Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is this official stance creating a social divide?

34 replies

EerieSilence · 04/01/2022 11:48

This is the Government Social Mobility chief speaking. How can you support social mobility if you tell the parents that their children don't get enough education at school (paid for and supported by the very state she's employed by) and should do it themselves?
How are the working classes supposed to do that? From what?
Isn't this creating more of a social divide where the wealthy already can afford more education and support of extra-curricular interests for their children?
Are people in Britain really OK with this?

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-10367349/Parents-children-lessons-DAY-school-says-Superhead-Katharine-Birbalsingh.html

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hawkins001 · 05/01/2022 21:54

Ok * many years ago

Hawkins001 · 05/01/2022 21:54

A few years ago when it was the door to door book sales people, I was brought some religious books, and I liked the art work in them, and slowly I started to understand the words of the stories.

JennyForeigner · 04/01/2022 20:03

Last seen banging on about children being trained out of original sin.

She's so weird.

Onionpatch · 04/01/2022 20:01

She is right in that children need a parental input and parents cant rely in school to raise their child and lots of parents are doing this.
But where the advice falls short is not recognising that for some this is a problem around long hours in low paid work, fuel and food poverty and insecure housing so some parents arent in a position to do more.

Winnerwinnerveggiedinner · 04/01/2022 19:45

Sleeping, I think you’re looking at ends of a spectrum. People don’t have to pay for tuition, either. There are plenty of free or cheap resources out there to print off, play or watch to develop skills and knowledge for primary and secondary. Even if you don’t have access to the internet there are lots of activities in real life to help. Most parents can support the primary curriculum - it isn’t so advanced. Reading to and listening to a child read is fundamental in developing literacy.
As a former teacher, it was blatantly obvious which parents were supporting their child’s education and the divide wasn’t drawn simply on class.

SleepingStandingUp · 04/01/2022 19:21

The "you" who makes excuses why they won't read with their kids.
But no ien was saying they don't want to. The point is if you're working crazy hours you have less time to do that. If you're bringing home £200k you can pay someone else to do it. If you're on minimum wage, not so much.

CatsArePeople · 04/01/2022 16:28

Who's the "you" @CatsArePeople? Cos that's either incredibly personal and rude to the PP or you're generalising a whole "class" of people you don't know

The "you" who makes excuses why they won't read with their kids.

Why are people so offended at common sense?

The Social Mobility chief said that parents themselves need to put an effort in their kids' education if they want a success, because school alone is unable to do that.

AppleButterfly · 04/01/2022 15:14

I grew up in a very deprived area.
My mother was a single mother working part time at Asda. When I was falling behind, she got a tutor. I even saw children from school at the tutoring centre, who I know where also poor! Mad to think working class people have the ability to understand what it means when their child is ranking towards the bottom and figure out how to get a tutor. Families i know just tightened their belts temporarily.
My niece (not by blood) is middle class, she was very behind at her outstanding little school in a middle class area, so much so to the point the school were discussing SEN. A few months of tutoring and on track! I think that's interesting, are children without tutors / not supported educationally outside of school more likely to be diagnosed with learning difficulties?

CatJumperTwat · 04/01/2022 15:12

You know what also creates and sustains horrible divides in society? The Daily Mail.

SleepingStandingUp · 04/01/2022 15:10

@CatsArePeople

You can't if you're working every hour you can to keep a roof over your heads. But you still would find time for the things you like or find important, like your social media. You just don't like books and your kid doesn't either.

Most deprived areas don't have museums and cultural events at all, unless you can travel to the nearest city, which means spending money.
Ok, I get that. But those in cities have such opportunities, yet ignore them.

Who's the "you" @CatsArePeople? Cos that's either incredibly personal and rude to the PP or you're generalising a whole "class" of people you don't know
CharSiu · 04/01/2022 14:59

I’m a product of tiger parenting and it’s very much cultural, poor immigrant parents with too many dc.

They did school us at home to some extent. We were also dropped off at the library from a very young age. Plus we were expected to work. We taught our dc at home as well. We were perfectly ok sending DS to the local poor results comp as we knew we could make up the shortfall. We were luckier as not hard up like my parents. I also encouraged DS to get a job which he did, DH and I didn’t see eye to eye on that one but it worked out fine. I was working 20 hours a week when studying for my A levels, at least ds just had a paper round once a week.

I ascribed to a lighter version of tiger parenting, no where near as rigid as my parents. it’s paid off well though it caused a few tussles with DH who is white English.

So my Dad who opened the first Chinese restaurant in a small town in 1959 and who endured shocking racism ended up with children who academically all did very well. He died 8 years ago, he was so proud of us all.

Overall I agree with this woman though it doesn’t always work out and I imagine anyone with liberal sensibilities reading that article will be horrified.

CorrBlimeyGG · 04/01/2022 14:52

But you still would find time for the things you like or find important, like your social media. You just don't like books and your kid doesn't either.

Wow, some ignorance here.

5128gap · 04/01/2022 14:49

@Pinkdelight3

How are the working classes supposed to do that? From what?

There isn't a general working class that can't prioritise and provide extra educational support for their kids. In the past, workers' libraries, grammars and night school helped achieve some social mobility and more recently it's been a clearer part of some immigrant cultures to educate their DC to succeed beyond what was possible for the parents. It's not a matter of money, but a matter of aspirations and priorities. Encouraging, motivating, making time for extra study at libraries or online, which are accessible for all, if you can get past the hurdle of being intimidated or thinking it's not for you and the school should do it.

By saying this, I guess the chief is highlighting the known issue that it's not just down to schools but that parental involvement and support for the DCs education is a vital factor in social mobility. Which doesn't mean paying for tutoring etc, but on a fundamental level, not assuming the school will do it all and that's the DC education sorted. The tone of the OP suggests the very opposite - that it's entirely the state's job - a misconception that needs dispelling if social mobility is to gain any traction. Obviously the state has to do its bit, but parents must too. Sadly there will still be parents who are unable or unwilling, but that's the smaller subset and not the entire working classes by any stretch. The more everyone else can step up, the more state resources can target those in the most need of support.

It is absolutely not all down to aspirations and priorities. Many people have not been sufficiently well educated themselves to support their children's learning. Motivation only goes so far if you have no idea yourself how to do algebra or decline a verb. And if you think that is a small subset, then you are wrong. I agree it's not the 'entire WC', but parents without the resources to assist their children are disproportionately represented amongst lower income families, and putting more onus on them to fill the gaps caused by underfunding will increase the divide.
gogohm · 04/01/2022 14:34

What she is saying is extreme BUT in reality the school can only provide so much, parents need to be supporting their children by listening to them read, helping them learn spellings and supervising homework (not doing it, more providing a quiet space to do it (eg kitchen table) plus where possible encouraging their broader education by visiting museums, historical sites, taking walks in nature etc many are completely free.

The main reason middle class kids do better is this subtle extra curricular support rather than hothousing or coaching. Mine never had tutors but we did have a national trust membership!

SleepingStandingUp · 04/01/2022 14:26

@WorraLiberty

How are the working classes supposed to do that? From what?

I don't understand what you mean by 'from what'?

This. Do you mean I can't hire a tutor or I'm too thick to provide education myself?
Hawkins001 · 04/01/2022 14:10

With a phone or tablet or PlayStation there's is youtube, or Wikipedia ect, many ways to learn

Pinkdelight3 · 04/01/2022 13:59

Most deprived areas don't have museums and cultural events at all, unless you can travel to the nearest city, which means spending money.

Hmm. I come from one of the most deprived areas and it has a museum and cultural events. Most towns in this country have something going on even if it's run by amateur enthusiasts (often the best people to do it so no hierarchy intended). It's another pervasive myth that you have to be in a big city and go to the top galleries and museums or you're screwed. Again, it's about a shift from that mind-set of £ and big trips to the smaller, more prosaic matters of the local library, reading each night, talking about whatever topic they're studying over tea at night and so on.

CatsArePeople · 04/01/2022 13:30

You can't if you're working every hour you can to keep a roof over your heads.
But you still would find time for the things you like or find important, like your social media. You just don't like books and your kid doesn't either.

Most deprived areas don't have museums and cultural events at all, unless you can travel to the nearest city, which means spending money.
Ok, I get that. But those in cities have such opportunities, yet ignore them.

Namenic · 04/01/2022 13:29

What she’s saying is that you shouldn’t ASSUME that your kid is getting the right education at school (true for both private and state school) - so you should also check for yourself and do additional things if you can. I’m from a culture where kids regularly do work after school. It’s got benefits - some people from poor backgrounds had kids who achieved stellar results and much better standard of living. It also has some drawbacks - poor stress and mental health. I personally benefitted from a tiger parent, but not all kids are the same and different kids need different things.

Most of a child’s time is spent out of school. If parents are able to, it is usually beneficial to do what they can to help their kids with education. Saying that is not classist - of course parents shouldn’t be blamed if this is not possible - some parents don’t have the right circumstances (eg shift work, inadequate time, language issues)- but if they can and have a choice, it would usually benefit the child.

CorrBlimeyGG · 04/01/2022 13:18

You can still buy and read books when you're working class. Also visit museums, cultural events - so many are free

You can't if you're working every hour you can to keep a roof over your heads.

Most deprived areas don't have museums and cultural events at all, unless you can travel to the nearest city, which means spending money.

malificent7 · 04/01/2022 13:17

What about all those working parents of all classes who aren't there after school.

Pinkdelight3 · 04/01/2022 13:15

(worth adding - obviously there are many other factors in social mobility and am no fan of this gov's approach to it, fucking up opportunities in myriad ways. so parental support ain't gonna solve wider societal issues, but just in relation to this specific story, I get the stance)

malificent7 · 04/01/2022 13:14

My parents went on and on about grades...was quite damaging.

CatsArePeople · 04/01/2022 13:13

You can still buy and read books when you're working class. Also visit museums, cultural events - so many are free.

Annaghgloor · 04/01/2022 13:12

She’s preying on the widespread British anxiety about offspring not ‘getting ahead’ educationally (which weirdly manages to co-exist with an entrenched suspicion of academic intelligence, multilingualism and ‘performance parenting.’

People should calm the hell down and just read with their children. And if they can’t, it’s not catastrophic. My parents were only semi-literate, and my schools were pretty poor, but I turned out all right.