Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To just let you know (re, SEN funding)

531 replies

theqentity · 04/01/2022 10:01

That TA in the class that does 1-1 with the child that had additional needs is not funded by the school, but the LA, and a parent had to probably go to tribunal in order to get that level of support for their child.

What they are NOT doing is taking away from the school funding and the education of others. They are not there to support other children, although many do despite it not being in their job description.

Sorry, just the pass gag What's App group has really depressed me today.

OP posts:
Mumofsend · 05/01/2022 06:42

@spanieleyes what sort of made up procedure is that? A stage 1 appeal being available after that initial meeting shows they didn't actually agree to assess at all. Once an agreement to assess has been made the LA MUST seek advice from all and if they decide to issue its a refusal to issue appeal. A big grounds for a refusal to issue appeal would then be that the LA haven't actually completed a needs assessment.

As a senco can I suggest you figure the system out and not whatever made up process the LA suggest they are using, because its complete and utter BS. Its worrying your post has come from a senco Confused

spanieleyes · 05/01/2022 06:28

I think there is a degree of cross purposes here!
In my county ( and I stress that because each county will have different procedures)
A parent can request an assessment ( using either the model letters or simply a letter requesting assessment)
The LA will agree to complete every assessment ( because to do so would be unlawful and, as has been said, the level of need is set very low)
The first stage of the assessment is to require the 25 page application from schools- and similar from parents. This includes the need for prior support, use of budget, three cycles of review etc. This is PART of the assessment process. Schools can and will miss out the " request assessment" step and go straight to the assessment paperwork. Once completed, with supporting evidence, a review panel sits ( within the county SEND team) to sift through the part one assessments. Those that are agreed go on to the part 2 assessment. This is where the SEND caseworker meets with parents and school to complete the rest of the assessment, an educational psychologist is appointed to complete THEIR report. If the SEND team feel that there is not enough evidence to go on to part 2, the assessment is rejected at this point and returned to school/parents for stage 1 appeal- which means more evidence!
After the stage 2 assessment, the completed paperwork goes to Panel, where a multi disciplinary team assess all the applications made and agree/reject the application. Further appeal is possible if rejected.

So yes, the level to agree to assessment is very low and ( in my experience) never refused. It is the actual assessment which requires the evidence, the use of budgeted funds, the detailed assessment of support, the review periods etc which is what ( I believe) the SENDco's here are referring to!

Hercisback · 05/01/2022 05:35

And who sorts out the appointment with the Ed psych and SALT? These people don't (and shouldn't) act totally independently of schools.

There's a disconnect between the wording of the law and what happens in reality. This is because (shock) most schools want the best for the children that go there.

IncessantNameChanger · 05/01/2022 01:53

If you appeal a needs assessment and you win, the tribunal rule that professionals carry out assessments like Salt, EP and OT. So they give the evidence.

Some things you really do need a specialist degree in like speech therapy to give solid evidence or a PhD to be a EP. Plus those assessments are then also not paid from.the school budget.

That's the difference in inforcement of legal duty and local policy. No senco however experienced or knowledgeable can carry out say a CELF or Wisc assessment. If your found to score very low on such tests and making negligible progress on that score then that in itself can be one of a variety of ways to trigger a ehcp. So it's not true that a appeal will just the LA asking the school what they think. The judge looks for hard evidence from professionals mostly Eps, slt and OT.

In appeal its down to the judge. Its not between the parent and the LA or the LA and school. The judge needs more than "well he looks ok to me" they can not take opinion from.either school.or parent on things like scores. They need solid proof.

In case of language how can even the most outstanding school rank speach against age levels and relative peers of the same chronological age without using a speach therapist? I have a science degree, I'm not to shabby on the IQ front but if I did a CELF who would take my word for it? No one. Because I'm not a speach therapist.

So it's not that black and white

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 23:27

@Hercisback the threshold for a needs assessment is really low so you could provide minimal info to parents to get them over the threshold for assessment. Assessment would be based on a lot more than information from school it should include ED PSych, SALT OT and anyone that a parent feels should provide evidence so from services outside of school as well as a parents input. This would be the evidence that would determine whether or not an EHCP is issued.

OwlinaTree · 04/01/2022 23:22

I will look into that thank you. I've never been given any advice regarding this.

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 23:17

@OwlinaTree You should use every resource you have to empower parents as that would be a far better use of your time as they have the power at the end of the day. Prepare support packs using the resources readily available through IPSEA and SOSSEN. Instead of jumping hoops for LA meet with parents, help them draft a letter requesting an EHC needs assessment using IPSEA template give them the evidence they require levels progress any interventions and behaviour reports. If assessment is refused support them to approach IPSEA SOSSEN investigate Legal Aid and encourage them to appeal. Give them statistics 95% of appeals are won by parents. Don't spend time jumping hoops use your time in the best way possible to get the results.

Hercisback · 04/01/2022 23:14

Who do you all think the LA come back to and ask for evidence of need?

It's all well and good saying appeal, but if your appeal has no evidence or school support then it's unlikely you'll get what your dc need.

There's a lag (especially at primary), between support required, possibly diagnosis and EHCP. The funding for the support before the EHCP has to come from somewhere. Not saying it deprives other children, it doesn't, but it's not like you click your fingers and £46k appears.

OwlinaTree · 04/01/2022 23:06

In the local authority I work for, schools have to provide:
At least two cycles of APDR
Evidence of at least two outside agencies working with the child.
Scores in the 2nd centile or below in two areas.
Evidence of at least 10 hours support across the week.
You are also strongly encouraged to gain support from the LMG for your application, although I have got them through without this.

It's insane. It's completely illegal. But the LA have all the power, schools have very little in reality and have to play the game.

SENCOs in my experience are class teachers on top of SENCOing and don't have the time to be fighting the local authority on top of everything else they are doing every day.

In our LA we can apply for HLN funding, but there is no time frame for applications to be looked at, so you can wait two terms plus for a response. In the meantime you are funding out of the school budget.

I have never had a child with SEND excluded, we have gone above and beyond to support children with additional needs while fighting to get an EHCP sorted. It's a real challenge for schools.

cherrybonbons · 04/01/2022 22:54

There are some schools with high pupil premium that use that funding for an extra TA (mostly in the early years)

cherrybonbons · 04/01/2022 22:52

Sorry you've had a shit morning.
The first 6k a year is paid for out of the school budget.
It doesn't take away from other necessities and an extra pair of hands in the classroom is always useful.
People can be awful and ignorant

littleowls83 · 04/01/2022 22:51

We viewed a local secomdary 2school who are actively discouraging children with any SEND from out of catchment from applying as their learning support department is 'over run' with children with additional needs according to their prospectus. They take quite a lot of children out of catchment. They have said they will try and contest placements through an ECHP out of catchment as they don't have the resources to cope. I was pretty stunned any school would put that in print! It worked however as we applied for the other local school - DS will need very minimal support - probably just use of a laptop and exam arrangements, but clearly wasn't welcome.

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 22:47

Yes would definitely use IPSEA or SOSSEN over Sendiass who are often LAs mouthpiece. If on Facebook Educational Equality are also trustworthy offering law based advice and support.
@Lougle yes knew you during the fight for my son, learned my lessons well to become the nightmare demanding legislation spouting parent for my daughter. Planning for next Tribunal and don't even have an amended EHCP such is my low expectation of our LA.

Rinoachicken · 04/01/2022 22:36

@Imitatingdory thank you!

Imitatingdory · 04/01/2022 22:32

SENDIASS often repeat the LA’s unlawful policies. They receive LA funding so ultimately toe the party line. IPSEA and SOSSEN are better IMO.

Rino start with reading the SENCOP and IPSEA and SOSSEN’s websites. You don’t need representation to appeal, many self repping parents succeed. Here is IPSEA’s information on Legal Aid.

Lougle I wouldn’t bother waiting either. You have more than enough evidence to get over the EHCNA threshold.

Lougle · 04/01/2022 22:26

Thanks @hiredandsqueak. I think I recognise you from times of old.

Boring story is that DD2 went to school 1 in year R. Fell apart in year 1, after class move, physically ill as a result. School HT accused me of FII.

School 2 in year 1. Fell apart in year 2, after class move. They tried nurture groups. Paediatrician saw her and said she was 'passive' but he didn't see ASD. SALT saw her and said she had x,y,z traits of ASD but 'they weren't affecting her'. OT said she scored very low in some areas, but high in others, so overall was average Hmm They tried nurture group but she fell apart when it was withdrawn after 6 weeks (as per policy). So I withdrew her and HE for 1 term.

School 3, year 3. They recognised her ASD traits and managed her accordingly. Did well with support in year 3&4 (mixed year classes). Year 5, she fell apart completely after a class change. School put in huge efforts, using pre-teaching to avoid the startled shutdowns, dictation and scribing, timers to produce a paragraph, etc. They realised she wouldn't pass SATs because she couldn't infer from text, so they taught her inference discretely, i.e., 'jumper means cold'. 110 in English SATs.

Year 7, move to secondary school. DX with ASD. She's had a generic SEN profile, but not much support. Little things like 2 minute early pass, seated near teacher, etc., Won't talk to teachers, won't ask for help, doesn't understand, hates school environment, can't stand being near people, cries for days before term starts.

stripesonmyscarf · 04/01/2022 22:25

@Rinoachicken

Try asking your local SENDIASS/parent partnership/SEND support. All local authorities should have one but often they are called different things. If you want, PM me your local authority and I can see if I can find the details for you.

stripesonmyscarf · 04/01/2022 22:23

@ElvenDreamer my dc is academically able. OK so they work within the lower ability groups but this is a planned strategy in their EHCP. If they perceive work as being too difficult they will either a) point blank refuse to try or b) it's a flash point for some difficult behaviour. Usually the latter.

My local authority tried to refuse me an EHCP when I applied for it. They changed their tune very quickly when I asked for the mediation certificate so I could take them to a tribunal.

If you have a sendiass/parent partnership/SEND advice service in your local authority they can tell you how to go about starting the process. Depending on the relationship you have with your son's school/SENCO they may be able to tell you who the person is you contact.

Rinoachicken · 04/01/2022 22:21

DS2 (8) school have just applied for an EHCP for him. I don’t know the law on this at all, I have tried to find o it but it’s all very confusing (by design I’m assuming!).

There’s no way we would be entitled to any legal aid (is anyone these days? I wasn’t even entitled to it for divorce after DV!) so we can’t afford to take it to tribunal if we can’t get it pushed through.

I might be surprised and it’s granted - the school have been fantastic and we have a huge amounts of evidence and professional reports - but I know they just refuse on principle first time it seems.

Could someone please point me in the right direction of what the LA legal duties/responsibilities are, what the SEN law actually says, so that like PP have done I can write an effective letter if they refuse? I’m in Surrey and the school is an academy, if that makes a difference?

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 22:11

@Lougle I wouldn't bother waiting put in the SAR and get the process started as soon as possible if a school has got to year ten and allowed a child to fail to make significant progress in all that time then little is going to change now regardless of their assurances. You also have to consider how your dd is going to manage the increased pressure that will be applied now, it was that pressure and the constant assessment and reassessment that broke dd despite her having full time support and an IQ of 162. She got the expected top grades in independent specialist anyway with none of the pressure applied.

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 22:03

Tbh the experiences of parents in our LA specific support group is that all requests for assessment are refused, sometimes LA even dream up some extra hoops or try to add on weeks before they will give a decision by producing a form that will start the process when it has been completed and returned and sometimes they advise that they should speak to school about GRIP funding for a year before applying again but for every parent who replies quoting their legal duty and an expectation they comply with that duty there is an about turn and the decision is almost always positive. I don't know anyone who had to appeal refusal to assess they usually give in before they get there.

Lougle · 04/01/2022 21:58

@spanieleyes

Those that say you can just apply for an assessment-of course you can! But those that say its not quite as simple as that are also correct. This is the guidance for page 11 of the 25 page EHCP assessment request form we need to complete

SECTION G.1: Current Support Arrangements
Assess, Plan, Do and Review
All mainstream schools are provided with resources to support those with additional needs, including students with SEN and disabilities. Please therefore identify from the school's budget the targeted support provided for the child. This will be in addition to or different from that made available for children of the same age, for example, through Quality First Teaching.

You should indicate in this section evidence of a graduated approach and the current support arrangements over a minimum of three cycles of assess, plan, do and review.

So yes, we do need to prove what the notional funding has been spent on and we do need evidence of support over a period of time ( along with 24 other pages of information!) Otherwise the application wont even get through the first sift!

Actually, that may be what you are told to do, but when I applied for DD1's Statement, back in the day, I submitted a couple of letters from professionals and a letter from me. It wasn't down to me to prove DD1 needed a Statement, just that she 'might'. Same goes for EHCP needs assessments. All you have to show is that they 'may' need an EHCP.
Lougle · 04/01/2022 21:55

@spanieleyes

Those that say you can just apply for an assessment-of course you can! But those that say its not quite as simple as that are also correct. This is the guidance for page 11 of the 25 page EHCP assessment request form we need to complete

SECTION G.1: Current Support Arrangements
Assess, Plan, Do and Review
All mainstream schools are provided with resources to support those with additional needs, including students with SEN and disabilities. Please therefore identify from the school's budget the targeted support provided for the child. This will be in addition to or different from that made available for children of the same age, for example, through Quality First Teaching.

You should indicate in this section evidence of a graduated approach and the current support arrangements over a minimum of three cycles of assess, plan, do and review.

So yes, we do need to prove what the notional funding has been spent on and we do need evidence of support over a period of time ( along with 24 other pages of information!) Otherwise the application wont even get through the first sift!

But if a child has SEN and it's clear enough that they have SEN that a parent is requesting an EHCP, then you should already be building that evidence and if you aren't, it's shameful. It's shameful to leave a child to struggle, or fail to document the support you are providing accurately.

My DD2 (diagnosed with ASD in year 7) managed to get 110 on her year 6 English SATs, with a huge amount of work from her teachers. She's now working at a level 1 GCSE grade in year 10. She's been badly let down.

I have a meeting on Thursday with a SLT link. If they impress me, I'll give them a chance. If not, I'll be doing a SAR and putting in an application for an EHCP, if nothing else to find out what school are actually doing for her, which I suspect is not enough.

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2022 21:42

It's not the end of the world if it's refused at first request anyway, LA's routinely refuse to test to see if parents are determined to push. LA's lose 95% of appeals or 99% if in Derbyshire so obviously they aren't refusing on law based evidence they are refusing in the hopes parents will give in. Encourage and support parents to appeal at every stage if they have to.

Mumofsend · 04/01/2022 21:40

I fully agree with @hiredandsqueak. There's nothing stopping you being honest with parents, saying you think they will need to refuse. Provide them the evidence you do have (which only needs to be minimal). Doing the letter and saying they should appeal if refused. Save yourself a 25 booklet.