their bosses feelings.[/quote]
There isn’t a double standard. Women are entitled to seek employment & hide their pregnancy, employers are entitled to be pissed off about it.

Pigsears · 05/01/2022 17:14

You see the double standard? Business's are ok to act this way, but women are not? I don't see any women mentioned in the thread acting outside the law, and they definitely don't have to consider their bosses feelings.

This.... agree with @BethTTC on this

BethTTC · 05/01/2022 17:09

@Lifeisnteasy

*Because businesses aren’t benevolent organisations, a lot of people on this thread don’t seem to be able to process this fact.

They have zero duty to consider the woman’s feelings or affirm her life choices, only to act within the law.*

'Because women aren’t benevolent beings, a lot of people on this thread don’t seem to be able to process this fact.

They have zero duty to consider the business's feelings or affirm their business choices, only to act within the law.'

You see the double standard? Business's are ok to act this way, but women are not? I don't see any women mentioned in the thread acting outside the law, and they definitely don't have to consider their bosses feelings.

Lifeisnteasy · 05/01/2022 17:03

[quote BethTTC]@blossomtoes

Not hiring the best candidate for the job just because she's pregnant is deceptive, discriminatory and wrong.

I don't really understand how we accuse women of a myriad of misogynistic tropes just because they dared to need a new job in pregnancy, but don't say the same about the MULTIPLE employers on this thread admitting they wouldn't employ a pregnant woman. Is it any wonder they 'deceive' an employer, when the alternative is being discriminated against?

It seems to me the double standard here is that we let businesses get away with practices that we rip women apart for.[/quote]
Because businesses aren’t benevolent organisations, a lot of people on this thread don’t seem to be able to process this fact.

They have zero duty to consider the woman’s feelings or affirm her life choices, only to act within the law.

There’s a wider conversation to be had about work/life balance and how motherhood can put careers at disadvantage etc, but that simply isn’t something that fledgling businesses need to be taking a stand on.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 05/01/2022 16:59

@bcc89

Employers just want to not hire you if you're pregnant, basically. Maternity discrimination, plain and simple.
Why would you hire someone who will be gone for extended periods of time and not be able to work? Then you have to find another person to cover them. Pay 2 people to do 1 persons job. Are you for real?
BethTTC · 05/01/2022 16:54

@blossomtoes

Not hiring the best candidate for the job just because she's pregnant is deceptive, discriminatory and wrong.

I don't really understand how we accuse women of a myriad of misogynistic tropes just because they dared to need a new job in pregnancy, but don't say the same about the MULTIPLE employers on this thread admitting they wouldn't employ a pregnant woman. Is it any wonder they 'deceive' an employer, when the alternative is being discriminated against?

It seems to me the double standard here is that we let businesses get away with practices that we rip women apart for.

Blossomtoes · 05/01/2022 16:22

@bcc89

Employers just want to not hire you if you're pregnant, basically. Maternity discrimination, plain and simple.
Why would you want to hire someone who’s just about to disappear for a year? Why do you think employers hire people? Because they enjoy repeatedly going through the recruitment process for shits and giggles?
girlmom21 · 05/01/2022 16:16

@bcc89

Employers just want to not hire you if you're pregnant, basically. Maternity discrimination, plain and simple.
There's a difference between not wanting to hire someone and not hiring someone.
girlmom21 · 05/01/2022 16:15

And, to be fair, she's told OP before she's signed a contract, knowing OP could withdraw the offer. So she's not exactly done anything wrong.

bcc89 · 05/01/2022 16:15

Employers just want to not hire you if you're pregnant, basically. Maternity discrimination, plain and simple.

girlmom21 · 05/01/2022 16:14

To be fair I do agree women TTC or who know they're pregnant shouldn't apply for jobs with clear time-sensitive training programmes or anything else that would mean they can't actually do the job. We wouldn't apply for heavy lifting manual jobs in early pregnancy, would we?

OP, you say she knew at the point of interview but I'm guessing, as she was only 5 weeks then, she didn't know when she applied?

Abigail12345654321 · 05/01/2022 16:03

@Blossomtoes

Apparently, expecting people you pay for work to do some actual work is ‘deceptive’.