Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cutting down 100+yr old Willow trees

68 replies

MsLup · 03/01/2022 21:29

We have a few very old large Willow trees on our farm land. DH wants to cut them down to 10ftish and pollard them in future. Reason given, they are in the way (between two fields) and could potentially become dangerous and destroy fencing.

To me it is sacrilege as they are a haven for wildlife with many nesting species particularly owls and can be seen across the rather flat landscape of the area.

I have tried to discuss a compromise such as only removing a third of their height and pollarding but DH is insistent (rather aggressively) that they will be coming down.

We own the land jointly and besides trying to get a TPO discreetly I have no idea where to go from here. Utterly heartbroken he feels the need to be so destructive. I still recall how he cut down a 25ft Holly tree at a previous property 25years ago. Angry

Suggestions please as this is causing severe marital disharmony. He is currently sulking after a very heated discussion.

OP posts:
picklemewalnuts · 04/01/2022 09:00

Perhaps suggest doing one and seeing how it goes. An end one. If it recovers, do two the next year, and so on. It will give the wildlife a chance to relocate.

Mayhemmumma · 04/01/2022 08:51

I'm having a similar argument, new house with the most incredible weeping willow and husband desperate to 'tidy' the low hanging branches!
I've said the whole garden is his but leave the willow! It's a part of history! And will be so beautiful in spring.

Hold firm OP don't let this one go!

LaurieFairyCake · 04/01/2022 07:52

Well you've talked about it and he has become entrenched and for some bizarre reason thinks it's his way or the highway

You now have to move to PREVENTING his action - so take all legal means necessary to do so - they are just as much YOUR trees as his Thanks

YourenutsmiLord · 04/01/2022 07:47

Crazy - compromise, cut one down and leave one

oviraptor21 · 04/01/2022 07:43

Yes - 10ft seems ridiculous and unnecessary. Surely a compromise at 20ft or 30ft would achieve much the same objective and be less damaging to wildlife and visual amenity

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 04/01/2022 07:42

Compromise? Find a balance for nature & business?
Agree to height reductions for these trees, ideally pollarding, on the advice of a specialist, and he agrees to plant 20 new trees around the farm to create the treescape for future generations.
I'd suggest oak, lime perhaps, hornbeam?
And also setting aside a wet field corner or two to let willow scrub re-establish.

musicalfrog · 04/01/2022 07:33

10 ft stumps will be ugly. He's mad.

Bluntness100 · 04/01/2022 07:24

Op, just get a good tree surgeon out to have a look. There is no point arguing, it doesn’t read like you actually know the variety or age, it is unlikely but feasible they are as old as you think and peoples memories are funny things, it is also feasible your husband is right and they are approaching end of life span and could be a risk. Large trees coming down can be really dangerous.

Ask on your local Facebook to see if anyone knows a good arborist, he or she can age the trees for you but also tell you if they are hollowing inside and if they do indeed pose a risk.

No one should take trees down for the fun of it, but in addition no one should be so sentimental they cause risk and it sounds like yoire both arguing and neither playing with facts.

I’ve had a large tree come down, and if anything or anyone had been in it’s path it would have been fatal.

Just have them assessed and then decide.

MsLup · 04/01/2022 00:20

Thanks for the many replies. These trees are known as the oldest willows in the area. I have spoken to a few locals all in their 80's who remember them as decent sized trees. Yes they are doing a superb job of supping up the water in a flood zone 3 area.

It isn't that he wants to cut them down totally but to reduce them to a mere10ft, so effectively just the stump will remain. I expect they are too old to be pollarded and therefore could die. Cutting them to this low height will change the landscape and views.Confused

OP posts:
Kookookachuu · 03/01/2022 23:38

I’m with you OP, why do men have a caveman desire to destroy everything Sad hope you get your way. Willows are thirsty trees, without them it will probably flood. Nature needs mature trees.

powershowerforanhour · 03/01/2022 23:27

"I'm with your H on this. We had a similarly aged willow of around 60ft which we had maintained and regularly pollarded and it's just suddenly come down onto the neighbour's summerhouse, squashing it flat. They're lovely trees but they don't last as long as others and big pieces can suddenly fall. Now we are going to take the other one down, just in case."

Location, location, location. If there's a neighbour's summerhouse to squash, potentially with a neighbour in it, then yeah get chopping. If they are beside a road or public right of way, get chopping. If the only thing they are likely to squash is a few metres of fence then who cares?

powershowerforanhour · 03/01/2022 23:19

Reason given, they are in the way (between two fields) a
In the way of what?

And could potentially become dangerous
To whom? Is there a public right of way underneath them?

and destroy fencing.
I know fence posts and wire are quite dear but are yours made out of solid silver and spun gold or something?

Sounds like excuses. Yeah time to plaster your local FB with some lovely arty photos of them in the frost and at sunset, audio of the owls calling and say how much you love them.

Is he planning to take them off at 10ft himself or get tree surgeons to do it?

EishetChayil · 03/01/2022 23:14

Just chop the weepy feckers down.

whymewhyme · 03/01/2022 23:12

Oh nooo he can't cut them down!!

IamaBluebird · 03/01/2022 23:09

Agree with the suggestions about getting expert advice about the trees.
You seem reasonable in your approach to this Op, your husband sounds like
a bully.

Alexandra2001 · 03/01/2022 23:06

@Bluntness100 Nope, 400 species of Willow, Salix is the Willow bit, Babylonica is the weeping version.....

Try the Goat Willow, a UK tree.

google makes arborists of us all lol!

powershowerforanhour · 03/01/2022 23:06

"We own the land jointly"
Well then. He's on a sticky wicket.

Bluntness100 · 03/01/2022 23:01

@Cocoabutterformula

I've just googled lifespan of a willow and got anything from 30-300 years

Lo and behold there's one in the state's that's 5,000 years old! Mmmm....

Love this, there is indeed one that’s that age, but the average age is 30 years for Salix, we can all Google 🤣🤣🤣
Janeandjohnny · 03/01/2022 23:00

Hello, take a look at regenerative pasture/ carbon farming. He really should not cut them. Derek Gow on twitter is fascinating on this stuff plus Knepp Castle- all doing amazing stuff. Try to gently discuss alternatives. They are so important.

Alexandra2001 · 03/01/2022 23:00

@Bluntness100

But the bigger issue is he is not respecting your POV nor will he compromise, you need to put your foot down and tell him NO! you also own these trees

I think she needs to be sure of what kind of willow these are exactly to have lived a hundred years, it’s possible but highly, highly unusual.

Op, stop thr arguing, get a tree surgeon in to appraise them,

Not unusual at all, many Willows live over 100 years, its the Weeping Willow that has a very short life span.

Don't get a tree surgeon, their job is to cut down trees, you need a tree consultant, he/she will check the tree for rot etc

The OPs partner needs to get on board with the fact his OH owns the land too.

Cocoabutterformula · 03/01/2022 22:57

I've just googled lifespan of a willow and got anything from 30-300 years

Lo and behold there's one in the state's that's 5,000 years old! Mmmm....

AlwaysLatte · 03/01/2022 22:55

I'm with your H on this. We had a similarly aged willow of around 60ft which we had maintained and regularly pollarded and it's just suddenly come down onto the neighbour's summerhouse, squashing it flat. They're lovely trees but they don't last as long as others and big pieces can suddenly fall. Now we are going to take the other one down, just in case.

Youaremypenguin · 03/01/2022 22:55

Trees do require maintenance if they've become too big for their space or are a risk if high winds. Pollarding these trees is a very sensible solution to maintain the tree while ensuring it's health and safety.

Cocoabutterformula · 03/01/2022 22:54

Yes get someone in to give neutral advice.

Bluntness100 · 03/01/2022 22:51

@Rockbird

There were willow trees in my school grounds that were not young trees when I was there 40 years ago. They're still there although the school has gone, and they look beautiful. Never heard of them only living 30 years.
Then Google it.
Swipe left for the next trending thread