Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New recruit pregnant before job starting

536 replies

FlimFlamJimJams · 04/01/2022 16:24

I've started a new business, it'll open to the public around April time.
It's a very small, community focused business with only 4 staff members initially.
I recruited all the staff within the last few weeks and are finalising contracts. Everyone has formal job offers, no one yet has a job contract.

The roles require training on the job resulting in a nationally recognised qualification, probably achieved within 12 months or so. The business is paying for this.

I have had meetings with everyone individually this week to go through bits and bobs, start dates etc - and at the end of a meeting with one lady yesterday, she tells me that she's 12 weeks pregnant and anticipates starting her Maternity leave around mid-July. She said she found out at 5 weeks - so she'd have known she was pregnant at interview.

I'm now stuck in a difficult position - the business is already going to struggle financially for the first few years (it's not quite a non-profit, but it's close) and I'm now facing having to extend someone's training at least 6 months past everyone else's as well as find temporary cover, which is expensive. She may well choose not to return after her maternity. I turned down other applicants who applied after her job offer was made.

I guess there isn't a AIBU, because I'm not going to do anything, but I feel really deceived and a bit stressed about the whole thing.
I know everyone is entitled to get pregnant etc. But I wasn't anticipating someone going on ML before they'd even qualified, or finished their probation.

OP posts:
twominutesmore · 04/01/2022 19:49

If you can tighten your belt and make a few manageable adjustments, employ her as planned because it's the right thing to do.

If you genuinely believe that this will kill your business before its properly off the ground, retract the offer. The most important thing is protecting the business. No one benefits, including this employee, if the business fails.

Obviously, if you can legally do so in the country you're trading in.

SofiaMichElf · 04/01/2022 19:47

I'd have already withdrawn the offer without starting this thread, OP.

It's bloody hard getting a new business off the ground, and especially so when employees require extensive, costly training before they'll contribute to revenue.

It's not in the least bit misogynistic or discriminatory to understand that your business will be fucked before it launches if you take this woman on.

OverTheRubicon · 04/01/2022 19:46

[quote Abigail12345654321]@ShirleyPhallus
It isn’t illegal. No contract has been signed. The offer can be withdrawn because the Op decides she fancies employing a flying unicorn instead, or just because she changed her mind. That is perfectly legal. Or because she now knows this employee will cost her a lot of money.

If she thinks the prospective employee told her because she was doing the decent thing (as opposed to being stupid!) then she may choose to employ her anyway and discuss when training might be viable.

But there is no signed contract so there is no legal issue. Withdrawing the offer after contract signing would be illegal in the uk. But not before.[/quote]
There's some shocking legal advice here. This is particularly bad. A verbal contract IS a contract.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 04/01/2022 19:41

@WiddlinDiddlin

I think this problem high-lights some errors you've made in calculating your outgoings for the next couple of years.

You should have calculated for this necessary training to take twice as long, and for employees to drop out/quit/have accidents.

Instead.. you've decided to pay them 3 x the going rate.. leaving you no fall back to cover such issues as you are now experiencing...

Recalcuate your numbers - then decide if she can actually do the job if she defers training until after mat. leave. Put that to her and see what she decides to do, if she can't do the full training now, and can't do the work without the training, I do not see how she can do the job now?

All of this.

Because realistically, you should always have a plan for multiple people in your team going on maternity leave - just in case.

Lifeisnteasy · 04/01/2022 19:38

If she doesn’t return after maternity leave, doesn’t she have to pay back everything apart from the stat? Or am I imagining things?!

There’s no ‘baddie’ here, this woman is within her rights to seek employment & OP is right to be pissed off about it. OP doesn’t owe this woman anything other than fair treatment, she’s allowed to prioritise her own business over another woman’s pregnancy.

Tigertigertigertiger · 04/01/2022 19:34

Who would do that ?
That’s shocking.

BeardyButton · 04/01/2022 19:33

@LethargicActress

It’s shitty when people do this, especially when they knowingly do it to small businesses. You have my sympathy OP. Is there any chance you could find another job for her and give someone else the job that comes with the training and qualification?
“People”? You mean women?! So pregnant women don’t have the right to seek employment? Or they have an obligation to disclose at interview and risk discrimination?

The misogyny of this thread.....

WiddlinDiddlin · 04/01/2022 19:32

I think this problem high-lights some errors you've made in calculating your outgoings for the next couple of years.

You should have calculated for this necessary training to take twice as long, and for employees to drop out/quit/have accidents.

Instead.. you've decided to pay them 3 x the going rate.. leaving you no fall back to cover such issues as you are now experiencing...

Recalcuate your numbers - then decide if she can actually do the job if she defers training until after mat. leave. Put that to her and see what she decides to do, if she can't do the full training now, and can't do the work without the training, I do not see how she can do the job now?

MrsTrue · 04/01/2022 19:29

@BurbageBrook

Never thought there would be so much misogyny on MN from WOMEN against those unlucky enough to need to apply for jobs when pregnant. Really shitty attitudes.
This 100%. You have no idea what this woman has gone through, how many children she may already have or how many she may have in future. Yes the owner needs to protect her business but legally retracting the offer after being told she's pregnant would be discrimination.

I've actually been in a very similar position but in reverse, when 5-6 weeks pregnant I applied internally for a promotion I'd been wanting for years. I had no idea if the pregnancy or job application would be successful after trying to get pregnant for a long time. I told them after my second interview and was petrified they'd not offer me the job if I told them I was pregnant, or that they'd have some unconscious bias against me if they knew during the interview process. Miraculously both the pregnancy and job application were successful and my employer (all my management are male) was over the moon for me. Different because I was already employed there, but a promotion and inconvenience nonetheless. Yes it's hard as a small business but there is support from the government as others have said and you cannot retract an offer purely based on her maternity status, morally or legally!!! Delaying training courses until she's back full time sounds sensible if that could work in the role and I think it would be an understandable compromise, she may even be grateful to have one less thing to worry about when dealing with pregnancy! Sounds like legal advice may be needed to find a suitable path forward.

Honestly, the opinions on here that are promoting discrimination against women of childbearing age are absolutely disgusting and people should be ashamed of themselves. Maybe as women we are our own worst enemies after all?!

HTH1 · 04/01/2022 19:28

@PGSTesting123

If you can legally withdraw and want to, then do it. I'm not saying this is right but if it is right for your business then do it. Also, paying 3 times more than the going rate! There's a reason why they have the rates they do. Your bottom line is already affected. Which country is it?
This. You feel deceived and that she was immoral to hide her pregnancy when interviewing, knowing that you would be unlikely to hire her in those circs. Therefore, would it really be immoral to withdraw the offer before she even starts?

You already know it’s not illegal…

Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/01/2022 19:27

It’s probably already been said but look for the thread in legal where this happens and the lady takes them to court (rightly IMO)

Yes, this and similar have been said countless times, and all by PPs who seem not to have read the thread; had they done so they'd have seen that where OP lives there's no legal bar to refusing this lady the job

Whether it's the right thing to do is something else, but then the same applies to those who routinely avoid employing women of childbearing age, and that happens all the time

I'd expect that we all want to protect womens' workplace rights, but there has to be balance and sometimes it's wise to be careful what you wish for

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 04/01/2022 19:27

Hope the people insinuating @RoomOfRequirement "pulled this stunt" in the past feel suitably ashamed tbh.

sweetbellyhigh · 04/01/2022 19:22

@Viviennemary

Yes indeed big drip feed. Since you are not even in the UK and would not even be acting illegally if you withdraw the offer. What a time waster.
😂 😂

You know @Viviennemary

I actually agree with you for once. You do indeed waste your time posting ill-informed and sexist comments. I don't for a moment imagine you'll ever stop though.

Abigail12345654321 · 04/01/2022 19:19

I don’t know why everyone is so up in arms. For most jobs this wouldn’t be an issue. It’s the training that makes this situation unusual. Under normal circumstances the Op would bear the burden of mat leave. That’s ok.

But in this case the Op would either need to spend a lot of extra money to schedule extra training or agree with the candidate that they would wait until it’s convenient for the company.

bonetiredwithtwins · 04/01/2022 19:18

If it's perfectly legal in the jurisdiction you are in I would detract the offer. It was made clear the requirements of the job when she applied. She chose not to disclose her circumstances. Why should you suffer financially.

Scottishnewbie2022 · 04/01/2022 19:14

It’s probably already been said but look for the thread in legal where this happens and the lady takes them to court (rightly IMO).

Borland · 04/01/2022 19:13

I'm not going to retract her offer (though we're not in the UK, and legally I'm allowed to) nor treat her any differently.

If no contracts have been signed and you can legally retract the offer then what is stopping you doing so? Not great for her and perhaps morally dubious, but if it will cause your business to suffer and potentially threaten your livelihood and that of your other employees, at the end of the day you don't owe her anything.

bcc89 · 04/01/2022 19:12

@BurbageBrook

Never thought there would be so much misogyny on MN from WOMEN against those unlucky enough to need to apply for jobs when pregnant. Really shitty attitudes.
This. I'm always disgusted by people's attitudes on these types of threads to pregnant women trying to make a career, or a living.
PinkTonic · 04/01/2022 19:11

I think this is somewhat nuanced given the requirement for training within a specified timeframe. It’s not the same as taking on a job you’re already qualified to do and then going on mat leave which can be covered. A condition of accepting the role is the completion of a mandatory training course which she can’t do. It seems unreasonable to expect the business to run another training course just for her.

BurbageBrook · 04/01/2022 19:07

Never thought there would be so much misogyny on MN from WOMEN against those unlucky enough to need to apply for jobs when pregnant. Really shitty attitudes.

Pugroll · 04/01/2022 19:05

You can still dismiss someone who is pregnant but you have to be absolutely watertight in procedure and 'evidence' that would withstand scrutiny to prove it wasn't because they are pregnant. If someone is grossly incompetent and endlessly pregnant then it doesn't mean they can't be disciplined (as long as justified and not for sickness). It's just very hard and risky so most employers don't bother.

Lookingoutside · 04/01/2022 19:01

Maryjane3227

‘I work with someone who had had 3 pregnancies/babies in the last 5 years. The impact on my work place's finance and other staff is immense. This person is now pregnant again. She never fully commits, sees plans through, or has the insight that comes from sticking with projects long term. She is incompetent at times. She is totally protected by law.
I have no sympathy with Boris Johnson, whom I consider an imposter. I think of this colleague as one too.
The rights of everyone need to be balanced, not just the desires of one individual who desires to have children.
Colleagues who don't have children feel especially pissed off and I don't blame them.
If I ran my own business, I'd be annoyed too. There is an element of self interest and game playing here or playing the system. If "the system" was all powerful and money was no object, this strategic financial survival would be fine.
But "the system" being played is fellow human beings. So yeah, you can do this and get away with it, but you clearly know there's a cost to others.’

@Maryjane3227

What sector are you in? Regardless, your employer needs to spend more money to reduce the immensity of the impact on you and your colleagues.

Ellowyn · 04/01/2022 18:59

Your ad was clear and so she has been dishonest from the very start. I wouldn't want her in my company.

ShirleyPhallus · 04/01/2022 18:58

[quote Abigail12345654321]@ShirleyPhallus
It isn’t illegal. No contract has been signed. The offer can be withdrawn because the Op decides she fancies employing a flying unicorn instead, or just because she changed her mind. That is perfectly legal. Or because she now knows this employee will cost her a lot of money.

If she thinks the prospective employee told her because she was doing the decent thing (as opposed to being stupid!) then she may choose to employ her anyway and discuss when training might be viable.

But there is no signed contract so there is no legal issue. Withdrawing the offer after contract signing would be illegal in the uk. But not before.[/quote]
Incorrect, that’s still maternity discrimination which is illegal in the UK

Millionairesshortbreadshort · 04/01/2022 18:57

Many women don’t want to tell anyone they are pregnant until after the 11 week scan. The right thing to do is to support her to do the training, value her so that she wants to come back after maternity leave. I appreciate your business might struggle but the reason pregnancy shouldn’t make a difference to things like this is to address the massive inequalities there are for women. It’s fine what she had done. Completely within her rights and I’d have done the same. Sorry.

Swipe left for the next trending thread