Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To just let you know (re, SEN funding)

531 replies

theqentity · 04/01/2022 10:01

That TA in the class that does 1-1 with the child that had additional needs is not funded by the school, but the LA, and a parent had to probably go to tribunal in order to get that level of support for their child.

What they are NOT doing is taking away from the school funding and the education of others. They are not there to support other children, although many do despite it not being in their job description.

Sorry, just the pass gag What's App group has really depressed me today.

OP posts:
StationaryMagpie · 07/01/2022 09:48

@CinnamonJellyBeans

In the situations described by imitatingdory; the risks have not been adequately managed by having a 1:1 TA

It's nigh on impossible to keep a child from having zero physical contact in a mainstream school.

Most mainstream schools are definitely not secure enough to prevent a child who is determined from absconding

well.. yes it is actually.

Ds had similar issues, he sat in a corner of the classroom, in front of the teachers desk, with a little cubicle almost, he sat against the wall, and his TA sat next to him between him and the rest of the class... so when she was sat with him, teaching him/supporting him, no-one else was able to get near him, and he wasn't able to bolt... what he had to do was let her know he needed to leave the room, and she would escort him where he needed to go.

Had she been the other side of the classroom helping someone else, she'd be leaving him exposed to the chance of someone bothering him.

StationaryMagpie · 07/01/2022 09:39

@CinnamonJellyBeans

Some of those incidents sound too risky for mainstream school
most of them are, however there is an extreme lack of specialist provision out there.. where i live, there is ZERO for primary age unless the child also has profound learning difficulties.

So, my DS who has ASD/ADHD/DCD needed a full time 1:1 with him in primary school to enable him to access the education he is legally entitled to.

His TA's job was to supervise him, to differentiate the set class work so he could actually DO the work (executive functioning issues) work as a scribe (DCD meant DS can't hold a pencil/write) accompany him if he needed a movement break or time out of the classroom/in the calm room because he was having a meltdown. To restrain him during a meltdown. To protect him from other students actions that could provoke a meltdown, to provide therapy, emotional support, and to facilitate his participation in all aspects of the school day for enrichment and social development.

She was employed specifically for him, attending extra training courses to enable her to work with him, was paid for by his EHCP.

So no, she wasn't there to support the other kids in class.

Hospedia · 07/01/2022 09:29

Carers Allowance = £67.60 for 35hrs p/wk care, the equivalent of £1.93 an hour.

However most carers are caring 24/7 and even in the times when they are not actively caring, e.g., when they're sleeping, they are "on call/on standby".

Therefore £67.60 over 24/7 = 40p per hour.

And that's just for the people who qualify for it, there are plenty of carers who don't qualify because their income pushes them over the threshold or they're in education or they're outside the age limits or the person they card for can't access the qualifying benefits. They're still carers.

Bit of a kick in the teeth when you realise that all of these carers save the government an estimated £132 billion a year in social care costs.

elliejjtiny · 07/01/2022 00:50

@hiredandsqueak that's brilliant, a huge achievement for your ds.

theqentity · 07/01/2022 00:25

@Dithercats

£62 per week carers allowance. Parents who mostly cannot work around our children's high needs.

Enjoy your pondering cinnamon

Exactly this. I haven't been on a night out with my husband in over six years. Because only he or I can safely supervise DS. Must be nice to be able to ponder...
OP posts:
theqentity · 07/01/2022 00:22

@Missdread

Some of these stories are truly heartbreaking. As both a parent of a child with SEND and a primary teacher, I have a pretty good overview and I'm sad to say that the system truly is broken. From a parent's point of view, IF you can get a referral to CAMHS early enough (and it's a big IF with GPs, HVs and schools all passing the buck over whose job it is to refer as they're all too swamped and have so little capacity), you may have an 18 month to 3 year wait to be seen. IF you are "lucky" enough to receive a diagnosis for your child, you will then be cast off and left alone without support ("Congratulations! Your child has ASD. Now off you go!"). If you need support for issues connected to the diagnosis you need to re-refer in many cases. It's desperate, hopeless and I know many families who have been advised to ring the POLICE when they are at breaking point due to meltdowns or a child in danger as there is no effective community mental health provision.

From a teacher's point of view, IF you have a child in your class with an ECHP, they MAY come with hours of funding, typically 15, 20 or 30 hours. But many do not and in these cases, we still have to keep the child and everyone else safe so the TA would be funded from the school budget. The vast majority of children with SEND do not have an ECHP, as these can take years to get. In infants especially, it is common to have 3 or 4 children without ECHPs in a class of 30 with severe behavioural needs. There may be 1 TA between two classes. So much of my day is spent supporting and dealing with challenging behaviour related to SEND that I can often barely teach at all. There is no support from anywhere. It is dire and I'm not sure what the answer is :-(

'Severe behavioural needs'.

No such thing mate. Unmet needs maybe.

OP posts:
hiredandsqueak · 06/01/2022 23:57

My son had a dedicated 1 to 1 in primary, she sat with him at a table out of throwing distance of all other children. If she had left him to see to another child he would have launched whatever he got hold of at the head of whoever had annoyed him at some pont in the past or believed might annoy him at some point in the future. Annoying him could have been speaking, breathing, coughing, moving if he didn't want them to. If he didn't launch something he'd have gone to attack, usually with something in his hand, he'd always get three hits in before anyone could get to him. It was safer for everyone pupils and staff included as he didn't discriminate (sports day, beanbag race, he grabbed up the bean bags and got three to HTs head because her blowing the whistle annoyed him) to have a dedicated member of staff at his side. With incredible support from his 1 to 1's in Y10 in mainstream secondary he got HT award for behaviour and attitude to learning. Proof I suppose that the right support changes lives.

wonderstuff · 06/01/2022 23:41

We have children with TA all the time in case of medical emergency, it’s unusual but definitely needed sometimes. Had to fight school transport for one kid who was getting dropped off before the TA cover started, you couldn’t make it up how much of a fight it is to keep kids safe.

OliviaBond · 06/01/2022 23:35

@CinnamonJellyBeans

If he has a medical emergency, she can step back and attend to him surely? If his condition warrants needing someone to be looking at him and not stepping away from him, he must have some kind of device or have been shown how to make his medical emergency apparent, like asking for help by saying the TAs name?
I just snorted with laughter at this!
Missdread · 06/01/2022 23:25

Some of these stories are truly heartbreaking. As both a parent of a child with SEND and a primary teacher, I have a pretty good overview and I'm sad to say that the system truly is broken. From a parent's point of view, IF you can get a referral to CAMHS early enough (and it's a big IF with GPs, HVs and schools all passing the buck over whose job it is to refer as they're all too swamped and have so little capacity), you may have an 18 month to 3 year wait to be seen. IF you are "lucky" enough to receive a diagnosis for your child, you will then be cast off and left alone without support ("Congratulations! Your child has ASD. Now off you go!"). If you need support for issues connected to the diagnosis you need to re-refer in many cases. It's desperate, hopeless and I know many families who have been advised to ring the POLICE when they are at breaking point due to meltdowns or a child in danger as there is no effective community mental health provision.

From a teacher's point of view, IF you have a child in your class with an ECHP, they MAY come with hours of funding, typically 15, 20 or 30 hours. But many do not and in these cases, we still have to keep the child and everyone else safe so the TA would be funded from the school budget. The vast majority of children with SEND do not have an ECHP, as these can take years to get. In infants especially, it is common to have 3 or 4 children without ECHPs in a class of 30 with severe behavioural needs. There may be 1 TA between two classes. So much of my day is spent supporting and dealing with challenging behaviour related to SEND that I can often barely teach at all. There is no support from anywhere. It is dire and I'm not sure what the answer is :-(

wonderstuff · 06/01/2022 23:24

Schools don’t need to prove £6k of funding before they apply for an EHCP, although LEA will try to push for that, but they do need to provide the first 6k of funding from notional SEN funding, which is well below £6k per child before they get additional funding from the LEA, this means often in mainstream schools there is only a tiny amount to support kids on the SEN register after the schools portion of the EHCP funding has been allocated. This situation encourages more EHCP applications and results in the children of parents who fight for funding getting better support than the kids of the parents who don’t. It’s utterly shit and not how things should be but it is reality.

Imitatingdory · 06/01/2022 23:22

The risks can be adequately managed by having 1:1 if the (trained, experienced, good) 1:1 is actually providing 1:1.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 06/01/2022 23:19

In the situations described by imitatingdory; the risks have not been adequately managed by having a 1:1 TA

It's nigh on impossible to keep a child from having zero physical contact in a mainstream school.

Most mainstream schools are definitely not secure enough to prevent a child who is determined from absconding

Imitatingdory · 06/01/2022 23:17

Well luckily you aren’t the one deciding what type of school is right for DC. Both DC in the examples I mentioned are thriving at MS now they have the correct provision in place and it is actually provided.

Parents have the right for their DC to receive a mainstream education unless it is incompatible with the efficient education of others, and there are no reasonable steps could mitigate this. Neither example I posted would fall in that category.

Dithercats · 06/01/2022 23:15

£62 per week carers allowance.
Parents who mostly cannot work around our children's high needs.

Enjoy your pondering cinnamon

Dithercats · 06/01/2022 23:13

Special schools are so expensive, and considered non inclusive that they were shut, and are now few and far between. Only the most severely disabled children are usually given a place at a special school
(Where I live anyway).

Westmeathtip · 06/01/2022 23:11

Thankfully parents always have a right to mainstream, CinnamonJellyBeans and deserve to be supported, with risks mitigated.

If I were you I’d sit down and think quietly right now. Hmm

Dithercats · 06/01/2022 23:11

Incidentally it is cheaper for the LEA to provide full time 1:1 than to place my child in a 'special school'. One with nurses, OT, physio etc on hand in case of medical emergency.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 06/01/2022 23:09

Some of those incidents sound too risky for mainstream school

Dithercats · 06/01/2022 23:08

That's neither relevant or your business.

School have a legal duty to keep my child safe while educated. The LEA have decided that they can do that by providing my child with a PA or 1:1 assistant. They are legally entitled to that person at all times while in school. End of.
That person is not there for the other children in the classroom.

Imitatingdory · 06/01/2022 23:06

There can be a risk, but as others have posted it’s irrelevant.

Using 2 different examples, neither are my DC.

  1. Y1 child with GDD and ASD. Part of the reason for 1:1 was to prevent other pupils touching the child or getting into their space. 1:1 was helping another child open their banana when another pupil tapped child on the arm, child had meltdown during which they hurt themselves, other pupil and 1:1.
  2. Y5 child with ASD and ADHD. Part of the reason for the 1:1 is because the child is known to bolt, which they did when the TA was helping another child. It gave the child enough of a head start that they managed to scale the fence and get to the end of the road.

Many DC with medical needs do have carers, either via CC funding or via social care. Others just have parents who have to give up work and are exhausted, but all is OK because they can receive the ever so generous carer’s allowance.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 06/01/2022 22:58

Do you also have a home care package, so there is a paid carer available to be constantly in a room, looking at him without stepping away?

Dithercats · 06/01/2022 22:54

My child's 1:1 is for them and them alone. The risk in the 1:1 being distracted by another child could result in my child's medical needs being missed.
Yes the 1:1 will talk to the other children on my child's table....no she does not leave my child alone - ever. The TA in the class is there for the rest of the children. Simple.

hiredandsqueak · 06/01/2022 22:53

It makes no difference whether or not the child might be ok if left momentarily if the EHCP states 1 to 1 for that child at all times that is what must happen.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 06/01/2022 22:49

Within sight