Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teenager debit card or Go Henry card ?

138 replies

BeaLola · 04/01/2022 11:57

Yes I am in posting here but really need traffic and experience from others please

DS is 14 We pay for all his clubs/activities and phone contract , clothes etc and are happy to do so.

He gets £10 pocket money each week - invariably over last year he doesn't get hard cash and it mounts up to go towards paying off his debt for his very expensive pc - we paid just over hslf and the rest he saved up birthday and op jet money for.

So to allow him more independence , help teach him a bit more re value of money, let him make his own mistakes etc we are thinking of him having a debit card that we put the £40 a month on & could add odd gift money to etc

I hear a lot about Go Henry , not so much about Santander 123 - any thoughts please ? Thank you v much

OP posts:
newname12345 · 04/01/2022 18:23

@downtonupton Rooster card is now £25/year if you want the card. Seems expensive when a proper bank account with a debit card is free.

downtonupton · 04/01/2022 17:56

DS is Y10 and has been using a Rooster card for ages - we're happy with it - cheaper than Go Hentry (small annual fee £10) and we have had no issues with it at all.

Much easier for me when I get a panicky call that he has lost the card because I can manage it all with the parent app - stop the cards and re-start when he finds it. Other people can pay money to the card as they could any other bank account.

When he asks to have a proper bank account we will sort it out but DD had a regular back account from 11 and it was much more awkward as the apps weren't as good and we had little control or access to it. We had a lot of faff and hassle to get her a debit card when she was old enough rather than just a cashpoint one and the Rooster card has just been no hassle at all - can use it online, as contactless and with a pin.

The money management in the child and the parent app is great - we can set goals, he can save and put money in pots for different things and we can set chores etc his pocket money goes in once a month and I get a notification every time he uses it.

Comefromaway · 04/01/2022 17:31

And he’s studying music at college and goes on theatre trips several times per year. His friend he often goes with is entitied to access prices.

DiamondBright · 04/01/2022 17:09

@BeaLola

Huge thanks to you all for taking the time to comment & add info

I was wanting a d/card as it annoyed me that Go Henry was paid for etc but DH (older) was way more cautious than me about it all

Yes he may go wild but that said he will then learn the hard way if he blows it on sweets , etc - I said to DH - when he' at uni come 18 he can do all sorts without us knowing - hopefully though we have bought him up with correct values & boundaries that he will be okay ,

When DD gets larger amounts of money, like Christmas, I keep it in a savings account and transfer it to her as and when she needs it, so it's not just sitting in her account being frittered away on online games. Spending money goes straight into her account and she has to manage it.

I find this just mitigates the risk of her wasting money a bit, she doesn't have to run purchases past me, but it's still an extra step that hopefully makes her think about what she's buying.

DiamondBright · 04/01/2022 17:01

I just set DD up with a current account at the same bank I use, with a proper debit card and online banking app.

Apple Pay is ideal for teenagers who are glued to their phones but don't necessarily want to carry a purse or wallet.

elfycat · 04/01/2022 16:53

We're using GoHenry (one DC in Y6, the other in Y8) and it's working well for us. DD1 is 13 soon and I might talk to her about a proper bank account and start the transition.

Most of their spending is online and often I pay with PayPal and they transfer the money back to me on the app. They have a basic level of pocket money, and then tasks that pay more (or would if they ever did them). Their understanding of the fact there is real world money behind tapping a card on a contactless reader has really taken off. DD1 sweeps a lot of her money into the savings part of the app, though she has no goal at the moment.

Bayleaf25 · 04/01/2022 16:48

Proper bank accounts here for secondary age kids. No overdraft obviously but can use debit card for online purchases/transferring money to us or friends as needed. Basics getting them used to managing money.

One child has Santander 123 mini, the other has TSB (think they offered the best deals at the time and Santander was very easy to switch to student bank account with free railcard on going to uni).

CheesyWeez · 04/01/2022 16:46

I keep a tenner in my phone case for emergencies where I might need cash but I only have to use it once a month or so. Even our poppy seller from the British Legion had a card reader out in November. The busker in the market square also has a card reader.

Sorry VelvetChairGirl but the world is changing and I think COVID made it change faster as people ordered more stuff online and sent virtual money for birthdays. Our kids will cope, it is their world now.

My family has a small business and has started putting up a sign saying "WE TAKE CASH" because most businesses in their line of work don't now. It has actually attracted some customers. My family don't want cash especially as the bank charges them for taking it in but some customers still want that service.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 04/01/2022 16:45

so I really want to know what shops dont take cash as a policy.

Again, I'm not going to out my location as all the shops concerned are independents and easily found on Google.

I live in rural Cumbria if that helps.

VelvetChairGirl · 04/01/2022 16:37

@fairylightsandwaxmelts

parking is a niche thing, as is online payments.

I really wouldn't call parking or online payments niche, lol.

I dont know any shop that doesnt take cash, what shops?

I'm not going to out my location, but plenty of small independent shops don't take cash as it's a security risk (theft) and costs them time and money to bank it, especially with the closure of many high street banks and post offices.

I live in london, not been in a single shop that doesnt take cash, yes a few may have self service tills that dont but they also have manned tills in the same stores that do and TBH theres only two shops I can think of that have self service that are card only, co-op and M&S, so I really want to know what shops dont take cash as a policy.
Worldgonecrazy · 04/01/2022 16:36

DD has a Starling debit card. No overdraft facility and I can check what she is spending, and she has savings spaces within the account to budget for Christmas and holiday spending.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 04/01/2022 16:35

@2022willbebetter

Proper bank account to learn proper banking. Need debit card, online banking and app so when he goes to university or starts earning money he is used to living within budget and if possible moving money to /from low level savings account. My DC are with Nationwide and I think it's brilliant.
University is another good point.

He'll need to be able to manage a debit card and online banking so he can do things like pay his student loans, pay his rent, pay for things like gym membership or subs for various clubs etc.

Yes, you can pay in cash but you won't receive your student loan in a cash-stuffed envelope Grin

CheesyWeez · 04/01/2022 16:34

We don't take cash in the shop I work in. When people come to collect the things they have ordered they pay by card or we get them to do a bank transfer.

My teen has an HSBC teen debit card, the lady in the bank spent maybe an hour with him setting up his account and explaining things to him, I was impressed. When he turned 16 they automatically sent him a new 16+ card and when he is 18 I believe they will again renew the card (as a teen card does not let them buy adult things, such as alcohol) and if he goes to uni he can have it changed to a student card.
His savings get a small interest payment which he was very interested in.

After a month or so of the HSBC card he cancelled his Go Henry card as he realised it was costing him a monthly fee.

Comefromaway · 04/01/2022 16:31

The music shop that DS buys his accessories from

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 04/01/2022 16:29

parking is a niche thing, as is online payments.

I really wouldn't call parking or online payments niche, lol.

I dont know any shop that doesnt take cash, what shops?

I'm not going to out my location, but plenty of small independent shops don't take cash as it's a security risk (theft) and costs them time and money to bank it, especially with the closure of many high street banks and post offices.

VelvetChairGirl · 04/01/2022 16:24

[quote fairylightsandwaxmelts]what places only accept card payments?

Off the top of my head (in my area):

  • you can't use cash to pay for parking anymore.
  • plenty of local shops will only accept card.
  • lots of services require payment online or via card - window cleaners, or dog walkers, for example.
  • you can't buy anything online if you insist on only using cash.

People talk about it being legal tender, but actually, shops and businesses are under no obligation whatsoever to accept cash.

According to Bank of England, "Legal tender has a narrow technical meaning which has no use in everyday life. It means that if you offer to fully pay off a debt to someone in legal tender, they can’t sue you for failing to repay."

www.bankofengland.co.uk/knowledgebank/what-is-legal-tender[/quote]
parking is a niche thing, as is online payments.

I dont know any shop that doesnt take cash, what shops?

trulyconfuseddotcom · 04/01/2022 16:16

We've got ours a Santander account - the big plus was it is one of the few that gives them a contactless debit card at that age so can be used for public transport etc. it's very easy and works well for us.

2022willbebetter · 04/01/2022 16:09

Proper bank account to learn proper banking. Need debit card, online banking and app so when he goes to university or starts earning money he is used to living within budget and if possible moving money to /from low level savings account.
My DC are with Nationwide and I think it's brilliant.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 04/01/2022 16:08

what places only accept card payments?

Off the top of my head (in my area):

  • you can't use cash to pay for parking anymore.
  • plenty of local shops will only accept card.
  • lots of services require payment online or via card - window cleaners, or dog walkers, for example.
  • you can't buy anything online if you insist on only using cash.

People talk about it being legal tender, but actually, shops and businesses are under no obligation whatsoever to accept cash.

According to Bank of England, "Legal tender has a narrow technical meaning which has no use in everyday life. It means that if you offer to fully pay off a debt to someone in legal tender, they can’t sue you for failing to repay."

www.bankofengland.co.uk/knowledgebank/what-is-legal-tender

Sockpile · 04/01/2022 15:56

My three all had Nationwide current accounts with a debit card from age 11. My older two opened themselves savings accounts when they got part time jobs at 16. The nationwide app is useful but two of mine can see their child trust fund in the app.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/01/2022 15:47

@VelvetChairGirl

"What a load of shit. If anything, a card requires better maths - after all, with cash you have an easy visual check of funds - which isn't maths. Having a card as a teen is an introduction to how things will work. Very few young people do much in cash now."

"What bullshit. If you're greedy and going to impulse buy, you'll still do it with cash, it's just your cash will be gone a lot faster."

no because it brings home to you how much you have and when you get change how much you have left, the physicality means you think more about it before spending. and when secondary school did the maths test regarding money, how much change from a fiver if you buy x y z etc, most of my sons class messed up something they should have known in primary and none of the amounts exceeded £10 so that tells me something, hardly any of them understood money. most of the kids in that secondary school have a phone and a travel card kept topped up by mum and nothing else, lunch is a biometric account, no life skills.

When you have an app on your phone that tells you what you have left as soon as you spend something that is just as good an indication as having an assortment of coins and notes you need to count through.

The question of being able to work out the change from a fiver is mental arithmetic - it's a good skill to have but becoming less relevant.

DD can't spend more than she has so functionally it works the same as cash - just without the need to faff about with coins and notes.

She does have cash too for occasional use, so best of both worlds, but I am certainly not going to prevent her having the exact kind of account she'll be using for the rest of her life just to try and force her to learn mental arithmetic.

skyeisthelimit · 04/01/2022 15:43

DD is 13 and has a Santander 123 Mini account. I tried to open one with Lloyds which is where her savings are, but they insisted on me driving a 40 mile round trip with ID as her savings account wasn't good enough, so I went with Santander instead where I could open it online (and have my own account there too)

DD has the Santander app on her phone so that she can check her balance before she goes shopping and I transfer £10 a week into there. Although she is generally with me when she goes shopping as we live rurally I wanted her to get a sense of independence plus she needs to realise that you can only spend it once, something she is learning the hard way when she blows it all then sees something she really wants but can't have it.

Before she had that account we used Revolut, but she used my card as there was a limit on the junior one and a cost for the card.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 04/01/2022 15:40

14 yo has a Halifax debit card. Her just turned 11yo sister has an appointment next month for the same. You can't micromanage their spending in the way you can with GoHenry, but TBH I think giving them some slack and letting them make the odd mistake is ok at this age. They still can't spend what isn't there, so if you're worried you could stick savings somewhere separate and just have the monthly allowance in the debit card account.

VelvetChairGirl · 04/01/2022 15:40

@Comefromaway

Try going to see a show at any west end theatre Velvet.

None are taking cash.

Thats not an everyday thing is it, never been to one in my life I'm not rich and its not an essential, certainly isnt something a child would be spending their money on is it.
ct22 · 04/01/2022 15:39

Proper bank account everytime - our 11 year old got a Nationwide current account with full debit card etc in the summer. We make direct payments of his pockt money and are able to directly credit him with anything else we owe him which is far easier than faffing around with cash. He finds it very satisfying to check his balance and this morning we went to the branch to pay his christmas cheques in - all good life experience and we hope it gives him an appreciation of the banking system

Swipe left for the next trending thread