Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give a lift to a stranger?

190 replies

LondonQueen · 03/01/2022 19:01

Tonight I went to grab a few things from the shops with my DS as they didn't come on my usual online shop. As I was leaving the store, with DS holding my hand, a woman came up to me and asked for a lift to a street I hadn't heard of, which she assured me wasn't far and was near a local landmark (said landmark is about a 10 minutes drive from the shop)
I normally would have said yes but there was something off about this woman. I said No, sorry I have to go and pick up DD in the opposite direction. Despite this she followed me to my car! I politely but firmly said please step away from my car as you're scaring my DS. She walked away and asked again, I ignored her and got in the car and locked my doors. As I drove away, she walked up to another car with a young looking teenager walking towards it. WIBU to say no? Like I said I normally would give someone a lift so close but she made me feel uncomfortable, especially with DS with me. DH said he would have given her a lift as she was clearly in need or wouldn't ask! Please reassure me I did the right thing, or tell me I should stop being so paranoid.

OP posts:
purplebunny2012 · 04/01/2022 17:44

YWNBU! No way would a give a stranger a lift, anything could happen. Your DH is naive

MummyMayo1988 · 04/01/2022 17:43

Definitely NBU - if your gut sent warning signals; you'd be stupid to ignore them. It's all very well DH saying; "I'd have done it" but a woman alone with a child is a different story. Not to sound sexist or anything 😬 it shouldn't be this way but it is.
What if her aim was to chuck you out the car or she had a bloke waiting at the other end? What if - God forbid - the goal was to take your DC?!
You definitely did the right thing.

Zipper666 · 04/01/2022 17:42

You played safe, which is always the best option.

If she had kept asking, get your phone out and say "I will just take your photo and send it to my home account"

If she shies away that's a good clue.

GrandmasCat · 04/01/2022 17:33

@Russelhobskettle

Does anyone else routinely put their handbag in their boot rather than keep it in seating area of their car? My handbag is always in my boot, shoved under the random horse junk.
Never, it is more likely that you are mugged while opening/closing the boot than coming out of the car. If I have to run out of the car, I don’t want to be fiddling with the boot in the middle of a busy road/motorway. My safety is more important than my bag.

I put it in the passenger footwell but my doors are always locked and my windows never fully open.

alfiegirl61 · 04/01/2022 17:20

Absolutely not!! Could have been a man dressed/made up as a woman. Or she could have pulled a knife on you and car-jacked you. Even if he/she wasn't planning violence or robbery, who goes out to the shops without any means of getting home, nor enough money for a bus or a taxi, and just expecting some random stranger to ferry them back home? No back story - e.g. my car has broken down/I was going to walk but sprained my ankle/I've lost my phone/purse so can you possibly lend me £5 for a taxi? She wasn't stuck miles from anywhere... and who doesn't have a phone to call a taxi/partner/family member/friend if they get stranded? If she'd asked if she could use your phone to call a taxi - you'd have said yes. Quite right to trust your instincts. I bet your DH would have hit the roof if you'd had an incident (i.e. "how could you possibly have been so gullible/taken such a risk!")

jamandmarmaladethesecondcoming · 04/01/2022 16:58

You don't give lifts to strangers (Your mum told you)

Anything could have happened. Knife pulled at your throat? Your child threatened/kidnapped/raped/murdered?

Russelhobskettle · 04/01/2022 16:52

Does anyone else routinely put their handbag in their boot rather than keep it in seating area of their car? My handbag is always in my boot, shoved under the random horse junk.

LaurieFairyCake · 04/01/2022 16:21

You did ABSOLUTELY the right thing OP

She didn't give a reason, she was persistent - she followed you to your car AFTER you said no, your child was frightened

Separately I often give people lifts in London. I live near a music college and the young people with their cellos and double bases at the bus stops are often offered lifts by me in the rain or like today when loads of bus drivers are off with Covid

The last bloke with a cello said people always stopped and offered him lifts Smile

NYnewstart · 04/01/2022 16:00

Not quite the same situation but I was driving home from work one day pre mobile phones, and I suddenly felt too unwell to drive.
I knocked on a random door and asked to borrow their phone to call my dad to fetch me. Fortunately the couple let me in to wait and use their phone.

I don’t think I would in today’s world. Maybe make the call for me and make me wait In my car perhaps.

LuaDipa · 04/01/2022 15:32

In this situation I would have said no also. I have given a lift to a stranger on a couple of occasions previously but something seems quite off here.

DanielRicciardosSmile · 04/01/2022 06:52

@Sweetpeasaremadeforbees

I wonder if you're the lady who gave me a lift? I was in exactly the second situation you describe.

If so, thankyou. I never forgot your kindness.

Probably not unless you were in Hull in the 90s Grin

But it's nice to think that maybe the girl appreciated it. Flowers

Ahh no it wasn't me then! It was the 90s, but it was in Wales.

I'm sure she was just as grateful though.

Duckerbizzle · 04/01/2022 06:49

Oh gosh, absolutely you did the right thing. Could well have been getting you to drive somewhere to then be mugged or whatever. Hope the next person she approached is OK though! (Not blaming you OP btw)

ALongHardWinter · 04/01/2022 02:27

I think you were right to listen to your gut instinct. And like a previous poster,I agree that what made it suspicious was her persistence. Most odd.

CelestiaNoctis · 04/01/2022 00:55

If its not far then why can't couldn't she walk it. Very strange. Definitely don't give lifts to strangers, even the elderly. Remember, Ted bundy pretended to be injured to gain sympathy. Just because someone's old doesn't mean they're a nice person.

pinkmink · 03/01/2022 23:58

My instinct would be to say no way, because I’d assume it was some sort of scam or it would put me in danger. I’d probably then worry that she was in danger. Either way, I think you did the right thing by saying no and letting the police know. If she’s being used by a gang this could help her.

EightNationNavy · 03/01/2022 23:41

Big difference between seeing someone in distress trying to cope on their own and deciding of your own volition to offer help, and a stranger coming up to you asking for a lift. Huge difference. Not at all comparable.

Think about it, if normal people find themselves a bit stuck, they would either suck it up and walk, or phone a friend, or if their phone was flat, go back into a store and see if someone could charge it for them. You would only ask a stranger for a lift if you were totally desperate and even then you would more likely just ask them to phone someone for you, or to take you a very limited way, with many apologies.

Someone sauntering up to a complete and utter stranger and just insouciantly requesting a lift - (not counting the odd situation where hitching is more normal or expected) - obviously up to no good.

KTheGrey · 03/01/2022 23:14

Gosh @SE13Mummy that's a lovely story of kindness just because somebody needed it. Given me a warm glow that has.

SE13Mummy · 03/01/2022 22:54

@TakeMe2Insanity

Hang on, where do you live that it’s ok normal to give total strangers a lift in your car? No way on earth I’d do that in London.
I'm in London and have given a lift to stranger. She was a sobbing student on the last train out of London. Phone battery had died, she'd been split up from friends, the train wasn't going to where she lived and it was snowing. I was with my DD, suggested to the student that she got off the train with us and came back to at least charge her phone and come up with a plan in the warm (she wasn't dressed for snow) but that I'd happily drive her home if need be. That's what happened in the end as there were no taxis available. It was four or five years ago and I'd absolutely do it again; a 20 year old wandering around SE London in her clubbing outfit, upset, unable to contact anyone and freezing cold was the vulnerable one in the situation and I was in a position to help keep her safe.

I wouldn't have given a lift to a stranger who accosted me in a shop and then pestered me.

ClaudiaJ1 · 03/01/2022 22:38

YANBU We have these instincts for a reason. That she was intimidating you was enough.

Londongent · 03/01/2022 22:24

As others have said no chance would I have given her a lift. She could well have been trying to drive you to a location where someone would be waiting to rob you.

MrsWinters · 03/01/2022 22:16

I probably would’ve called the non-emergency police line as well and given a description

Hagpie · 03/01/2022 22:07

No you’re not unreasonable. I love helping but the risk is not worth the warm fuzzy feeling in this case. You trusted your guy and just might have saved yourself and your kid.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 03/01/2022 22:02

I wonder if you're the lady who gave me a lift? I was in exactly the second situation you describe.

If so, thankyou. I never forgot your kindness.

Probably not unless you were in Hull in the 90s Grin

But it's nice to think that maybe the girl appreciated it. Flowers

DdraigGoch · 03/01/2022 21:54

@TakeMe2Insanity

Hang on, where do you live that it’s ok normal to give total strangers a lift in your car? No way on earth I’d do that in London.
London is not exactly the sort of place where randoms would generally need lifts though, is it? It's not like the snowy country lane above where a bus probably passes through once a week.
Whywonttheyhelpme · 03/01/2022 21:52

There is not a cat in hell’s chance I would have given this stranger a lift. You did the right thing