Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New recruit pregnant before job starting

536 replies

FlimFlamJimJams · 04/01/2022 16:24

I've started a new business, it'll open to the public around April time.
It's a very small, community focused business with only 4 staff members initially.
I recruited all the staff within the last few weeks and are finalising contracts. Everyone has formal job offers, no one yet has a job contract.

The roles require training on the job resulting in a nationally recognised qualification, probably achieved within 12 months or so. The business is paying for this.

I have had meetings with everyone individually this week to go through bits and bobs, start dates etc - and at the end of a meeting with one lady yesterday, she tells me that she's 12 weeks pregnant and anticipates starting her Maternity leave around mid-July. She said she found out at 5 weeks - so she'd have known she was pregnant at interview.

I'm now stuck in a difficult position - the business is already going to struggle financially for the first few years (it's not quite a non-profit, but it's close) and I'm now facing having to extend someone's training at least 6 months past everyone else's as well as find temporary cover, which is expensive. She may well choose not to return after her maternity. I turned down other applicants who applied after her job offer was made.

I guess there isn't a AIBU, because I'm not going to do anything, but I feel really deceived and a bit stressed about the whole thing.
I know everyone is entitled to get pregnant etc. But I wasn't anticipating someone going on ML before they'd even qualified, or finished their probation.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Annoyedtoomuch · 19/03/2022 18:12

YABU. This is just a fact of life. Women get pregnant. Lots of women don’t want to share that until after the 11 week scan. Why would she tell you before her mother, for example? Women are under no obligation to tell employers or prospective employers if they are in the early stages of pregnancy. It is difficult for you financially but this is just life. She did nothing wrong. If she was best for the job now, she will be after mat leave. Invest in her, develop her and she is far more likely to come back and work hard.

dfendyr · 19/03/2022 16:48

@Viviennemary

Tell her the offer is now withdrawn. And deal with the Consequences if any. That is what I would do.
and see yourself in court!

Do not do this

implantreplace · 19/03/2022 16:17

@threatmatrix

Find someone else. I know small companies that have had to close because of maternity leave
Bloody hell Those companies must have been flying by the seat of their pants anyway
strivingtosucceed · 08/01/2022 11:56

@Aderyn21

An employer in a start up should have money available for unforeseen circumstances but I don't think they should have to use that money to cover the costs of a brand new employee who is pregnant. I don't believe that any employer should be deemed discriminatory for not hiring a person who they know will be unable to do the job for months on end. They absolutely shouldn't be allowed to sack existing employees, who were hire pre pregnancy, but I'm not convinced that new employees should automatically be protected. Why should a business have to cover a brand new employee's decision to have a baby? As far as I'm concerned protection is there for employees who have already provided value to the employer.
I agree with you here. I also think there's a big difference from a stable company hiring a few new workers because they're trying to expand and a startup/micro-business hiring one or two new staff to fulfill a contract that is starting soon.

I don't think it's right to apply for a job at a small company where you KNOW you won't be able to fulfill the requirements because you won't be present. Eg a nanny for a family going onto maternity just as the mother is going back to work.

SunnyUpNorth · 08/01/2022 10:13

@BlueMountains5

I can really see both sides of this and the OP is clearly in a difficult position. On the one hand, women absolutely shouldn’t be discriminated against just because they are pregnant. She obviously didn’t know if she would get the job when applying and I think has actually been quite transparent, telling you as quickly as she has.

On the other hand, it is a challenge for the business and while I think it would absolutely be wrong to rescind the offer, I don’t blame you for feeling a bit put out and anxious.

The advice around engaging your employee in the problem-solving process is a really good one, as is potentially exploring options for her to possibly continue training during maternity - there might be some creative solutions to mitigate the impact.

Also try to see beyond the six months (difficult in a small business, I know). You’ve responded with grace to the situation and it seems like you’re creating a really positive work environment - that’s what retains people. Yes, in the short-term it’s a challenge, but you may end up with a loyal employee for years to come. And even if not, your other employees see the human-centred approach you’re taking and that means something.

Rescinding the offer, like some suggest, would likely shade your other employees’ perception of you and the business. Worth thinking about

Blue mountain has said what I came on to say. People are piling in very unfairly on the OP. She has repeatedly said she isn’t going to rescind the offer but she is allowed to process that fact that it’s a bit of a blow to her new venture which has probably been a while in the planning.

Hopefully your fairness will pay off in the long run with a loyal employee and you won’t regret your choice. Good luck with it all.

Aderyn21 · 08/01/2022 08:03

An employer in a start up should have money available for unforeseen circumstances but I don't think they should have to use that money to cover the costs of a brand new employee who is pregnant. I don't believe that any employer should be deemed discriminatory for not hiring a person who they know will be unable to do the job for months on end. They absolutely shouldn't be allowed to sack existing employees, who were hire pre pregnancy, but I'm not convinced that new employees should automatically be protected. Why should a business have to cover a brand new employee's decision to have a baby? As far as I'm concerned protection is there for employees who have already provided value to the employer.

MiniatureHotdog · 07/01/2022 21:19

You mention the statistics on her likelihood of returning to work... you do realise that a lot of women don't return precisely because many employers are crap towards women taking maternity leave??

MiniatureHotdog · 07/01/2022 21:13

It's clear you think she's in the wrong for not telling you sooner, but it's also very clear that had you known you'd have discriminated against her by not offering her the job. YABU. As a pp said, if the business can't support her then it's not viable.

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 20:58

@MabelsApron

The pandemic and home schooling has been a nightmare and many women have realised they are married to dickheads who don’t do their share!

Within my team I aimed to have parents (of both sexes) work 4 hours a day. But I also ensured everyone else worked no more than 8 hours. Productivity went down, but that was necessary. I didn’t pile the work onto the wider team. Indeed it’s the first time I’ve ever worked 9-5 myself as I wasn’t willing to compensate for the parents - and I was clear about my strategy with the more senior management team above me.

What really shocked me was how many women’s husbands or partners clearly had zero respect for their careers, believe their own jobs to be ‘more important’ and regarded all things child related to be the mothers problem. And didn’t care how exhausted their own wife was.

Have been having discussions since then about introducing policies at work to assist women - financially and practically - to leave their awful marriages as it’s clear many would leave if they could, but can’t for practical reasons. Discretionary funds need to be available for HR managers to allocated to individuals for such things. Rather than peeing money away on accumulated annual leave!

Oldmumsie · 07/01/2022 20:56

@Luckyducky75
That is actually what the returning mum asked for. My well respected colleague who was under two years service got dismissed for no reason. I have children. But i am shocked how someone can threaten, lie and see a decent person out of a job. Sisterhood, i don't think so.

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 20:50

@Luckyducky75
I expect she will make her own claim. The owner will have weighed up which claim will cost less I expect.

Luckyducky75 · 07/01/2022 20:44

[quote Abigail12345654321]@Luckyducky75
Well if the company employed two women and there was a promotion advertised, both applied, 6 months pregnant women didn’t get it, goes on mat leave, returns and claims she didn’t get the promotion because she was pregnant, why is that implausible?[/quote]
It's implausible because you're just focusing on the pregnant women and not the woman who was supposedly made redundant to give someone else her job. Would you accept it if your boss said to you tomorrow they were letting you go so they could give your job to someone else to avoid them raising a tribunal claim. You'd just accept that and walk away!

MabelsApron · 07/01/2022 20:42

I suspect the reason why women on here wouldn’t support exemptions that would assist small businesses owned by women, is that they don’t care about womens rights, they care about mothers rights.

The same way that threads on here often defend parents getting priority for summer and Xmas leave, parents getting to work fewer hours than other employees due to doing school runs/having to pick up kids etc, and parents getting the benefit of flexi working even where that impacts upon their colleagues. Anyone complaining about this is brushed off with “management problem”, as if those behaving badly enough to require management intervention is completely divorced from a wider issue of entitlement.

I’ve not once seen a champion of womens rights on a thread like this get agitated about how women without children get treated in the workplace and wider society. Then suddenly it’s all “that’s not parents’ faults, it’s bad management”.

My workplace came up with an outrageous policy during the pandemic that meant parents were doing 50% hours on full pay and those without kids - women - were picking up considerable amounts of extra hours for no extra. A large portion of MN has told me that this was fair enough as parents suffered during the pandemic. That’s a clear cut case of discrimination (brought on by an employer that’s terrified of being sued) but MN was all for it. Whenever I see anyone on here arguing womens rights, I just laugh.

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 20:42

[quote Oldmumsie]@Luckyducky75
This happened. We don't have a HR department just an egotistical MD. The returning mother's solicitor was the biggest firm in London. I am a director but not on the board. I have been shocked by their actions.[/quote]
Fight fire with fire. Hope the rightful role holder pursues an unfair dismissal claim. Hard for the company - but they must learn to stand firm in the face of unfounded threats or face the consequences.

Oldmumsie · 07/01/2022 20:38

@Luckyducky75
This happened. We don't have a HR department just an egotistical MD. The returning mother's solicitor was the biggest firm in London. I am a director but not on the board. I have been shocked by their actions.

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 20:29

And it’s not polite to accuse someone of lying when you can’t possibly know that’s the case.

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 20:29

@Luckyducky75
Well if the company employed two women and there was a promotion advertised, both applied, 6 months pregnant women didn’t get it, goes on mat leave, returns and claims she didn’t get the promotion because she was pregnant, why is that implausible?

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 20:27

[quote Oldmumsie]@Abigail12345654321
The senior lady had brought extensive new business to the company. However the new mum was parinoid, jealous and dishonest. She had set out to sue the company (she recorded every conversation and sent them to the owner). Her aim? a payoff. I am angry but can do nothing as the company are scared of being sued. This company is classed as a SME and owned by a woman. So people just be honest, you are pregnant, how may i help you. Because you if you are decent, people will help you.[/quote]
Trouble is it’s often the weakest workers who head for SMEs because they can’t successfully compete for roles in established companies - it’s a minefield. But the more SMEs have experiences like yours, the less likely they will be to employ any women aged 18-45. Even though in most cases they likely couldn’t successfully prosecute, SMEs can’t afford to defend themselves. An exemption to equality laws seems to me the most sensible way forward.

Luckyducky75 · 07/01/2022 20:25

[quote Oldmumsie]@Abigail12345654321

Mumsnet seems to favour pregnant women even if they are liars, manipulative and not very good at their job. I hear you. My employer lost a senior talented well liked menber of staff because a returning mother wanted her job (she applied at six months pregnant, was rejected and has now alleged discrimination.). Total nonsense as the successful candidate was multi lingual, had a further degree and extensive contacts. We had to make her redundant as the new mother alleged she didn't get the job as she was pregnant. Sometimes people are just nasty. I miss my colleague and feel for her. She did nothing wrong. Tbh i think my colleague could claim age discrimination and I bet you nobody cares![/quote]
This didn't happen. No HR team would agree to fire a high performing member of staff, recruited and appointed into a role to avoid a discrimination claim 🤔 A redundancy means there is no role so the company has to dismiss you. It doesn't mean we gave the job to the wrong person so now we're going to fire you so we can give it to someone else! I mean what would you even write in the termination letter, I don't think you I'm understand how these things work! Stop listening to gossip!

Oldmumsie · 07/01/2022 20:22

@Abigail12345654321
The senior lady had brought extensive new business to the company. However the new mum was parinoid, jealous and dishonest. She had set out to sue the company (she recorded every conversation and sent them to the owner). Her aim? a payoff. I am angry but can do nothing as the company are scared of being sued. This company is classed as a SME and owned by a woman. So people just be honest, you are pregnant, how may i help you. Because you if you are decent, people will help you.

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 20:02

That’s terrible @Oldmumsie - I do think sometimes HR departments are excessively cautious and focused on avoiding any claims of discrimination rather than robustly defending themselves when wrongly accused. But this is exactly what I mean when I say thinks will become more hostile toward women if people carry on as they currently do - as it is Covid is massively widening the pay gap between the sexes and things will get much worse for women in the coming years. And because the economy will be in a bad way, jobs will be scarce and people will be discriminated against even more. Which is why I think there need to be robust changes - to protect women in the longer term.

Exemptions to equality laws are permitted if it is a proportionate means to achieve a legitimate aim. I’m curious as to why women wouldn’t support that if it means small companies can succeed and thus contribute to economic growth. That, surely, would benefit women - and most importantly, their children.

Oldmumsie · 07/01/2022 19:07

@Abigail12345654321

Mumsnet seems to favour pregnant women even if they are liars, manipulative and not very good at their job. I hear you. My employer lost a senior talented well liked menber of staff because a returning mother wanted her job (she applied at six months pregnant, was rejected and has now alleged discrimination.). Total nonsense as the successful candidate was multi lingual, had a further degree and extensive contacts. We had to make her redundant as the new mother alleged she didn't get the job as she was pregnant. Sometimes people are just nasty. I miss my colleague and feel for her. She did nothing wrong. Tbh i think my colleague could claim age discrimination and I bet you nobody cares!

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 18:25

Sorry, applied not allied

Abigail12345654321 · 07/01/2022 18:23

[quote BlueBellsArePretty]@Abigail12345654321

"I have said they should use some common sense in choosing where to apply because small startups cannot sustain much additional financial burden in the early years"

Why should it be a prospective employees responsibility to determine whether their presence within the company will render it unviable? Also at what point does it stop being a 'small' business?

"I would like small companies to be exempt from many anti discrimination requirements for a limited time - although it’s difficult to know how to implemented that without companies manipulating the system to their advantage and thus discriminating for longer than should be permitted."

So in effect yes you would be ok then with pregnant women being discriminated against in the workforce. Where would you draw the line? Such exemption would be a welcome green light for unscrupulous employers, as you fortunately acknowledge. Do you think that these start up businesses should be obliged to divulge that they're free to discriminate? I certainly know that I would not want to use any business that wanted a special exemption from equality legislation.[/quote]
I take your point. And I agree it’s impossible without legislation for it to work because individual women and individual companies won’t behave well otherwise.

Absolutely agree and I did say that implementing exemptions to equality laws would be difficult as it would allow some companies to exploit it - but at the moment the discrimination is still happening and everyone just pretends it isn’t. Which isn’t right and isn’t helpful.

We know no manager is ‘super thrilled’ then any staff have children, including fathers. Their productivity does down. But they must pretend they are. If their company offered much better support for parents, it wouldn’t be a burden to managers and colleagues. And then maybe people would be thrilled!

But it’s impossible to force companies to offer really good parental support because it isn’t viable for small companies. So sooner or later we need to look at how to set a threshold where some companies are exempt. In reality they already discriminate - what, after all, is a ‘young dynamic company’? It means no old people, no ill people, no pregnant women and most likely few parents. Of course they already discriminate - if they didn’t they wouldn’t survive the early years. So why do we keep pretending they don’t? Why not be open about it and legislate properly so once turnover hits a certain level or employee number goes above a certain level, the rules applied to big corporations allied? I accept it would be hard to do and would be open to abuse - but it would mean larger firms could be forced to provide much better parental support so the resentment of parents of young children (who are carried by their colleagues very often) would be lessened. Surely that should be the aim?

BlueBellsArePretty · 07/01/2022 18:09

@Abigail12345654321

"I have said they should use some common sense in choosing where to apply because small startups cannot sustain much additional financial burden in the early years"

Why should it be a prospective employees responsibility to determine whether their presence within the company will render it unviable? Also at what point does it stop being a 'small' business?

"I would like small companies to be exempt from many anti discrimination requirements for a limited time - although it’s difficult to know how to implemented that without companies manipulating the system to their advantage and thus discriminating for longer than should be permitted."

So in effect yes you would be ok then with pregnant women being discriminated against in the workforce. Where would you draw the line? Such exemption would be a welcome green light for unscrupulous employers, as you fortunately acknowledge. Do you think that these start up businesses should be obliged to divulge that they're free to discriminate? I certainly know that I would not want to use any business that wanted a special exemption from equality legislation.