Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Employers hate private schools?

206 replies

5329871e · 04/01/2022 16:06

In the fortunate position of choosing between one of the best private schools in the country, vs one of the best non-selective state schools in the country. Private school is affordable with sacrifices, which we’re happy to make, and it has all the expected advantages of better funding and selective intake, but the state school is also lovely.

To avoid this thread being bogged down by all the nuances of our choice, I’ll keep the question simple:

DH is convinced that employers dislike privately educated applicants. All things being equal, they’ll pick the state educated person. In other words, job applicants are disadvantaged by a private education.

Is this true? If so, how much better does a privately educated applicant have to be, for you to pick them?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hivemindneeded · 05/01/2022 09:56

Any employer who hates private school candidates is a tosser - no one chooses what school they attend. That's like employing people on the basis of what their parents decided when the candidate turned 11.

Some employers might find the veneer of confidence and pushiness (that some private schools foster) a bit abrasive but others will find it useful and dynamic in the work place.

I sent DC to a private school because that particular school helped them use their brains and think in a way no other schools I looked at would have done. They have both been told at uni how well they think and tackle a problem intellectually. I hope that skill will be valuable in the workplace. And DS2 in particular is the absolute antithesis of the braying toff with his rugby thighs crammed into a hand made suit. Grin

JuergenSchwarzwald · 05/01/2022 09:27

People always say that kids who go to private schools have more confidence, but is that down to the schools or down to the fact that their parents have money and it's easier to be confident about your place in the world when you've never had to struggle for money?

JuergenSchwarzwald · 05/01/2022 09:26

@Mum090521

It's not Peter Symonds is it? It's huge so statistically sends large numbers to uni.
Yes a lot of the sixth form colleges in Hampshire do very well because they specialise in sixth form studies and obviously take in a lot of very bright 16 year olds.

My son swam with a friend who went to our local state sixth form college and secondary school and ended up at Warwick studying Maths. One of the boys whose parents were in my NCT baby group and were loaded and sent him to very expensive private schools has also ended up studying Maths at Warwick.

He might do better in life, but probably only because the pressure is off a bit when you know your parents can bail you out if necessary.

Andante57 · 05/01/2022 09:20

KBut in my last job I interviewed an Oxford grad who also was on Uni Challenge. He was so smart and I passed his interview with flying colours. He failed miserably on the exam in the next stage. It’s just so subjective*.

Very true that intelligence comes in different forms.
Dh’s nephew is a maths lecturer but he tried to catch our whippet by running after her…..

ToykotoLosAngeles · 05/01/2022 08:24

I've got 2 jobs off the back of my university (Durham). Nobody had noticed or cared that I went to a local comp for high school or that I went to the top state sixth form in England because it happened to be 3 miles from my house.

PhilCornwall1 · 05/01/2022 08:17

DH is convinced that employers dislike privately educated applicants. All things being equal, they’ll pick the state educated person.

When reading CVs, I pay no attention to the schools/Universities applicants went to. To be honest, I pay very little attention to a degree. What's important for the roles I recruit for, is evidence that they can come through the door and do what's required.

HoliHormonalTigerlilly · 05/01/2022 08:16
Biscuit
Annaghgloor · 05/01/2022 08:13

Private schools to me are about the parents’ decisions, not the candidate’s. The fact that this decision is unethical in my opinion has no bearing on whether I would hire you.

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 05/01/2022 08:07

I doubt my employer even knows I went to a private school. Honestly though if you have a good state school locally I wouldn't bother with private. I went to one and although I loved my time at school, I wouldn't say I have done any better than my non privately educated friends.

Save the money to help them get on the housing ladder, will be much more beneficial long term.

crazycrochetlady · 05/01/2022 08:03

@5329871e The implication remains. I don't particularly care because me and mine are out the other end.
It's a common misconception though, parroted to the private parents I know, who tell me their schools tell their children that they are disadvantaged when it comes to places at top universities. I think it's a case of news management myself - preparing those who don't get in by implying its the fault of the system. My friends are lovely, but I do have to correct them!
Just choose the school you think will be right and try not to second guess on the basis of myth and speculation, and good luck to your DC in securing those great future jobs.

Captainj1 · 05/01/2022 07:58

@SmaugMum sorry the above post was a reply for you

5329871e · 05/01/2022 07:55

@crazycrochetlady

Your DH is being quite insulting to the talented state educated people working in great jobs. His implication is that they got a leg up by dint of private applicants being disadvantaged. An implication which is so very wrong. That's why I called him daft. A fairly soft insult in comparison I think.
That’s over sensitive.

He’s a talented state educated person, in fact, who performed over the odds.

As I keep explaining, we’re not pro private sector, and we’re not moaning about anything. We’re right at the start of the decision process and want to know what the best choice is for our kids.

OP posts:
Captainj1 · 05/01/2022 07:54

She would be seen as more privileged than a comp educated child and less privileged than a privately educated child, based on academics alone (simplifying - it takes actual data from schools and is essentially looking for outperformance). The other factors you describe would also be taken account of in the screening using non-academic data (disability, neurodiversity etc) where available or a more subjective lens where not. In interview, we actually ask questions about character and motivations, more than experience - again, because those in more privileged positions can have had access to work experience that is directly relevant, whereas what we actually care about is their genuine interest in/knowledge of the work and what it entails, and what will motivate them (their development, working as part of a team etc v pursuing financial reward and promotion).

5329871e · 05/01/2022 07:50

The outstanding state school isn’t a super selective grammar, it’s a very “normal” state school that had a good reputation locally and some people move into the catchment for that purpose.

The private school isn’t a household name, but it’s top 20 in the UK. I hadn’t heard of it until I started researching schools.

Thanks again for the replies in the meantime - once again a big mix of opinions and experiences!

OP posts:
lioncitygirl · 05/01/2022 07:39

Not to my knowledge. We don’t care who we hire - as long as they’re educated enough to do the job. Do you genuinely believe that Op?

Lolamento · 05/01/2022 07:35

I do not think they discriminate based on this. However, the social resentment for privately educated children in this country is real.

ChateauMargaux · 05/01/2022 07:32

@PelvicFloorTrauma... the 6% in 20% statistic that you mention needs a closer look... between the ages of sixteen and eighteen the total number of students in private school does not change significantly, this 20% number comes from a reducing denominator which excludes state educated students who transfer to vocational courses.

It is disingenuous to imply that that the 20% number that should be used.

crazycrochetlady · 05/01/2022 07:09

Your DH is being quite insulting to the talented state educated people working in great jobs. His implication is that they got a leg up by dint of private applicants being disadvantaged. An implication which is so very wrong. That's why I called him daft. A fairly soft insult in comparison I think.

PGSTesting123 · 05/01/2022 00:59

Also, grammars are considered better than most privates.

But it's the uni that really matters, I guess.

PGSTesting123 · 05/01/2022 00:58

However, top employers still prefer public over private regardless of the origins.

So it doesn't serve this conversation to lump them together.

I'm my working class city there were 2 private schools, one was considered good the other a joke.
Nearby by Rugby the public school was out of reach for the ones sending their kids to the private fee paying.
They aren't the same.

I went to a state, a rubbish one so I'm not biased.

PGSTesting123 · 05/01/2022 00:37

16:27feyzer

The thing is the really good employers, the ones where you get a golden handshake wait for you after graduation and knab you before your job search has begun.
Then it's the normal graduate jobs that everyone applies for.
Depends on OP's ambitions for her kids or their own dreams..

PGSTesting123 · 05/01/2022 00:32

Eton etc are public schools not private.
They are considered crème de la crème.

PGSTesting123 · 05/01/2022 00:27

16:15Rrrob
Are the disadvantaged applicants good though?

PGSTesting123 · 05/01/2022 00:25

Another case of save your money.

I know someone that earns very little and her and her husband sent their kids to private school.
Kids are average, waste of money.
The parents now realise and wished they saved their money.

PGSTesting123 · 05/01/2022 00:20

They prefer public schools first
Then private dependent upon results - not just any old private
I think grammars equal private
State - dependent upon reputation

However, if your child is bright and you pay for private tuition then your kid will do well even if he goes to a crap school.
Tutor him yourself.

To give you an example 30 minority kids out of a year of 300 where only one parent could speak English are now all in good professions, accountant, architect, doctor, banker, engineer.

We went to a crap comp full of racists majority kids from broken families with no interest in education and racist teachers that did not want to help the minority kids.
The kids did well because their parents tend to be good at mathematics and private tutors for the rest.

I want to school in the 90's maybe things have changed now.

However, my sibling is much younger and went to Oxbridge. Same crap comp as me but had a private tutor plus parental help.
School took the credit of course when it came to the local paper Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread