Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To just let you know (re, SEN funding)

531 replies

theqentity · 04/01/2022 10:01

That TA in the class that does 1-1 with the child that had additional needs is not funded by the school, but the LA, and a parent had to probably go to tribunal in order to get that level of support for their child.

What they are NOT doing is taking away from the school funding and the education of others. They are not there to support other children, although many do despite it not being in their job description.

Sorry, just the pass gag What's App group has really depressed me today.

OP posts:
hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 13:58

@imitatingdory Well I got the number of Tribunals the LA used the services of a barrister within a timeframe and the supposed costs or barristers services. Supposing the barrister attended only one day (when I knew at least two hearings were two day hearings and one was a three day hearing with barrister attending all days) and a day was eight hours, the costs the LA quoted worked out at £50ph when that is obviously not the case and didn't allow for any work prior or after to the hearing, travel (mine arrived by train ticket that day would have been in excess of £100) or subsistence.

Iveputmyselfonthenaughtystep · 04/01/2022 13:58

I'm getting extreme anxiety reading this. I have finally managed to get an EHCP for DS but I worry and worry that it might not be specific enough, or cover everything. I'm undergoing diagnosis for adhd myself and I struggle with legal stuff and confrontational situations, so even getting him an EHCP was a fucking triumph of determination over natural ability. I'm lucky to be educated, good at writing and determined, I feel endless sorrow for less fortunate children with families less able to advocate, but it was by no means easy or simple for me, eao since his dad was quite happy to just turn up to meetings, contribute irrelavancies because he hadn't bothered researching and let me do the legwork.

And don't get me started on the LA who tried to wriggle out of providing any funding because DS was achieving at school. He was only achieving because he had the school funding 121 for him for about 3/4 of his timetable and made the SENDCO his form tutor for the next school year. Before his diagnosis and the extra help they funded he was at risk of exclusion. He would have been excluded of they hadn't worked so hard with him. Even then I was having to call the LA constantly, point out that my child was a risk to other students without supervision, that just because his processing speed was 'average' (at 50 percent) that he wasn't disabled by it, because his IQ is 98 or 99 percent and he literally ends up speechless because his brain is running faster than his ability to do anything about it.

God I am so angry and upset any time I think about this. And yes, the snide, PA comments from other parents are just the salt in the fucking wound because the sheer ADMIN needs of an SEN child, never mind the emotional, physical, financial toll it takes are just overwhelming and yet they somehow act like you're depriving them or trying to get one over on them.

I am so looking forward to DSs secondary school. I met the SENDCO and they have a SEN parents WhatsApp group set up for all SEN parents as well as a bunch of other measures that prove to me they truly understand and support neuordiversity. I have so much hope.

Imitatingdory · 04/01/2022 13:50

Hiredandsqueak With some digging you can find how much LAs are spending without FOI requests IF the LA are not fiddling with payments to get under the limit. LAs are required to publish payments and expenses over £500, so if you are aware of when the LA are using someone’s services you can see, or take an educated guess depending on how much detail your LA publishes, the exact amount.

Meadowbreeze in that case law the disputed provision was to be undertaken at home. There is a difference between a certain amount of flexibility that may be beneficial and a vague and woolly worded EHCP that allows the LA/school to squirm out of providing necessary provision when provision could reasonably be detailed, specified and quantified. No doubt there will be further case law in due course.

DS1 has EOTAS and his EHCP is specified and quantified to the nth degree because otherwise the EOTAS package doesn’t work. DS3 is in MS and he also has a highly detailed, specified and quantified section F. Perhaps if they were in SS a degree of flexibility in provision, not wording, may be better suited.

chimpandzee · 04/01/2022 13:47

@Sirzy

Unfortunately there is now recent case law that has called the whole need for very specified and quantified provision in to question and has stated that flexibility should be considered especially as the EHCP is a living document.

That’s worrying and goes against the SEN code of practise.

Surely that’s why you have annual reviews/emergency reviews because it’s a live document so may need to change.

I've linked to a Council For Disabled Children review of the case here, yes very worrying as it has definitely made the issue of specificity more difficult to argue for. The argument is that waiting for formal reviews may not be in the best interests of the pupil/child, from what I understand after reading this.

councilfordisabledchildren.org.uk/resources-0/case-law-directory/ehc-plans/case-law-update-52-redbridge-v-ho-level-specificity

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 13:43

@gogohm schools are schooled in LA policy. The only requirement to secure an EHC needs assessment is that a child has or may have SEN and they need or may need support through a plan. That is the law and it is the law that will be upheld if the EHC needs assessment is refused and a parent appeals.

drspouse · 04/01/2022 13:42

@errnerrcallnernnernnern

I hope someone called them out on the Whatsapp group?
In our case, yes, the HT told them not to use it to bully people. But the parents got what they wanted - DS was still excluded permanently.
friedeggandsauce · 04/01/2022 13:41

The authority start every meeting saying that school pay £6000, school then say but that's just for books/staff/heating etc and we go round in circles

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 13:41

@friedeggandsauce tbh I would point parents to IPSEA and SOSSEN and advise them to make the request for an EHC needs assessment themselves. The only criteria is that the child has or may have SEN and needs or may need support through an EHCP anything else your LA are asking for is unnecessary. I'd also advise them to put in a SAR to the school so that they have the evidence to submit with the application. Job done!

gogohm · 04/01/2022 13:38

Actually my DD's school told me that they had to pay the first £6000 of interventions. It's not something parents are making up, schools claim this is the case

friedeggandsauce · 04/01/2022 13:36

@Meadowbreeze the application must be very different for your authority as there is no way for my authority it would be that quick, each form regardless of us asking for band A-G takes the same time 🤷🏼‍♀️

Meadowbreeze · 04/01/2022 13:35

I really hope this thread shows any parent that's raising their eyebrows about the support another child is getting because the likelihood is:

  1. The parents have gone to hell and back to get their child that TA or support.
  2. Based on the situation across the country, it's unlikely that support is meeting their needs fully anyway.
DeepaBeesKit · 04/01/2022 13:33

There are loads of little pitfalls.

Hnbf is capped at 6k total where I live. It's also capped at 2 terms so good luck if your EHCP process/appeal etc takes longer.

The 6k ordinary provision isnt ways 6k guaranteed ringfenced in reality. It is only applicable per child on register, there are timing lags to accessing it and issues where children move school etc.

There are so many ways where the system falls down and school budgets plug the gap temporarily.

Meadowbreeze · 04/01/2022 13:30

@friedeggandsauce I am really not implying the system is fit for purpose or funded well. However, this is exactly why after an 18 month enquiry, the government was found to be funding all this perfectly well!
£1000 is a lot of money. The application takes 15mins and you can reapply. Again, I am not saying this is perfect or will cover everything, but this is exactly the attitude that meant the government has now washed their hands of this problem.

Mumofsend · 04/01/2022 13:30

And now my daughter (she is year 2) is correctly funded after a hideous first year when her needs absolutely were not able to be met due to her plan she is now thriving, in mainstream. It does make a huge difference.

Mumofsend · 04/01/2022 13:29

@friedeggandsauce BCP.

It took school being fairly blunt with me they absolutely couldn't meet the needs with the proposed funding, the LA playing silly buggers because the plans werent written well enough to justify the needed funding and me pursuing appeals to get the plans correctly written and to ensure the school got the correct funding. It was a massive joint effort between school and I.

I think LAs are far far too good at painting schools as the 'enemy' when qctually schools can't correctly challenge with dire plans and only the parent can get a plan correctly written for the school to correctly cost to get the funding. Instead schools are portrayed as the bad guys and parents end up battling the wrong people.

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 13:26

@friedeggandsauce you need to take up IPSEA training and avail yourself knowledge of SEN law. As I posted above our LA issued dd's EHCP with band one funding (about £1.5k) at Tribunal costed provision of her EHCP was £46k. School would have taken the funding I wouldn't.

trydry22 · 04/01/2022 13:25

@Annabellerina

The stories on this post of parents trying to bully SEN kids out of mainstream schools is sad beyond belief.
Yep! Been there .. ended with me removing my children from mainstream education. The worst heartbreaking thing ever is seeing your child bullied by others because they don't quite fit the norm.. twice over as I have two children with autism.
spanieleyes · 04/01/2022 13:24

Schools do NOT get £6000 per child with special needs, how I wish we did! The £6000 is a notional amount and is based on IDAC characteristics of the school, not the number of SEN children. So if a child with additional needs changes school, the receiving school does not get an additional £6000. However, if a child has a funded EHCP, then the additional funding agreed- over and above the first £6000, does transfer. But in my LA, it doesn't transfer until the next financial year. Not does the funded amount cover all of the additional funding needed, in my county it is based on an hourly rate of £9.16, anything over this ( including pension and other on costs) is paid for out of general school funds. Different counties may have different ways of doing things but, whatever the process involved, I'm sure we can all agree that funding for children with additional needs is beyond pathetic!

Meadowbreeze · 04/01/2022 13:23

@deepabeeskit I'm sorry to hear that. How frustrating. I complete agree with you, however the enquiry really made me angry. The government can now wash its hands clean because people just weren't asking or applying. This thread itself just shows how little people know about funding. The Sen funding is per pupil on the register, not per school.
I don't know where this nursery is but here, high needs funding is based on date of application. If successful the money is given from date of application. I am sorry that this wasn't the case here. I am not familiar with the law around it but our LA is not very generous so I would he surprised if this wasn't the law. The EHCP funding is frustratingly not backdated.

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 13:22

@Imitatingdory 39 Essex Chambers who our LA used to represent them at Tribunal no longer do so because their losses were damaging their reputation Grin I have no sympathy for them though as their intention was to deny SEN children the provision they needed to access an education. Funnily enough when I stuck in an FOI LA's figures were such that Essex Chambers were working for less than £50 ph without travel or subsistence (we are a long way from Essex)

friedeggandsauce · 04/01/2022 13:19

@Meadowbreeze a lot of schools don't do the funding as they end up with £1000 extra a year, the hours this takes just isn't worth it 🤷🏼‍♀️

friedeggandsauce · 04/01/2022 13:18

@Mumofsend

My daughter is funded 28k via her EHCP. My son 22k. Damn right are their TAs their TAs. The rest of the class are not missing out because they have their own TAs, they just wouldn't be there at all if my children weren't. In fact the class benefit from my children's funding and also prevents my two impacting the learning of others. Resources are there for all because of my DD especially.

Any parent who dares to complain about my children dominating their TAs would get a very blunt response from me.

@Mumofsend wow what authority are you in? Those figures could only be dreamed of in my authority and to get the highest top up funding you require severe medical needs or you don't get it at all
DeepaBeesKit · 04/01/2022 13:15

@tractorandheadphones
Thank you for reading my post. My point is the system is not fit for purpose and inevitably the negative impacts of that reach beyond simply those with SEN.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 04/01/2022 13:14

@Howshouldibehave

So school x with just 2 kids will find it easy to allow £6k per pupil for support.School Y with 15 kids will need to take way more money out of their budget.

This.

The first £6000 per year per child the schools have to find isn’t ringfenced.

Yes it is. They get SEN funding that is seperate from their regular funding. This is made up of a set amount per SEN child and to be spent on SEN only. Whether that is equiptment, staff, resouces at the school's discretion.
TractorAndHeadphones · 04/01/2022 13:13

[quote Meadowbreeze]@DeepaBeesKit Unfortunately the early years funding is crazy and even quite woolly in law. But in that situation the nursery should've still applied for the high needs funding.[/quote]
But they did apply.
It just took months and instead of doing the ‘easy’ thing and rejecting said child while waiting general money was used instead.

The way things are set up as pp said there’s so much misdirection.

I don’t think people should be passive aggressive, or angry at people with SEN needs /make snide remarks but equally it’s not true that there’s no impact on other kids. The law and practice are two different things.

Ironically schools following the ‘law’ might not be the best either because that means just ignoring the kid until official funding etc is acesse.