Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Employers hate private schools?

206 replies

5329871e · 04/01/2022 16:06

In the fortunate position of choosing between one of the best private schools in the country, vs one of the best non-selective state schools in the country. Private school is affordable with sacrifices, which we’re happy to make, and it has all the expected advantages of better funding and selective intake, but the state school is also lovely.

To avoid this thread being bogged down by all the nuances of our choice, I’ll keep the question simple:

DH is convinced that employers dislike privately educated applicants. All things being equal, they’ll pick the state educated person. In other words, job applicants are disadvantaged by a private education.

Is this true? If so, how much better does a privately educated applicant have to be, for you to pick them?

OP posts:
AutumnAlmanack · 04/01/2022 19:34

I went for an interview for my first job, which I got. I learned afterwards that the Director who had interviewed me said I was to be employed whatever they thought of me, because I had been to public school. Sometimes, it works!

BlingLoving · 04/01/2022 19:31

Here it is - I can't believe I tracked it down! here

BellesBells · 04/01/2022 19:26

@notanothertakeaway
It's not done in a particularly scientific way so just generally would look at state vs private rather than how good the state school is, although I suppose I would group selective with private. But it's also about trying to get a balanced and diverse staff so we try to make sure the team is a good mix of backgrounds, including gender, race and personality types (as much as you can get a feel for that at interview). Worth saying this is just at graduate level -with senior staff the experience is much more of a factor. In case it's relevant it's a multinational professional services firm with offices in all uk cities.

Lucyccfc68 · 04/01/2022 19:25

I am responsible for early years and graduate recruitment and have seen lots of organisations looking at their social mobility agenda over the last few years.

Attending a private school, for the majority, would mean coming from a family with money, resources and a great network. All organisations are trying to do is to give kids who don’t come from a privileged background a level playing field.

Some examples - Grant Thornton’s are offering a priority place on their summer work experience programme to those students who: have been on free school meals or attended a school with a high number of pupils on free school meals, neither parent have been to university and they live in certain postcodes. Just as an example, if they have 50 places for work experience, then 35 would come from that group.

Manchester Uni have a programme for the same student demographic and offer a 3 day summer school, a mentor, assistance with doing a personal statement and a £1000 bursary if they then go on to take up a place at the Uni.

A lot of the law firms and professional services companies are doing similar.

This doesn’t disadvantage those who have been to a private school. As my Director found out recently. She was concerned that her child couldn’t get onto any of the work experience programmes that were being offered because she had been to private school, both parents have degrees and they live in a very affluent area. It really was irrelevant, as she just got in the phone and spoke to friends who were Directors and partners and used good old nepotism to get her child work experience.

The company I work for specifically chooses schools in areas of high deprivation and those with high numbers of pupils on free school meals to partner with. We don’t partner with any of the private, independent grammars in the area.

Being privately educated brings many, many advantages. For other students, most of us just want a level playing field.

halulat · 04/01/2022 19:24

DD is currently at Oxford. She is the only one of her friendship group who went to a ( inadequate rated )comp . Her friends at uni went to either private ( about half of them) or state selective.
DS attended another RG uni also noticed most of his peers attended either private or selective state schools.
So yes definite advantages to private or selective state. That said I was happy with my children's comp and the outcomes for them.

5329871e · 04/01/2022 19:15

@notanothertakeaway Agree with you 100% - private school kids do better at university applications and job applications, much of it is causation (private schools giving better education) but much of it is correlation (exams selecting intelligence, fees selecting the type of parents who support education at home).

Teasing this apart is difficult.

Our kids will always have the privilege of parental education and attention. What we’re trying to figure out is whether the private school adds enough value to outweigh the social prejudice that comes with it (as well as the cost!) Judging by this thread, probably not…

OP posts:
notanothertakeaway · 04/01/2022 19:05

[quote puffyisgood]People on this thread keep saying that going to a state school will help you get to Oxbridge but this is a total nonsense.

firstly, private school improves your grades, and, secondly, the newest available data shows that private schools still punch above their weight when it comes to Oxbridge places - they get a higher share of them than their share of the top grades would predict (and always have done).

www.ox.ac.uk/about/facts-and-figures/admissions-statistics/undergraduate-students/current/school-type[/quote]
@puffyisgood I take issue with "private school improves your grades"

Children of parents who can afford private school are more likely to have families who support their education, can afford a computer, can pay for a tutor if required, have a quiet place to study

Children at a state school, especially if in a deprived area, are more likely to have parents who didn't have a great experience at school, work in jobs which don't require a high level of education, can't afford a computer, children share bedroom with sibling etc

So, yes, overall, private schools generate better exam results, but that's because schools reflect their catchment / families ie it's correlation, not causation

notanothertakeaway · 04/01/2022 18:54

@BellesBells

I look at schools in recruitment choices and would take a state school applicant with good qualifications and experience over a private school applicant with the same. All else being equal I'd say a private school applicant would need a set of grades one grade up on the state applicant at GCSE and A level or equivalent for me to consider them as equal candidates. Also take into account that work experience is generally easier to come by with privately educated applicants due to parents networks.
@BellesBells Out of interest, do you treat all state schools the same, and all private schools the same? Genuine question, just interested, not having a go

I'm asking because my nephew attends a sought after state school which tends to deliver better exam results than the local private school. Unless you lived locally and showed an interest, you wouldn't know that, and I appreciate that's not always the case. I wonder, if he had the same grades as a child from the private school, would he be perceived as a better candidate?

WWDD · 04/01/2022 18:51

I hope this is true but unfortunately it's probably bollocks.

notanothertakeaway · 04/01/2022 18:50

@eagerlywaitingfor

The only employers who would be likely to have the slightest interest in the school you went to, or be influenced by it, are the sort of employer who would actively seek out the privately educated, imo.
Agree with this
socialistcab · 04/01/2022 18:33

It’s a hard decision to make.

Between two of the best schools in one of the richest countries in the world

Fuck me

AlexaIWillNeverSayDucking · 04/01/2022 18:13

Your DH is confusing the recognition of your privilege with disadvantage.

How likely is it that all other things are equal? If someone from a poor school has the same grades and application/interview skills as someone from a private school, they will have worked harder to get there and therefore be a better applicant.

You are paying for your kids to have an easier ride, you can't complain that this is then recognised.

gogohm · 04/01/2022 18:05

I don't think it normally makes a difference but if it's a really famous school you may find some people would potentially feel strongly against employing someone if they are anti private school. I have been asked for my secondary schools at every job I've applied for. (Comp)

headintheproverbial · 04/01/2022 18:05

Many graduate employers are now trying to be more inclusive from a social mobility point of view. That wouldn't typically mean that those educated at other schools are dismissed out of hand.

I'd also say that beyond the first job or two in your career most people wouldn't have their school on their cv...

Lowpotassium · 04/01/2022 18:01

I think some on here should stick to their troll hunting games rather than comment on children. I doubt they are employers anyway.

puffyisgood · 04/01/2022 18:00

People on this thread keep saying that going to a state school will help you get to Oxbridge but this is a total nonsense.

firstly, private school improves your grades, and, secondly, the newest available data shows that private schools still punch above their weight when it comes to Oxbridge places - they get a higher share of them than their share of the top grades would predict (and always have done).

www.ox.ac.uk/about/facts-and-figures/admissions-statistics/undergraduate-students/current/school-type

Bluntness100 · 04/01/2022 17:59

Out of the serious replies, there’s some disagreement, so I guess a private school education can be a disadvantage in some situations but not others.

As can state

This feels like you’re trying to build a case for something that simply doesn’t exist. Like sone weird Labour manifesto.

Lowpotassium · 04/01/2022 17:59

In my county there are a reasonable amount of children with an EHCP funded by the council in mainstream private schools, all publicly available data. The ignorant comments on here just show what these children are up against.

Totalwasteofpaper · 04/01/2022 17:58

@astoundedgoat

lol your husband is HUGELY wrong.

However, when it comes to Oxbridge applications - and an Oxbridge primary degree WILL help your child significantly in many if not most careers - all other things being equal (i.e. grades, quality of applicant etc.), A-levels from a state school WILL help.

If your child is in any way lacking in confidence, I would absolutely prioritise that over anything else at this stage and choose the private school, because that is where they excel above all else, but then perhaps consider a state school for sixth form.

If your child is a confident, outgoing and academically able child, you might be better off taking advantage of your excellent local state school - just be prepared to throw some money at tutoring nearer the time for exams to compensate for the class sizes/individual attention deficit.

I would agree with this.

My personal view is your CV gets you in the door and from that point onward the job is yours to lose.
I have been offered inteviews for every job bar 2 I have applied for since getting my first grad job (and I have 17 years experience in my industry)

My private education (top 10 school) and associated grades/degree have no doubt opened doors, and I firmly believe it "paints a picture" as to who I am before employers even meet me. I have been given interviews and considered for roles most people with my CV would be thought "too young" or "too inexperienced in sector" for and I def think my education helps skew that in my favour.

My husband and I work in VERY different sectors. His education (also top 10) and degree (oxbridge) have made his career possible.

His company is almost exclusively oxbridge and they actively (as of this month) recruit grads from oxbridge only pools. The odd exceptional candidate from bristol or durham might sneak in at a manager level...

It does make a difference and keeps certain career sectors open to you..

Lowpotassium · 04/01/2022 17:56

Fwiw, every private schooler I’ve ever worked with has had no common sense

What a pathetic comment.

We recruit completely blind, as do most decent companies these days.

Clymene · 04/01/2022 17:53

@ChateauMargaux - it was a typo! I meant aren't which I hope would have been obvious from the rest of my post (and the rest of the sentence for that matter).

jeepersdeepers · 04/01/2022 17:50

However, when it comes to Oxbridge applications - and an Oxbridge primary degree WILL help your child significantly in many if not most careers - all other things being equal (i.e. grades, quality of applicant etc.), A-levels from a state school WILL help.

agree

SultanOfSwing · 04/01/2022 17:49

All things are hardly ever equal.

I am fairly intimately acquainted with Oxbridge admissions, for example, and they are desperate for all things to be equal. A kid from a state school with the same or similar set of results to a kid from a private school, will definitely have an advantage - they really do want to get the balance better. If your child is a mediocre private school applicant, a good state school applicant will have an advantage over him at all top universities.

The problem is that kids from private school, besides often presenting with better grades, also often come out better at interview. They are more practised, no doubt, but also they have had perhaps 5 years of an education system that pushes them towards confidence and participation. Also, as someone up thread has said, they likely have had more interesting work experience due to networking.

When it comes to jobs, and later in life, Oxbridge matters less, but Russell Group overall still matters a lot. So if you think it will help getting your child into a good uni private school is very helpful. But if the kid is going to be a top performer in a state school that could be more helpful for university.

But there is another reason for private school and that is often because the kids really have a lovely time. If you can balance at home the potential tendency towards arrogance and privilege, then your child may have a wonderful, enriching experience with a fantastic education. (Whatever the end result re jobs or university, on the whole the educational opportunities at private school are unmatched, especially at the top ones. That seems to me the very best reason for choosing that route.)

ChateauMargaux · 04/01/2022 17:46

@PelvicFloorTrauma Oxford students may be less likely than they were before to be privately educated but if you are privately educated you are overwhelmingly more likely to be offered a place!! 6% of the population gets 40% of the places.

@Clymene... I have to say.. that makes me laugh... ‘We cannot pretend that privately educated white men are given every advantage in life.’ They may not get every job and advantage out there.. but we are still far far far from having a society where money power and share of voice is equally shared.. look at my metric.. it is still overwhelmingly in the hands of privately educated white men in the UK.

and @5329871e.. if you want a perspective on how quickly things change round here.. read who own’s England by Guy Shrubsole... land is still largely in the hands of those closest to the king when the Magna Carta was written! In twelve years, you kids are safe!!

jeepersdeepers · 04/01/2022 17:46

Nobody puts ‘Elm Park primary school’ on their CV.

My job wanted secondary school details

Swipe left for the next trending thread