Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To just let you know (re, SEN funding)

531 replies

theqentity · 04/01/2022 10:01

That TA in the class that does 1-1 with the child that had additional needs is not funded by the school, but the LA, and a parent had to probably go to tribunal in order to get that level of support for their child.

What they are NOT doing is taking away from the school funding and the education of others. They are not there to support other children, although many do despite it not being in their job description.

Sorry, just the pass gag What's App group has really depressed me today.

OP posts:
theqentity · 04/01/2022 12:05

[quote DeepaBeesKit]**@Sirzy

If I hadn’t fought to get DS a watertight EHCP (30 hours 1-1) then one of two outcomes would have happened -

- the education of the whole class would have been disrupted daily due to his unmet needs

The ridiculous thing is because EHCPs are a bloody nightmare for all but the best equipped and advised, this is exactly what happens in many cases, often for months at a time. and it's why you get disgruntled other parents. Of course those parents should never be blaming other parents, least of all those of the childs with additional needs, but are you surprised parents of other kids in this situation are disgruntled?[/quote]
Genuinely, @Sirzy, @DeepaBeesKit is a lost cause in this thread and it's better to ignore them. Maybe they'll learn something, but they seem very keen not to.

OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 04/01/2022 12:02

@Sirzy

If I hadn’t fought to get DS a watertight EHCP (30 hours 1-1) then one of two outcomes would have happened -

- the education of the whole class would have been disrupted daily due to his unmet needs

The ridiculous thing is because EHCPs are a bloody nightmare for all but the best equipped and advised, this is exactly what happens in many cases, often for months at a time. and it's why you get disgruntled other parents. Of course those parents should never be blaming other parents, least of all those of the childs with additional needs, but are you surprised parents of other kids in this situation are disgruntled?

Punxsutawney · 04/01/2022 11:44

I've yet to meet a Senco that understood the legal aspect of EHCPs needing to be specified and quantified. Even Ds's LA case officer told me a few months ago that EHCPS are never specific as the school can then interpret them as they see fit!

Ds is currently not in school. His woolly EHCP meant that support and provisions weren't put in place. And a young man who could have done well in mainstream (if he had been supported adequately). Now needs an expensive specialist provision. It's costing way more than it ever should have.

Sirzy · 04/01/2022 11:43

If I hadn’t fought to get DS a watertight EHCP (30 hours 1-1) then one of two outcomes would have happened -

  • the education of the whole class would have been disrupted daily due to his unmet needs.

Or

  • the LA would have had to fund a place at a suitable specialist setting. The only one that could come close to being suitable for him is an independent specialist. It would have cost an awful lot more than his 1-1 does.

As it is he has had full 1-1 since year 2, funded from his ehcp since year 3. He is now in year 7 at a mainstream secondary and because he is supported he is thriving and he isn’t negatively impacting the education of others at all.

Getting the right support in for the individual child with additional needs at an early age will often actually cost a lot less and be a lot less disruptive to others over time.

Meadowbreeze · 04/01/2022 11:42

@Saffy123456 that will be because it was nursery. Early years funding is different. If the child needs it moving forward into reception, they should be starting reception with an ehcp.

Meadowbreeze · 04/01/2022 11:41

@TractorAndHeadphones definitely. I ended up training with IPSEA and was briefly a parent advisor. Even the rich parents who can afford lawyers get really inaccurate advice from firms. Most often though, even when the school does help and it ends with an echp, it's not worth the paper it's written on, it's general and doesn't equate to any funding.

So after all that fighting, I am not surprised parents get very defensive when messages like that float around WhatsApp groups. I honestly feel like I have PTSD from that period. It was horrible.

Saffy123456 · 04/01/2022 11:33

My son received 1-1 funding in a private day nursery paid by the LEA without an ECHP, would that have happened without the Paediatrician sending them a legal notice probably not. Thankfully I wasn't on a class WhatsApp group.

DeepaBeesKit · 04/01/2022 11:33

@DeepaBeesKit while what you say is true. It’s never the people who might actually lose out complaining. Like lower income families or kids of lower ability but undiagnosed.

@tractorAndHeadphones I think that's true, sadly.

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/01/2022 11:29

@Meadowbreeze

Its interesting because lots of people working in schools don't actually understand this. People in the LA don't understand it. In fact, most lawyers don't either. IPSEA provides training for barristers and lawyers as it's an area their normal training basically doesn't touch.

The £6k argument is irrelevant. When a child has a TA they have funding for that TA. If the school is funding it out of the £6k and topping it up themselves that's not really anything to do with parents. If the child has an EHCP that says they need a full time TA and the council gives the school £8k to find this, that's for the school to take up. That's the schools fault for not making sure they get the correct funding.
My DDs EHCP is textbook material. I fought for years to make sure it's like a shopping list. Took my LA to appeal at every review. Its very detailed and very specific. The LA still tried to pull their crap. I fought for months demanding for the correct funding to be given, however this is the schools responsibility, not mine so it caused issues as they refused to talk to me about it.

The state of the situation is really dire. Most professionals are clueless about the process, let alone the parents.
We once had a child stuck into my DDs 1:1 SALT sessions. I was not told for weeks until my DD cried and explained why she hates it. When I brought this up with the school they, and the parents, tried to guilt trip me into letting the girl join. You couldn't make this crap up.
I am sorry the system is screwed. But don't guilt trip me for it.

The worst part is that it takes a very determined parent tto get all of this.

Kids with uninvolved / lower ability parents are screwed. Or parents who ‘don’t believe’ in SEN

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/01/2022 11:27

*not be the man he is today with a degree, job and a relationship. God only knows what he’s have ended up as.

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/01/2022 11:26

@DeepaBeesKit while what you say is true. It’s never the people who might actually lose out complaining. Like lower income families or kids of lower ability but undiagnosed.

It’s the naice parents who frankly want SEN kids to just go away.

If they had their way my DP would be

Meadowbreeze · 04/01/2022 11:25

Its interesting because lots of people working in schools don't actually understand this. People in the LA don't understand it. In fact, most lawyers don't either. IPSEA provides training for barristers and lawyers as it's an area their normal training basically doesn't touch.

The £6k argument is irrelevant. When a child has a TA they have funding for that TA. If the school is funding it out of the £6k and topping it up themselves that's not really anything to do with parents. If the child has an EHCP that says they need a full time TA and the council gives the school £8k to find this, that's for the school to take up. That's the schools fault for not making sure they get the correct funding.
My DDs EHCP is textbook material. I fought for years to make sure it's like a shopping list. Took my LA to appeal at every review. Its very detailed and very specific. The LA still tried to pull their crap. I fought for months demanding for the correct funding to be given, however this is the schools responsibility, not mine so it caused issues as they refused to talk to me about it.

The state of the situation is really dire. Most professionals are clueless about the process, let alone the parents.
We once had a child stuck into my DDs 1:1 SALT sessions. I was not told for weeks until my DD cried and explained why she hates it. When I brought this up with the school they, and the parents, tried to guilt trip me into letting the girl join. You couldn't make this crap up.
I am sorry the system is screwed. But don't guilt trip me for it.

Eyesofdisarray · 04/01/2022 11:23

Parents at my DDs school were quite annoyed that she went there at all and her place should have been given to a child without SEN!!! Let alone her"special help"
Just ignorance and bloody maddening

DeepaBeesKit · 04/01/2022 11:21

Nobody is saying children without additional needs don't deserve support. I don't know where on earth you plucked that from.

I quoted x2boys.

The stories on this post of parents trying to bully SEN kids out of mainstream schools is sad beyond belief.

It is so sad. And it's happening because there is not enough money spent to provide decent support.

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 11:20

@DeepaBeesKit
It's a sliding scale where children need differing amounts of support, and at the moment, education funding is such that only those who need the highest levels of support get any

But those who do get support have probably had parents who have fought very hard through SENDIST to get that support and that support for those children isn't depriving others it is the lack of funding.
Our LA pay close to six figures to educate dd in an out of County independent specialist school. If they didn't and funded her in an in County maintained school none of the funding attached to her EHCP would be used to support other children it would all go to support dd. School wouldn't be funding it LA would.

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/01/2022 11:16

You’re on

Annabellerina · 04/01/2022 11:13

The stories on this post of parents trying to bully SEN kids out of mainstream schools is sad beyond belief.

theqentity · 04/01/2022 11:11

@DeepaBeesKit

The child with SEN gets extra support so they can access education,other children who don't require support don't get it because they don't need it ,other children are not being short changed.

It's not binary! Its not black and white that I child either "needs support" or "doesnt".

It's a sliding scale where children need differing amounts of support, and at the moment, education funding is such that only those who need the highest levels of support get any.

Nobody is saying children without additional needs don't deserve support. I don't know where on earth you plucked that from.
OP posts:
hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 11:10

@floundery parents in ds's primary got up a petition to have my son removed from the school. HT and I had had our moments (usually over not implementing support properly) but she invited the ringleaders to bring in the petition, gave them all pen and paper told them that ds was staying but they could withdraw their own children from the school effective from that day if they chose and to pass that message to each and every parent who had signed the petition (she kept it for reference) I had new found respect for her that day.

DeepaBeesKit · 04/01/2022 11:06

The child with SEN gets extra support so they can access education,other children who don't require support don't get it because they don't need it ,other children are not being short changed.

It's not binary! Its not black and white that I child either "needs support" or "doesnt".

It's a sliding scale where children need differing amounts of support, and at the moment, education funding is such that only those who need the highest levels of support get any.

Floundery · 04/01/2022 10:54

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

germsandcoffee · 04/01/2022 10:52

I once had a parent complaining my son was getting a better education because he had in their opinion his own personal teacher!
No mate he had a one to one assistant who wasn't a trained teacher at all!
The headteacher absolutely called her out in front of the whole playground of parents as she tried to get a gang together to get my son removed from the school as he was using all the funding just for him!
It's hard enough for us parents without other parents interfering in shit they know nothing about 🤷‍♀️

x2boys · 04/01/2022 10:47

@DeepaBeesKit

Yes so the point is it is the fault of the LAs not funding it properly, but where they don't, why should other people's kids be shortchanged instead of yours? It does happen and yes, parents will grumble where that happens.
My child is at a special school so thankfully I don't have to put up with this kind of crap Do you not understand equality ? The child with SEN gets extra support so they can access education,other children who don't require support don't get it because they don't need it ,other children are not being short changed .
drspouse · 04/01/2022 10:46

you can imagine how pass agg my experience is. (I'm not even invited to the WhatsApp group!)

Me neither, it was used to egg other parents on to tell the school to PEx my son.
School told the parents off but guess what, he was PEx.

I also have a low-achieving but not struggling TOO badly child, and we support her at home so she can be more relaxed at school. That's what we do. I don't complain that other children in her class have 1:1.

User2638483 · 04/01/2022 10:44

School WhatsApp groups can be the work of the devil