Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To just let you know (re, SEN funding)

531 replies

theqentity · 04/01/2022 10:01

That TA in the class that does 1-1 with the child that had additional needs is not funded by the school, but the LA, and a parent had to probably go to tribunal in order to get that level of support for their child.

What they are NOT doing is taking away from the school funding and the education of others. They are not there to support other children, although many do despite it not being in their job description.

Sorry, just the pass gag What's App group has really depressed me today.

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 04/01/2022 15:48

So yes, a TA may well work with a child on a 1:1 basis, but will also be working with a group or a pair of children. This does not mean they are ‘taking money’ away from a child who has an EHCP.

I can't see where this is being posed as a problem by the OP.

Imitatingdory · 04/01/2022 15:48

The benefit of a SAR over requesting a pupil's school record under The Education (Pupil Information) (England) Regulations 2005 is the former should (although often doesn’t) disclose all data held, not limited to that in a pupil’s record as is the case with the latter.

Soontobe60 · 04/01/2022 15:46

Sorry, OP, but you’re not completely right.
As a SENCo, in my last year our total budget spent on SEN was over £120k. The funding from the LA ring fenced for SEN was £75K. This included, amongst other things, covering EHCP hours. The first 12 hours of every EHCP was funded from the general school budget. The remaining hours were funded at an hourly rate equivalent to a TA2 post. We paid all our TAs working with EHCPs at TA3 rate.
Some children with an EHCP do need a high degree of 1:1, but many also need support in pairs or group tasks, or even discrete monitoring in order to give them opportunities to practice developing their independence skills. This is often part of their long term objectives on their EHCPs. So yes, a TA may well work with a child on a 1:1 basis, but will also be working with a group or a pair of children. This does not mean they are ‘taking money’ away from a child who has an EHCP.

chimpandzee · 04/01/2022 15:32

[quote hiredandsqueak]@chimpandzee thank you I didn't know that I will save that info for other parents in the support groups I am a member of.[/quote]
You're welcome. There's a model letter on IPSEA that you can use. Also this is helpful.
commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-7657/

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 15:30

@chimpandzee thank you I didn't know that I will save that info for other parents in the support groups I am a member of.

Onionpatch · 04/01/2022 15:30

@VikingsandDragons - but her school budget is for the benefit of the pupils in the school and has an element that is supposed to be spent on send.

I dont doubt there isnt enough money but its not a surprise to have to spend the school budget on the pupils either.

DickMabutt73962 · 04/01/2022 15:30

@theqentity

That TA in the class that does 1-1 with the child that had additional needs is not funded by the school, but the LA, and a parent had to probably go to tribunal in order to get that level of support for their child.

What they are NOT doing is taking away from the school funding and the education of others. They are not there to support other children, although many do despite it not being in their job description.

Sorry, just the pass gag What's App group has really depressed me today.

And also to add, as a TA that did exactly this, whose funding came from council to the one the school was in (child went to school in a different borough) that the school should not be using that TA to do any roles that aren't related to said child. Some schools will try to use it to cut down on extra staff
chimpandzee · 04/01/2022 15:28

[quote SkiRun0077]@hiredandsqueak could I ask what sort of information should I expect from a SAR to my DDs primary school? I’m in the process of putting in a unsupported by school, parental request for educational needs assessment, she’s in Year6, so I do think there’s a high level of feet dragging hoping I’ll go away as she won’t be their issue soon. Masking highly anxious ASD suspected child who has gone from above expectations in year1 to failed to meet learning standards on her year5 report. But academically bright.[/quote]
If the school is not a mainstream independent school or an academy you can make a request for your child's education records under the Pupil Information Regulations 2005 and they have to comply within 15 days.

TeenPlusCat · 04/01/2022 15:26

In summary, if a child with SEN is 'upsetting' other children, or taking too much time of the class teacher/TA, then other parents should lobby the school to provide extra support to the child, not to have the child removed.

As someone currently going through the EHCP process this has been insightful & depressing in equal measure.

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 15:12

A SAR should contain all the information the school holds about your child so you should get , attendance records, learning levels, progress, any interventions they have done, any behaviour incidents, any support or advice they have asked for basically everything that the school has they are obliged to supply within thirty days. This would support your EHC needs assessment request . There are templates online that you can use to make the request

workingtheusername · 04/01/2022 15:12

@Sirzy

If I hadn’t fought to get DS a watertight EHCP (30 hours 1-1) then one of two outcomes would have happened -
  • the education of the whole class would have been disrupted daily due to his unmet needs.

Or

  • the LA would have had to fund a place at a suitable specialist setting. The only one that could come close to being suitable for him is an independent specialist. It would have cost an awful lot more than his 1-1 does.

As it is he has had full 1-1 since year 2, funded from his ehcp since year 3. He is now in year 7 at a mainstream secondary and because he is supported he is thriving and he isn’t negatively impacting the education of others at all.

Getting the right support in for the individual child with additional needs at an early age will often actually cost a lot less and be a lot less disruptive to others over time.

Absolutely early intervention is not only best for the child it provides the best long term out comes
workingtheusername · 04/01/2022 15:08

It amazes me how many people thing equality means treat everyone the same. It doesn't. Sen children get additional support/funding to enable them to achieve to the best of their ability which they would be unable to do with out additional support. All schools need more funding for all pupils but the sen budget is for Sen children it should not be reallocated to none sen children. And it does not take away from none sen children. They were not entitled to it in the first place. Unfortunately there is a lot of ignorant people who have no clue of the challenges sen children deal with every day.

SkiRun0077 · 04/01/2022 15:02

@hiredandsqueak could I ask what sort of information should I expect from a SAR to my DDs primary school? I’m in the process of putting in a unsupported by school, parental request for educational needs assessment, she’s in Year6, so I do think there’s a high level of feet dragging hoping I’ll go away as she won’t be their issue soon. Masking highly anxious ASD suspected child who has gone from above expectations in year1 to failed to meet learning standards on her year5 report. But academically bright.

workingtheusername · 04/01/2022 14:53

@DietrichandDiMaggio

Just to be clear, I am totally of the opinion that a TA employed as 1-1 for a child with an EHCP should not be used as a general class TA, but I'm also saying that not every TA working 1-1 is working with a child that has an EHCP stating that they need full-time 1-1 support (in my school). Also, in my school, there will always be a general TA in the class, as well as the 1-1.
Not always in our infant school there's a TA in each class 9-12. No TA in junior school at all.
VikingsandDragons · 04/01/2022 14:52

I'm sat beside my relative who has been a deputy head and then a head for more than 20 years across 3 local authorities. She has never received enough funding for a full time support assistant even where they have complex needs and need a full time one to one, the most that has ever been granted is equivalent to a half time post (and that is what is usually granted). The rest comes from her schools budget. That is not in any way to say this is how it should be, but like with so many things the rhetoric is there and the funding isn't.

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 04/01/2022 14:48

When I first became a secondary SENCo, there were, in my department, 25 TAs and two teachers. There were a high number of students with statements (at that time) and a specialist SLCN unit.

I discovered recently, that the school now has a total of 8 TAs and no specialist provision.

I made it my business to investigate the funding for the department and discovered that part of that funding was being used to make up the salary of a newly qualified teacher in the IT department. When I challenged this, I was told that he would be teaching some children with SEND.

From the perspective of a SENCo, it can be totally frustrating and anger inducing, to see the money that should be available to support more vulnerable students, being diverted. It is also the case that challenging these financial decisions can lead to a swift departure from the school.

I’ve had parents of children without additional needs being completely unable to see that the amendments we made to the curriculum, to the day to day logistics, to the support we offered, did in fact benefit their children, because it meant support was in place to promote learning and teaching in the classroom.

BoredZelda · 04/01/2022 14:47

It can be toilet paper money.

The difference in having a SFLA or not is whether or not my daughter can access the toilet in the first place. These people allow my daughter to access the same level of education as your child. You think she shouldn't have that because there is a lack of funding across the board? The SEN funding gives her equality. Sure, that might be equality to fully access a system that is failing in some areas but I don't believe it would be fair to put her at a further disadvantage so that non SEN kids can have something better.

If you need to fight for more toilet paper, go and fight for more toilet paper. I'll join you in that. Don't expect money is taken from kids who aren't even given enough in the first place and who without it won't have the same advantages as even the toiletpaperless kids in your school.

drspouse · 04/01/2022 14:44

'It's incredible what mental yoga NT parents do to blame the disabled kid for needing and accessing support.'
It's the same I find for their child associating with your ND child.
If their child is actively friendly with yours - obviously your child is OK making friends, so they need not make the effort to find a playdate/outing that your child could cope with if they don't do cinema/loud spaces/large groups/parties but could do the park/at home 1:1 to play games etc.

If their child doesn't know your child that well - obviously your child is so poor at making friends then trying to get them together so they can become friends is not going to work.

BoredZelda · 04/01/2022 14:25

AND when LAs again cut the funding for SEN assistants, who do way more than just work with kids with SEN, your child will be affected just as much as mine is. So, please use your considerable voices to argue against these cuts. Because when they listen to you making a fuss about say, cutting back on music tuition and decide not to do that, they quietly make cuts in ASN provision instead.

Next time you complain because that kid in the class who has autism disrupted the class for the umpteenth time, perhaps think about whether you have given enough support to the parents who have been fighting for appropriate provision for their child for years?

Our council wanted to cut the school day by 15 minutes, still protecting the 190 hours of F2F teaching. So many parents went absolutely batshit about it, they didn't do it. Instead they reduced Support for learning assistant hours by 25% (on top of similar cuts year on year for the previous 3 years) Previous year they retained breakfast clubs for all instead of only having them for kids on free school meals.

It is a fucking disgrace how our kids are sidelined because other voices are louder.

SmellyOldPartridgeinaPearTree · 04/01/2022 14:16

'It's incredible what mental yoga NT parents do to blame the disabled kid for needing and accessing support.'

Yep. If they don't have a 1-1 they're taking up too much of the teachers time. If they do have a 1-1 it's not fair because why shouldn't my child have a 1-1 too Hmm sorry but SEN children also exist in this world and won't just disappear to make life easier for you.

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 14:15

No doubt they were lies. That said I have Head of SEND recorded admitting she had lied to my solicitor and admitting school had lied as well. Have a lovely email from school advising me that they couldn't confirm they had lied before they checked with Head of SEND whether they could admit they had lied after I sent them the recording of Head of SEND admitting lying( and dropping the school in it) whilst denying sabotage, Complaint about school accepted by Ofsted Wink

Onionpatch · 04/01/2022 14:10

I confess that i have read so much on this and still dont quite get how the funding works.

I know schools get one payment that is per child and its presumed some of that goes on send, like employing a SENCo and training.

I know they get another payment that is for SEND specifically, but isnt linked to specific children and can be spent how the school wants in theory.

And i know they can apply for top up funding from the high needs block for specific children.

Its the middle funding i dont get - thats where the notional 6k is and I read some things that say an ehcp should be fully funded and another that say the first 6k should come from this bit of the budget.

Which leaves a gap in provision for children on SEN support if the whole of that middle bit is used on ehcps. I can see that legally if you have more ehcps than that middle band of funding funds a school can argue for more funding in that block as the LA has to fund it. I cant get my head round if the block and number of ehcps match what the situation is then, as it leaves no other general funding for SEND other than the bit of the per pupil funding assumed for SEND.

Imitatingdory · 04/01/2022 14:08

@hiredandsqueak you would think they would make their lies believable. I know a neighbouring LA released different information via FOI to that which was publicly published as part of their payments and expenses information.

@Meadowbreeze that and I’m sure there will be further case law soon is why I posted it don’t think the case law is as damaging as to say EHCPs can be vague and woolly and shouldn’t be detailed, specified and quantified.

Meadowbreeze · 04/01/2022 14:04

@Imitatingdory I see. In any case, case law doesn't trump statutory law. At best it works alongside but these sorts of tribunal cases are always so very different from each other. I wouldn't particularly worry about this. It is not the laws intent to ensure LAs provide the best provision, but to provide provision that meets the child's needs which is sometimes hard to accept.
They can appeal that decision too though and the fact it is case law just shows how rarely this type of decision is made.

Iveputmyselfonthenaughtystep · 04/01/2022 13:59

*that doesn't mean he wasn't disabled by it