Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Employers hate private schools?

206 replies

5329871e · 04/01/2022 16:06

In the fortunate position of choosing between one of the best private schools in the country, vs one of the best non-selective state schools in the country. Private school is affordable with sacrifices, which we’re happy to make, and it has all the expected advantages of better funding and selective intake, but the state school is also lovely.

To avoid this thread being bogged down by all the nuances of our choice, I’ll keep the question simple:

DH is convinced that employers dislike privately educated applicants. All things being equal, they’ll pick the state educated person. In other words, job applicants are disadvantaged by a private education.

Is this true? If so, how much better does a privately educated applicant have to be, for you to pick them?

OP posts:
5329871e · 04/01/2022 17:07

@skeumorph - or maybe people’s lives are more complicated than you imagine?

@girasol - my DH showed me something from the FT that says the same thing. I guess this is my main concern.

@AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair - I completely agree. On the other hand, it’s so hard knowing what my kids will be like in future - whether they’re the sort to do well regardless or whether they need the extra support!

OP posts:
Franklin12 · 04/01/2022 17:06

Complete rubbish. Has your husband got a chip on his shoulder about private education? Why on earth does he think this. A word of caution though, if he is like this and you go down the private route he will very likely moan and moan about it for years!

Also there is private and private. Are you talking about the likes of Eton, Harrow, Charterhouse etc?

Wanlight22 · 04/01/2022 17:06

Grinyou're funny,OP.

MapleMay11 · 04/01/2022 17:05

@girlmom21

Honestly though OP - I'd suggest your DH doesn't want him privately educated and is trying to make excuses.
Yep. Saving himself a few quid.
Skeumorph · 04/01/2022 17:04

@astoundedgoat

lol your husband is HUGELY wrong.

However, when it comes to Oxbridge applications - and an Oxbridge primary degree WILL help your child significantly in many if not most careers - all other things being equal (i.e. grades, quality of applicant etc.), A-levels from a state school WILL help.

If your child is in any way lacking in confidence, I would absolutely prioritise that over anything else at this stage and choose the private school, because that is where they excel above all else, but then perhaps consider a state school for sixth form.

If your child is a confident, outgoing and academically able child, you might be better off taking advantage of your excellent local state school - just be prepared to throw some money at tutoring nearer the time for exams to compensate for the class sizes/individual attention deficit.

No, the 'private until sixth form when you enroll them in the local comp sixth form or a-level college' doesn't work for a moment when it comes to universities contextualising applications!

Grin they know the score I'm afraid.

However for OP's completely fake dilemma, it matters not a jot anyway as there will be no contextual lower offer for someone from one of the top state schools, either!

JessieLongleg · 04/01/2022 17:03

Most of my husband's work top management and wages are men, white and top educated same in last work. Didn't see their schools (worked there for a bit) buy all the top universities which are possible from state schools but all educated beyond student loans. And know people that have been privately education and no going into the same legal profession and much easier for the one from private as need references and has been associated with the right kind of people their who life. You might find employers over looking well educated as believe they will move on. But one of my old bosses was privately educated and really she should of done more with education but has be a vet loyal worker as company give good benefits beyond pay.

logsonlogsoff · 04/01/2022 16:59

Get. a. fecking. grip.
Take a look a round you, at your government, politics, the art world, finance, law, the medical profession, journalists, publishing... I'm mean I could go on but if you're really that unaware of the advantages and privileges that private education affords then perhaps there's no point.

TeeBee · 04/01/2022 16:59

I recruit lots of people in a professional setting...I don't even pay any attention to what school mummy and daddy could or couldn't afford; its no measure of what that person is like as an individual. I'm looking at grades to see they meet the minimum requirements but I'm mainly looking for passion, interest, gumption, character, personality, skills, work ethic, unique perspectives, etc. So, in my experience...and in my particular job market...it neither helps nor hinders.

ChateauMargaux · 04/01/2022 16:57

@girasol ... the statistics do not support this viewpoint.

MrsHGWells · 04/01/2022 16:56

Exactly which two secondary schools are we debating?

If your child is clever enough to attend a top Grammar school then go, if you have pockets full of cash burning a hole in your riding a jacket and cashmere sweater go independent..

Your child will encounter more social bias if your child is male vs female. Most corporates are seeking out diversity to level the playing field
from those truly disadvantaged or overlooked for years.

Only choose a Grammar schools if your child can meet the expected grades and you are happy meeting other regular folks at the front gate or socialise with .. or let another child take that place who cannot afford “the best secondary school in the world”.

Alternatively, Choose independent if your educational philosophy/ wallet/ and desire to tell everyone your DD/DS attends the best school money can buy.

I suspect your debate is more about the aesthetics of the school vs the actual education and long term job prospects at recruitment.

ChateauMargaux · 04/01/2022 16:56

Despite all the anecdotes about private school applicants being disadvantaged on application to Oxford.. the privileged 6% take up 40% of the places.. so your odds of being accepted are greater if you attend private school! cherwell.org/2020/06/29/inaccessible-why-oxfords-latest-state-school-statistics-shouldnt-be-celebrated/

PonyPatter44 · 04/01/2022 16:55

Did he goto the University of Life as well?

girasol · 04/01/2022 16:54

On a related note it does now seem that privately educated pupils are at a real disadvantage when it comes to getting a place at a top university - the Times had some interesting coverage and stats on this a few months ago. We’re likely to send our kids to a state secondary and for me that’s the main reason I want to do so.

So I think that indirectly a private education may impact negatively on ability to get graduate jobs.

In addition, the big city firm I work for is bending over backwards with access schemes and the like and is keen to recruit people from more diverse backgrounds.

(I should say I do appreciate not everyone does go/ wants their kids to go to university!).

Skeumorph · 04/01/2022 16:53

It honestly seems like you’re making an issue of absolutely nothing and that’s why it seems goady.

But of course it is - it's already been pretty much established that OP's lying about her circumstances to create a thread topic? Advanced search has shown that she's either lying about not being able to afford PS or was lying before

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 04/01/2022 16:53

@BellesBells

I look at schools in recruitment choices and would take a state school applicant with good qualifications and experience over a private school applicant with the same. All else being equal I'd say a private school applicant would need a set of grades one grade up on the state applicant at GCSE and A level or equivalent for me to consider them as equal candidates. Also take into account that work experience is generally easier to come by with privately educated applicants due to parents networks.
I would do the same, the private school candidate is likely to have been spoon fed throughout their school life, small class sies, extra support etc. If they can't do better than the state school pupil then they are probably not as good

This is a generalistion, don't think that you knowing one person for whom it was different doesn't mean the generalisation isn't true.

5329871e · 04/01/2022 16:52

@astoundedgoat - thanks, that sounds like really good advice!

@daimbarsatemydogsbone - sorry, I didn’t mean to insert a poll. Just ignore it.

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 04/01/2022 16:51

Okay, well if both schools are different weigh which one will fit your child and family situations (and finances) the best. Will your child do best in a state school with more financial options eg tutoring and clubs? Or in a private, more selective school?

Consider your specific child rather than wondering if they will possibly be discriminated against in employment as an adult due to their primary/high school experiences. Which is unlikely.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/01/2022 16:49

@5329871e

I knew this thread would attract some sarcasm, but I’m really grateful for the serious replies, so thank you for those.

Out of the serious replies, there’s some disagreement, so I guess a private school education can be a disadvantage in some situations but not others.

I myself had a very positive experience at private school (bursary), so I need to decide whether the positives outweigh the possible disadvantages for my own kids. It’s a hard decision to make.

What do the voting options mean?
mushroom3 · 04/01/2022 16:47

In terms of GCSE and A level grades, private school pupils are at a huge advantage, small class sizes, extra facilities etc. Universities have realised this and hence many of them have schemes involving lower entry grades and extra support to enable students from less advantaged backgrounds to access higher ranked universities. This means if a pupil has the same grades from a bog standard comp versus a private school, it should be now a bit easier for the bog standard school pupil to access a top university.

astoundedgoat · 04/01/2022 16:46

lol your husband is HUGELY wrong.

However, when it comes to Oxbridge applications - and an Oxbridge primary degree WILL help your child significantly in many if not most careers - all other things being equal (i.e. grades, quality of applicant etc.), A-levels from a state school WILL help.

If your child is in any way lacking in confidence, I would absolutely prioritise that over anything else at this stage and choose the private school, because that is where they excel above all else, but then perhaps consider a state school for sixth form.

If your child is a confident, outgoing and academically able child, you might be better off taking advantage of your excellent local state school - just be prepared to throw some money at tutoring nearer the time for exams to compensate for the class sizes/individual attention deficit.

5329871e · 04/01/2022 16:45

@Kanaloa

Well then if you’re so very worried about your child suffering discrimination from their private school education, and have the choice of two entirely equal schools, choose the state school and use the money saved to pump into extra curricular stuff/tutoring to further enhance their education.

It honestly seems like you’re making an issue of absolutely nothing and that’s why it seems goady.

Two schools that are apparently the exact same. One private, one state. You are worried about discrimination from the private school in the future. Pick the non private one.

They’re not exactly the same though, I never said that. They’re both excellent in their own sphere. Obviously the non-selective state school has inferior exam results, leavers’ destinations and facilities if you make a direct comparison between the two.
OP posts:
M4857493 · 04/01/2022 16:44

Yes you'll notice it mostly in government, no one ever votes for someone privately educated.

5329871e · 04/01/2022 16:43

@5128gap

It depends entirely on the industry and the views of the selection panel. There's no doubt that some people attach negative stereotypes to privately educated people, and value the achievements of people who have not been so advantaged more highly. But there's plenty of occupations where this isn't the case. It's probably not the best way to approach the decision though given you've no idea what your child will want to do in the future. Better to see it as paying for an experience rather than an outcome and weigh the two against each other on this basis.
This is a good way to think about it, i.e. the journey of childhood rather than the end result. Nobody can predict the future.
OP posts:
Kanaloa · 04/01/2022 16:42

Unless what you mean is you’re concerned your child won’t be placed at a significant advantage from attending private school. In which case it still comes down to choose which school is best for your child.

ChateauMargaux · 04/01/2022 16:42

Bollocks!!! Excuse the language!

www.itv.com/news/2019-06-25/britains-most-powerful-people-more-likely-to-have-attended-private-school

There are similar articles for other professions.

I would love to see data that supported his theory that on average, fee paying school attendees did less well overall than state school attendees, even when family income was taken into account.

Swipe left for the next trending thread