Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give a lift to a stranger?

190 replies

LondonQueen · 03/01/2022 19:01

Tonight I went to grab a few things from the shops with my DS as they didn't come on my usual online shop. As I was leaving the store, with DS holding my hand, a woman came up to me and asked for a lift to a street I hadn't heard of, which she assured me wasn't far and was near a local landmark (said landmark is about a 10 minutes drive from the shop)
I normally would have said yes but there was something off about this woman. I said No, sorry I have to go and pick up DD in the opposite direction. Despite this she followed me to my car! I politely but firmly said please step away from my car as you're scaring my DS. She walked away and asked again, I ignored her and got in the car and locked my doors. As I drove away, she walked up to another car with a young looking teenager walking towards it. WIBU to say no? Like I said I normally would give someone a lift so close but she made me feel uncomfortable, especially with DS with me. DH said he would have given her a lift as she was clearly in need or wouldn't ask! Please reassure me I did the right thing, or tell me I should stop being so paranoid.

OP posts:
WagnersFourthSymphony · 04/01/2022 20:48

I've both offered and accepted lifts from strangers, but only because it felt ok at the time. But no way would I do this if I felt there was something off about them, however hard to pinpoint. You were right to turn her down for this alone.

It is really weird that she persisted after you'd refused. Especially when you had your child with you.

You were right to trust your instincts. No one should be criticising you for making that choice.

Scottsy100 · 04/01/2022 20:36

Absolutely not she could be anyone

Sunnysideup78 · 04/01/2022 20:21

You definitely did the right thing. I always remember a story that my uncle told me when I was younger about a colleague of his being approached by an ‘old woman’ in a carpark who didn’t have enough money to get the bus home. She took pity on her and helped her into the car, got in the other side and looked down to reverse to discover that the old lady had man’s hands! Quick thinking she said ‘could you just get out and see me back’ which they did and she quickly drove off! Afterwards she found the old lady’s handbag in the footwell and there was nothing but a big knife in there 😱
No idea if this story was true or just my uncle trying to instill some sense into me for when I was older. Needless to say, I’ve never given a stranger a lift or vice versa!

Bertiebiscuit · 04/01/2022 20:10

No woman should ever allow a stranger into her car, for any reason ever - do you not watch the News

SlashBeef · 04/01/2022 20:01

Oh hell nah. Next thing you know you're handcuffed to a pipe in a disused bathroom.

OneTC · 04/01/2022 19:55

I've given strangers lifts before but in the scenario you described no, fuck that

Ddot · 04/01/2022 19:51

If your spider senses say 😱 dont go against them

Callingallskeletons · 04/01/2022 19:26

Erm no chance, OP you totally did the right thing and your husband is slightly mental?

But I wouldn’t give a total stranger a lift in any circumstance tbh, unfortunately now you just can’t trust anyone at face value

quicknamechange4000 · 04/01/2022 19:23

I'd have been the same, OP. Trust your instincts. Re your DH it's easier for a bloke to say they'd do it! Men aren't as vulnerable.

Kteeb1 · 04/01/2022 19:12

I gave a lift to a stranger recently. A young woman who was stranded at the train station as all the trains were cancelled and she cpuldnt get hold of her mum. But she had clearly been on the train and was I'm distress. A slight risk but a calculated one.i want going to leave her by herself it's am isolated train station with no taxis. But I trusted my gut, as you have. Your DH wasn't there you were so he can't judge.. Also men don't have to protect themselves, don't even think about it, in the same way we do.

Passenger42 · 04/01/2022 18:37

No way, read too many books on Fred and Rose West to give lifts to strangers. That’s how they lured their victims.

GiftedFish · 04/01/2022 18:33

No. I wouldn't have gave her a lift. Especially being that you had your child with you.

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 04/01/2022 18:30

You were right, and her behaviour after you refused when she followed you and tried to harangue you into changing your mind just emphasised that your instincts were right.

I have occasionally given lifts. We go on holiday to a very rural part of Ireland with next to no public transport and we occasionally see people walking and hitching. Usually the car is full with family but once when I was on my own in the car I gave a guy a lift because he looked like a young teen, too young to drive. It was an impulse decision and he turned out to be a charming young man. Other times I've been on my own and driven past men hitching and not even considered stopping for them so I must have some unconscious thought process that does a risk analysis from just a glance.

maybloss2 · 04/01/2022 18:27

I wouldn’t have a stranger in my car with my child.
I have picked up hitchhikers in the past when on my own.
I’d say trust yr instinct.

Celestine70 · 04/01/2022 18:26

You totally did the right thing. You have to put you and your child's safety first. Don't trust strangers is for adults too.

EllieHJ · 04/01/2022 18:24

I gave a lift to a guy just before Xmas a couple of years ago. I was with my teenage son and he wanted to get to the AELTC. He had asked directions in the village and we were about to drive past it on our way home. He seemed very nice. We dropped him off and thought nothing of it. About 30 minutes later my youngest son had popped over to a neighbours and left the front door slightly open so he could pop back.

Two armed policemen pushed into the house shouting. They were shouting my husbands name because the car was registered in his name.

The guy had been seen being dropped off by me on camera and then left something outside the bloody place which they thought was a bomb. So they thought we were something to do with it. It was crazy! It turned out to be someone’s ashes that he’d left outside the tennis club.

All got sorted in the end but I nearly shit myself when we got raided!

Suzanne999 · 04/01/2022 18:17

No. And never ever with a child in the car.
Sounds an odd scenario and she was too persistent. Something off there.

purplebunny2012 · 04/01/2022 18:16

There was one time I got in a stranger's car. It was after I crashed mine and he was a witness. I think he asked if we (my DS and me) had a way of getting home. My DH was at my FIL's house 90 miles away and we don't have anyone else around us, so I said no and he drove us home (IIRC I didn't have my mobile so called breakdown once we were at home). It was only a couple of miles, but a bit far for my DS to walk, I think he was 5 at the time.
Obviously he knew what had happened and that we were in need, and I hadn't asked him before he offered (I wouldn't have thought to do so), but as above I wouldn't drive a stranger who asked me

Cindefuckingrella · 04/01/2022 18:15

You absolutely did the right thing. Always trust your instincts.
I have given a lift to a stranger once- but only because I could see they were in distress and I offered. If they had asked I probably wouldn’t have, as I’m suspicious of everyone! It was in the residential area near the local hospital and I had just returned to my car from an appointment. She looked like she had parked and lost her bearings, which was easily done. She was very grateful and as suspected she was trying to get to the hospital where her husband had been admitted with mental health issues. Poor lady was distraught.

AcrossthePond55 · 04/01/2022 18:10

Why would anyone EVER allow a stranger to get in their car? I wouldn't care if she looked like Her Majesty the Queen. She's not getting in my car!

When my mother was around 90 and in the earliest stages of what turned out to be dementia, she told my brother and I that she'd given a ride to 'such a nice young lady'. We were appalled and it was when our eyes were opened that her 'forgetfulness' was more than just 'old age', her judgement was going, too . It was shortly thereafter that we asked her to stop driving and luckily she was willing to hand over her keys.

007Stocko · 04/01/2022 18:02

@phishy

YANBU. Never ignore your instincts.
Absolutely this
Tessabelle1 · 04/01/2022 17:50

I would NEVER give a lift to a stranger, call me paranoid but with my luck I'd pick up the local serial killer

Woeismethischristmas · 04/01/2022 17:48

My ex used to give hitchhikers a lift all the time. I think it’s different as a bloke. I’ve only ever given a lift once I was up on Orkney and it was so windy/ rainy that I offered a lift to a woman walking down the road. She did say they were used to the weather but hopped in anyway.

Scarriff · 04/01/2022 17:48

I'm someone who occasionally gives lifts to strangers, usually when public transport is having a hiccup. I did a lot of hitchhiking when I was young so see it as a way of paying back. ALWAYS listen to your gut . If something seems off, then jog on. Waste no time. The woman might have been fine, but you could not tell at the time. You did the right thing

Oh never had a problem with strangers btw.

EvilPea · 04/01/2022 17:48

Your instincts are there for a reason

I have given a lift to a stranger before. We met in the queue at Sainsburys and got talking. She wasn’t local, and needed to get somewhere that was a short walk but directions were tricky so I ended up giving her a lift there, waited for her and lift back to her hotel.
Id never normally offer, but she seemed nice and a bit lonely in a new town,I’d trusted my guts and I guess so did she.