Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New recruit pregnant before job starting

536 replies

FlimFlamJimJams · 04/01/2022 16:24

I've started a new business, it'll open to the public around April time.
It's a very small, community focused business with only 4 staff members initially.
I recruited all the staff within the last few weeks and are finalising contracts. Everyone has formal job offers, no one yet has a job contract.

The roles require training on the job resulting in a nationally recognised qualification, probably achieved within 12 months or so. The business is paying for this.

I have had meetings with everyone individually this week to go through bits and bobs, start dates etc - and at the end of a meeting with one lady yesterday, she tells me that she's 12 weeks pregnant and anticipates starting her Maternity leave around mid-July. She said she found out at 5 weeks - so she'd have known she was pregnant at interview.

I'm now stuck in a difficult position - the business is already going to struggle financially for the first few years (it's not quite a non-profit, but it's close) and I'm now facing having to extend someone's training at least 6 months past everyone else's as well as find temporary cover, which is expensive. She may well choose not to return after her maternity. I turned down other applicants who applied after her job offer was made.

I guess there isn't a AIBU, because I'm not going to do anything, but I feel really deceived and a bit stressed about the whole thing.
I know everyone is entitled to get pregnant etc. But I wasn't anticipating someone going on ML before they'd even qualified, or finished their probation.

OP posts:
Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 17:59

25% of women don’t return to work after maternity leave.

The overwhelming majority who return do so part time.

Many of those who do return, full time or part time, generally take a huge amount of time off in the first year back due to accumulated annual leave.

Therefore, unless doing a job like nursing or working in a call centre, where you hand over to the next shift each day, the period after returning will likely impact the workplace.

Where women have worked for a time before pregnancy and benefited the company, there is no debate. The issue here is people arriving, contributing little (due to limited time) and then going on maternity leave and most likely never returning full time.

It’s absolutely true that many employers and managers make life difficult for women during their pregnancies and beyond. That is absolutely wrong. But do you really believe that the current system is working well?

BlueBellsArePretty · 07/01/2022 17:52

@MeredithGreyishblue

You've got a lot to say for yourself?

Really? Is this where we are? Being chastised like little girls in 1950?

So depressing

The misogynistic tone of this whole thread is depressing.
BethTTC · 07/01/2022 17:45

*Well my name probably gives you a clue as to my sex. So putting ‘women’ in italics does suggest you think those with a different view to yours are not women. Or not ‘real women’ perhaps?

You still haven’t made any case for your position. Do you have one?*

All your username shows is that you can type some letters into a forum. I have no idea who you or anyone else actually is. Is this really new internet information?

And what 'position'? That discrimination against women is wrong? It is.

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 17:38

@BethTTC

*Totally agree. Absolutely disgusting of BethTCC to put ‘women’ in italics in this context.

Can you see why that is so offensive BethTCC?*

Not at all. I have no idea who anyone on this thread actually is and no intentions of having everyone prove their sex or credentials.

The fact remains many people on this thread are advocating for discrimination of women and it makes no sense to me why other women would do so when we have enough of it from men.

Well my name probably gives you a clue as to my sex. So putting ‘women’ in italics does suggest you think those with a different view to yours are not women. Or not ‘real women’ perhaps?

You still haven’t made any case for your position. Do you have one?

ShirleyPhallus · 07/01/2022 17:21

@BethTTC

*Totally agree. Absolutely disgusting of BethTCC to put ‘women’ in italics in this context.

Can you see why that is so offensive BethTCC?*

Not at all. I have no idea who anyone on this thread actually is and no intentions of having everyone prove their sex or credentials.

The fact remains many people on this thread are advocating for discrimination of women and it makes no sense to me why other women would do so when we have enough of it from men.

✊🏼✊🏼✊🏼✊🏼✊🏼✊🏼

BethTTC · 07/01/2022 17:08

*Totally agree. Absolutely disgusting of BethTCC to put ‘women’ in italics in this context.

Can you see why that is so offensive BethTCC?*

Not at all. I have no idea who anyone on this thread actually is and no intentions of having everyone prove their sex or credentials.

The fact remains many people on this thread are advocating for discrimination of women and it makes no sense to me why other women would do so when we have enough of it from men.

Oldmumsie · 07/01/2022 16:53

I personally would ask the candidate how she intends to complete the training. I usually find returning mums super hardworking. However a recent experience of a manipulative report has destabilised our whole company. A very well loved employee was made redundant to accommodate her demands. No flexibility on her part just threats because some of her role had been reallocated during her maternity leave. Her tenure before announcing her pregnancy? Four months! Lets hope the posters applicant is genuinely helpful to her new business.

Lweji · 07/01/2022 16:35

Note: not that the OP should be or deserves to be attacked; and thus shouldn't be defended either, because she isn't (or wasn't) planning on withdrawing the offer, but was annoyed and worried. She is clearly trying to do her best for her business and for another woman, but is struggling. We all tend to be selfish in our own ways. In this case, the two women have different interests that happen to conflict.
It's shit that both are put in difficult positions.

Lweji · 07/01/2022 16:30

IMO, whether the OP (i.e. the employer) in this case is a woman or a man is, and should be, irrelevant. It is not feminist to defend the OP just because she is a female employer starting a new business.

What is evident from this thread (and others) is that maternity protection should not be a burden on employers, but having children should not affect women disproportionately. IMO, there is a case for fathers to contribute significantly to child care, or directly pay for it if they decide not to provide it themselves. And there is a case for the state to provide better protection for mothers and employers.

BTW, having children is not a selfish act. It is an act that benefits the societies we live in. Older people must be supported and have to be replaced. Most developed societies, certainly in Europe, have dwindling populations, only really replaced by immigrants. Having lots of children, yes, it will be selfish.
The overpopulation problem is mainly felt in developing nations and nations that have achieved better economic statuses and health outcomes, but still have similar fertility rates than when they had high childhood mortality rates.
In Europe, most women do tend to have less than two children on average, which is below replacement level (it should be at about 2, representing a couple).
ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Fertility_statistics
And the total fertility rate in different countries:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_fertility_rate
It could become a problem for the UK, and even worse with Brexit.
www.smf.co.uk/baby-shortage-could-spell-economic-stagnation-for-uk/
The word's population is still growing, but it is expected to level off in the next few decades:
www.worldometers.info/world-population/
Being at a growth of just over 1% now:
ourworldindata.org/world-population-growth

You can see here the rate of natural increase in the population for different countries:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rate_of_natural_increase

But, regardless of this woman disclosing or not her pregnancy (and I do think it is fair that she doesn't), it is also clear that the OP is walking a tight rope in terms of starting her business, as it seems to depend too heavily on a significant number of her workforce being able to complete training in what seems like a tight schedule. As I and others have pointed out, even start ups should conduct risk assessments and allow for employers having time off or leaving for any reason. Even the OP could be forced to take time off at some point. Have you prepared for it?

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 16:10

@MabelsApron

Not if the 'women' on this thread are anything anything to go by!

Think I said earlier that MN only cares about feminism when it can be used to argue for mothers. Key example - unless you agree with the pregnant woman in this case, you’re not a woman.

Totally agree. Absolutely disgusting of BethTCC to put ‘women’ in italics in this context.

Can you see why that is so offensive BethTCC?

MabelsApron · 07/01/2022 15:43

Not if the 'women' on this thread are anything anything to go by!

Think I said earlier that MN only cares about feminism when it can be used to argue for mothers. Key example - unless you agree with the pregnant woman in this case, you’re not a woman.

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 14:27

@MeredithGreyishblue

You've got a lot to say for yourself?

Really? Is this where we are? Being chastised like little girls in 1950?

So depressing

Tragic isn’t it?

These are the mothers of the next generation of young women. And thus women do it to themselves. Over and over from one generation to the next. With no insight or self awareness.

At least I know when I’m choosing to be overbearing on a thread! Hahaha!!!

MeredithGreyishblue · 07/01/2022 13:54

You've got a lot to say for yourself?

Really? Is this where we are? Being chastised like little girls in 1950?

So depressing

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 13:18

@BlueBellsArePretty

I do have lots to say for myself. Isn’t it wonderful that free speech is permitted? Though maybe read my posts more carefully as you seem to have been rather selective in your reading.

I believe people conflate maternity rights with family friendly policies. The former are a legal entitlement and I have not said that women should not be employed while pregnant and I haven’t even said they shouldn’t conceal it. I have said they should use some common sense in choosing where to apply because small startups cannot sustain much additional financial burden in the early years; I would say the same to the chronically ill or anyone who prefers a 9-5 ethos because young startups do need dynamic people willing to go the extra mile in the hopes they will benefit later if the company flies. I would like small companies to be exempt from many anti discrimination requirements for a limited time - although it’s difficult to know how to implemented that without companies manipulating the system to their advantage and thus discriminating for longer than should be permitted. With large established and public sector firms I would want to see much family friendlier policies than most have now so they attract the young mums and dads - if they look after them through the small child years they may buy loyalty for many years and they can afford the initial outlay. I’d like to see big firms funding private schools and paying the fees for their staff, and funding those facilities to run after school care and early morning clubs to take the pressure off parents with drop off and pick up times. Parents make themselves ill stressing about how to juggle childcare. Many have no local family support. It’s not good for employers if staff are not coping.

And all women should use every available opportunity to advance these issues in their workplaces, particularly senior women. And parents should apply some common sense in deciding where to work and when to make complaints - if a large company or public sector organisation discriminates, by all means get onto ACAS and pursue compensation. But doing the same with a small startup is not cricket.

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 12:57

@saleorbouy

Are you hoping to scale up the business. Perhaps discuss her thoughts on returning back to the role after giving birth. How long will she take off, returning F/T or P/T etc. Would there be an opportunity for an additional P/T role that would mean an additional member of staff jow but then leads to cover Mat leave and then job share or P/T depending on how she plans to return to work. I fully understand the need to enable, pregnancy, mat leave in the work place but it does leave small businesses with a predicament to cover costs and posts.
It’s generally recommended that you not ask pregnant women about their plans for after the baby is born as a) things might change anyway so it’s all quite meaningless and b) it might make them feel stressed and pressured, risking accusations of you harming them or the baby if they miscarry subsequently
BlueBellsArePretty · 07/01/2022 12:16

@McOrange

I don’t think I’ve ever seen a thread be steam rollered by one poster as much as *@Abigail12345654321* on this one. You’ve made your opinion known, isn’t it time to give it a rest?
Actually agree, you've got a lot to say for yourself *@Abigail12345654321* on this topic and the only points that you're making clear are that:

-The right of pregnant women to not face discrimination is conditional.
-Small businesses should be exempt from complying from equality legislation.
-Small businesses should be lauded and their growth facilitated by allowing them to discriminate.
-Pregnant women's primary concern should be how their condition affects the place they work for.

saleorbouy · 07/01/2022 12:07

Are you hoping to scale up the business. Perhaps discuss her thoughts on returning back to the role after giving birth. How long will she take off, returning F/T or P/T etc.
Would there be an opportunity for an additional P/T role that would mean an additional member of staff jow but then leads to cover Mat leave and then job share or P/T depending on how she plans to return to work.
I fully understand the need to enable, pregnancy, mat leave in the work place but it does leave small businesses with a predicament to cover costs and posts.

OlgaDaPolga1 · 07/01/2022 11:55

This is why I would only employ older women or men

Iwantamarshmallowman · 07/01/2022 11:23

@UnshakenNeedsStirring

Absolutely shitty of her to do this. She shouldve informed you before taking the offer. She just wants someone to pay for her maternity unfortunately you got stitched up OP
This.
Mollysocks · 07/01/2022 11:00

@Viviennemary

Yes indeed big drip feed. Since you are not even in the UK and would not even be acting illegally if you withdraw the offer. What a time waster.
I agree what a waste of everyone’s time!
BethTTC · 07/01/2022 10:52

@Pugroll

Women owned businesses are good for women.

Are they?

Not if the 'women' on this thread are anything anything to go by!
Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 10:25

@Oblomov22

I agree with Abigail, lying by omission may make you deceitful and untrustworthy. Why hire that person?

Pregnancy laws are here to protect all women, but if some go in knowing you are pregnant, not declaring it, can't do the training, may not return, that is actually an abuse of the pregnancy benefits we are all given, so you are damaging it for other women.

Not my quote - but I would question whether this candidate has any common sense in applying, if they can’t complete the training.
Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 10:24

@Pugroll

Women owned businesses are good for women.

Are they?

Apparently so, yes!
Pugroll · 07/01/2022 07:46

Women owned businesses are good for women.

Are they?

Oblomov22 · 07/01/2022 07:38

I agree with Abigail, lying by omission may make you deceitful and untrustworthy. Why hire that person?

Pregnancy laws are here to protect all women, but if some go in knowing you are pregnant, not declaring it, can't do the training, may not return, that is actually an abuse of the pregnancy benefits we are all given, so you are damaging it for other women.

Swipe left for the next trending thread