Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Employers hate private schools?

206 replies

5329871e · 04/01/2022 16:06

In the fortunate position of choosing between one of the best private schools in the country, vs one of the best non-selective state schools in the country. Private school is affordable with sacrifices, which we’re happy to make, and it has all the expected advantages of better funding and selective intake, but the state school is also lovely.

To avoid this thread being bogged down by all the nuances of our choice, I’ll keep the question simple:

DH is convinced that employers dislike privately educated applicants. All things being equal, they’ll pick the state educated person. In other words, job applicants are disadvantaged by a private education.

Is this true? If so, how much better does a privately educated applicant have to be, for you to pick them?

OP posts:
crazycrochetlady · 04/01/2022 22:20

@Darbs76

Not sure about employers but harder to get into top uni’s if from a private school
Evidence?
Darbs76 · 04/01/2022 22:18

Not sure about employers but harder to get into top uni’s if from a private school

Momicrone · 04/01/2022 22:16

I guess oxford or cambridge on one's cv implies private

socialistcab · 04/01/2022 22:11

@jeepersdeepers - same here. My kids will work damn hard whether they’re in state or private. Hence questioning which choice to make.

I actually feel quite sorry for them. All the pressure you're going to put on them, life is so much more than this

Whatabambam · 04/01/2022 21:53

I really hope that you actually just enjoy having your children and allow them to be their own person, regardless of how they 'perform' as adults. You are overly preoccupied with achievements and outcomes and goals. Jesus. Let them be. You will be in danger of alienating them in years to come if they somehow fail you. You don't own them. You nurture them to be the happiest and best human beings that they can be. Not mini me.

onedayoranother · 04/01/2022 21:38

I love how people think private school kids are 'hand held and spoon fed'. One child didn't do much work and did crap at exams, my other one works extremely hard. If you don't put in the work it doesn't matter where you went to school, and you have to work hard to get top grades no matter where - I don't think my daughter is working any less hard than her state school equivalent. And unless you are talking about an 'inadequate' school, it's not true to assume all state schools offer a poor education, which seems to be the assumption here, and there are plenty of private schools who aren't that great either.
If your choice is between two of the best schools in the country, I don't know why you wouldn't choose the state school. I went private only because all the state schools in the area were not good, and during the last two years this was made even more evident.

LondonQueen · 04/01/2022 21:20

Who puts their school on their CV? How would they know unless you specifically stated. If so I wouldn't hire them either as it makes them seem like a pretentious twat.

girlmom21 · 04/01/2022 21:17

OP how many kids do you have? Are you absolutely certain you won't have any more? I only ask because if you need to make sacrifices now I'd guess you wouldn't be able to manage private school fees for an extra child potentially.

Undertheoldlindentree · 04/01/2022 21:16

"The screening does make use of contextualised academic data, so it evaluates academic results in the context of the educational institutions at which the results were gained (eg BBB at a state school in a deprived area would be considered a better achievement than BBB in a private school or selective grammar)"

Really wish all employers had to apply this by law.

NotMeekNotObedient · 04/01/2022 21:15

My employer loves privately educated applicants. State definitely in the minority and most of those are in 'business services'. But its one of those sectors.

Which school would your child be happier at?

TakeMe2Insanity · 04/01/2022 21:00

It’s impossible to tell what employers will want next year let alone in 15/20 years! Do what’s right for your child now. Oh and my school isn’t on my cv.

expat101 · 04/01/2022 20:58

We sent ours to a mixture of both depending on our location at the time and their age. I don't believe it has set them back at all career-wise.

If there has been anything noticeable, having left the schooling system, they have retained friendships with their private school friends rather than the public ones, not by choice, just how its worked out and I guess the personalities involved.

crazycrochetlady · 04/01/2022 20:40

But @5329871e the point is your OH would have it that people like my family have been given a leg up. That's the corollary of private school pupils being disadvantaged. And that simply isn't true.

5329871e · 04/01/2022 20:35

@crazycrochetlady

Oh, OP I could contribute far more! We are a comp- educated family: me, DH and two DC in their twenties. Two of us are Oxbridge educated, the other two still high achieving. There's a PhD, a couple of masters and some excellent jobs thrown in too. And I guarantee we didn't get any of those things as back hangers because we didn't go to private school. We just worked hard and were quite bright.
I wasn’t challenging your CV, but thanks for posting it anyway. It was the aggressive tone of your post and the fact that you called my DH “daft” when all he did was show me an article he read. We don’t have strong opinions pro state / private, hence the reason for the thread.
OP posts:
crazycrochetlady · 04/01/2022 20:31

Oh, OP I could contribute far more! We are a comp- educated family: me, DH and two DC in their twenties. Two of us are Oxbridge educated, the other two still high achieving. There's a PhD, a couple of masters and some excellent jobs thrown in too. And I guarantee we didn't get any of those things as back hangers because we didn't go to private school. We just worked hard and were quite bright.

5329871e · 04/01/2022 20:25

Sorry that bold fail was supposed to read A star A star A star

OP posts:
5329871e · 04/01/2022 20:23

@BlingLoving - thanks, it’s a fascinating read!

@CertainUncertain - we’ll definitely be considering the whole package, but I didn’t want to weigh down the thread with a list of personal pros and cons. Quite simply though, if the benefit of attending private school is going to be cancelled out at the university/job application stage, then we’re not going to want to pay ££££ for it.

@olivehater - that’s what I think too. If private school upgrades BBB to AAA, then universities view it as BBB anyway, then there’s less of an incentive to pay ££££. A more extreme example: if my kid is “destined” to get AAA* at state school, they can’t get any higher in private, they’d be literally disadvantaged by attending private as universities would see them as AAA only.

@notanothertakeaway - oh I see. Well, I think it’s a mix of causation and correlation, but I don’t know what the proportions are of that mix. So you’re saying that causation may be 0% and correlation 100%, and I agree that that may be the case (and is what we’re trying to work out). If indeed causation is 0% and correlation is 100%, then attending private school would be a disadvantage because you’re paying ££££ for no added value. Right?

@jeepersdeepers - same here. My kids will work damn hard whether they’re in state or private. Hence questioning which choice to make.

@crazycrochetlady - what a contribution to the debate! Haha. Obviously I’m making choices about sacrifices Hmm

OP posts:
ChateauMargaux · 04/01/2022 20:22

@tempester28... as repeated many times, just because the proportion of private school students at Oxbridge has decreased.. does not mean that they are disadvantaged!!! 6% of the total student population takes 40% of the places... attending private school gives you a greater chance of getting a place at Oxbridge.

I wish people would stop saying this... great that there are moves a foot to change this but state educated pupils do not have an advantage when it comes to getting into Oxbridge... admissions may consider state applications with lower grades than privately educated ones... that is not the same thing!!

Mum090521 · 04/01/2022 20:19

I think it can work both ways. I think there are jobs I've got because of my fee paying school and jobs I haven't got because of it. I've opted for a good state secondary for mine as if they're anything like us, they'll probably opt for a public sector job rather than an elite City role. Where will they fit in was driving my choice.

tempester28 · 04/01/2022 20:12

I would say it is not an issue - possibly for oxbridge entry you may find having gone to state school is now an advantage?

crazycrochetlady · 04/01/2022 19:57

@5329871e

In the fortunate position of choosing between one of the best private schools in the country, vs one of the best non-selective state schools in the country. Private school is affordable with sacrifices, which we’re happy to make, and it has all the expected advantages of better funding and selective intake, but the state school is also lovely.

To avoid this thread being bogged down by all the nuances of our choice, I’ll keep the question simple:

DH is convinced that employers dislike privately educated applicants. All things being equal, they’ll pick the state educated person. In other words, job applicants are disadvantaged by a private education.

Is this true? If so, how much better does a privately educated applicant have to be, for you to pick them?

OP your husband is daft And you won't be making sacrifices. You'll be making CHOICES. Get a grip
jeepersdeepers · 04/01/2022 19:52

You know what? If my kids miss out on an opportunity to someone from a less privileged background, that's life. They'll be just fine. As will yours.

Exactly

notanothertakeaway · 04/01/2022 19:51

[quote 5329871e]@notanothertakeaway Agree with you 100% - private school kids do better at university applications and job applications, much of it is causation (private schools giving better education) but much of it is correlation (exams selecting intelligence, fees selecting the type of parents who support education at home).

Teasing this apart is difficult.

Our kids will always have the privilege of parental education and attention. What we’re trying to figure out is whether the private school adds enough value to outweigh the social prejudice that comes with it (as well as the cost!) Judging by this thread, probably not…[/quote]
@5329871e Just to clarify, I don't agree with you that "private schools giving better education". I didnt say that, and that's not my opinion

I agree that private schools generally have better exam results, but it's due to various other factors ie correlation, not causation

Zilla1 · 04/01/2022 19:49

Trying to be helpful, OP. Education has contested means and ends but putting the whimsy aside that seems to have offended a PP, it might be better to remember the value of education in realising your DC's potential and development beyond any possibly notional cost of private education to UK job applications (which would have little impact if they seek employment or apply to overseas universities). Some of my acquaintances who were convinced there was unfair discrimination by Oxbridge Colleges encouraged their DC to apply to Ivy League counterparts. That said, I've some affluent American acquaintances who have begun to complain that their Alma Maters should discriminate against Asian applicants who tend to have relatively better academics than the DC of traditional WASPy alumni. Funny old world.

olivehater · 04/01/2022 19:45

They won’t be equal though your child will likely get better grades going to private school. Therefore a state school educated child with A is a bigger achievement than privately educated. So in theory that have and equal chance at the same job whichever school they go to. They can get Bs from the state school or As from the private. Put v simply obviously. That seems fair to me. So no if I had to make sacrifices for private school I wouldn’t bother.

Swipe left for the next trending thread